Jamestown Villas Homeowners Ass'n v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · September 4, 2026 · No. 25-3154 (8th Cir.)
Applying Minnesota law, a clear appraisal award is binding, cannot be reviewed for adequacy, and should not be sent back for clarification. Like kind and quality of shingles was part of the amount of loss.
Limits: A federal prediction of Minnesota law, not binding on Minnesota courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McDonald v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Appellate Court of Maryland · August 26, 2026 · No. 2104, Sept. Term 2024 (Md. App. Ct. Aug. 26, 2026) (reported; reporter cite not yet assigned)
An umpire signed a paper by mistake that looked like an appraisal award. The court held it was not an award. A party who says no award exists does not have to move to modify or vacate it within the statutory deadlines, and a court cannot confirm an award that does not exist. The court affirmed the denial of confirmation and sent the case back for a declaratory judgment.
Limits: The opinion treats appraisal as analogous to arbitration and uses the arbitration act's deadlines as the framework without deciding they govern appraisal awards.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
People's Trust Insurance Co. v. Fernandez
Florida Fifth District Court of Appeal · August 7, 2026 · No. 5D2025-3174 (Fla. 5th DCA 2026)
An insurer may demand appraisal for the first time after suit. It waives appraisal only by taking part in the lawsuit or acting inconsistently with appraisal. A $100 settlement offer, an appraisal defense in the answer and a prompt motion to compel were not waiver.
Limits: Fifth District. The opinion is marked corrected; the date is from the PDF text.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
CVC Investments LLP v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · August 5, 2026 · No. A24-1915
An insured that sued after demanding appraisal and tolling, while the insurer's time to respond had not run, showed no justiciable dispute for its declaratory or contract claims.
Limits: Decides justiciability, not whether appraisal was waived.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
One Church v. Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Ohio · July 23, 2026 · 2026-Ohio-2764 (No. 2024-1329)
A binding appraisal can be challenged only for fraud or mistake. An insured who cashed the paid award and then sued for more "hidden" damage had to plead a specific mistake with particularity, and did not. The court reinstated the dismissal.
Limits: Slip opinion, subject to formal revision. Decided on the pleadings; it does not say a separate new claim can never be made. Justice Fischer dissented.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Young v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit · June 17, 2026 · No. 25-60518
An insured who accepted and cashed an appraisal award, and never challenged it, could not go on suing on the policy. Her tort claims fell with the contract claims, and she had not shown the insurer lacked an arguable basis.
Limits: Unpublished, not precedent. Federal court applying Sweet Valley; homeowner fire claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
In re ACE American Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Texas · May 8, 2026 · No. 25-0461 (Tex. 2026)
Ordered a trial court to compel appraisal on a water damage claim. A possible coverage dispute does not defeat the right to appraisal, an insurer's alleged bad faith in handling the claim does not excuse the insured from appraisal, and a party needs only a disagreement about the amount of loss, not an impasse, to demand it.
Limits: Commercial property policy, decided on mandamus before any appraisal. The court did not decide what the panel may do at the award stage or that no coverage disputes remain.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Stewart v. Farmers Insurance of Columbus, Inc.
Ohio Court of Appeals, 8th District (Cuyahoga County) · April 23, 2026 · 2026-Ohio-1451 (No. 115049)
A court-ordered binding appraisal had settled the named plaintiff's total-loss valuation, and the insurer paid the difference, so the individual and class claims were moot. Class certification was reversed.
Limits: Automobile total-loss case, not property. The appeals court did not decide whether appraisal could be compelled after suit was filed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. Rymer Cos.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · March 27, 2026 · 170 F.4th 1159 (8th Cir. 2026) (No. 24-3356)
A court may send an unclear appraisal award back to the panel for clarification. With no motion to vacate, the clarified award stood. Appraiser testimony cannot change an award.
Limits: A federal prediction of Minnesota law, not binding on Minnesota courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of 3041 Ocean, Inc. v Seneca Ins. Co.
New York Supreme Court, Kings County · March 13, 2026 · 88 Misc 3d 1233(A), 2026 NY Slip Op 50315(U)
In appointing an umpire under section 3408, the court reviewed candidates' CVs, refused candidates with no information or a poor record, and chose one who had worked for both owners and insurers.
Limits: Trial court; unpublished; commercial fire policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Maksym v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · February 24, 2026 · Docket No. 372827 (published)
Cantina is read narrowly. Paying for items the insurer found covered while disputing others does not admit coverage for the disputed ones, so there is no appraisal of them until coverage is decided.
Limits: Published but subject to revision until final publication. It also reversed in part on whether a denial letter was a formal denial ending suit-period tolling.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Talluri v. AIG Prop. Cas. Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit (unpublished) · February 10, 2026 · No. 24-30744
After AIG paid about $10 million on a $16 million Ida appraisal award, the earlier payments were still tried as a bad-faith question. The court upheld a defense verdict: the jury found the insureds had not proved the insurer got satisfactory proof of loss and paid late. Leaving the award amount out of the trial, even if wrong, was harmless.
Limits: Unpublished federal appeal; decided on evidence rulings, not on whether paying an award ends penalty claims.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nashville Communications, Inc. v. Auto-Owners (Mutual) Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, M.D. Tennessee · November 13, 2025 · No. 3:24-cv-01020, Doc. 47
The court held an award replacing the whole roof binding as to the amount of loss, with scope of work within the panel's power, but rejected a bad-faith penalty claim because the insurer had substantial legal grounds to dispute causation.
Limits: Federal trial court. Opinion signed 2025-11-12, filed 2025-11-13.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Ohio Court of Appeals, 12th District (Butler County) · November 10, 2025 · 2025-Ohio-5089 (Nos. CA2024-07-091, CA2024-09-113)
The court affirmed the denial of a motion to compel appraisal. Whether code required a full roof replacement and whether the policy covered it were law and coverage questions that the policy kept out of appraisal. State Farm had reasonable justification, so the bad faith claim failed.
Limits: Homeowner policy. Rests on this policy's express exclusions. The court did not decide whether causation can go to appraisal, and said the dispute was not about causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Andazola v. Travelers Personal Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals, District III (unpublished per curiam) · September 30, 2025 · No. 2024AP750
Paying the full appraisal award cured the insurer's breach, so the contract claim was dismissed. But the insured's bad faith and statutory interest claims, based on the insurer's handling and delay before appraisal, went back for trial because a jury could find the delay unreasonable.
Limits: Unpublished per curiam; under Wis. Stat. 809.23(3) it cannot be cited as precedent. Homeowner hail and workmanship claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Vento v. Vermont Mutual Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Appeals Court · August 19, 2025 · No. 24-P-643 (Rule 23.0 memorandum and order)
After referees fixed a fire loss and the insurer paid the award less earlier payments, the insured's c. 93A and 176D claim was tried to a jury, which found for the insurer. The breach of contract claim was properly dismissed as duplicative.
Limits: Unpublished Rule 23.0 order: persuasive only, not binding. It does not decide whether paying an award bars a c. 93A claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit (Indiana law) · July 25, 2025 · No. 24-1307
Predicting Indiana law, the court held an umpire acted within his authority when he decided hail, not wear and tear, damaged the roofs, and the award was binding. Appraisers may not decide liability. The policy's right-to-deny clause keeps defenses unrelated to the award but does not let the insurer refuse to pay because it disagrees on cause.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Indiana law; not binding on Indiana state courts. It notes Indiana courts have not squarely decided causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Morris v. Access Home Ins. Co.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Third Circuit · May 21, 2025 · No. 25-25 (La. App. 3 Cir. 5/21/25) (writ denied; memorandum opinion)
The policy endorsement made appraisal non-binding, and that language was not ambiguous, so the insureds could not get summary judgment on the appraisal amounts. Their concession that the appraisers could not always say which hurricane caused what damage was itself a genuine fact dispute.
Limits: Memorandum opinion on a writ application (Hurricanes Laura and Delta, LIGA after the insurer failed). The Louisiana Supreme Court declined to consider a further writ as untimely (No. 2025-CC-00989, Nov. 12, 2025), without reaching the merits.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Zhao v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Second District · May 12, 2025 · 2025 IL App (2d) 240723
The court ordered appraisal of a hail claim where the insurer called the window dispute a coverage question. Coverage and law are for the court, but some causation questions are part of setting the amount of loss. A late-notice defense did not stop appraisal.
Limits: One published Second District decision on a State Farm homeowners policy. Federal courts in Illinois have gone both ways on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
3201 St. Charles Avenue Condominium Homeowners Ass'n v. Lexington Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. La. · April 30, 2025 · No. 23-2314, Rec. Doc. 28
The court said appraisers may make causation findings where an exclusion is disputed and that the insurer can still deny coverage after. An insurer could not narrow appraisal to wind damage only. But the insured waited about two and a half years after its demand, far past a reasonable time, so appraisal was denied.
Limits: Federal decision on a Hurricane Ida policy that said the insurer keeps its right to deny the claim after appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
BRE Hotels & Resorts LLC v. ACE American Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · April 25, 2025 · No. 1:24-cv-00159-MWJS-KJM, ECF No. 78
Asked to pick an umpire, the court weighed experience with the type of loss, lack of bias, and nearness and available time, and chose a retired Hawaii Supreme Court justice familiar with local construction costs over an out-of-state retired judge.
Limits: Federal court order under the parties' agreed procedure; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
First Assembly of God Church of Leesville v. Church Mut. Ins. Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit (unpublished) · April 14, 2025 · No. 24-30173
A jury could be told the appraisal award is presumed accurate even though the award was not binding: an award can be presumed accurate without being binding.
Limits: Unpublished federal appeal from a Hurricane Laura claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Church Mutual Ins. Co., S.I. v. Ephesus Richmond Seventh-Day Adventist Church
Court of Appeals of Virginia · April 8, 2025 · No. 0628-24-2 (published)
The appraisal clause in one policy was not an agreement to arbitrate, so the circuit court lacked jurisdiction to modify the award under the Virginia Uniform Arbitration Act. The court described appraisal as a process to resolve a disagreement over value.
Limits: Decided on the wording of that contract. Left open whether the Act can ever reach an appraisal. Not a ruling on coverage or causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Vermont Mutual Insurance Co. v. New England Property Services Group, LLC
Rhode Island Supreme Court · March 20, 2025 · No. 2023-335-Appeal (slip opinion)
A homeowner appraisal clause is arbitration under the Arbitration Act. The award was vacated for evident partiality where the contractor-assignee's sole owner served as its appraiser and the award was not unanimous. A policy saying only competent cannot shield that.
Limits: Slip opinion, no reporter cite found. Applies the Grabbert two-step test (improper interest plus causal link).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of Perry v Hanover Ins. Group
Appellate Division, Fourth Department · March 14, 2025 · 236 AD3d 1301, 2025 NY Slip Op 01441
Neither CPLR 7601 nor Insurance Law 3408 lets a court order an appraisal panel to use a particular method to set replacement cost. That relief is available only in a regular lawsuit. The court said CPLR 7601 can be used to confirm, modify or vacate an award.
Limits: Fire loss; the court did not decide the waiver argument.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cook v. Nationwide General Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Oregon · March 14, 2025 · No. 3:24-cv-01686-AB (D. Or.)
The insured could force appraisal. A policy requiring the insurer's consent was less favorable than ORS 742.232, so the statute's wording (either side may demand) was read into the policy under ORS 742.021.
Limits: Federal trial court opinion, four pages. Wilson (2024) applied a similar clause as written in a different posture, without discussing ORS 742.021.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
New England Property Services Group, LLC v. Vermont Mutual Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · March 10, 2025 · No. 2024-67-Appeal (slip opinion)
A party that took part in an appraisal without objection and sought confirmation under the Arbitration Act could not later say the Act does not apply, even though the clause omitted disinterested.
Limits: Slip opinion. Affirmed denial of a Rule 60(b)(4) motion; the earlier vacatur was not appealed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
New England Property Services Group, LLC v. NGM Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · February 11, 2025 · No. 2023-238-Appeal (slip opinion)
Appraisal awards are treated as arbitration awards and reviewed very narrowly. A later labor-price update is not a miscalculation, and there is no right to a second appraisal. An insurer that paid the award promptly and refused to supplement it was not in breach or bad faith, and using unlicensed inspectors alone is not bad faith.
Limits: Slip opinion. Summary judgment on a contractor-assignee's claims.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ariel, Inc. v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Minnesota Court of Appeals · December 16, 2024 · 15 N.W.3d 673 (No. A24-0604)
A demand for appraisal is not a suit, so the two-year suit limit does not bar it while the insured can still sue on time. Appraisal needs a disagreement over the amount of loss first.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kennedy v. GeoVera Specialty Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. La. · November 22, 2024 · No. 23-6395, Rec. Doc. 18
The court struck a $146,436.65 award because the insured appraiser flat fee schedule rose with his valuation, which worked like a contingency fee and made him not impartial under the policy. A neutral umpire signature did not cure it, and appraisal had to restart with impartial appraisers.
Limits: Decided on policy wording that barred appraisers paid by the award, not on the appraisal code; federal court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wilson v. Liberty Insurance Corp.
U.S. District Court, District of Oregon · November 1, 2024 · No. 3:24-cv-00856-SB (D. Or.)
Applying Oregon law, the court ordered a homeowner to resume appraisal. A policy saying appraisal needs both sides' agreement to be bound became a condition precedent to suit once both sides took part, and the insured could not leave the process.
Limits: Federal trial court opinion by a magistrate judge. It applied the consent clause as written and did not discuss ORS 742.021. Cook (2025) took a different approach when an insurer refused consent.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Schmidt v. Farmers Mutual Hail Insurance Co. of Iowa
Iowa Court of Appeals · October 2, 2024 · No. 23-0894
Homeowners who did not claim fraud, mistake or misfeasance could not defeat a binding appraisal award by arguing the storm caused more damage than the panel found.
Limits: Unpublished Court of Appeals decision. Not controlling authority under Iowa R. App. P. 6.904(2).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Willeford v. Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit · September 27, 2024 · No. 2024-C-0489 (La. App. 4 Cir. 9/27/24)
After the insured made written demands, the insurer could not refuse to take part by calling appraisal premature, and by not naming an appraiser it waived that right. The court would not appoint an umpire, because the clause lets a judge appoint one only when two appraisers cannot agree, and it also undid the order letting the insurer name an appraiser late. Because the clause made the result not binding and the suit showed a coverage and amount dispute, an umpire request was beyond the clause.
Limits: Writ decision on a Hurricane Ida claim under a policy saying an appraisal decision is not binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Patrick v. Liberty Mutual Group, Inc.
U.S. District Court, E.D. Kentucky · September 26, 2024 · No. 7:21-CV-74-REW-EBA
After the court compelled appraisal on the insurer's motion and the insurer paid the agreed award, the contract claim failed, and the insureds were not prevailing parties entitled to costs or pre-judgment interest. Invoking appraisal after suit was filed was treated as proper and timely.
Limits: Federal court. The earlier order compelling appraisal, which the court says found the demand proper and timely, is not published.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
BRE Hotels & Resorts LLC v. ACE American Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · September 11, 2024 · No. 1:24-cv-00159-MWJS-KJM, ECF No. 47
The court compelled appraisal of storm losses at two resorts. A dispute over whether the storm or old construction defects damaged tile underlayment is a factual causation question the panel may decide. Whether the policy pays to replace matching undamaged tiles is coverage, for the court. Claimed non-cooperation did not block appraisal without a showing of harm.
Limits: Federal court; did not decide whether Hawaii or New York law applied; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Holaday v. Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids, Michigan
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · August 20, 2024 · No. 1 CA-CV 23-0541 (mem. decision)
A homeowners policy limited appraisal to the amount of loss and barred it from deciding causation or whether an item is insured. The panel did not decide those issues, so it did not exceed its powers, but the trial court was wrong to confirm the award and enter judgment while causation and coverage were still open. The award is the ceiling on the amount of loss once those are decided.
Limits: Memorandum decision, not precedent under Ariz. Sup. Ct. R. 111(c). Decided on the policy wording. The court did not decide whether causation is inherently part of appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Anderson v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · August 13, 2024 · No. 1 CA-CV 23-0611 (mem. decision)
The policy let appraisers decide only the amount of loss, and the appraisers did not decide causation or coverage. The trial court was wrong to treat the award as settling them, so its confirmation order, the judgment and the fee award were vacated and the case sent back. A party need not file a separate suit before appraisal to keep these defenses.
Limits: Memorandum decision, not precedent under Ariz. Sup. Ct. R. 111(c). Decided on the policy wording. The court declined to adopt or rely on federal or out-of-state cases.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
B.R.S. Real Estate, Inc. v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London
U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit · August 12, 2024 · No. 23-1531
Applying Rhode Island law, the court treated appraisal as arbitration with a strong presumption of validity. A challenge to an appraiser or umpire whose background was known before the appraisal came too late, and a lawyer may serve as umpire if otherwise qualified.
Limits: Federal court applying Rhode Island law. The lawyer-as-umpire point was an alternative ground; the main ground was that the challenge came too late.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
New Hope Church of God Waldorf v. Brotherhood Mutual Insurance
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · August 1, 2024 · Civ. No. MJM-23-2341 (D. Md.)
The court denied, without prejudice, a motion to compel appraisal because the dispute was whether the loss was covered at all. An appraisal would serve no purpose if the loss is not covered.
Limits: Commercial property policy; federal ruling that does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Quach v. California Commerce Club, Inc.
Supreme Court of California · July 25, 2024 · 16 Cal.5th 562 (No. S275121)
A party can waive the right to compel arbitration by litigation conduct, and the other side does not have to show prejudice. California courts now apply ordinary contract waiver principles.
Limits: Employment arbitration case, not insurance appraisal. No published appraisal decision has applied it yet.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Thompson v. Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · June 25, 2024 · No. 1:22-cv-02379-JMC (D. Md.)
The court compelled appraisal of a homeowner's roof claim. Whether particular damage is covered is outside the appraisal clause, so appraisers had to itemize and the insurer could contest coverage afterward. Filing complaints and suit did not waive appraisal without actual prejudice.
Limits: Federal magistrate judge ruling; does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bailey v. Certain Interested Underwriters at Lloyd's London
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit · May 31, 2024 · No. 23-1642 (unpublished)
Where the insurer paid the full appraisal panel award, which was less than half of what the insureds demanded, bad faith and unfair trade practices claims based on a valuation dispute were properly dismissed.
Limits: Unpublished federal opinion applying North Carolina law; not binding. It does not address statutory interest or attorney's fees.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bojovic v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · May 23, 2024 · Docket No. 362469 (unpublished)
Once the insurer admitted the water leak was covered, disputes over whether damage to the bathroom and sunroom came from the leak were scope-of-loss questions for the appraiser, not coverage questions for the court. The insured must still prove each loss was caused by the covered event.
Limits: Unpublished, so not binding precedent. Relies on Cantina (2024).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance Co. v. Sunset Villas Phase III Condominium Ass'n
Florida Third District Court of Appeal · May 15, 2024 · No. 3D23-1672 (Fla. 3d DCA 2024)
When the parties dispute whether post-loss conditions were met, the trial court must hold an evidentiary hearing before compelling appraisal. If appraisal is ripe, the court may control the order of appraisal and coverage. A claim of waiver failed because the insured demanded appraisal at the start.
Limits: Commercial condominium claim; Third District.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Badgerland Restoration & Remodeling, Inc. v. Federated Mutual Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals, District IV (published) · May 9, 2024 · 2024 WI App 36, No. 2023AP2109
The complaint stated a claim that the insurer breached the policy by refusing an appraisal demand on the ground that the amount of loss was not disputed. The other side must abide by an invoked appraisal clause unless it shows waiver, bad faith or illegality. Waiver by delay that causes prejudice, or by conduct inconsistent with appraisal, needs a factual record. Reversed and remanded.
Limits: Decided on a motion to dismiss. The reasonable-time and waiver standard is drawn from other states' cases.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Detroit Club Management Corp. v. Cincinnati Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · March 25, 2024 · No. 22-13057
A dispute over which parts of a building the smoke actually damaged is a factual question for appraisers, not a coverage question for the court. Courts in the district have taken a broad view of Kwaiser.
Limits: Federal, commercial policy, not binding on state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Meier v. Wadena Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · March 8, 2024 · Nos. 23-2282, 23-2354
Applying Wisconsin law, the court upheld an umpire's award that used the broad evidence rule for actual cash value. The insurer paid the binding award, so there was neither breach of contract nor bad faith.
Limits: Federal court predicting Wisconsin law; not binding on Wisconsin courts. Commercial fire loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rodriguez v. Safeco Insurance Co. of Indiana
Supreme Court of Texas · February 2, 2024 · 684 S.W.3d 789 (Tex. 2024), No. 23-0534 (answering a certified question from the Fifth Circuit)
When an insurer pays the full appraisal award plus any statutory interest, chapter 542A bars the insured's attorney's fees because no money judgment is left to base them on.
Limits: Chapter 542A claims only (weather-related property claims).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
American Coastal Insurance Co. v. San Marco Villas Condominium Ass'n
Supreme Court of Florida · February 1, 2024 · No. SC2021-0883 (Fla. 2024)
A trial court has discretion over the order in which coverage and amount-of-loss issues are decided. It may compel appraisal while a coverage defense such as fraud is still open. Coverage defenses stay outside appraisal and are decided in court.
Limits: Did not decide whether the trial court abused its discretion on the facts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cantina Enterprises II Inc. v. Property-Owners Insurance Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · January 18, 2024 · 349 Mich App 682; 28 NW3d 800 (Docket No. 363105)
Partial payments waived the policy's 60-day proof-of-loss deadline. Where the insurer admitted the fire was covered, a fight over which items count as business personal property was an amount-of-loss question and the court had to order appraisal and name an umpire. Agency bulletins are advisory only.
Limits: Published. Read narrowly by Maksym (2026).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
L & M Auto Repair, LLC v. Federated Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Kansas (magistrate judge) · January 17, 2024 · No. 6:23-cv-01203, ECF No. 20 (D. Kan. Jan. 17, 2024)
On undisputed facts, the court disqualified the insured's appraiser as not impartial under a policy calling for competent and impartial appraisers, and held a request to appoint an umpire premature until impartial appraisers had tried to agree.
Limits: A federal magistrate judge's order on an unopposed motion. It does not discuss Friday or whether Kansas enforces appraisal, and it does not mention the appraiser's fee.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Great American Insurance Co. v. Crystal Shores Owners Association, Inc.
Supreme Court of Alabama · December 22, 2023 · No. SC-2023-0092
An appraisal clause is not an arbitration clause under the Federal Arbitration Act, whether federal or Alabama law defines the term, so an order denying an insurer's motion to invoke appraisal cannot be appealed right away. The appeal was dismissed.
Limits: Decides appealability, not the grounds for vacating an award. Three justices concurred only in the result. The U.S. Supreme Court denied review in 2024.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Owners Insurance Co. v. HUB Multifamily, LLC
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · November 29, 2023 · No. 1:23-cv-0060-RGJ
The court appointed a retired judge with insurance-dispute experience as umpire. General local ties do not disqualify a candidate, and a background mostly working for insureds does not either; the court preferred relevant experience and ordered the policy's equal split of umpire expenses.
Limits: Federal court; the clause calls for a competent and impartial appraiser.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of Stanz v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.
Appellate Division, Fourth Department · November 17, 2023 · 221 AD3d 1479, 2023 NY Slip Op 05832
After an award is set aside through no fault of the insureds, a court cannot send them back to further appraisal. They may sue on the policy. The insurer had first refused the appraisal demand and the court compelled it.
Limits: The decision to set the award aside was not appealed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ball v. Liberty Mutual Group Inc.
U.S. District Court, E.D. Kentucky · October 20, 2023 · No. 5:22-179-DCR, 2023 WL 6961557
After the insurer invoked appraisal following the suit, both appraisers agreed on an amount and the insurer paid it. The breach-of-contract claim failed because the agreed amount set the loss. New statutory late-payment and unfair-practices theories raised first in opposing summary judgment were not considered.
Limits: Federal court; not a merits ruling on KRS 304.12-235.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
First Protective Insurance Co. v. Rike
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of North Carolina · October 12, 2023 · No. 4:22-CV-42-FL
A policy appraisal is not an arbitration under the state arbitration act, so the act's immunity and fee provisions did not protect an appraisal umpire accused of hiding prior work for the insured's side.
Limits: A federal trial court order at the pleadings stage. It did not decide that the umpire was biased or the award invalid. The Fourth Circuit affirmed in an unpublished opinion, which is not binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Groenig v. Safeco Insurance Co. of America
U.S. District Court, D. Idaho · September 21, 2023 · No. 1:20-cv-00538-BLW (Dkt. 77)
Appraisers set the amount only for items they were asked about and left denied roof and crawlspace items as coverage issues. The insured could sue on those items. Bad faith failed because the claim was fairly debatable, despite a complaint that the insurer's appraiser was biased.
Limits: Federal trial court summary judgment order. Not binding Idaho law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Monarch Claims Consultants, Inc. v. Fleming
Florida First District Court of Appeal · September 6, 2023 · No. 1D22-601 (Fla. 1st DCA 2023)
A public adjuster contract that took the 10% statutory maximum and also required the insured to name the adjuster as appraiser for another 10% broke the fee cap. The promise to appoint the adjuster as appraiser was itself a thing of value, so the whole contract was void.
Limits: Venue appeal; decided under the emergency-claim 10% cap.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Montler v. Belfor USA Group, Inc. (First American Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co.)
Washington Court of Appeals, Division III (unpublished) · August 31, 2023 · No. 39497-2-III, 28 Wn. App. 2d 1006 (unpublished)
The trial court did not have to enforce appraisal awards that expressly left coverage out while causation and coverage of mold damage were still disputed. Awards are otherwise binding on the amount of loss absent proof of bias. The insurer's delay in naming an appraiser did not violate IFCA, and the Olympic Steamship fee award was reversed because the insured obtained nothing beyond what she had already been paid.
Limits: Unpublished, nonbinding. The court did not decide whether appraisers may decide causation. Review denied 2024 (No. 102421-5).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rod & Reel, Inc. v. State Automobile Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · July 28, 2023 · Civ. No. DKC 20-3388 (D. Md.) (ECF 63)
After an appraisal set monthly business-income losses, the court held the insurer owed the unpaid months of the award. The bad-faith claim could not be decided on summary judgment because it turns on how the insurer handled the claim, not the result.
Limits: Commercial policy; the insurer had not paid the full award; federal ruling that does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Papagiannopoulous
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · July 27, 2023 · No. 8:22-cv-02314-LKG (D. Md.)
An insurer asked the court to declare the insured's appraisers unqualified because of ties to the public adjuster's sister company. The court held the appraisal dispute is covered by the Federal Arbitration Act, dismissed the case, and said a challenge to an appraiser's qualifications is premature until the appraisal is complete.
Limits: Commercial property policy; Federal Arbitration Act; federal ruling that does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wright v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Alaska · July 11, 2023 · No. 3:19-cv-00323-HRH, Doc. 93 (D. Alaska)
The appraisal statute makes the policy include an appraisal clause. It does not force every dispute into appraisal. A policy term barring an appraisal demand after the party sues does not conflict with the statute, so insureds who sued in 2019 could not compel appraisal in 2023.
Limits: Federal trial-court order on a motion to compel, persuasive only. It did not decide waiver by conduct or whether appraisers may decide coverage questions.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Romeo v. Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · May 3, 2023 · No. 2022-50-Appeal (slip opinion)
An appraisal demand made within the policy's limitation period and refused by the insurer was timely, and the clock does not restart. The insurer's later insistence that appraisal was required bound it, and the court ordered appraisal.
Limits: Slip opinion; turned on that policy limitation clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wesser v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · April 26, 2023 · 989 N.W.2d 294 (No. A21-1587)
A fire policy clause that says no interest accrues on the loss until it becomes payable is enough to bar preaward interest on an appraisal award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
O'Connor v. Allied Trust Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. La. · April 20, 2023 · No. 23-218, Rec. Doc. 32
When a policy says any appraisal outcome is not binding, an award does not set the amount of loss and the court will not confirm it. The court was not persuaded that the standard fire policy changed that for a homeowner policy.
Limits: Federal decision on a Hurricane Ida policy that began before the residential clause took effect.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Martinique Properties, LLC v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's of London
U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · March 1, 2023 · 60 F.4th 1206 (8th Cir. 2023) (No. 21-3561)
An Omaha apartment owner sued to undo a binding appraisal award on a Lloyd's policy, saying it used wrong figures. The court treated the award as an arbitration award and affirmed dismissal because no lawful ground to vacate it was alleged.
Limits: Federal court, surplus-lines Lloyd's policy, decided under federal arbitration law. It did not apply Rawlings or Nebraska's insurance arbitration exclusion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Krafchow v. Dongbu Insurance Co.
Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals (published opinion) · February 17, 2023 · 152 Hawai‘i 248, 525 P.3d 697; Nos. CAAP-21-0000513 and CAAP-21-0000517
The appraisal clauses in a homeowners policy and two dwelling fire policies are arbitration agreements under chapter 658A. Because the panel was to set "the amount of loss", the appraiser and umpire had to value what the insured lost to the wildfire, not decide coverage or what the insurer owed. Awards that ordered payment of set amounts were vacated.
Limits: Reads policies that do not define "loss". Does not decide who decides causation. The Hawaii Supreme Court rejected certiorari on June 30, 2023.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Parrish v. State Farm Florida Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Florida · February 9, 2023 · No. SC21-172 (Fla. 2023)
An appraiser who, or whose firm, will be paid a contingency fee as the insured's public adjuster is not "disinterested" under the policy. The court approved the Second District and disapproved the Third District's Brickell Harbour decision to the extent inconsistent.
Limits: Decides only the policy word "disinterested". Did not decide "impartial" or "independent".
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · January 25, 2023 · No. 1:19-cv-04875-JPH-MG, Dkt. 94 (reconsideration denied 2023-08-18, Dkt. 111)
The umpire's finding that hail caused the roof damage, and its dollar value, were binding. The policy's "right to deny the claim" clause keeps other defenses alive but does not let the insurer ignore the award because it disagrees on cause. The court said earlier S.D. Indiana decisions leaving causation to the court came before Villas.
Limits: Federal trial court. Affirmed by the Seventh Circuit on 2025-07-25 (No. 24-1307).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · January 18, 2023 · No. 3:21-cv-274-RGJ, 2023 WL 320004
The court compelled appraisal and let the panel decide whether a June 2019 hailstorm caused the damage, and its amount, even though the policy did not say the panel decides cause. The panel could not include damage outside the policy period.
Limits: Federal court; the filed stamp reads January 19, 2023, the order is dated January 18.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Khushi Partnership v. Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, M.D. Tennessee · January 13, 2023 · No. 3:22-cv-00265, Doc. 44
The court ordered appraisal where the insurer admitted wind and hail damage was covered, noting that Tennessee courts have not decided whether appraisal must wait for coverage.
Limits: Federal trial court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cunningham v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Oregon · December 27, 2022 · No. 6:21-cv-00264-MK (D. Or.)
After an appraisal award, the insurer could still decide what the policy covered. The appraisers' statements about which damage they priced were evidence, and a fact question on coverage survived. The good-faith claim failed because State Farm acted timely and denied loss it believed was excluded.
Limits: Federal summary judgment ruling by a magistrate judge. It did not decide whether appraisers may make causation findings.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Gardner v. Erie Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia · November 4, 2022 · No. 22-1977 (RC)
Insureds who sued to compel appraisal or appoint an umpire almost three years after a sewer loss were barred by the policy's one-year suit clause. The appraisal clause does not override it, and COVID orders did not toll it.
Limits: Federal trial court predicting D.C. law; non-binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Post River Road, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · November 1, 2022 · No. 1317 EDA 2021
A denial of a motion to compel appraisal was vacated. The trial court must decide which expense items are inside the appraisal clause, and the timeliness and waiver questions were sent back without being decided.
Limits: Non-precedential memorandum; commercial property policy with a 60-day demand clause. Read from a HallApproved copy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Haddock v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · November 1, 2022 · 638 F. Supp. 3d 748 (No. 4:21-cv-12395)
Predicting Michigan law, the court held that appraisers may, and must, decide whether claimed damage came from the covered cause of loss once the insurer admits a covered loss. True coverage defenses are still for the court first.
Limits: Federal prediction of Michigan law; not binding on Michigan courts. Amended opinion; the original of 2022-10-25 differed only in a statutory citation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Angus v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of Utah · September 30, 2022 · No. 1:21-cv-00034-JNP-JCB (D. Utah 2022)
The court said a jury could likely find bad faith in an alleged refusal to appraise. It found no controlling Utah law on whether attorney and public adjuster fees alone can support a bad faith claim, found the Blakely reasoning thin, and denied summary judgment without prejudice.
Limits: Trial-level federal decision; it asked the parties about certifying the fee question to the Utah Supreme Court. The outcome of that step was not found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Point-O-Woods, LLC v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · August 31, 2022 · No. 2:22-cv-54-KS-MTP
Motion to compel appraisal denied without prejudice. The court said appraisal cannot decide causation or coverage, only value, and that disputed causation and coverage should be decided first.
Limits: Federal district court, Hurricane Zeta apartment-complex claim; reads Kuehn narrowly and disagrees that appraisal may go first.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Westview Village v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Ohio · August 22, 2022 · No. 1:22-cv-00549, 2022 WL 3584263
A federal judge applying Ohio law predicted the Ohio Supreme Court would let an appraisal panel decide causation when the policy does not take it out. He relied on Saba's reference to the "extent" of the loss.
Limits: Federal court prediction of Ohio law; no state court has decided it. The policy there did not define "amount of loss" or exclude causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Allied Trust Ins. Co. v. Fuselier
U.S. District Court, W.D. La. · August 5, 2022 · No. 2:22-cv-01265, Rec. Doc. 12
The insurer waited seven months after receiving the insured estimates to demand appraisal, which was too late. Appraisal must be demanded within a reasonable time after the amount dispute arises, and about four months or more is too long. The court also held a non-binding appraisal result has no binding effect and did not decide whether the standard fire policy applies.
Limits: Federal decision on a Hurricane Laura and Delta claim; the policy form said outcomes were not binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Auto Club Insurance Co. of Florida v. Santee
Florida Third District Court of Appeal · July 20, 2022 · No. 3D21-1853 (Fla. 3d DCA 2022)
Filing suit does not by itself waive the right to appraisal, and the insureds here did not waive it because they asked for appraisal in their complaint. The trial court still needed to hold a hearing on whether post-loss duties were met.
Limits: Short opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
O'Malley-Joyce v. Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · June 28, 2022 · No. 2021-0068 (Grafton)
Homeowners were paid an appraisal award, then sued for more for breach of contract and bad faith. The trial court granted summary judgment for the insurer, treating the appraisal as binding. The Supreme Court said the homeowners had not preserved their arguments, reviewed only for plain error, and found none because whether a clause without the word "binding" binds the parties is a question of first impression.
Limits: Did not decide whether the clause binds or whether payment of an award ends later claims. The homeowner policy said "impartial" and had the appraisers pick the umpire; the opinion does not discuss RSA 407:22.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ridgewood Bay Resort, Inc. v. Auto-Owners Ins. Co.
Minnesota Court of Appeals · June 20, 2022 · No. A21-1352 (nonprecedential)
A panel did not exceed its authority by deciding whether a septic system was part of the building when valuing demolition costs, a fact question incidental to the amount of loss.
Limits: Nonprecedential. The insured had proposed the award form wording it later challenged.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
James Hamilton Properties, LLC v. Great Midwest Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. Kentucky · June 8, 2022 · No. 21-95-DLB (Pikeville)
The court appointed an umpire over the insured's argument that KRS 417.050(2) bars arbitration in insurance contracts, enforcing the policy's court-appointment language. It said no Kentucky court has decided whether the umpire's decision is binding arbitration and reserved that question, and said an umpire's impartiality should be held to a higher standard than an appraiser's.
Limits: Federal court; reserved the binding-effect question.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co. v. Galena at Wildspring Condominium Association
Illinois Appellate Court, Second District · May 23, 2022 · 2022 IL App (2d) 210394
No prejudgment interest was owed on an appraisal award. The amount was not readily ascertainable before the award, the policy made payment due 30 days after it, and the insurer paid on time.
Limits: Interest Act claim reviewed for abuse of discretion. The insured did not argue the delay was vexatious, so that point was forfeited.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Legend's Creek Homeowners Association v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of America
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit (Indiana law) · May 10, 2022 · 33 F.4th 932
A motion to compel appraisal counts as a "legal action" under a policy's two-year suit limit. The insured had no right to compel appraisal after the two years ran, so the resulting award was void.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Indiana law. Turned on that policy's suit-limit wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Travelers Indemnity Co. of America v. Townes of Cedar Ridge Condominium Association
Illinois Appellate Court, Third District · April 25, 2022 · 2022 IL App (3d) 200542
An insurer that denied a hail appraisal demand as a coverage dispute could not then ask a court to declare the denial proper. Once it refused, no live controversy remained for a declaratory judgment.
Limits: Decides only whether a declaratory judgment lies; it does not decide whether the dispute was appraisable.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Houle v. Liberty Insurance Corp.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · March 30, 2022 · 271 A.3d 591
After an appraisal award, the insureds' claims that the insurer breached the policy and acted in bad faith by investigating poorly could go forward. The trial court was wrong to dismiss them on the ground that appraisal had settled the claim.
Limits: Decided on the pleadings; no finding that the insurer acted in bad faith.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · March 28, 2022 · No. 4:19-CV-186-JHM
The court vacated an appraisal award because the insured's appraiser was not impartial: his fee deal gave no pay without added recovery, he promised a referral fee to the assignee roofer, and he set out to add scope. It did not decide whether the umpire exceeded his authority on cause.
Limits: Federal summary judgment on these facts; the opinion is signed March 28, 2022 and stamped filed March 29.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kellogg v. Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co. (second action)
Connecticut Appellate Court · March 22, 2022 · 211 Conn. App. 335
In a later suit for breach of contract, CUTPA/CUIPA and promissory estoppel over the same loss, the trial court wrongly denied the insurer summary judgment by relying on findings from the reversed vacatur ruling. The case was sent back so the insurer could pursue its motion.
Limits: Procedural. It did not decide whether the claims survive an appraisal award or payment of it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Belleza v. Erie Insurance
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · March 9, 2022 · No. 668 WDA 2021
No prejudgment interest was added to an umpire's award because the insured had agreed appraisal would resolve her claims and never raised interest. Section 7342(b) applied to the entry of judgment on the award.
Limits: Non-precedential memorandum; rests on the settlement agreement, not a rule that awards never carry interest.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Brewer v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District · March 8, 2022 · 641 S.W.3d 445 (No. WD84331)
A dispute over how much damage there was and what repairs it needs, where the insurer says parts are not covered, is a coverage dispute. The appraisal clause does not reach it, so appointing an umpire was wrong. The court dismissed the umpire petition without prejudice as premature.
Limits: Rental dwelling policy. Coverage issues must be settled first; appraisal may follow.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Elm Creek Courthome Ass'n v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Minnesota Court of Appeals · February 14, 2022 · No. A21-0964 (published)
The written notice of claim that starts preaward interest on an appraisal award must come from the claimant to the insurer. The interest was recalculated and the case sent back.
Limits: Decided before Wesser; interest depends on policy wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Leadbetter v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · February 10, 2022 · Docket No. 354901 (unpublished)
The trial court must decide the insurer's coverage defenses, such as unmet policy conditions, before ordering appraisal. If only the scope of loss is disputed, the case can go straight to appraisal.
Limits: Unpublished, so not binding precedent.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Klass v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court · January 11, 2022 · 341 Conn. 735, SC 20451
When the insurer concedes a covered peril, the extent of its duty to replace undamaged adjacent items so they match is part of the amount of loss and goes to appraisal. The court said coverage is a legal question for the courts, treated causation as a different question, and declined to take sides in the out-of-state split on whether appraisers may decide causation.
Limits: Homeowner's wind loss and the matching statute, § 38a-316e. The coverage line is a footnote the parties agreed to, not a holding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Andersen v. Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids, Michigan
U.S. District Court for the District of Utah · December 22, 2021 · No. 1:20-cv-115-DAK-DBP (D. Utah 2021)
Insureds who disagreed with the insurer's scope of loss, replaced the roof, and sued without invoking the policy's appraisal clause could not recover repair costs or fees as bad faith damages.
Limits: Trial-level federal decision predicting Utah law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Axis Surplus Ins. Co. v. Condor Corp.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · December 7, 2021 · No. 21-1022 (8th Cir.)
Applying Minnesota law, a dispute over whether hail damage came before or during the policy period is part of the amount of loss, so the appraisers decide it.
Limits: A federal decision on Minnesota law, not binding on Minnesota courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Musto v. Liberty Insurance Corp.
U.S. District Court, District of Maine · November 21, 2021 · No. 1:20-cv-00188-GZS (D. Me. Nov. 21, 2021) (recommended decision), aff'd (D. Me. Jan. 11, 2022)
A federal court upheld a homeowner appraisal award signed by the insurer's appraiser and the umpire after the insured's appraiser stopped taking part. The insurer did not waive appraisal by objecting to the insured's appraiser while naming its own. Once the valid award was tendered, the contract and unfair claims practice claims failed.
Limits: Federal trial court predicting Maine law; not binding on Maine courts. Homeowner policy, not the fire policy form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Giles v. GEICO General Insurance Co.
Tennessee Court of Appeals · October 28, 2021 · No. M2021-00165-COA-R3-CV
The bad-faith penalty statute, Tenn. Code Ann. 56-7-105, does not apply to automobile insurance policies.
Limits: Auto policy case; listed only for the statute's reach.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
BonBeck Parker, LLC v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of America
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · October 1, 2021 · 14 F.4th 1169 (No. 20-1192)
Applying Colorado law, the phrase "amount of loss" in a commercial hail policy unambiguously includes causation disputes, so an appraisal panel could decide whether hail caused the disputed roof damage.
Limits: Federal court predicting Colorado law because the Colorado Supreme Court has not ruled; does not bind Colorado state courts. Commercial property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
First Choice Property & Development, LLC v. Travelers Property Casualty Co. of America
U.S. District Court, W.D. Tennessee · September 1, 2021 · No. 1:21-cv-02371-STA-jay, Doc. 18
The court dismissed a petition to set aside an appraisal award, because under Tennessee law the award is binding unless the umpire exceeded his authority and none was alleged.
Limits: Federal trial court predicting Tennessee law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Selective Ins. Co. of South Carolina v. Sela
U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · August 30, 2021 · No. 20-2029 (8th Cir.)
A bad-faith claim under the Minnesota statute could go forward where an appraisal panel set the amount but a jury resolved coverage.
Limits: A federal decision. The court noted no Minnesota court had interpreted "resolve" in 604.18 subd. 4(c).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Owners Insurance Co. v. Dakota Station II Condominium Ass'n
Colorado Court of Appeals · August 26, 2021 · 2021 COA 114, 499 P.3d 1069 (No. 20CA254)
Where the policy needs at least one impartial appraiser to agree for an award to bind, an award agreed to only by a partial appraiser and the umpire is invalid. The trial court properly found that appraiser partial, and the judgment vacating a $3 million award was affirmed.
Limits: Published appeals court opinion. The motion was brought under the Colorado Uniform Arbitration Act; the opinion does not decide whether that Act governs appraisals.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hart v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · August 21, 2021 · 556 F. Supp. 3d 735 (No. 2:20-cv-10573)
Applying Michigan law, nine add-on appraisal conditions in a State Farm homeowners form were void as contrary to the statute. These included advance itemized documentation, a ban on demanding appraisal after suing, extra notice before asking a judge for an umpire, mandatory professional licenses for appraisers, and bars on appraisers with a financial interest.
Limits: Federal district court, not binding on Michigan state courts. It kept the bar on an umpire with a financial interest.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Church of the Nativity v. GuideOne Specialty Mut. Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Minnesota · August 9, 2021 · No. 21-cv-1398 (D. Minn.)
An appraiser was not shown biased just because he had been paid by the insurer for an earlier appraisal of the same property.
Limits: A federal trial court order, not binding on Minnesota courts. It applied the policy's impartial appraiser clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Woodrum v. Georgia Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
Court of Appeals of Georgia · June 25, 2021 · 360 Ga. App. 126, 860 S.E.2d 900 (No. A21A0320)
Diminution in value can be part of the amount of loss that appraisal settles, but the insurer could not say the award covered it when the award did not show it was assessed. The clause cannot decide whether the insurer is liable for that loss.
Limits: Reversed a summary judgment for the insurer on that record; the liability point is a footnote quoting McGowan. Second appeal; Woodrum I, 347 Ga. App. 89 (2018), was about lay value testimony.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Machado v. Narragansett Bay Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · June 17, 2021 · 252 A.3d 1206
Insureds who cashed the insurer's check and waited almost two years to ask for appraisal did not act reasonably and in good faith, so the insurer was relieved of its duty to appraise.
Limits: Decided on that policy's 180-day replacement-cost notice and the facts; summary judgment.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nationwide General Insurance Co. v. 1616 Gardiner Lane, Inc.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · June 16, 2021 · No. 3:20-CV-651-GNS-CHL, 2021 WL 2459473
The court decided before appraisal that the policy did not require matching undamaged shingles, treating that as a coverage question for the court, and left the amount of loss to the panel.
Limits: Federal court; also denied the insured leave to file late counterclaims.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
DC Plastic Products Corp. v. Westchester Surplus Lines Insurance Co.
United States District Court, District of New Jersey · May 19, 2021 · Civil Action No. 17-13092 (SRC) (unpublished)
The court ordered appraisal of the amount of a Superstorm Sandy property loss and said it would appoint an umpire if the appraisers could not agree. Outstanding coverage issues did not have to be decided first, because appraisers cannot decide liability and the insurer kept its right to deny.
Limits: A federal district court applying New Jersey law, unpublished, on a commercial policy whose wording let a court appoint the umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Luigi’s, Inc. v. United Fire & Casualty Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · May 14, 2021 · 959 N.W.2d 401 (No. 19-1669)
The insurer paid the appraisal award in full within the time the policy allowed, so the insured had no bad-faith delay claim over the payment. Disputing the scope of the award afterward was fairly debatable. Verdicts for breach of contract, bad faith and punitive damages were reversed.
Limits: Commercial property policy with its own 30-day payment term. Opinion amended July 19, 2021.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Sinclair Wyoming Refining Co. v. Infrassure, Ltd.
Supreme Court of Wyoming · May 10, 2021 · 2021 WY 65, 486 P.3d 990
A policy is "issued for delivery" in Wyoming when a Wyoming company is a named insured and the policy covers Wyoming risks, so the insurance code's fee-and-interest remedy can apply even if no copy went to Wyoming.
Limits: Does not discuss appraisal. It decides only when the code applies, and a policy may say otherwise if it does so unambiguously.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Herco, LLC v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co.
Indiana Court of Appeals · April 7, 2021 · No. 20A-PL-1682
The insured got a court-appointed umpire and an award. It then sued for delay and bad faith in a second suit while the first stayed open. Res judicata barred the second suit, because those claims could have been added to the first suit. Payment of an award is not a prerequisite to suing.
Limits: Turns on claim preclusion. It does not say whether a delay claim would succeed on the merits.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
The Travelers Home and Marine Insurance Co. v. Layton
U.S. District Court, D. Idaho · April 5, 2021 · No. 1:20-cv-00509-BLW (Dkt. 22)
When the appraisers could not agree on an umpire, the court picked one from seven candidates under the policy clause, choosing a Boise lawyer with umpire experience.
Limits: Commercial property policy. Federal trial court order.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hinojos v. State Farm Lloyds
Supreme Court of Texas · March 19, 2021 · 619 S.W.3d 651 (Tex. 2021), No. 19-0280
When an insurer accepts a claim but pays only part of what it owes before the statutory deadline, paying the full appraisal award later does not erase its Prompt Payment Act liability for interest and fees.
Limits: The insurer accepted the claim and paid significantly less before the deadline than the appraisers later found it owed. A pre-appraisal payment must roughly correspond to the amount owed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Max v. Great American Security Insurance Co.
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · March 11, 2021 · No. A-0042-19 (unpublished)
Because the parties agreed the umpire's award would be governed by the Alternative Procedure for Dispute Resolution Act, review stopped at the trial court and the appeal was dismissed under N.J.S.A. 2A:23A-18(b).
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent. The bar on appeal came from the parties' agreement, not the standard appraisal clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hill v. Auto-Owners (Mutual) Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. Tennessee · November 30, 2020 · No. 4:19-cv-78, Doc. 39, 2020 WL 7034321
Following Batts, the court held that causation and coverage are for the courts, not the umpire, while admitting it is hard to separate them from the appraised loss.
Limits: Federal trial court on a motion to dismiss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Parko Properties, LLC v. Mercer Insurance Co. of New Jersey
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · November 19, 2020 · No. A-4137-17T2 (unpublished)
The trial court decided coverage first, then sent only the amount of loss to appraisal, and the appraisers agreed on a figure. The insurer did not act in bad faith. The insured could still recover fees, costs and interest under the offer-of-judgment rule after the appraisal, because appraisal is not court-annexed arbitration.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent under R. 1:36-3. A commercial collapse claim. The footnote on waiver of challenges to an appraiser is a passing remark.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Professional, Inc. v. Mutual Benefit Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · November 17, 2020 · No. 1155 WDA 2019
Once either side demands appraisal the other must take part, and filing suit does not by itself revoke that right when the insurer raises it promptly. A coverage dispute is outside appraisal, and a dispute over the cost of repairs already made was not an amount-of-loss dispute.
Limits: Non-precedential memorandum; auto policies.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fortune v. First Protective Insurance Co.
Florida Second District Court of Appeal · September 4, 2020 · No. 2D19-2209 (Fla. 2d DCA 2020)
An insurer that invoked appraisal and paid the award after the 60-day cure period had not, as a matter of law, cured a bad-faith claim for failing to settle in good faith. A lowball offer made in bad faith is not cured by later paying what appraisal finds is owed.
Limits: Second District; decided before s. 624.1551 (adverse adjudication rule for property) and does not decide whether bad faith occurred.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Sinclair Wyoming Refining Co. v. Infrassure, Ltd.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · August 17, 2020 · 970 F.3d 1317 (10th Cir. 2020), No. 19-8018
The court upheld confirmation of a $60.4 million appraisal award on a Wyoming refinery fire. It found no fraud, bias, bad faith or misconduct, including on a claim that the umpire was not disinterested.
Limits: Federal appeals court. New York law governed the appraisal under the policy, so it does not state Wyoming law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Buchanan v. North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
North Carolina Court of Appeals · March 17, 2020 · No. COA19-887
The trial court properly stayed the suit and compelled appraisal because the homeowner policy made full compliance, including appraisal, a condition of suit, despite bad-faith allegations. After the award, summary judgment for the insurer on unfair practices was upheld because it had made payments and done what the policy required.
Limits: Turns on the policy's suit clause and the facts. Slip opinion carries no unpublished-opinion notice.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Oliver v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Ins. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · March 4, 2020 · 939 N.W.2d 749 (No. A18-0367)
The Uniform Arbitration Act does not apply to appraisal awards under the standard fire policy, so its 90-day limit did not bar a request for preaward interest after the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
State Farm Florida Insurance Co. v. Valenti
Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal · December 11, 2019 · 285 So. 3d 963 (Fla. 4th DCA 2019), No. 4D19-205
An insured's public adjuster, who held an assignment of 20% of the recovery and had hired on that basis, could not later serve as the insured's disinterested appraiser.
Limits: Decided on its facts, before Parrish; Parrish now controls the contingency-fee point.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's v BioEnergy Dev. Group LLC
Appellate Division, First Department · December 5, 2019 · 178 AD3d 463, 2019 NY Slip Op 08779
A counterclaim that the insurers held back interim payments until an appraisal panel awarded more than double, and did not pay in full what the panel set, could go forward as a breach of the implied duty of good faith, seeking consequential losses and legal fees.
Limits: Motion to dismiss only; commercial business interruption and property policies.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
River Farm Realty Trust v. Farm Family Casualty Insurance Co.
United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit · November 19, 2019 · No. 19-1188
After a reference award for an ice dam loss, which the insurer paid less earlier payments, the insureds still sued under c. 93A and 176D. The court affirmed judgment for the insurer because no evidence showed unreasonable estimates. A gap between early estimates and the award is not a violation by itself.
Limits: Federal court applying Massachusetts law. Not binding on state courts. No Massachusetts appellate court has ruled on this.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit (Indiana law) · November 8, 2019 · 942 F.3d 824
The appraisal clause was unambiguous and the signed award was binding. The umpire settled the dispute the parties put to him, the amount of hail damage, and did not decide coverage. The mere presence of a coverage dispute does not undo an award.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Indiana law. Not a decision of an Indiana court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Park Meadows Homes Association, Inc. v. American Family Mutual Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals, District I (unpublished) · July 16, 2019 · No. 2018AP1484
An insurer could demand appraisal after the insured sued because the insured had never given it an amount of loss before suit. After the panel's award was timely paid, the insurer won summary judgment on breach of contract and bad faith: no breach, so no bad faith.
Limits: Unpublished, not binding. Commercial condominium policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Barbara Technologies Corp. v. State Farm Lloyds
Supreme Court of Texas · June 28, 2019 · 589 S.W.3d 806 (Tex. 2019), No. 17-0640
Paying an appraisal award does not by itself end a Prompt Payment Act claim, and it does not make the insurer liable either. Interest and fees are owed only if the insurer accepted liability or is found liable and also missed a deadline.
Limits: The insurer had already rejected the claim before invoking appraisal. Commercial property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ortiz v. State Farm Lloyds
Supreme Court of Texas · June 28, 2019 · 589 S.W.3d 127 (Tex. 2019), No. 17-1048
Paying an appraisal award bars a breach of contract claim for the amount of loss, and bars bad faith claims when the only damages sought are the policy benefits already paid. A Prompt Payment Act claim can still go forward.
Limits: Left open whether other damages, such as appraisal costs or independent injuries, could support a bad faith claim. Part III(D) had a narrower majority.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Owners Insurance Co. v. Dakota Station II Condominium Ass'n
Colorado Supreme Court · June 24, 2019 · 2019 CO 65, 443 P.3d 47 (No. 17SC583)
A policy that calls for an impartial appraiser requires one who is unbiased, disinterested and unswayed by personal interest, so the appraiser may not advocate for the side that picked him or her. A fee cap tied to a percentage of the award did not make the appraiser partial as a matter of law on those facts.
Limits: Turns on the policy word "impartial". The fee cap never applied in that case, so a straight percentage-of-award fee was not decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Veranda Gardens, LLC v. Secura Insurance
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · June 11, 2019 · No. 3:18-cv-611-DJH-RSE, 2019 WL 2438788
The insurer's appraiser was impartial. An appraiser is not impartial if a party directs him or he has a financial stake, but doing the earlier inspection is not enough, and nothing in the record showed a contingency fee.
Limits: Federal court applying Kentucky law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
The Mews at Byers Station Condominium Association v. Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · April 16, 2019 · No. 1047 EDA 2018
An award was upheld after the insurer paid it. Review is limited to a denied hearing or fraud, misconduct or irregularity in the process. A bad faith claim based on the appraisers' conduct cannot replace that standard, and the confirmed award fixed the amount for the contract claim.
Limits: Non-precedential memorandum; commercial property policy that required "competent and impartial" appraisers.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Statewide Commercial Cleaning, LLC v. First Assembly of God (Mercer Insurance Co. third-party defendant)
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · March 21, 2019 · No. A-3792-17T1 (unpublished)
The court upheld an umpire's award based on the insurer's unopposed appraisal after the other side's appraiser repeatedly failed to submit a figure by the umpire's deadline. The side that missed the deadline could not reopen the award.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent. The appraisal ran under a written agreement by the parties and an assignee's claim, so it may not reflect an ordinary insured's rights.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Prosight-Syndicate 1110 at Lloyds v. RST Westwick, LLC
U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · January 28, 2019 · No. 3:17-cv-885-CWR-LRA
An award signed by the insured's appraiser and the umpire was upheld. A consultant the umpire asked for, splitting his fee, and private talks between one appraiser and the umpire did not void it where the policy did not forbid them.
Limits: Federal district court predicting Mississippi law; commercial hail claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
State Automobile Mutual Insurance Co. v. Rod & Reel, Inc.
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · November 7, 2018 · No. PWG-18-340 (D. Md.), aff'd, 774 F. App'x 168 (4th Cir. 2019)
An appraisal award stated a 15-month period of restoration when the panel was only to set the amount of loss. The court held the period of restoration was outside the appraisal, refused to confirm the award as written and modified it to the month-by-month loss figures.
Limits: Commercial business-income policy; applied the Federal Arbitration Act with Maryland law; does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit · October 31, 2018 · No. 17-6498, 741 F. App'x 318
Affirmed the appointment of the insurer's umpire candidate and the refusal to let the insured rescind the appraisal clause. The panel presumed the court may appoint an umpire because it is enforcing the contract, citing a 1936 Kentucky case.
Limits: Unpublished. Did not decide whether the Federal Arbitration Act applies.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Andres Trucking Co. v. United Fire & Casualty Co.
Colorado Court of Appeals · September 20, 2018 · 2018 COA 144, 488 P.3d 425 (No. 17CA1672)
Appraisal fixes the amount of loss but does not decide the insurer's liability for breach of contract or statutory bad faith delay, so completing appraisal does not end those claims. An award is binding if the panel followed the policy and may be set aside only for lack of authority, fraud, accident or mistake. A plain written request to go to appraisal is enough to invoke it.
Limits: Commercial truck policy, not a building. Its award-challenge standard is borrowed from out-of-state decisions.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Walnut Creek Townhome Ass’n v. Depositors Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · June 1, 2018 · 913 N.W.2d 80 (No. 16-0121)
Appraisers may decide the factual cause of damage to work out the amount of loss. Coverage questions go to the court. The award is presumptively binding on the parties and the court. A policy sentence reserving the insurer’s right to deny the claim was unenforceable to the extent it changed the standard fire policy wording.
Limits: Opinion amended August 10, 2018. Preexisting damage and anti-concurrent-cause questions were left for the trial court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of Louati v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Appellate Division, First Department · May 31, 2018 · 161 AD3d 701, 2018 NY Slip Op 03908
Whether water damage came from a covered burst pipe or an excluded cause must be settled before appraisal. Factual disputes about how much tile needed replacing belong in appraisal.
Limits: Dismissal was without prejudice to a new proceeding after coverage is decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Barriga
Colorado Supreme Court · May 29, 2018 · 2018 CO 42, 418 P.3d 1181 (No. 15SC934)
A statutory award of two times the covered benefit for unreasonable delay is not reduced by benefits that were delayed but later paid through the policy's appraisal process, and recovering both on the statute and for breach of contract is not double recovery.
Limits: Apartment building fire claim. It decides how damages are counted, not whether a given delay was unreasonable.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Raja v. Ohio Security Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico · March 31, 2018 · 305 F. Supp. 3d 1206 (D.N.M. 2018), No. CIV 17-0834 JB\CG
A hotel owner sued over a hail loss and asked that the claim go through the policy's appraisal process. The court let the bad faith and breach claims about delay in agreeing to appraisal go forward, saying they did not depend on what appraisal concluded. It also predicted New Mexico's Supreme Court would require the insurer to show substantial prejudice before a failure to meet certain conditions bars the suit.
Limits: Federal trial court ruling on a motion to dismiss, predicting New Mexico law. The insurer agreed to appraisal during the case. It does not decide any appraisal question (scope, umpire, award, waiver).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Thompson v. Homesite Insurance Co. of Georgia
Court of Appeals of Georgia · March 14, 2018 · 345 Ga. App. 183, 812 S.E.2d 541 (Nos. A17A1938, A17A1940)
A bad-faith demand under 33-4-6 must alert the insurer that it faces a bad-faith claim for a specific refusal to pay. Where the insured's claims rest on the insurer's failure to pay, 33-4-6 is the only route to attorney's fees, so the general fee statute (13-6-11) was not available.
Limits: The demand ruling (Division 1) is physical precedent only. The insurer paid the umpire award less earlier payments; the court did not decide whether those offsets were proper.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Witcher v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Fifth District · March 6, 2018 · 2018 IL App (5th) 170001
A judge appointed an umpire without serving the insurer, so the court had no power over it. The appointment and the award confirmation were vacated. Asking a judge to pick an umpire is a court proceeding that needs notice and a chance to be heard.
Limits: The court made no ruling on the award itself. First filed as a Rule 23 order on January 26, 2018.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Khorsand v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist., Div. 4 · February 27, 2018 · 20 Cal.App.5th 1028, 230 Cal.Rptr.3d 89 (No. B280273)
Review of an appraisal award is narrow because appraisal is arbitration. An appraiser's declaration cannot be used to attack the merits of the award, and the judgment confirming the award was affirmed.
Limits: Only part of the opinion is certified for publication; the evidence ruling is in the published part.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. West Virginia · November 29, 2017 · No. 5:14-cv-15201 (Doc. 93)
The court refused to vacate a business interruption appraisal award. It said West Virginia has not recently set the test, read older cases to allow vacatur for fraud, corruption, partiality, misconduct, clerical or plain errors or an award outside the clause, and would not second-guess the panel's method. Because the insurers paid the award promptly and the insured did not substantially prevail, Hayseeds damages were refused.
Limits: Federal court predicting West Virginia law. Commercial property policies. Mentions causation evidence but does not rule on whether a panel may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Minden Air Corp. v. Starr Indemnity & Liability Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · November 3, 2017 · No. 16-15712 (9th Cir. Nov. 3, 2017) (unpublished)
Applying Nevada law, a policy may leave the amount of loss to an appraiser or umpire who does not interpret the policy or decide coverage. The umpire's repair cost figure was binding and decided the total loss question. The insurer had paid that figure, and the bad-faith claims failed with the contract claim by the parties' agreement.
Limits: Unpublished memorandum, not precedent, and a federal ruling that does not bind Nevada state courts. Aircraft policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Arla v. Peerless Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · September 22, 2017 · No. 3:15-CV-00596-GNS-CHL
A bad-faith claim failed where the insurer paid what the umpire awarded promptly, because under the policy payment was due only after the award, and the insurer's valuation was reasonably debatable.
Limits: Federal summary judgment; the policy tied payment to the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Shearer v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
United States District Court, District of New Jersey · August 22, 2017 · Civil Action No. 16-09469 (FLW)(LHG) (not for publication)
The court compelled appraisal of a homeowner's actual cash value dispute and stayed the suit. A dispute over the valuation method did not stop appraisal, and a demand made about two and a half months after suit was timely because no law or policy term limited the time.
Limits: A federal district court applying New Jersey law, not for publication; does not bind New Jersey courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kellogg v. Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court · August 22, 2017 · 326 Conn. 638, 165 A.3d 1228
A trial court wrongly vacated a homeowner appraisal award after weighing the evidence itself. Where the submission is unrestricted, a court may vacate only on the statutory grounds, and a challenge for misconduct is limited to whether a party was denied a full and fair hearing. Disagreeing with the amount is not a ground. The panel's reading of the policy on depreciation was not a manifest disregard of the law.
Limits: Restorationist policy with an unrestricted arbitration clause. No one claimed the umpire or appraisers were partial.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Olga Despotis Trust v. Cincinnati Insurance Co.
United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · August 16, 2017 · 867 F.3d 1054 (No. 16-2093)
Applying Missouri law to a commercial policy, the court held the insurer did not waive appraisal where the insured called appraisal pointless and sued. The clause, including its equal cost split, did not take away vexatious refusal rights. The insurer that paid the undisputed amount and then promptly paid the award had not refused to pay without reasonable cause.
Limits: Federal court, commercial property policy; no Missouri state court has decided the same points.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Poehler v. Cincinnati Ins. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · July 19, 2017 · 899 N.W.2d 135 (No. A15-0958)
An insured may recover preaward interest on an appraisal award for a fire loss, even after the insurer paid the award, unless the policy explicitly bars interest.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Glenn Homeowners Ass’n v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Iowa Court of Appeals · July 6, 2017 · No. 16-0912
The court enforced the award. Appraisal does not violate due process. The causation finding was binding because no fraud, mistake or misfeasance was shown. An appraiser who testified elsewhere that he would say what his client asked was not shown to be partial, because appraisers may act as advocates.
Limits: Policy said "competent and impartial". Decided before Walnut Creek and before chapter 522F.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Alfiero v. MetLife Auto & Home Insurance Agency, Inc.
U.S. District Court, District of Maine · June 28, 2017 · No. 2:16-cv-513-DBH, 2017 WL 2804902 (D. Me. June 28, 2017)
A homeowner who never named an appraiser after the insurer demanded appraisal could not sue on the claim. Appraisal is mandatory, and being unable to pay an appraiser was no excuse.
Limits: Federal trial court predicting Maine law; not binding on Maine courts. Homeowner policy mirroring the statutory clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · June 27, 2017 · 691 F. App'x 526 (10th Cir. 2017)
Utah law did not let the insureds recover appraisal costs or fees as bad faith damages, because the policy split those costs. The insureds also could not blame the insurer for harm from waiting three years to demand appraisal.
Limits: Unpublished and not binding precedent. Federal court predicting Utah law. The Angus decision (D. Utah 2022) questioned its fee reasoning.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Chase v. Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · May 23, 2017 · 160 A.3d 970
A policy requiring suit within two years of the loss, not of the insurer's rejection, barred a suit about an appraisal demand first made nearly four years after the loss.
Limits: Decided on the policy limitation wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nickola v. MIC General Insurance Co.
Michigan Supreme Court · May 12, 2017 · Docket No. 152535
The reasonably-in-dispute limit in MCL 500.2006(4) applies only to third-party tort claimants. An insured claiming under its own policy is owed 12 percent penalty interest on late benefits regardless of dispute.
Limits: An underinsured motorist claim, but it reads the same statute that governs property claims and approves Griswold (2007).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hayes Family Trust v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit · April 19, 2017 · No. 15-6231 (10th Cir. 2017) (unpublished order and judgment)
An insurer that resisted appraisal because of a real question whether the dispute was about coverage did not act in bad faith. The Tenth Circuit found no Oklahoma or Tenth Circuit case holding that delaying appraisal over a coverage question is bad faith. The insurer had already paid the award in the companion case.
Limits: Unpublished, so only persuasive. Decided on the insured's theories of delay and poor investigation, not on whether payment of an award ends bad-faith claims.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Long v. Farmers Insurance Co. of Oregon
Oregon Supreme Court · February 2, 2017 · 360 Or 791, 388 P3d 312
After an insured sued and a court ordered appraisal, the insurer's later payments above its earlier tender counted as a "recovery" under ORS 742.061. The insurer owed attorney fees for work up to those payments, not after.
Limits: Water-leak homeowner claim. Decides fees only.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
In re Appointment of Umpire for Hayes Family Trust v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit · January 4, 2017 · 845 F.3d 997 (10th Cir. 2017), No. 15-6164
Under Oklahoma law an award binds only the party that invoked appraisal and settles only the amount of loss, not coverage or causation. When the insurer paid an award it had not invoked and the insured accepted, the dispute over the amount was settled, so the trial court rightly vacated its judgment confirming the award. Fees and interest under 36 O.S. 3629(B) need a judgment.
Limits: Federal court predicting Oklahoma law. The reporter cite 845 F.3d 997 is confirmed by the court's April 19, 2017 order in No. 15-6231, not printed on the slip opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point
U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · November 18, 2016 · No. 1:13-cv-1453-SEB-DML, Dkt. 61 (adopting Dkt. 55 report and recommendation of 2016-01-28)
The district judge adopted a magistrate judge's recommendation and set aside an appraisal award. The umpire had refused the insured's engineering evidence, and the process was unfair to the insured. The report also cites a federal decision treating a contingency-paid appraiser as not impartial.
Limits: Federal trial court. Fact-heavy, decided on the whole process rather than one rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Sweet Valley Missionary Baptist Church v. Alfa Insurance Corp.
Mississippi Supreme Court · June 2, 2016 · 192 So. 3d 990, No. 2014-CA-01748-SCT
After appraisal set the loss and the insurer paid it in full, no dispute remained and dismissal was right. No prejudgment interest was owed, because the statute only allows interest on a court judgment or decree.
Limits: Commercial policy, Hurricane Katrina claim. Did not decide any bad-faith claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
St. Croix Trading Co./Direct Logistics, LLC v. Regent Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals (published) · May 24, 2016 · 2016 WI App 49, 370 Wis. 2d 248, 882 N.W.2d 487
The court affirmed vacatur of an appraisal award because the panel exceeded its authority by deciding which losses were covered. The panel's task was to value the property and the amount of loss. The court said no Wisconsin case was on point and did not decide whether panels may decide causation or whether the insurer's appraiser was impartial.
Limits: Commercial policy that kept the insurer's right to deny the claim. Does not decide causation, impartiality or bad faith (n.1).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McElroy v. Evanston Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · May 6, 2016 · No. 3:14-cv-180-CWR-FKB
Summary judgment for the insurer. An award agreed by two of three is presumed correct under Munn. A claim that the insured's appraiser was unlicensed or incompetent did not undo an award the other appraiser and the umpire agreed on.
Limits: Federal district court; commercial warehouse fire claim; assumed the license point was true without deciding it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Citizens Property Insurance Corp. v. River Oaks Condominium II Ass'n
Florida Second District Court of Appeal · March 30, 2016 · 190 So. 3d 1110 (Fla. 2d DCA 2016), No. 2D13-4331
Appraisal expenses could not be taxed as costs against the insurer, because the policy required the insured to pay its own appraiser and half of the umpire and other appraisal expenses. Public adjuster fees were not taxable costs either.
Limits: Second District; sinkhole claim; turns on the policy's cost-sharing clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Thomas v. Standard Fire Insurance Co.
Tennessee Court of Appeals · February 17, 2016 · No. E2015-01224-COA-R3-CV, 2016 WL 638559
Homeowners were bound by the umpire's $132,793.95 award, because they only challenged the amount. The appraisal clause is not an arbitration agreement and needs no separate initials.
Limits: Unpublished (Westlaw cite only). Homeowners did not challenge the umpire's qualifications.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hays v. State Farm Ins. Co.
Washington Court of Appeals, Division II (unpublished) · December 23, 2015 · No. 46679-1-II
Even though the insurer had paid a policy arbitration award on a home fire loss, the insureds' bad-faith and Consumer Protection Act claims for delay in explaining the claim went to trial. A gap between the insurer's offer and the later award was not by itself evidence of unreasonable conduct.
Limits: Unpublished and nonbinding. The valuation was decided by the policy's arbitration tool, not an appraisal clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lytle v. Country Mutual Insurance Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, First District · September 30, 2015 · 2015 IL App (1st) 142169
An insured could not use appraisal to decide whether ordinance-related costs were covered. That was a coverage question, not an amount-of-loss dispute. The policy had each party pay its own appraiser and split the umpire and other costs.
Limits: The insured's written appraisal request was missing from the record, which limited the review.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (umpire appointed)
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · September 30, 2015 · No. 3:14-cv-40-DJH-DW, 2015 WL 5793951
The court appointed an experienced umpire over bias objections. It said cause and amount of loss are for the umpire and the scope of coverage is for the court, and refused to instruct the umpire that cosmetic matching was required.
Limits: Federal court; the Sixth Circuit affirmed in 2018.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Moran Industries, Inc. v. Erie Insurance Exchange
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · September 29, 2015 · No. 1835 MDA 2014
A panel that limited a collapse loss to one side of a building stayed within its authority. An umpire's averaging mistake is not a ground to vacate, and appraisers are final judges of law and fact unless the submission limits them.
Limits: Non-precedential memorandum.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hawley v. Preferred Mutual Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Appeals Court · September 16, 2015 · 88 Mass. App. Ct. 360, 36 N.E.3d 1284
A request for a reference does not pause the 2-year time limit to sue under § 99. Even if it did, suing long after the insurer refused was not prompt. The c. 93A and 176D claims failed because the loss was not covered.
Limits: Concerned time limits and a denial of coverage, not a completed reference.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Botai v. Safeco Insurance Co. of Illinois
U.S. District Court, D. Idaho (magistrate judge) · July 24, 2015 · No. 2:14-CV-00445-EJL-REB (Dkt. 16)
Compelled appraisal and stayed all claims, including bad faith, until the award. Made no findings on the insureds' claim that the insurer's appraiser was not disinterested.
Limits: Federal trial court order, not binding Idaho law. Used the Idaho Uniform Arbitration Act only for guidance and did not decide whether appraisal is arbitration.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Global Aerospace, Inc. v. Aero Ways, Inc.
Delaware Court of Chancery · July 9, 2015 · C.A. No. 10735-VCN (letter opinion)
The appraisers under an aircraft damage policy could not agree on an umpire, and the policy gave no fallback method. The court appointed an umpire under the Federal Arbitration Act, picking a neutral expert in the damaged wing structure.
Limits: Unreported trial-level letter opinion on an aviation hull policy, not a building policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Zurich American Insurance Co. v. Omni Health Solutions, LLC
Court of Appeals of Georgia · July 2, 2015 · 332 Ga. App. 723, 774 S.E.2d 782 (No. A15A0170)
An umpire's partiality is a ground for setting aside an award, and the trial judge has discretion. An award both party appraisers signed in writing stayed binding. An award only the insurer's appraiser and the umpire signed, after the umpire joined a firm doing work for the insurer, was properly set aside.
Limits: Commercial property policy that said impartial; the parties had jointly asked the superior court for a new umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lee v. California Capital Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist., Div. 3 · June 18, 2015 · 237 Cal.App.4th 1154, 188 Cal.Rptr.3d 753 (No. A136280)
A court may order appraisal of items where coverage or causation is disputed, as long as the panel only values them and the award does not decide coverage. It was error to make the panel value items that inspection showed were undamaged or never existed, and confirmation was reversed.
Limits: Also states the vacatur grounds in Code Civ. Proc. 1286.2 are exclusive.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Texas Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance Co. v. Sampley
Court of Appeals of Texas, Amarillo (7th Dist.) · May 26, 2015 · No. 07-13-00151-CV (Tex. App.-Amarillo May 26, 2015, pet. denied) (mem. op.)
Texas law does not require a party appraiser to be disinterested unless the policy says so. A policy that asks only for a competent appraiser let the insured use a body shop employee whose shop would be paid from the result.
Limits: Personal auto hail claim; memorandum opinion. Policies under 28 TAC 5.9804 (on or after March 1, 2027) now require disinterested appraisers.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (motion to rescind appraisal)
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · May 22, 2015 · No. 3:14-cv-40-DJH-DW
The insured could not abandon appraisal and go to a jury because it disliked the insurer's umpire candidates. Old Kentucky cases finding waiver involved policies with no court-appointment step, and past work for insurers does not alone show bias.
Limits: Order on a motion to rescind; the court did not yet pick an umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Des Longchamps v. Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia · May 4, 2015 · 102 F. Supp. 3d 299
A homeowner's suit asking the court to appoint an umpire, filed more than a year after a 2012 storm loss, was barred by the policy's one-year suit clause, which ran from the start of the loss. A later separate storm loss did not restart the clock, and the insured raised no waiver or estoppel argument.
Limits: Federal trial court predicting D.C. law; non-binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. West Virginia · February 18, 2015 · No. 5:14-cv-15201 (Doc. 75)
The court compelled appraisal and stayed the suit. The policies allowed a demand within 60 days of a sworn proof of loss, and the insurers' demand was timely, so there was no waiver. One policy had no deadline. The court declined to apply New York's policy favoring appraisal, saying West Virginia courts have shown no such preference.
Limits: Federal court. Commercial property policies with a 60-day demand window. Not a fire form case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bjorklund Cos. v. Auto-Owners Ins.
Minnesota Court of Appeals · January 26, 2015 · No. A14-1175 (unpublished)
Under the appraisal waiver statute, a party's right is waived only if the other side elects that. An insured that kept seeking appraisal did not elect waiver, even though the insurer was late naming an appraiser.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedential. Applied to a wind loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cedar Bluff Townhome Condo. Ass'n v. Am. Fam. Mut. Ins. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · December 17, 2014 · 857 N.W.2d 290 (No. A13-0124)
Questions of fact that are mere incidents of the amount of loss, such as a reasonable color match for replacement siding, can be decided by the appraisal panel. The award for full siding replacement was affirmed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Dixon
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District · December 16, 2014 · 450 S.W.3d 831 (No. ED101609)
Appraisal applies only to a dispute over the amount of a covered loss. Where the insurer said the concrete damage was wear and tear, not hail, that was a coverage dispute and appraisal could not settle it. The arbitration ban for insurance contracts was part of the reasoning.
Limits: Summary judgment for the insurer reversed and remanded on a limited record.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Florida Insurance Guaranty Association v. Hanse
Florida Fifth District Court of Appeal · November 21, 2014 · 150 So. 3d 1272 (Fla. 5th DCA 2014), No. 5D13-4501
Insureds could not name their own attorney as their disinterested appraiser. An attorney owes a duty of loyalty to the client.
Limits: About attorneys, not public adjusters. Parrish cites the same Fifth District line (Branco, 148 So. 3d 488).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dupree v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co.
Michigan Supreme Court · November 18, 2014 · 497 Mich 1; 857 NW2d 247 (Docket No. 147647)
Coverage is for the courts and the method of measuring loss is for the appraisers. Review of an award is limited to bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake. Because the award stated actual cash value, the policy's replacement-cost proof requirement still controlled and the insured got only actual cash value.
Limits: Per curiam, in place of leave to appeal. A policy condition such as proof of replacement is a coverage question the court decides.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Coppins v. Allstate Indemnity Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals (published) · November 12, 2014 · 2014 WI App 125, 359 Wis. 2d 179, 857 N.W.2d 896
The court set aside an appraiser's award because on its face it used market value where the policy required actual cash value, so the appraiser did not understand the assigned task. It also held that the insured's breach of contract, estoppel and bad faith claims raised fact questions, so summary judgment for the insurer was wrong.
Limits: Fire loss on a landlord policy valued at actual cash value, with a panel of two appraisers and an umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Island Concepts, LLC v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London
U.S. District Court, E.D. La. · October 31, 2014 · No. 13-6725, Rec. Doc. 34
Where the policy said a decision of any two would be binding, the award was presumed accurate and the challenger carried the burden. An insurer that paid the full award within 30 days was not liable for bad-faith penalties.
Limits: Federal decision on a business income claim, decided before Louisiana repealed 22:1973. It follows the state appellate decision in Long.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Baldwin Mutual Insurance Co. v. Adair
Supreme Court of Alabama · September 30, 2014 · 181 So. 3d 1033; No. 1100872
Insureds must meet their post-loss duties under the policy before demanding appraisal. Without a duty to pay, there is no real disagreement over the amount to trigger appraisal.
Limits: Decided on the policy language in the case, over one dissent. Reversed a trial court order that forced appraisal early.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point
U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · September 3, 2014 · 44 F. Supp. 3d 813
The court let the insured demand appraisal even though the insurer said most roof damage came from poor construction, not a storm. It reasoned that an appraiser cannot set the storm-damage amount without separating storm from non-storm damage. It also noted the policy lets the insurer deny the claim after appraisal. The court said Indiana courts had not spoken authoritatively on this.
Limits: Federal trial court order on a motion to dismiss. No state appellate decision on causation was found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Currie v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Pennsylvania · August 19, 2014 · No. 13-6713, 2014 WL 4081051
A dispute over how much damage a storm caused, or whether a covered peril caused part of it, is an amount-of-loss dispute for appraisal, not a coverage dispute. State Farm's refusal to appraise could not be excused as a coverage issue at summary judgment.
Limits: Federal court applying Pennsylvania law; not binding on state courts. Treats an insurer's exclusion argument as a true coverage dispute.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
German Automotive of Tinton Falls, Inc. v. Harleysville Insurance Co. of New Jersey
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · July 29, 2014 · No. A-2571-13T3 (unpublished)
A policy appraisal clause limited to the 'amount of loss' is not an arbitration agreement and does not cover disputes about the extent of damage, the scope of work or the cause of the damage. Insureds who litigated for 21 months before moving to compel arbitration had waived any such right.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent under R. 1:36-3. A garage owners policy; the motion sought arbitration, not an order for appraisal alone.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Glenn Homeowners Ass’n v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Iowa Court of Appeals · July 16, 2014 · 854 N.W.2d 67 (No. 13-0859)
Causation is part of the definition of loss, so appraisers must consider it. Once a party demands appraisal, the appraisal goes forward and other rulings wait. The appraisal does not decide coverage.
Limits: Interlocutory appeal. Whether an award is conclusive depends on the damage, the causes and the form of the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lam v. Allstate Indemnity Co.
Court of Appeals of Georgia (whole court) · March 26, 2014 · 327 Ga. App. 151, 755 S.E.2d 544 (No. A13A1733)
Where the insurer admitted wind damaged some shingles but the parties disagreed how much of the roof the wind damaged, the majority held that was a coverage dispute, not a proper basis for appraisal.
Limits: Decided four to three. The dissent would have treated it as a dispute over the amount of covered loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Pilkenton v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.
Appellate Division, Fourth Department · December 27, 2013 · 112 AD3d 1327, 2013 NY Slip Op 08709
Appraisal under section 3408(c) applies to a covered loss. While a lawsuit over whether the loss is covered was pending, the court refused to order appraisal.
Limits: Short memorandum decision.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lincoln County Port Authority v. Allianz Global Risks US Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · December 10, 2013 · 2013 MT 365, 373 Mont. 60, 315 P.3d 934
The trial court decided coverage first, then ordered appraisal. The appraisers did not have to follow the policy's adjustment clause for demolition property, but did have to follow its actual cash value and replacement cost terms, so the court cut that part of the award to actual cash value. Interest on that part runs only from when the court adopts the new valuation.
Limits: Commercial property policy on a public body's building. One justice dissented on coverage.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Artist Building Partners v. Auto-Owners Mutual Insurance Co.
Tennessee Court of Appeals · November 21, 2013 · 435 S.W.3d 202
A panel may decide matters that the policy and the parties expressly sent to it, including the repair time frame and business income loss, and that decision is binding.
Limits: Commercial fire loss. The panel had express agreement to decide these issues.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Brechbill
Supreme Court of Alabama · September 27, 2013 · 144 So. 3d 248; No. 1111117
Bad faith in Alabama is one tort. An insurer with a reasonably legitimate or arguable reason for refusing to pay cannot be liable, even if its investigation had gaps.
Limits: Homeowner roof-damage claim; not an appraisal case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Alexander v. Farmers Insurance Exchange
California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist. · September 23, 2013 · 219 Cal.App.4th 1183, 162 Cal.Rptr.3d 455 (No. B239840)
A trial court has discretion to delay appraisal until legal issues raised in a declaratory relief claim are decided, and it was within that discretion to deny a motion to compel appraisal without prejudice.
Limits: Follows Kirkwood and Doan; the denial was without prejudice to renewing the motion later.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Shree Hari Hotels, LLC v. Society Insurance
U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · September 5, 2013 · No. 1:11-cv-01324-JMS-DKL, Dkt. 156 (2013 WL 4777212)
An appraiser paid hourly with a fee capped at 10% of the claim payment had a financial interest in the outcome and was not "impartial". The award was set aside and could not be used at trial.
Limits: A single federal trial court order. No Indiana state court has decided it. The policy said "competent and impartial".
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ex parte Tower Insurance Co. of New York (In re Cullman Bowling Center, LLC v. Tower Insurance Co. of New York)
Supreme Court of Alabama · August 23, 2013 · 140 So. 3d 456; No. 1120228
The court denied the insurer's mandamus petition against an order appointing an umpire, with no opinion. A concurring justice said Rogers means coverage disputes are not for appraisers or umpires.
Limits: No majority opinion; the concurrence is not controlling.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Citizens Property Insurance Corp. v. Mango Hill 6 Condominium Ass'n
Florida Third District Court of Appeal · July 10, 2013 · 117 So. 3d 1226 (Fla. 3d DCA 2013), No. 3D10-2630
Appraisal decides only the amount of loss. The trial court wrongly used the Arbitration Code to confirm an award. The insurer's defenses had to be decided in the lawsuit by summary judgment or trial.
Limits: Not the same case as Citizens v. Mango Hill Condo. Ass'n 12, 54 So. 3d 578 (3d DCA 2011).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McDonnell v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.
Alaska Supreme Court · April 26, 2013 · 299 P.3d 715 (Alaska 2013), Nos. S-14378, S-14407
The mandatory appraisal statute covers disputes over the value of a loss to property, not personal injury claims. In explaining why appraisal differs from arbitration, the court remarked that coverage, causation and liability are not resolved by appraisal.
Limits: An uninsured-motorist injury case, not a property claim. The remark about coverage and causation supports the holding; it is not itself a ruling on what a property appraisal panel may decide.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Auto-Owners Ins. Co. v. Second Chance Invs., LLC
Minnesota Supreme Court · March 20, 2013 · 827 N.W.2d 766 (No. A11-1145)
Whether a building is a total loss is for a court, not an appraisal panel, because the fire policy statute removes total loss on buildings from appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bell v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Court of Appeals of Georgia · November 30, 2012 · 319 Ga. App. 302, 734 S.E.2d 894 (No. A12A1094)
An umpire's awards giving separate totals for the dwelling and the personal property were valid. The standard fire policy's 'each item' wording did not require the umpire to itemize further, and the homeowner policy did not either.
Limits: Fire loss under a homeowner policy; the court did not reach the bad-faith or 'wholly destroyed' questions.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · October 22, 2012 · 500 F. App'x 734 (10th Cir. 2012) (unpublished)
An appraisal award far above the insurer's first payment helped show the insurer may have undervalued the loss, so summary judgment against the bad faith claim was reversed.
Limits: Unpublished and not binding precedent. Federal court predicting Utah law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Audubon Hill South Condominium Ass'n v. Community Ass'n Underwriters of America, Inc.
Massachusetts Appeals Court · September 20, 2012 · 82 Mass. App. Ct. 461, 975 N.E.2d 458
A reference award of the amount of loss did not decide coverage. The insurer had reserved coverage in writing seven times, cited § 101E, and the referees stayed out of it. The court then decided the loss fell under an earth movement exclusion.
Limits: Different facts from Augenstein, where the insurer reserved nothing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bello v. Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · July 12, 2012 · No. A-4750-10T4 (unpublished)
After the insurer compelled appraisal and paid its policy limit for a storm-damaged retaining wall, the insured was allowed to add a bad-faith claim over the earlier coverage denial. The court upheld the jury's verdict for the insured and refused a new trial.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent. The bad-faith claim concerned the denial of coverage before appraisal, not the appraisal amount.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Patel v. Scottsdale Insurance Co.
North Carolina Court of Appeals · July 3, 2012 · 221 N.C. App. 476, 728 S.E.2d 394, No. COA11-1198
Where the policy made appraisal a condition of suit and the insured never invoked it, the trial court should have stayed the suit and ordered appraisal rather than enter judgment.
Limits: Turns on the policy's suit clause. A commercial fire loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Quade v. Secura Ins.
Minnesota Supreme Court · June 12, 2012 · 814 N.W.2d 703 (No. A10-0714)
Deciding the amount of loss includes deciding what caused it, such as separating storm damage from earlier wear. Whether damage is excluded is a coverage question for the court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Evanston Insurance Co. v. Cogswell Properties, LLC
U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit · May 29, 2012 · 683 F.3d 684 (Nos. 10-2075 and 11-1068)
Michigan appraisal is not covered by the Federal Arbitration Act. Review of an award follows Michigan law and is limited to bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake. An umpire who valued the building and the loss by two different methods made a manifest mistake and the award was properly vacated.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Michigan law to a commercial property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Liberty Mutual Group, Inc. v. Wright
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · April 25, 2012 · Civ. No. DKC 12-0282 (D. Md.) (ECF 15)
The insurer had not waived appraisal by finishing its review of the claim before going to appraisal. The court moved to appoint an umpire and asked each side for more candidates.
Limits: Federal ruling on a homeowner policy under the Federal Arbitration Act; does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kochendorfer v. Metropolitan Property & Casualty Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Washington · April 11, 2012 · No. C11-1162-MAT
Applying Washington law, the court confirmed an appraisal award for a house fire and granted summary judgment for the insured on the awarded loss-of-use, code-upgrade and remediation amounts, because the insurer challenged amounts rather than coverage and showed no unfairness in the appraisal. Coverage questions stay with the court.
Limits: Federal magistrate judge order; not binding on Washington courts. An earlier order confirming the award is dated November 22, 2011.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dufrene v. Certain Interested Underwriters at Lloyd's of London
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fifth Circuit · March 27, 2012 · 91 So. 3d 397, 11-CA-1002
The trial court could appoint an umpire and set fair-process rules, such as no one-sided contact with the umpire. A challenger must show an appraiser honesty or integrity is suspect to remove him. The award was binding because the umpire and appraiser did their duties, and the challenger carried the burden. The court called the issue before the umpire the amount of damage, not causation.
Limits: Hurricane Katrina wind claim; the policy said a decision of any two is binding. The causation remark came in a ruling on excluding documents, not a holding on appraiser power.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Liberty Mutual Group, Inc. v. Wright
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · March 5, 2012 · Civ. No. DKC 12-0282, 2012 WL 718857 (D. Md.)
When the appraisers could not agree on an umpire, the insurer asked the federal court to appoint one. The court held the appraisal clause is an arbitration agreement under the Federal Arbitration Act and kept the umpire appointment before it.
Limits: Federal ruling on a homeowner policy under the Federal Arbitration Act; the court did not pick the umpire in this opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Westfield National Insurance Co. v. Nakoa
Indiana Court of Appeals · February 10, 2012 · 963 N.E.2d 1126
An insurer that stood by through an appraisal without saying it valued the loss differently waived that policy defense. An award that said an amount was owed only "if Court finds coverage" left coverage to the court and was not binding on that item.
Limits: Waiver here was of replacement-cost conditions, not of the right to appraisal itself.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Coker v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of South Carolina · January 27, 2012 · No. 3:11-cv-0446-CMC (D.S.C.), Doc. 39
On reconsideration the court kept its waiver ruling: the insurer's delay cost the insureds time and expense and gave the insurer discovery.
Limits: Federal trial court order on reconsideration.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Jadick v. Nationwide Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
Alabama Court of Civil Appeals · December 16, 2011 · 98 So. 3d 5; No. 2100432
An insured who asked for appraisal 15 months after the claim was paid and the repairs finished waived the right, because the delay so prejudiced the insurer.
Limits: Intermediate appellate court; the Alabama Supreme Court denied review. Turned partly on policy duties to report a disagreement right away.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Coker v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of South Carolina · October 31, 2011 · No. 3:11-cv-0446-CMC (D.S.C.), Doc. 26
An insurer that waited six months after suit and demanded appraisal on the last day of fact discovery waived the right to appraisal.
Limits: Federal trial court. It assumed, without deciding, that appraisal is treated like arbitration for waiver. Not a South Carolina state-court holding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
White v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · July 28, 2011 · 293 Mich App 419 (Docket No. 298083)
A public adjuster on a 10 percent contingency contract could serve as the insured's appraiser, because independent does not mean impartial. The other side must be told about the fee deal. Appraisers are not quasi-judges, so the insurer's due-process challenge failed.
Limits: Published. The appraiser was paid hourly (capped) for the appraisal. Did not decide whether a policy may add "disinterested".
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange
Supreme Court of South Dakota · July 6, 2011 · 2011 S.D. 35, 800 N.W.2d 726
The insured invoked the policy's appraisal clause and an umpire set the repair cost. The court held the appraisal clause does not change the loss-settlement terms: the insurer pays actual cash value until repairs are done, and the claim stays open for newly found damage. The clause there said an appraisal decision was not binding.
Limits: Did not decide whether appraisal may be demanded or how SDCL 21-25A-3 applies. The policy language, not the court, supplied the nonbinding rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. v. Sadler
Supreme Court of North Carolina · June 16, 2011 · 365 N.C. 178, 711 S.E.2d 114, No. 267PA10
The policy's appraisal process decides only the amount of loss, not coverage. The insurer may still cut or deny an award under exclusions and limits, and the trial court must first resolve fact questions about what the covered loss is.
Limits: Based on the policy's own wording, which barred appraisal from deciding causation or coverage. It does not cite G.S. 58-44-16. Does not say what happens when a policy is silent on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group
Ohio Court of Appeals, 9th District (Summit County) · May 25, 2011 · 2011-Ohio-2502 (C.A. No. 25643)
The trial court could appoint an umpire under the policy but had no power to bar the panel from considering causation. The appeals court called the causation question a matter of substantial debate and declined to decide it.
Limits: Commercial property policy. Resolved on the limits of the court's power, not on whether panels may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 6th Dist. · May 24, 2011 · 195 Cal.App.4th 1082, 125 Cal.Rptr.3d 793
Appraisal under Insurance Code 2071 is not the exclusive remedy. A trial court may defer appraisal while a declaratory relief action settles legal questions such as how depreciation is calculated.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
In re Universal Underwriters of Texas Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Texas · May 6, 2011 · 345 S.W.3d 404 (Tex. 2011), No. 10-0238
A party does not waive appraisal just by waiting until suit is filed. Waiver takes conduct showing waiver plus prejudice to the other side, and delay is measured from the point of impasse.
Limits: Policy with no deadline to demand appraisal. Link is a free copy on hallapproved.com, not the court's site.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hahn v. Allstate Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · March 31, 2011 · 15 A.3d 1026
An insurer must go to appraisal when the dispute is the amount or extent of loss and it does not deny coverage for the loss. Causation and amount were treated as intertwined. A real coverage dispute can be litigated, but the insurer must say specifically why.
Limits: Fire loss; the insurer did not deny the claim as a whole.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
LeBlanc v. Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Oklahoma · March 23, 2011 · No. CIV-10-00503-HE, 2011 WL 1107126 (W.D. Okla.)
Predicting how Oklahoma's Supreme Court would rule from Massey, the court held an umpire went beyond what Oklahoma allows by deciding what caused the damage. The amount the umpire set to repair the house could be used, but causation stayed for the court. The invoking party, not only the other side, may challenge an award.
Limits: Unpublished federal trial court order on a homeowner policy, not binding on Oklahoma state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kirkwood v. California State Automobile Association Inter-Insurance Bureau
California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist. · February 28, 2011 · 193 Cal.App.4th 49
Appraisers have no power to interpret the policy or the governing statutes. The court upheld denying a motion to compel appraisal so a declaratory relief action on the depreciation method could go first.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v Seibert
New York Supreme Court, Monroe County · February 10, 2011 · 31 Misc 3d 523, 2011 NY Slip Op 21060
In a proceeding to appoint an umpire, the court appointed one and refused to limit what the umpire decides or to rule whether a party's appraiser is competent and disinterested.
Limits: Trial court decision.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · January 25, 2011 · 633 F.3d 944 (10th Cir. 2011)
After the insurer paid an appraisal award, the insureds' contract claim failed because the insurer followed the policy. Their bad faith claim was not barred by the appraisal or the payment and was not frivolous.
Limits: Federal court predicting Utah law; the policy's appraisal clause was not itself in dispute.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Long v. American Security Ins. Co.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit · November 17, 2010 · 2010-CA-0026, 52 So. 3d 260
An insurer that followed the appraisal clause, paid nothing during appraisal, and paid its policy limits within 30 days of the umpire's award was not shown to have acted arbitrarily or capriciously, so the bad-faith claim was dismissed. Complying with an appraisal the insured invoked is not evidence of bad faith.
Limits: Hurricane Katrina claim under former R.S. 22:658 and 22:1220; the court did not decide whether appraisal pauses the statutory payment deadlines.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. v. Sadler
North Carolina Court of Appeals · May 18, 2010 · 204 N.C. App. 145, 693 S.E.2d 266, No. COA09-1054
The insurer did not name an appraiser within 20 days of the insured's demand or for a month after, so the trial court properly appointed an umpire without an appraiser for the insurer. Appraisers who considered the known cause of damage while valuing the loss did not exceed their role.
Limits: Reversed in full by the supreme court in 2011 on the coverage issue; the umpire ruling was not discussed but the judgment fell. The umpire was appointed in 2006, before the 2013 notice and hearing rules in G.S. 58-44-35.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Willwoods Community v. Essex Ins. Co.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fifth Circuit · April 13, 2010 · 09-CA-651, 33 So. 3d 1102
During appraisal, the insurer's own appraiser valued the remaining loss, and the insurer later paid nearly that amount but more than 30 days after his report. Because it had undisputed written proof of at least that amount, the late payment was arbitrary and capricious and penalties and attorney fees were owed.
Limits: Decided under former R.S. 22:658 (now 22:1892); affirmed in part, vacated in part and remanded on other penalty issues.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co. v. Komondy
Connecticut Appellate Court · March 30, 2010 · 120 Conn. App. 117, 991 A.2d 587
A homeowner's motion to vacate a fire appraisal award was late because it was not made within 30 days of notice of the award. Written notice to her husband, who acted as her agent in the process, counted as notice to her. The court confirms an award unless a statutory defect is shown, and has no authority to order the manner of payment of a purely money award.
Limits: Part II arbitration statutes (agreement made before 2018). The appeal was decided in part for each side; I read only the award-timing part.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mikelson v. United Services Automobile Ass’n
Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals · March 24, 2010 · 122 Hawai‘i 393, 227 P.3d 559; No. 28332
A motion to confirm an arbitration award was not moot because the insurer had already paid it. With no ground under chapter 658A to vacate, modify or correct, the circuit court had to confirm the award.
Limits: Auto underinsured motorist arbitration, not property appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Villa Highlands, LLC v. Western Community Insurance Co.
Idaho Supreme Court · February 9, 2010 · 148 Idaho 598, 226 P.3d 540; No. 35472
Under builders risk policy wording that a decision agreed to by any two is binding, the umpire's appraisal bound the insured, and the court upheld denial of a late request to undo it.
Limits: Builders risk policy. The insured had stipulated to the amount and did not challenge the umpire until after judgment.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mahnke v. Superior Court
California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist. · December 21, 2009 · 180 Cal.App.4th 565, 103 Cal.Rptr.3d 197 (No. B216110)
The disclosure and disqualification rules in Code Civ. Proc. 1281.9 and 1281.91 apply to the umpire, not to party-selected appraisers. A party appraiser can still be challenged for a substantial business relationship, and any challenge should come at the first reasonable opportunity.
Limits: Writ proceeding; reinstated the insureds' appraiser.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Coates v. Erie Insurance Exchange
Fairfax County Circuit Court · November 4, 2009 · 79 Va. Cir. 440
Where the insurer admitted the event was covered and the dispute was how much had to be repaired, the dispute was about amount of loss and the insurer had to go to appraisal. Coverage questions remain for the courts.
Limits: Trial court opinion, not binding. Relied on out-of-state decisions. The insurer there did not dispute what caused the damage.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kuehn v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · August 17, 2009 · No. 1:08CV577 LTS-RHW, 2009 WL 2567485
An appraisal award was upheld. Appraisers may not decide disputed causation, but Munn does not bar an appraisal where both sides' appraisers agree on what is in and out. Awards are presumed valid and set aside only for fraud, substantial mistake or lack of authority.
Limits: Federal district court predicting Mississippi law; Hurricane Katrina homeowner claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Farmers Automobile Insurance Association v. Union Pacific Railway Co. (Donaubauer)
Wisconsin Supreme Court · July 10, 2009 · 2009 WI 73, 319 Wis. 2d 52, 768 N.W.2d 596
A valid appraisal clause binds both sides even without the word binding. Awards are presumptively valid and are set aside only for fraud, bad faith, a material mistake, or a panel that did not understand or finish its task. Review usually stops at the face of the award, and the court said appraisal is not governed by the arbitration statute.
Limits: Homeowner fire loss. The court said it need not decide how far Lynch reaches (para. 36) and left the Court of Appeals' ruling on the bad faith claim in place (n.2).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
State Farm Lloyds v. Johnson
Supreme Court of Texas · July 3, 2009 · 290 S.W.3d 886 (Tex. 2009), No. 06-1071
A hail damage dispute over how much of a roof was damaged is an amount of loss question for the appraisers. Every appraisal involves some causation, appraisers set the amount of loss but not liability, and appraisal should usually go forward before a court steps in.
Limits: Homeowners policy. The court did not decide whether the resulting award would be binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Firemen's Insurance Co. of Washington, D.C. v. Birch Pointe Condominium Ass'n
Delaware Court of Chancery · May 29, 2009 · C.A. No. 4313-VCP (letter opinion)
An insured's appraiser whose employer did paid construction work for the insured while he served was not impartial. Naming him broke the policy, the umpire he helped choose was void, and the court appointed a new umpire.
Limits: Unreported trial-level opinion on a businessowners policy. It turned on a business tie, not a contingent fee.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Choharis v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
District of Columbia Court of Appeals · December 18, 2008 · 961 A.2d 1080
D.C. does not recognize a separate tort of bad faith in handling a homeowners claim. Bad faith conduct is treated under contract law and the implied duty of good faith.
Limits: Not an appraisal case. The court left any added protection to the legislature.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Firemen's Insurance Co. of Washington, D.C. v. Birch Pointe Condominium Ass'n
Delaware Superior Court · December 17, 2008 · C.A. No. 08C-04-081 JAP (memorandum opinion)
The appraisal clause is an agreement to arbitrate. Because the Uniform Arbitration Act gave the Court of Chancery the power to appoint when the agreed method fails, the Superior Court said it lacked jurisdiction and let the case move to Chancery. It found the insured breached the clause by naming a tied appraiser.
Limits: Unreported trial-level opinion that predates the 2009 amendment of 10 Del. C. § 5702.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Taylor v. Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
Iowa Court of Appeals · October 1, 2008 · No. 8-338 / 07-1580
An appraisal sets only the amount of loss, not liability. The court refused to throw out the umpire’s award, because the trial court had disregarded the umpire’s comments on liability and causation.
Limits: Predates Walnut Creek on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Tiger Fibers, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. Virginia · August 15, 2008 · 571 F. Supp. 2d 712
Under the Virginia statute a disinterested appraiser can have no personal interest in the outcome. Only permanent employees of a party are disqualified, not independent contractors retained for the job. The insurer reimburses the insured's appraisal costs when the insurer invokes appraisal.
Limits: Federal court applying Virginia law. Does not address contingent fees.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Farmers Automobile Insurance Association v. Union Pacific Railway Co. (Donaubauer)
Wisconsin Court of Appeals (published) · June 3, 2008 · 2008 WI App 116, 313 Wis. 2d 93, 756 N.W.2d 461
The court affirmed summary judgment for the insurer on the insured's bad faith claim after a binding appraisal. The insurer had offered close to the amount the appraisers later set, then more, so its position was a legitimate disagreement over value and not objectively unreasonable.
Limits: Homeowner fire loss. Does not decide what paying an award does to later claims. Affirmed in 2009 WI 73, which left this bad faith ruling in place.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Harris v. American Modern Home Insurance Co.
United States District Court, Eastern District of Missouri · May 30, 2008 · 571 F. Supp. 2d 1066
An appraiser paid a flat fee plus 15 percent of the award had a direct financial interest and was not disinterested as the law and the policy required. With his other ties to the insured, that made his award void.
Limits: Federal trial court applying Missouri law; homeowner wind and hail claim. No Missouri state court has ruled on contingent fees.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
National Refrigeration, Inc. v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of America
Rhode Island Supreme Court · May 29, 2008 · 947 A.2d 906
A petition to compel appraisal is a legal action subject to the policy's two-year limitation, and the insurer was not estopped from raising it.
Limits: Commercial property policy with a competent and impartial appraiser clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Devonwood Condominium Owners Association v. Farmers Insurance Exchange
California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist. · May 20, 2008 · 162 Cal.App.4th 1498
A judgment confirming an appraisal award must conform to the award. A judgment that went beyond the award, where coverage for some items was disputed, was vacated and sent back for a conforming judgment.
Limits: Procedural decision about the form of judgment under Code Civ. Proc. 1287.4.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hall v. Farmers Alliance Mutual Insurance Co.
Idaho Supreme Court · February 13, 2008 · 145 Idaho 313, 179 P.3d 276; No. 32326
The insurer demanded appraisal but the process was never finished. Because the insurer did not follow its own appraisal process and both appraisers put the loss above the policy limit, the court upheld the award of the limit and would not let the insurer pay only actual cash value.
Limits: Homeowners policy. The appraisal wording is quoted only in a footnote; the court made no ruling on umpire selection or costs.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Boler-Phillips Body Shop, Inc. v. Employers Mutual Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit · October 24, 2007 · 251 F. App'x 912, No. 07-60284
Appraisal compliance was a condition to suit once the insurer invoked it. The insurer did not waive appraisal by not moving to compel it. Sharing appraisal costs did not make the clause unconscionable.
Limits: Unpublished, not precedent; commercial fire and business-interruption policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Supreme Court of Alabama · October 12, 2007 · 984 So. 2d 382; No. 1051458
Appraisers decide only the amount of loss. Coverage and causation disputes belong to the courts. An insurer that invoked appraisal almost two years after the loss and 14 months into the suit did not waive it, because the insureds did not show substantial prejudice.
Limits: Homeowner policy with "amount of loss" wording. Two justices dissented in part on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Griswold Properties, LLC v. Lexington Insurance Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals (special conflict panel) · September 6, 2007 · 276 Mich App 551 (Docket Nos. 263197, 265278, 268335)
An insured is owed 12 percent penalty interest on benefits not paid on time, whether or not the claim was reasonably in dispute. The panel rejected the contrary Arco rule. One of the three cases was a fire claim the insurer paid through appraisal.
Limits: Published conflict-panel opinion. Whether and when satisfactory proof of loss was received is a question of fact.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Johnson v. Mutual Service Cas. Ins. Co.
Minnesota Court of Appeals · June 5, 2007 · 732 N.W.2d 340 (No. A06-1478)
An appraisal demand made after the two-year limit, when the insured's suit was time-barred, comes too late.
Limits: Ariel (2024) limits its reach to cases where no timely suit is possible.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Griswold Properties, LLC v. Lexington Insurance Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · May 17, 2007 · 275 Mich App 543 (Docket Nos. 263197, 265278, 268335)
Going through appraisal does not give the insurer 60 days after the award to pay; O J Enterprises rested on a repealed statute and no longer applies. Satisfactory proof of loss does not require agreement on the amount. Interest was owed on the part of the appraisal award not paid within 60 days of proof of loss.
Limits: Published. Its part on reasonably disputed claims was vacated and replaced by the conflict-panel opinion (276 Mich App 551).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Travelers Property & Casualty Co. v. Christie
Connecticut Appellate Court · March 6, 2007 · 99 Conn. App. 747, 916 A.2d 114
After an appraisal award, the umpire's fee was split between insurer and insured under the policy. The insured's own appraiser, paid on the reasonable value of his work, disputed his fee with her; the court reversed his fee award and the prejudgment interest on it and ordered a new trial on the fee.
Limits: A dispute between the insured and her own appraiser. Decided 2 to 1.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hailey v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co.
North Carolina Court of Appeals · February 20, 2007 · 181 N.C. App. 677, 640 S.E.2d 849, No. COA06-187
An insured's appraisal demand was premature. The parties had to exchange enough information to reach a real disagreement over the amount of loss, and post-loss duties the insurer requested had to be met first.
Limits: A commercial property policy; turns on the policy wording. It adopted Florida reasoning (Romay).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McGowan v. Progressive Preferred Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Georgia · October 30, 2006 · 281 Ga. 169, 637 S.E.2d 27 (No. S05G2086)
An appraisal clause can settle only a disputed issue of value. It cannot resolve broader liability, so using it to decide fraud and similar claims would make it arbitration, which Georgia bars in insurance contracts. Paying an appraised value did not make those claims moot.
Limits: Auto total-loss claims, not a property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Washington Automotive Co. v. 1828 L Street Associates
District of Columbia Court of Appeals · September 14, 2006 · 906 A.2d 869
A written agreement to settle a dispute over the value of land or other property by appraisal is an arbitration agreement under the D.C. Arbitration Act. The appraisal was confirmed as an award, and the landlord had not met the high burden to set it aside.
Limits: Commercial lease, not insurance, decided under the earlier act. The court listed other states split on whether insurance appraisal is arbitration and did not decide it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co.
Indiana Court of Appeals · August 25, 2006 · 856 N.E.2d 713 (published by order of Oct. 26, 2006)
A court order that only named an umpire did not bar a later suit. The insured alleged a biased umpire who had known the insurer's appraiser for years and said he could ignore the insured's documents. That was enough to ask a court to set the award aside.
Limits: Reversed a summary judgment. It did not decide the umpire was in fact biased.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McGinity v. Pawtucket Mutual Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · June 13, 2006 · 899 A.2d 504
An arbitrator who was the insurer's lawyer and did not disclose it created evident partiality where he reached a very different amount than the other two arbitrators, so the award was vacated.
Limits: Uninsured-motorist arbitration, not property appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kacha v. Allstate Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 4th Dist., Div. 1 · June 1, 2006 · 140 Cal.App.4th 1023, 45 Cal.Rptr.3d 92 (No. D046961)
A panel exceeds its powers by deciding whether claimed items were damaged by the fire, which is causation and coverage. The insured did not waive the rule by agreeing to an award form, and holding the insurer's checks without cashing them did not bar him. The award was ordered vacated.
Limits: Wildfire loss under a standard form homeowners policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Angott v. Chubb Group of Insurance Companies
Michigan Court of Appeals · April 4, 2006 · 270 Mich App 465 (Docket No. 258026)
An insurer that admitted coverage in its answer and demanded appraisal gave up its coverage attack on the award. The insured may be owed 12 percent penalty interest on the parts of the claim not reasonably in dispute even though the amount went through appraisal, and is owed judgment interest and costs as the prevailing party.
Limits: Published. Its rule that penalty interest reaches only amounts not reasonably in dispute was rejected for insureds by Griswold (2007) and the Michigan Supreme Court in Nickola (2017). The waiver holding stands.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Frans v. Harleysville Lake States Insurance Co. (on reconsideration)
Michigan Court of Appeals · March 7, 2006 · 270 Mich App 201 (Docket No. 255091)
Because the statute requires the appraisal clause and lets either party demand appraisal, one side's demand starts appraisal and the other cannot revoke it as under ordinary common-law arbitration. Bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake can still be grounds to reject an award.
Limits: Published, on reconsideration; vacated the earlier unpublished opinion of 2006-01-12.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hartford Fire Insurance Co. v. Adcor Industries, Inc.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · December 14, 2005 · 158 F. App'x 430 (4th Cir. 2005) (per curiam, unpublished)
Applying Maryland law, the court said an appraisal award can be set aside only for narrow errors that are plain and palpable, and a court may correct concrete legal conclusions such as coverage rulings. An accountant's speculative affidavit did not raise a dispute, so the award stood.
Limits: Unpublished federal ruling on a commercial policy; not binding on Maryland courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cousino v. Stewart
Ohio Court of Appeals, 6th District (Fulton County) · November 23, 2005 · 2005-Ohio-6245 (Nos. F-05-011, F-05-004)
Under a homeowner policy, the court selected the umpire when the appraisers could not agree. Because the parties agreed to a binding resolution that also reached coverage questions, the court treated it as arbitration and confirmed the award. An insurer seeking to remove the umpire had to show evident partiality, which means more than an appearance of bias.
Limits: Turned on the parties' letters making the appraisal binding and broader than the amount of loss. Ries (Ohio 1909) treats the standard clause as an appraisal, not an arbitration.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Motorists Mutual Insurance Co. v. Post
U.S. District Court, E.D. Kentucky · October 20, 2005 · No. 04-487-JBC, 2005 WL 2674987
The court ordered appraisal and let the panel decide both cause and amount of loss, limited to damage from the named wind and ice storms. Whether the policy covers an event is for the court.
Limits: Federal court applying Kentucky law; the denial rested on fact-sensitive defenses the court could not decide yet.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kendall Lakes Townhomes Developers, Inc. v. Agricultural Excess & Surplus Lines Insurance Co.
Florida Third District Court of Appeal · October 5, 2005 · 916 So. 2d 12 (Fla. 3d DCA 2005), No. 3D04-3094
The insurer had not wholly denied coverage, so the appraisal panel could decide causation. But the umpire went beyond the task the trial court set and made coverage findings, so the order affirming the award was reversed and appraisal was sent to a new umpire.
Limits: Turned on the trial court's order limiting the umpire's role; does not set a general test for vacating awards.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
General Star Indemnity Co. v. Spring Creek Village Apartments Phase V, Inc.
Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston (14th Dist.) · November 30, 2004 · 152 S.W.3d 733 (Tex. App.-Houston [14th Dist.] 2004, no pet.), No. 14-02-00998-CV
A party appraiser whose fee grew with the size of the award raised a fact question about whether he was impartial. If a jury finds he was not, the award does not follow the policy and is not binding.
Limits: Commercial windstorm policy requiring a competent and impartial appraiser; a summary judgment ruling, not a flat ban on contingent fees. Link is a free copy on hallapproved.com, not the court's site.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Labrador v. Liberty Mutual Group
Hawaii Supreme Court · December 18, 2003 · 103 Hawai‘i 206, 81 P.3d 386; No. 25047
The insured’s attorney’s fee statute, HRS § 431:10-242, does not apply to a proceeding to confirm an arbitration award, and an arbitration is not a "suit" under it.
Limits: Auto uninsured motorist arbitration, not property appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bobick v. United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 27, 2003 · 439 Mass. 652
A final outcome may not be a definitive measure of whether an insurer's earlier offer was reasonable. An offer close to what a jury later awarded defeated the c. 93A and 176D claim.
Limits: A liability insurance case, not a reference award. Used only for how courts weigh early offers against a later figure.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
FTI International, Inc. v. Cincinnati Insurance Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Second District · May 27, 2003 · 339 Ill. App. 3d 258
The court reversed a stay for appraisal. Appraisal is a limited process for finding value, and a dispute over which policy provision sets the payment is a question of law for the court.
Limits: Commercial equipment loss. The court distinguished Beard and Bailey.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nelson v. Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · April 24, 2003 · 2003 MT 101, 315 Mont. 268, 68 P.3d 689
After a hail loss, a district judge picked the umpire under the policy. The insureds rejected the appraisers' joint report, so no appraisal award was filed and the 60-day payment clock never started. The insurer's later conduct did not violate the unfair claims statute.
Limits: Did not address vacating an award or the Arbitration Act. Claims were limited to conduct after the joint appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
HHC Associates v. Assurance Co. of America
U.S. District Court, E.D. Virginia · April 17, 2003 · 256 F. Supp. 2d 505
Section 38.2-2105 appraisal applies when the parties disagree on the amount of loss, not whether coverage exists. An insurer that denied the whole claim as wear and tear rather than storm damage did not act in bad faith by refusing appraisal.
Limits: Federal court predicting Virginia law; it noted no Virginia court had decided the point. Its footnote on appraisers weighing causation summarizes a Delaware case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Stratford West Homeowners Association v. Country Mutual Insurance Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Third District · April 4, 2003 · 338 Ill. App. 3d 288
An appraisal award on a condominium hail claim did not bind the parties or bar suit. The policy said an agreement of two sets the amount of loss but did not clearly say the insured gave up the right to sue. The court refused to overrule DeGroot.
Limits: Third District. Other districts treat appraisal awards as binding like arbitration awards.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hartman v. Estate of Miller
Supreme Court of North Dakota · February 19, 2003 · 2003 ND 24, 656 N.W.2d 676
An insurer must deal fairly and in good faith in handling claims, and is not liable for bad faith when the claim is fairly debatable. An insurer that fails in this duty may owe the insured attorney fees as damages.
Limits: Auto no-fault and uninsured motorist claim, not property appraisal. For property insurers, N.D.C.C. 26.1-39-29 (2025) now adds a precondition to a bad-faith claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
AIU Insurance Co. v. Lexes
Delaware Supreme Court · January 15, 2003 · 815 A.2d 312
A party may sue to decide whether appraisers had authority to award more than the policy limits or for items the policy excludes, even when the policy makes appraisal binding. That is a question of law for the court. The court did not disturb the appraisers' valuations.
Limits: Automobile policy. It cites Didimoi for the cause-of-loss point without adopting it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Harleysville Mutual Insurance Co. v. Narron
North Carolina Court of Appeals · December 31, 2002 · 155 N.C. App. 362, 574 S.E.2d 490, No. COA02-137
A policy appraisal award is presumed valid and binding unless there is fraud, duress or other impeaching circumstances. An umpire's private meeting with one appraiser after joint meetings did not void the award, and the Uniform Arbitration Act did not apply to a policy appraisal that does not call for it.
Limits: Decided on the policy's appraisal wording and the facts. It does not discuss what disinterested means.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Allstate Insurance Co. v. Suarez
Supreme Court of Florida · December 12, 2002 · 833 So. 2d 762 (Fla. 2002), No. SC01-1459
An appraisal clause that is not ambiguous is not read as an agreement to arbitrate. Once appraisal is properly invoked, it follows the policy's informal process, not the formal hearing procedures of the Florida Arbitration Code.
Limits: Decided on the wording of the clause; does not list grounds for setting an award aside.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Johnson v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Florida · September 26, 2002 · 828 So. 2d 1021 (Fla. 2002), Nos. SC01-91 & SC01-321
If the insurer wholly denies a covered loss, whether a covered cause produced the damage is a question for the court. If the insurer admits a covered loss and disputes the amount, the cause of the damage is for the appraisal panel.
Limits: Turns on whether the insurer wholly denies coverage or only disputes amount. San Marco (2024) says Johnson did not decide the order of coverage and appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hall v. Acadia Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · July 9, 2002 · 2002 ME 110, 801 A.2d 993
An umpire's award included diminished value, but the policy covered only the cost to repair. The court held the policy did not cover diminished value and affirmed judgment for the insurer, so the umpire's figure did not create coverage.
Limits: Automobile collision policy, not a property policy. Cited only for the point that an umpire's figure does not expand coverage.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Western National Mutual Insurance Co. v. University of North Dakota
Supreme Court of North Dakota · April 16, 2002 · 2002 ND 63, 643 N.W.2d 4
North Dakota's statutes codify the efficient proximate cause rule for property damage when a covered and an excluded peril both contribute. The court also upheld prejudgment interest on a certain amount and attorney fees to an insured who won coverage in court.
Limits: Not an appraisal case. Decided a coverage dispute for the court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Linder v. Insurance Claims Consultants, Inc.
South Carolina Supreme Court · February 25, 2002 · 348 S.C. 477, 560 S.E.2d 612
Public insurance adjusting is not the unauthorized practice of law. The court noted the parties agreed public adjusters may act as appraisers.
Limits: Decided under the former public adjuster statute (ch. 48), since repealed. It does not address appraisal panels directly.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Miller v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
Utah Supreme Court · January 11, 2002 · 2002 UT 6, 44 P.3d 663
Appraisal is not arbitration, so the Utah Arbitration Act and its case law do not directly apply. A result is either evidence or an enforceable award, depending on the policy. A clause limited to the amount of loss reaches only property damage, so bad faith and other extra-contractual claims stayed in court even after USAA paid the award. The court, not the panel, decides the scope of the clause.
Limits: Decided under the Arbitration Act as it stood in 2002. Did not decide whether the later Title 78B ch. 11 applies, or how to separate coverage from amount of loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Allstate Indemnity Co. v. Jellerson
Maine Superior Court (Cumberland County) · August 29, 2001 · No. CV-00-693
A trial court held a repair shop owner could serve as the insured's "qualified appraiser" because he had no stake in the outcome. It said the old Maine cases on "disinterested" referees dealt with different policy words.
Limits: Trial court order, not binding. Automobile policy using "qualified appraiser," not the fire policy clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Calandro v. Allstate Insurance Co.
Connecticut Appellate Court · June 5, 2001 · 63 Conn. App. 602, 778 A.2d 212
The trial court found that a public adjusting firm broke the policy's disinterested appraiser requirement by naming its own employee, who had worked on the claim, as the insureds' appraiser, and by not withdrawing the choice promptly. The appellate court affirmed the judgment against the insurer's claim for losses it said that conduct caused.
Limits: The disinterested finding was the trial court's. The appeal was about the insurer's CUTPA claim against the adjuster, so the appellate court did not decide what disinterested means.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Michael v. Aetna Life & Casualty Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist. · May 30, 2001 · 88 Cal.App.4th 925, 106 Cal.Rptr.2d 240 (No. B131509)
Two earlier cases for the insurer, both over before this one began, were not a substantial business relationship, so the party appraiser did not have to disclose them and the award was confirmed.
Limits: Applied the disclosure rule as it stood before the 2001-02 amendments, which Mahnke (2009) later held do not reach party appraisers.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lundy v. Farmers Group, Inc.
Illinois Appellate Court, Second District · May 24, 2001 · 322 Ill. App. 3d 214
An appraisal clause can be waived by conduct inconsistent with it. The insurer demanded appraisal years after paying and 10 months after suit, after litigating, so it waived. A claim needing policy interpretation was outside appraisal.
Limits: Auto policy. The court found no earlier Illinois case on waiver of an appraisal clause and borrowed arbitration rules.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Co. v. Batts
Tennessee Court of Appeals · May 15, 2001 · 59 S.W.3d 142
An appraisal clause in a homeowners policy is not an arbitration agreement. The appraisers may set the amount of the loss but not decide coverage, liability or whether a peril caused a loss.
Limits: Applies to the homeowners form in the case. Published.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Weidman v. Erie Insurance Group
Indiana Court of Appeals · April 6, 2001 · 745 N.E.2d 292
An appraisal award sets the amount of the loss, but other policy terms decide how much the insurer owes. The insurer could ask for proof of repair spending before paying more of the award, though it could not hold back overhead and profit on that ground. Bad-faith and breach claims over the withheld part went back for trial.
Limits: Policy wording about replacement cost drove the result.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bell v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · March 26, 2001 · 146 N.H. 190, 776 A.2d 1260
The Court declined to overrule Lawton and recognize a tort claim for bad faith delay or refusal to settle a first-party claim.
Limits: An auto uninsured-motorist arbitration case, not about property appraisal. Cited only for Lawton.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Jupiter Aluminum Corp. v. Home Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit (Indiana law) · August 22, 2000 · 225 F.3d 868
Applying Indiana law, an appraisal is binding even if the policy does not say so, unless the insured shows unfairness or injustice. A business-income award stood.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Indiana law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
County Forest Products, Inc. v. Green Mountain Agency, Inc.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · August 17, 2000 · 2000 ME 161, 758 A.2d 59
The insurers argued the insured's appraiser was not disinterested. Because they wrote that they would accept a representative of his firm, the court held they waived the objection and upheld the award. It also upheld bad faith and attorney fees where the insurers did not pay the award within 60 days or dispute it.
Limits: Did not decide whether the appraiser was actually disinterested. Commercial fire policy with an appraisal clause required by section 3002.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
CIGNA Insurance Co. v. Didimoi Property Holdings, N.V.
U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware · August 11, 2000 · 110 F. Supp. 2d 259
Applying Delaware law to a commercial property policy, the court held 'amount of loss' includes whether the fire caused the damage, so the appraisers may decide cause. Coverage and exclusion questions stay with the court.
Limits: Federal trial court, so not binding on Delaware courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McGee v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Second District · July 31, 2000 · 315 Ill. App. 3d 673
An insurer's use of appraisal and payment of the award, without more, did not defeat the insured's claim for unreasonable delay under section 155. A bona fide dispute over the amount had to be shown.
Limits: Decided on the pleadings; the court did not find the insurer liable.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Louise Gardens of Encino Homeowners' Association v. Truck Insurance Exchange
California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist., Div. 3 · July 25, 2000 · 82 Cal.App.4th 648, 98 Cal.Rptr.2d 378 (No. B132007)
An insured that accepted the benefits of an appraisal award, filed no petition to vacate or correct it, and then petitioned to confirm it could not later attack the award.
Limits: Contrast Kacha (2006), where merely holding uncashed checks was not a waiver.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ward v. Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · July 7, 2000 · 332 N.J. Super. 515, 753 A.2d 1214
Appraisal is a favored remedy consistent with the statutory fire form. A coverage dispute did not necessarily stop either side from invoking it. The court-appointed umpire's actual cash value figure stood, and parties have no right to formal evidence-taking in appraisal.
Limits: Main holding was on replacement cost and a wrongful denial of coverage; the case was remanded for a damages trial.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Gray v. North Carolina Insurance Underwriting Ass'n
Supreme Court of North Carolina · June 16, 2000 · 352 N.C. 61, 529 S.E.2d 676, No. 84PA99
Conduct that violates the unfair claim settlement statute, such as not trying in good faith to settle when liability is reasonably clear, is an unfair trade practice under G.S. 75-1.1 as a matter of law, without proof of a general business practice.
Limits: Not an appraisal case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fraley v. Allstate Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal · June 14, 2000 · 81 Cal.App.4th 1282, 97 Cal.Rptr.2d 386
Bad faith failed as a matter of law where there was a real dispute over repair scope and cost, the insurer paid the undisputed amount, went to appraisal on the rest, and promptly paid the replacement cost award.
Limits: Decided on its facts; not a rule that paying an award ends bad faith claims.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mutual Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · January 31, 2000 · 745 A.2d 1261
Appraisal is reviewed like common-law arbitration. Where the policy said only "competent", an appraiser paid under a contingency arrangement was not unfit by that fact alone.
Limits: Did not decide whether the word "disinterested" would change the result.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Auto-Owners Insurance Co. v. Allied Adjusters & Appraisers, Inc.
Michigan Court of Appeals · November 5, 1999 · 238 Mich App 394; 605 NW2d 685 (Docket No. 202933)
Since the 1990 statute, an appraiser need only be independent and may lean toward the side that hired him. The umpire must be impartial. An appraiser who was the adjuster on the claim is not disqualified.
Limits: Per curiam. Published.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Inland Group of Companies, Inc. v. Providence Washington Insurance Co.
Idaho Supreme Court · August 12, 1999 · 133 Idaho 249, 985 P.2d 674; No. 23875
An insured may not sue for policy proceeds without first using a valid clause for settling the amount, but not demanding it does not bar a bad faith claim for unreasonable delay. The insurer cannot simply wait for the insured to demand it.
Limits: Commercial fire policy. The clause said appraisal; the court called it arbitration and did not decide the difference.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Riley v. Farmers Fire Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · July 21, 1999 · 735 A.2d 124
A court that appointed an umpire could not vacate his award without evidence of fraud, misconduct or irregularity. The insurer had to petition to vacate within 30 days of the award; after that the court must confirm it.
Limits: The trial court had appointed the umpire; homeowner policy with an ordinary appraisal clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rastelli Brothers, Inc. v. Netherlands Insurance Co.
United States District Court, District of New Jersey · June 28, 1999 · 68 F. Supp. 2d 440 (D.N.J. 1999)
A property policy's appraisal clause covers only the amount of loss, not coverage, and the insurer kept its right to deny the claim. Where the insurer disputed only coverage, not the amount, the court declined to force appraisal under the Federal Arbitration Act.
Limits: A federal court applying New Jersey law, not a New Jersey court. Decided on the policy's own wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rubin v. Western Mutual Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist. · May 13, 1999 · 71 Cal.App.4th 1539, 84 Cal.Rptr.2d 648
A judgment confirming an appraisal award before trial did not end the case: the insured's contract and bad faith claims were still unresolved, so the insurer's appeal was dismissed as not from a final judgment.
Limits: Procedural; earthquake policy; does not decide the merits of any bad faith claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Minot Town & Country v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Dakota · December 22, 1998 · 1998 ND 215, 587 N.W.2d 189
A policy appraisal is not an arbitration, so North Dakota's Uniform Arbitration Act did not apply and the award stood. Appraisal fixes the amount of loss only, leaving liability for later decision.
Limits: The insured's argument that the insurer's appraiser was not impartial was not decided, because it was raised under the Arbitration Act. The policy kept the insurer's right to deny the claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
PHC, Inc. v. North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
North Carolina Court of Appeals · June 16, 1998 · 129 N.C. App. 801, No. COA97-1118
A policy appraisal is not arbitration, so attorney's fees under G.S. 6-21.1 were allowed after the loss was set by appraisal, because the insurer refused to pay even the undisputed amount without a release. Interest ran from the date of breach.
Limits: A car physical damage claim. The interest ruling was made after the court found it lacked jurisdiction over that point.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · April 24, 1998 · 27 F. Supp. 2d 1211; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK
After the award was confirmed, the insurer could still contest mitigation, coverage and causation for the second period. A bad-faith claim for unreasonable delay may reach the time before, during and after appraisal, up to payment. The unfair claims statute gives no private right of action, but violations can be evidence of bad faith.
Limits: Federal court applying Hawaii law; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Christiansen v. First Insurance Co. of Hawaii
Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals (published opinion) · March 18, 1998 · 88 Hawai‘i 442, 967 P.2d 639; No. 19968 (amended April 22, 1998)
An appraisal clause can imply an agreement to arbitrate only the amount of loss. A lawsuit on the loss must be stayed, not dismissed, while appraisal goes on. A first-party bad-faith claim is an independent tort, is not referable to appraisal, and is not barred by an ongoing appraisal.
Limits: Decided under former chapter 658. The Hawaii Supreme Court reversed only the equitable-tolling ruling and affirmed the rest on September 1, 1998 (88 Hawai‘i 136, 963 P.2d 345).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
National Standard Ins. Co. v. Westbrooks
Arkansas Supreme Court · February 19, 1998 · 331 Ark. 445, 962 S.W.2d 355
The 12% penalty and fees under the loss-claim statute require recovery within the statute's percentage of the amount demanded, and the statute is read strictly.
Limits: Not an appraisal case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McGourty v. Pennsylvania Millers Mutual Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · December 31, 1997 · 704 A.2d 663
Appraisal decides only the amount of loss, with all other issues left for negotiation or a lawsuit, and is reviewed like arbitration. An order removing an appraisal panel and starting over is not immediately appealable.
Limits: Per curiam; homeowner fire claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Terra Industries, Inc. v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of America
U.S. District Court, N.D. Iowa · October 10, 1997 · 981 F. Supp. 581 (No. C 97-4030-MWB)
Predicting Iowa law, the court held a demand for appraisal made after suit is waived only if not made within a reasonable time after the parties reach an impasse, with the burden on the party claiming waiver and prejudice as a factor.
Limits: Federal trial court. No Iowa appellate decision on this timing question was found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · September 26, 1997 · 27 F. Supp. 2d 1208; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK
The court confirmed an appraisal award in its entirety and refused to confirm only the part that favored the insured. Judicial review of the award is extremely narrow, and the panel’s time-period categories stayed within its authority.
Limits: Federal court under the Federal Arbitration Act; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Friday v. Trinity Universal of Kansas
Kansas Supreme Court · May 30, 1997 · 262 Kan. 347, 939 P.2d 869 (No. 74,666)
A homeowner's appraisal clause that sends the amount of loss to appraisers is a form of arbitration. The old Kansas arbitration act barred arbitration clauses in insurance contracts, so the clause could not be enforced, and the Federal Arbitration Act did not override that bar.
Limits: Decided under K.S.A. 5-401(c)(1), repealed in 2018. Two justices dissented on whether appraisal is arbitration. No Kansas appellate court has said whether it still controls under the 2018 act.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Steiner v. Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co.
Connecticut Appellate Court · March 11, 1997 · 44 Conn. App. 415, 689 A.2d 1154
The appraisal submission was unrestricted, but the panel's later award reset actual cash value beyond what had been submitted. The court reversed and ordered that award vacated, leaving the cost of code upgrades in undamaged areas to be decided.
Limits: Homeowner fire loss with a signed memorandum of appraisal. The policy required a demand within 60 days after proof of loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
General Casualty Co. v. Tracer Industries, Inc.
Illinois Appellate Court, Fourth District · December 18, 1996 · 285 Ill. App. 3d 418, 674 N.E.2d 473
The court upheld a fire appraisal award. It gave substantial deference to appraisers and would set one aside only for fraud, mistake or gross error shown on the face of the award. A court-appointed umpire's membership in a local business group was not a disqualifying conflict.
Limits: Commercial fire policy; one justice dissented. No objection to the umpire was made until after his report.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Friday v. Trinity Universal of Kansas
Kansas Court of Appeals · October 18, 1996 · 22 Kan. App. 2d 935, 924 P.2d 1284
The court of appeals held the policy's appraisal clause was an arbitration clause and was not enforceable, and reversed the dismissal of the insured's suit.
Limits: Affirmed by the Kansas Supreme Court in 1997 under the repealed arbitration act.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Enzor v. North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
North Carolina Court of Appeals · August 6, 1996 · 123 N.C. App. 544, 473 S.E.2d 638, No. COA95-568
A court could not enter judgment on an award signed only by the umpire when the policy required a written award signed by any two. Errors of fact or law do not void a fairly made appraisal award.
Limits: A crop fire case under the standard fire policy provisions then in G.S. 58-44-15.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Best Place, Inc. v. Penn America Insurance Co.
Hawaii Supreme Court · June 5, 1996 · 82 Hawai‘i 120, 920 P.2d 334; No. 16065
Hawaii recognizes the tort of bad faith in first-party insurance, including unreasonable delay in paying benefits. Article 13 of the Insurance Code gives no private cause of action, but its remedies are not exclusive.
Limits: Not an appraisal case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wolford v. Landmark American Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · May 17, 1996 · 196 W. Va. 528, 474 S.E.2d 458, No. 22947
A summary judgment that blamed the insured for stalling appraisal was reopened. Where a policy lets either side ask a judge to pick the umpire, either side could have made the request, so the insurer was not entitled to judgment on that ground.
Limits: Per curiam. Theft loss on mining equipment under a policy that said "impartial" appraisers. Decided on a Rule 60(b) motion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
J. Wise Smith & Associates, Inc. v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Tennessee · December 5, 1995 · 925 F. Supp. 528
An insurer waived appraisal by demanding it only after suit, an answer, disclosures and the close of discovery, five weeks before trial.
Limits: Federal trial court predicting Tennessee law. Businessowners policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bushey v. Allstate Insurance Co.
Vermont Supreme Court · October 27, 1995 · 164 Vt. 399, 670 A.2d 807
Vermont recognizes a bad-faith claim by an insured against its own insurer. The insurer must have had no reasonable basis to deny the claim and known or recklessly ignored that. The insurer there had paid an arbitration award within a month, and the claim still failed on the merits because it was fairly debatable.
Limits: Underinsured-motorist claim with arbitration, not property appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Gebers v. State Farm General Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist., Div. 4 · October 6, 1995 · 38 Cal.App.4th 1648, 45 Cal.Rptr.2d 725 (No. A068089)
A party-selected appraiser must be disinterested, and a policy cannot weaken the statute's word. The insurer's appraiser was then its paid expert witness and did not say so, so the award was voided and a new appraisal required.
Limits: Disclosure analysis relied on arbitration rules before the 2001-02 amendments.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Doggett v. McLachlen Bancshares Corp.
District of Columbia Court of Appeals · August 10, 1995 · 663 A.2d 511
When parties agree that appraisers will set a value, the valuation is binding and courts will not question it absent fraud or mistake. A challenger must show the appraisers exceeded their authority, misunderstood their duties, made a fundamental mistake, or acted from fraud or bias.
Limits: Ground lease rent appraisal, not insurance.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co. v. Clinton
Connecticut Appellate Court · August 1, 1995 · 38 Conn. App. 555, 662 A.2d 1319
An insurer could obtain an order compelling insureds to proceed with appraisal and the appointment of an appraiser under §§ 52-410 and 52-411. The insureds could not escape appraisal by waiving their own right to it. The court could not find that the delay before the insurer demanded appraisal was unreasonable as a matter of law.
Limits: Homeowner's fire loss. The insured said she wanted to waive appraisal to sue for breach of contract and CUTPA.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hueser v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Co.
Missouri Court of Appeals · April 11, 1995 · 901 S.W.2d 138
A circuit judge appointed an umpire on the insurer's request after the appraisers failed to pick one. The insured who asked for appraisal under the fire statute was not locked into taking cash; equity decides when the choice becomes binding.
Limits: Decided under the pre-2021 version of 379.150.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Tackett v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Insurance Co.
Delaware Supreme Court · February 10, 1995 · 653 A.2d 254
Delaware recognizes a first-party claim against an insurer for bad faith delay or nonpayment of a claim as a breach of contract. The insured must show the insurer lacked reasonable justification.
Limits: Underinsured motorist claim. It does not address appraisal or a claim after an award is paid.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · January 19, 1995 · 904 F. Supp. 1142; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK
Under Hawaii law a binding appraisal clause is an arbitration agreement. The panel decides the value of the property before the storm and the damage it caused, and may consider code-upgrade costs, but may not decide coverage or liability.
Limits: Federal court applying the Federal Arbitration Act and Hawaii law; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
DeGroot v. Farmers Mutual Hail Insurance Co. of Iowa
Illinois Appellate Court, Third District · December 8, 1994 · 267 Ill. App. 3d 723, 643 N.E.2d 875
An appraisal award was not binding because the policy did not clearly say the insured gave up the right to sue by taking part in appraisal.
Limits: Crop-hail policy. The Third District applied it to a condominium property policy in 2003. Other districts enforce appraisal like arbitration.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Silvey Companies v. Riley
Arkansas Supreme Court · December 5, 1994 · 318 Ark. 788, 888 S.W.2d 636
An insurer that pays a fire loss after suit is filed still owes the 12% penalty and attorney's fees if it paid later than the policy's time, unless continued investigation was reasonably necessary.
Limits: Not an appraisal case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Equity Mutual Insurance Co. v. Campbell
Missouri Court of Appeals · November 8, 1994 · 886 S.W.2d 221
An appraisal award is conclusive on the amount unless fraudulently procured. Skipping some inspection steps was not fraud. Challenges to an appraiser or umpire should be made when they are named, not after the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Meineke v. Twin City Fire Insurance Co.
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · September 20, 1994 · 181 Ariz. 576, 892 P.2d 1365
Arizona treats appraisal like arbitration. The insurer waived appraisal by filing an answer without demanding it and by delaying its demand, so the refusal to compel appraisal was affirmed. Where a policy gives no time to demand appraisal, the demand must come within a reasonable time, and waiver is not favored.
Limits: Two-to-one decision with a dissent. Review denied April 25, 1995. The policy was a homeowners-type policy that asked for a "competent" appraiser, with a one-year suit limit. It applies arbitration law to appraisal but does not itself decide impartiality or umpire questions.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dayton v. Farmers Ins. Group
Washington Supreme Court · July 21, 1994 · 124 Wn.2d 277, 876 P.2d 896
Olympic Steamship attorney fees are not available where the insurer accepts coverage and the only dispute is the value of the claim. The trial court could not add fees when confirming the arbitration award.
Limits: UIM arbitration under an auto policy; Montler (unpublished) applied it to a property appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Richter v. Western States Insurance Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Fifth District · June 28, 1994 · 264 Ill. App. 3d 230
Appraisers and the umpire did not exceed their authority by leaving seasonal inventory losses out. With no reservation in the policy, all matters in dispute are presumed to be for the appraisal. A party attacking an award must show excess of authority by clear and convincing proof.
Limits: Commercial fire policy. Later cases (FTI, Lundy, Lytle, Zhao) treat coverage as a court question.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
London v. Trinity Companies
Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals, Division 3 · April 12, 1994 · 1994 OK CIV APP 59, 877 P.2d 620 (No. 80077)
The insured demanded appraisal, the insurer paid the award, and the insured cashed the checks. The award bound the insured who invoked it because there was no fraud, collusion or other improper action. An insurer asking its appraiser to pay close attention to its own lower estimate was advisory only and not bad faith. Summary judgment for the insurer on the contract and bad-faith claims was affirmed.
Limits: Memorandum opinion of an intermediate court; its weight as precedent depends on how it was released for publication. The bad-faith ruling also rested on undocumented living-expense claims.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Williams v. Southern General Insurance Co.
Court of Appeals of Georgia · February 7, 1994 · 211 Ga. App. 867, 440 S.E.2d 753 (No. A93A1889)
An insurer can waive a policy provision by inaction and delay. Whether the insurer waived the appraisal clause by invoking it only after the suit began and the car was destroyed was a jury question, so summary judgment for the insurer was reversed.
Limits: Auto collision policy, not property.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co. v. Krawitz
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · November 15, 1993 · 430 Pa. Super. 25, 633 A.2d 215
An insurer could not block an appraisal award by having its own appraiser stay silent. The umpire could settle the loss, and nothing in the contract barred an appraiser from adopting a contractor's estimate.
Limits: Homeowner fire claim; the insurer's appraiser stopped taking part over a fee dispute.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Santos v. Insurance Placement Facility
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · May 20, 1993 · 426 Pa. Super. 226, 626 A.2d 1177
An insurer's slow handling under the Unfair Insurance Practices regulations did not forfeit its right to demand appraisal. Appraisal was the proper way to set the amount of loss.
Limits: FAIR Plan fire policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Pickett v. Lloyd's
New Jersey Supreme Court · March 15, 1993 · 131 N.J. 457, 621 A.2d 445
In a first-party claim, an insurer is liable for bad faith only when it lacked a reasonable basis to deny or delay the claim and knew or recklessly ignored that. If a claim is fairly debatable, no tort liability arises.
Limits: Not an appraisal case, and a collision claim by a trucker, not a homeowner. It says nothing about the effect of paying an appraisal award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lancellotti v. Maryland Casualty Co.
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · December 11, 1992 · 260 N.J. Super. 579, 617 A.2d 296
A fire policy's 30-day payment clause did not start running until the loss was ascertained by written agreement or by the filing of an appraisal award, so the insurer's duty to pay had not been triggered.
Limits: A short passage in a fire policy case about actual cash value; turns on that policy's wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hemingway v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Appellate Division, Third Department · November 12, 1992 · 187 AD2d 814
Insureds who cashed checks for the exact appraisal award made a full accord and satisfaction of their claim. Their conclusory claims that the umpire was partial did not overcome the presumption that the appraisal was valid.
Limits: Homeowners fire claim decided on summary judgment.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Massey v. Farmers Insurance Group
Oklahoma Supreme Court · June 2, 1992 · 1992 OK 80, 837 P.2d 880 (No. 75279)
An umpire's award under the statutory fire policy binds the party that demanded appraisal but not the party forced into it, because binding that party would deny its right to a jury. The court approved the view that appraisers decide only the amount of damage, and that awards generally cannot decide the cause of a loss.
Limits: Answered a certified question from the Tenth Circuit. The case involved no coverage or causation dispute. Two justices concurred in the result only. Corrected June 22, 1992; rehearing denied September 23, 1992.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Emmons v. Lake States Insurance Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · April 6, 1992 · 193 Mich App 460; 484 NW2d 712 (Docket No. 125869)
The court refused to set aside an award or remove a court-appointed umpire who had worked for insurers for thirty years. The person attacking an umpire or appraiser must prove partiality. Review is limited to bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake.
Limits: Decided under former 500.2832, which required disinterested persons.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lancaster v. General Accident Insurance Co. of America
Massachusetts Appeals Court · February 28, 1992 · 32 Mass. App. Ct. 925
A letter denying all coverage that said nothing about a reference could be found to waive the reference as a condition of suit. Waiver was a question of fact, and the insurer could still seek a reference.
Limits: The SJC granted further review and reversed the trial court for the reasons in this opinion, 413 Mass. 1007 (1992-12-09).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. v. Oakland
Montana Supreme Court · January 28, 1992 · 251 Mont. 352, 825 P.2d 554
After an umpire's award on a commercial fire loss, the court itself decided whether the policy covered asbestos removal. It held the cost was covered as debris removal and could not be deducted from the award, and sent back the fact question of how much removal was needed.
Limits: Insurer brought a declaratory action; no one argued the panel could decide coverage.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Darlow v. Farmers Insurance Exchange
Supreme Court of Wyoming · December 9, 1991 · 822 P.2d 820
In a first-party bad-faith case the court agreed that later payment of a denied or unreasonably delayed claim does not wipe out the wrong. It found no bad faith there because no claim had been denied or unreasonably delayed.
Limits: Auto medical-payments coverage, not property and not appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · November 22, 1991 · 186 W. Va. 195, 411 S.E.2d 850, No. 20073
Paying a loss through an appraisal does not bar a first-party bad-faith suit if the insured substantially prevailed in the appraisal. An ordinary appraisal clause decides only the amount of loss, not coverage or policy defenses. The insurer that invoked appraisal could have asked a judge to name an umpire after fifteen days and instead let the matter drift, and the court noted that courts apply waiver and estoppel to appraisal.
Limits: Commercial policy on a truck and drilling rig. The coverage statement is reasoning, not the main holding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Auto-Owners Insurance Co. v. Kwaiser
Michigan Court of Appeals · August 5, 1991 · 190 Mich App 482; 476 NW2d 467 (Docket No. 128236)
Appraisal replaces a court fight over the amount of loss. A court, not the appraisers, decides coverage, and it does so before appraisal if the parties disagree. Review of an award is limited to bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake. The appraisers' amount for personal property they never saw stood, because that was about how to measure the loss.
Limits: Published. Mixed on causation: it kept an exclusion fight for the court but treated what items are in the loss as the appraisers' call.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lynch v. American Family Mutual Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals (published) · July 2, 1991 · 163 Wis. 2d 1003, 473 N.W.2d 515
An insurer could not demand appraisal after the insured sued when it had ample opportunity to demand it before suit, because the policy did not make appraisal a condition of suing. The court reversed the stay of the lawsuit pending appraisal.
Limits: The Supreme Court later said Lynch did not hold that a post-suit demand is always barred (Farmers, para. 36). Turned on policy wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Grabbert
Rhode Island Supreme Court · April 23, 1991 · 590 A.2d 88
A party-appointed arbitrator on a 10 percent contingent fee had an improper financial interest, but the award stood because there was no proof the fee caused the result. Evident partiality needs an improper interest plus a causal link.
Limits: Uninsured-motorist arbitration, not property appraisal. Applied to property appraisal in Vermont Mutual (2025).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bates v. Allied Mutual Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · March 20, 1991 · 467 N.W.2d 255
Followed Seeman: chapter 507B creates no private cause of action.
Limits: Third-party claimant case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Northeast Financial Corp. v. Insurance Co. of North America
U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware · February 28, 1991 · 757 F. Supp. 381
Following Closser, the court treated an appraisal clause as arbitration on the amount of loss and reviewed the motion to vacate under the Delaware Uniform Arbitration Act. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss and leaves other issues to the court.
Limits: Federal trial court. It rejected a 1987 Court of Chancery letter that said appraisal review is not limited. The policy pre-dates the 2009 change to 10 Del. C. § 5702.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Central Life Insurance Co. v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · February 20, 1991 · 466 N.W.2d 257 (No. 89-1611)
Awards are presumed valid and stand unless fraud, mistake or misfeasance is shown. An appraiser paid a percentage of the settled loss is interested as a matter of law, so the award was voided with no showing of harm. Waiver needs knowledge of the facts, and advocacy alone does not disqualify an appraiser. A judge had no power to name an umpire on an informal request with no case filed. The insurer’s challenge to the award was fairly debatable, so the insured’s bad-faith verdict was set aside.
Limits: Commercial fire policy. The umpire-appointment point predates chapter 522F.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Meyer v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Court of Special Appeals of Maryland · November 28, 1990 · 85 Md. App. 83, 582 A.2d 275
A homeowner policy's appraisal clause does not violate the right to a jury trial, even though the policy was a contract of adhesion. The appraisal clause is valid and must be used in good faith before suing on the amount of loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Waradzin v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · February 23, 1990 · 570 A.2d 649
The standard-form appraisal is arbitration, so the award could be confirmed under § 10-3-11. A party objecting that a matter is not arbitrable must say so at the hearing or refuse to take part.
Limits: Fire policy on the standard form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dunn v. Way
Montana Supreme Court · February 5, 1990 · 241 Mont. 208, 786 P.2d 649
Following Garretson, the insureds had to go through the appraisal the insurer demanded before suing over a trailer and its contents. Leaving appraisal out of the answer did not waive it. No interest runs until the amount is fixed, and the bad faith claim could wait until appraisal was done.
Limits: Auto policy for the trailer and homeowners policy for its contents.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Monroe Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Backstage, Inc.
Indiana Court of Appeals · May 1, 1989 · 537 N.E.2d 528
The right to appraisal can be waived. If the policy sets no time to demand it, it must be demanded within a reasonable time. It is lost only if good-faith talks on the amount of loss ended and the delay caused prejudice. The insurer demanded appraisal after six months of impasse and had not waived it, because no prejudice was shown.
Limits: Interlocutory appeal on an insurer's demand. The court borrowed its test from out-of-state cases.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rawlings v. Amco Insurance Co.
Nebraska Supreme Court · April 21, 1989 · 231 Neb. 874, 438 N.W.2d 769 (No. 87-966)
A homeowners policy clause that lets either side demand appraisal of the amount of loss is void, because a promise made before any dispute to give up the courts is against public policy. An insured's refusal to appraise did not entitle the insurer to summary judgment. The Department's approval of the policy form did not change that.
Limits: Decides the pre-dispute policy clause only. It does not say what happens when both sides agree to appraisal after a dispute arises. The opinion's umpire, cost and qualification terms are quoted policy language, not rules.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · September 23, 1988 · 234 Mont. 103, 761 P.2d 1288
An appraisal clause that sets only the amount of loss is enforceable and binding, and the insured had to go through it before suing, even though the insurer demanded it after suit was filed. The Uniform Arbitration Act did not apply because it excludes insurance policies.
Limits: Private auto policy, not a property policy. The statute cited as (2)(b) is now (2)(c).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Southern General Insurance Co. v. Kent
Court of Appeals of Georgia · June 10, 1988 · 187 Ga. App. 496, 370 S.E.2d 663 (No. 75965)
An appraisal award binds the parties on the amount of loss unless it is set aside, and appraisal decides amount of loss while a suit decides liability. The 60 day bad-faith period is paused while appraisal is pending, so an insurer that paid soon after the award owed no penalty or fees.
Limits: 1988 decision about wind damage to a home; the insurer invoked appraisal before the bad-faith demand letter.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Binkewitz v. Allstate Insurance Co.
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · February 4, 1988 · 222 N.J. Super. 501, 537 A.2d 723
A homeowner fire policy's appraisal clause comes from N.J.S.A. 17:36-5.20. Statements made about a nominated appraiser during the appraisal are protected only by a qualified privilege, because appraisal has no presiding officer, oaths or formal evidence.
Limits: A defamation case. The court assumed the public adjuster named as appraiser was competent and disinterested and did not decide whether he was.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bainter v. United Pacific Ins. Co.
Washington Court of Appeals, Division III · January 7, 1988 · 50 Wn. App. 242, 748 P.2d 260
An appraisal award is conclusive as to the amount of loss, but evidence of bias, prejudice or lack of disinterestedness can raise a fact question for a jury. The insureds alleged bias but produced no evidence, so the trial court properly confirmed the award, including the living-expense award. The court had appointed the umpire when the appraisers could not agree.
Limits: Homeowner policy that called for a competent, independent appraiser and impartial umpire; the cost-split clause is quoted, not decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Giulietti v. Connecticut Insurance Placement Facility
Connecticut Supreme Court · December 8, 1987 · 205 Conn. 424, 534 A.2d 213
Insureds who took the amount of their loss to a jury, the very issue appraisers would decide, gave up their right to appraisal. The court said it was inclined to reject the insurer's argument that denying coverage excused it from appraisal, since that would let an insurer defeat the right whenever it resists.
Limits: The coverage-denial point was not needed to decide the case. Decided under former § 38-98.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Molodyh v. Truck Insurance Exchange
Oregon Supreme Court · November 3, 1987 · 304 Or 290, 744 P2d 992
Statutory appraisal is optional until one side demands it. After a demand, it is required before suit on the amount of loss, but the award binds only the party that demanded it, so the other keeps a jury trial. Appraisal fixes the amount of loss, not the insurer's liability.
Limits: Interprets former ORS 743.648 for fire policies. A footnote carries the scope statement.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Maine Mutual Fire Insurance Co. v. Watson
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · October 22, 1987 · 532 A.2d 686
After appraisers set the actual cash value, the money was due one month later. The insurer's check that required a full release did not stop interest, so the insured recovered interest and attorney fees under the late-payment statute.
Limits: Decided under the 1986 version of section 2436 (30-day period then; the fire peril period is now 60 days under section 3002).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wausau Insurance Co. v. Herbert Halperin Distribution Corp.
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · July 8, 1987 · 664 F. Supp. 987 (D. Md. 1987)
Maryland enforces appraisal clauses, but whether policy exclusions limit coverage is a contract question for the court, not appraisers. Disputes over how much repair the covered damage requires can be amount-of-loss questions for appraisal.
Limits: Federal ruling; the judge said the question was not easy and no clear answer was presented by the authorities.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Carroll v. Statesman Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Indiana · July 1, 1987 · 509 N.E.2d 825, adopting 493 N.E.2d 1289 (Ind. Ct. App. 1986)
After an umpire's award on a fire loss, the insurer paid part and underpaid the building. The Supreme Court adopted the Court of Appeals opinion, which held a jury should have been told the award cannot be contested without fraud, mistake or misfeasance and that payment was due within the policy's 60 days. That bears on a bad-faith claim for delay.
Limits: The 60-day payment time came from the policy, not a statute. The Supreme Court disapproved only the Court of Appeals ruling on a psychiatrist's testimony.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hayseeds, Inc. v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · December 12, 1986 · 177 W. Va. 323, 352 S.E.2d 73, No. 16782
When a policyholder must sue its own insurer over a property damage claim and substantially prevails, the insurer pays the insured's reasonable attorney fees, and also net economic loss from the delay and damages for aggravation and inconvenience.
Limits: Not an appraisal case. Later cases applied it to appraisals.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Sevier v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.
Louisiana Supreme Court · November 24, 1986 · 497 So. 2d 1380 (No. 86-C-0801)
An insurer that demanded appraisal more than 60 days after it received a satisfactory proof of loss demanded too late, so the insured did not have to submit to appraisal and his suit was not premature. A contractor's informal estimate counted as proof of loss.
Limits: Decided under the old standard fire policy, which made loss payable 60 days after proof of loss; the court did not decide whether appraisal clauses are valid under R.S. 22:629.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hanson v. Commercial Union Insurance Co.
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · June 10, 1986 · 150 Ariz. 283, 723 P.2d 101
An appraisal panel under a fire policy has only the powers the policy gives it, here to appraise actual cash value and loss to each item. It has no power to decide coverage, deductibles or offsets, interest, or attorney and professional fees. Appraisal awards get arbitration-level finality but not for matters outside that power. Judgment confirming the award was reversed.
Limits: Fire policy whose clause called for competent and disinterested appraisers and umpire. The case was sent back for the court to decide whether the insurer waived its objection. It did not address causation as such.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fishman v. Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co.
Connecticut Appellate Court · August 6, 1985 · 4 Conn. App. 339, cert. denied, 197 Conn. 806, 807 (1985)
A trial court wrongly ordered a disputed coverage question into appraisal under a homeowner appraisal clause. Coverage is a question for the court to decide before appraisal goes ahead. The clause is an arbitration agreement, so §§ 52-410 and 52-411 apply.
Limits: First released June 25, 1985; affirmed on reconsideration Aug. 6, 1985. The policy said 'competent, independent' appraiser and 'impartial' umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Southeast Nursing Home, Inc. v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · January 24, 1985 · 750 F.2d 1531; No. 83-7131
Applying Alabama law, a policy that named only an impartial umpire did not require the party appraisers to be impartial, so the insurer's choice of an allegedly partial appraiser did not waive appraisal. Appraisals are governed by the policy, not Alabama's arbitration statute. The insurer had a lawful basis to insist on appraisal, so the bad-faith claim failed.
Limits: Federal court applying Alabama law (Erie guess), 1985, before later Alabama bad-faith decisions.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Safeco Insurance Co. v. Sharma
California Court of Appeal · October 16, 1984 · 160 Cal.App.3d 1060, 207 Cal.Rptr. 104 (No. B004997)
Appraisers may decide only the value of the loss, not whether the insured lost what he claimed. A panel that decided the identity of stolen paintings exceeded its powers and the judgment confirming the award was reversed.
Limits: Theft loss on a standard form policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Erin Rancho Motels, Inc. v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.
Nebraska Supreme Court · July 20, 1984 · 218 Neb. 9, 352 N.W.2d 561 (No. 83-398)
A fire loss whose amount rested on competing opinion evidence was unliquidated, so the insured could not recover prejudgment interest, even though the insurer had offered a set sum.
Limits: No appraisal took place. Two justices dissented on interest.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Marcotte v. Farmers Insurance Co.
Oregon Court of Appeals · February 8, 1984 · 66 Or App 928, 675 P2d 1118
An insured who sued on a fire policy before any appraisal was demanded was held to have to complete appraisal first, so the suit was premature.
Limits: Expressly disapproved in Molodyh to the extent it makes appraisal mandatory in all circumstances.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Casualty Indemnity Exchange v. Yother
Supreme Court of Alabama · September 23, 1983 · 439 So. 2d 77; No. 82-949
The court upheld setting aside an award where the insured was given no notice and no chance to be heard, and the umpire set the figure alone. It said appraisal differs from arbitration but the award failed either way.
Limits: Auto theft policy, not a property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nichols v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · August 24, 1983 · 279 S.C. 336, 306 S.E.2d 616
An insurer's bad-faith refusal to pay a first-party claim is a tort. To get the statutory attorney's fees the insured must prove bad faith or refusal without reasonable cause.
Limits: Auto policy; not about appraisal or an award that was paid.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Brethren Mutual Insurance Co. v. Filsinger
Court of Special Appeals of Maryland · April 13, 1983 · 54 Md. App. 357, 458 A.2d 880
A fire policy award is final and binding. The courts cannot review the appraisers' mistakes of law except for the narrow errors Maryland arbitration law allows. The insurer could not take a depreciation deduction the appraisers had not made, and it owed prejudgment interest on the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Schnitzer v. South Carolina Insurance Co.
Oregon Court of Appeals · March 23, 1983 · 62 Or App 300, 661 P2d 550
An appraisal award is not reviewable for errors of law or fact, only for fraud or misconduct by the appraisers. Appraisers decide actual cash value and amount of loss, including the valuation method, but not the recovery for a separately insured debris removal expense.
Limits: The insurer demanded appraisal there. Molodyh (1987) holds an award binds only the demanding party.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Closser v. Penn Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Delaware Supreme Court · February 8, 1983 · 457 A.2d 1081
The court read a fire policy's appraisal clause, if invoked, as mandatory arbitration that bars going to court on the amount of loss. A jury could find the insurer failed to go forward with appraisal and misled the insured about the suit deadline, so summary judgment for the insurer was reversed.
Limits: The case was decided on whether the suit was time barred; the arbitration reading was part of that analysis.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Meadows v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · December 15, 1982 · 171 W. Va. 337, 298 S.E.2d 874, No. 15252
A fire policy's one-year suit period starts when the insurer writes that it declines to pay. In reaching that result the court explained that the loss is fixed either by agreement or by an appraisers' award, and reproduced the standard fire policy appraisal clause.
Limits: Decides the suit deadline, not the appraisal rules. The appraisal clause appears in a footnote.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Polito v. Continental Casualty Co.
United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · October 1, 1982 · 689 F.2d 457 (3d Cir. 1982)
Insureds whose lawsuit brought about payment of the appraised amount under a New Jersey standard fire policy were owed attorney's fees under R. 4:42-9(a)(6), and were entitled to a new trial on a contract claim for interest caused by the insurer's delay in the appraisal. Footnote 1 quotes the statutory appraisal clause in full.
Limits: A federal court predicting New Jersey law; does not bind New Jersey courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Seeman v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · July 21, 1982 · 322 N.W.2d 35
Iowa's unfair claims practices statute, chapter 507B, does not create a private cause of action. Enforcement is left to the insurance commissioner.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Insurance Commissioner
Court of Appeals of Maryland (now Supreme Court of Maryland) · May 13, 1982 · 293 Md. 409, 445 A.2d 14
An insured can ordinarily compel an insurer to submit to appraisal under the standard fire policy clause, even where the insurer says the dispute is about coverage. The court said appraisal is analogous to arbitration and relied on the arbitration act's policy of enforcing agreements to arbitrate.
Limits: Decides that appraisal can be compelled. It does not decide who rules on coverage.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Appalachian Insurance Co. v. Rivcom Corp.
California Court of Appeal · March 24, 1982 · 130 Cal.App.3d 818, 182 Cal.Rptr. 11 (No. Civ. 61032)
The standard fire policy appraisal clause is an agreement to arbitrate, and a court must order it unless the right was waived. The insurer had demanded appraisal, named its appraiser and given the insured more time, so nothing supported waiver; the order refusing appraisal was reversed.
Limits: The court did not decide whether bad faith claim handling alone could forfeit the right, as there was no evidence of it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Erickson v. Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Dakota · October 28, 1981 · 311 N.W.2d 579
An umpire appointed by a district court fixed the amount of a windstorm loss under a standard-form clause. The insurer, by going through appraisal, conceded the cause, and had to pay the award.
Limits: The court noted the clause provided for appraisal, not arbitration, but decided on summary judgment based on the insurer's admissions. It did not decide whether a panel may decide cause on its own.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Wright
Nevada Supreme Court · June 24, 1981 · 97 Nev. 308, 629 P.2d 1202
Appraisers and an umpire went beyond their powers when they decided coverage (code upgrade costs) while setting the loss. The court affirmed vacating the award. Appraisers decide the amount of loss, not coverage.
Limits: Decided under the repealed arbitration act. Does not decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Director v. South Carolina Insurance Co.
Oregon Court of Appeals · November 17, 1980 · 49 Or App 179, 619 P2d 649
After the insurers demanded appraisal, the insured could not first sue for a declaration on policy terms that fix the amount of loss. Appraisal had to be completed first.
Limits: Its condition-precedent holding was narrowed by Molodyh (1987) to cases where appraisal has been demanded.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lincoln Construction, Inc. v. Thomas J. Parker & Associates, Inc.
Oregon Supreme Court · September 30, 1980 · 289 Or 687, 617 P2d 606
When a contract says a neutral third person makes a final decision, it is final absent fraud, bad faith or a failure to exercise honest judgment.
Limits: Construction subcontract, not insurance. Schnitzer cites it for the award rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Figi v. New Hampshire Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal · July 30, 1980 · 108 Cal.App.3d 772, 166 Cal.Rptr. 774
An umpire who did business with the insurer's appraiser while the appraisal was pending was interested as a matter of law. Appraisers are held to a higher impartiality standard than arbitrators generally, and the confirming judgment was reversed.
Limits: Does not address fees paid to an appraiser. Past business with the insurer does not automatically disqualify an appraiser.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Spencer v. Aetna Life & Casualty Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · May 10, 1980 · 227 Kan. 914, 611 P.2d 149
Kansas does not recognize a tort of first-party bad faith against an insurer; the statutes, including the attorney-fee statutes, supply the remedies.
Limits: Answered a certified question on a fire loss. Followed in later Kansas cases through at least 2015.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
O J Enterprises, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of North America
Michigan Court of Appeals · March 18, 1980 · 96 Mich App 271; 292 NW2d 207 (Docket No. 44509)
An insurer that paid the appraisal award within 60 days of the award, after a reasonable dispute over the amount, owed no 12 percent penalty interest on the disputed difference and no judgment interest.
Limits: Decided under former 500.2832. The Court of Appeals held in 2007 (Griswold) that it is no longer relevant because that statute was repealed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Silverman v. Fireman's Fund American Insurance
Nevada Supreme Court · January 3, 1980 · 96 Nev. 30, 604 P.2d 805
An insurance appraisal fell under the state arbitration act, which then expressly named appraisals. The insured sued about five months after the award without moving to vacate within 90 days, so the suit was barred.
Limits: Decided under the 1969 act, which is no longer in force. The current act does not mention appraisals.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mathews v. Glacier General Assurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · November 28, 1979 · 184 Mont. 368, 603 P.2d 232
After an appraisal the insurer had demanded, the trial court gave the insured judgment for the award on the theory that the insurer had given up its policy defense. The Supreme Court reversed, leaving the insurer's defense of material alteration for trial.
Limits: Decided mainly on pleading and summary judgment rules. Two of five justices dissented, saying the demand for appraisal admitted liability.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Moran v. Phoenix Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Appeals Court · June 26, 1979 · 7 Mass. App. Ct. 822
An insurer's denial of liability, with no dispute over the amount of loss, can let a jury find it waived the reference condition. Waiver may be inferred from conduct, and the insured has the burden.
Limits: Summary judgment reversed. Waiver stayed a fact question.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Covenant Insurance Co. v. Banks
Connecticut Supreme Court · April 10, 1979 · 177 Conn. 273, 413 A.2d 862
The fire policy appraisal clause is an agreement to arbitrate under the state arbitration statutes. The judge-picks-the-umpire step applies only after both sides name appraisers. An insured whose insurer refuses to proceed must go to the Superior Court under §§ 52-410 and 52-411. That court may decide coverage questions that come before the umpire is appointed. An umpire appointed without that procedure produced an invalid award.
Limits: Decided under former § 38-98. The insurer in that case did not concede liability and cited evidence of arson.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lawton v. Great Southwest Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · September 27, 1978 · 118 N.H. 607, 392 A.2d 576
An insurer's wrongful refusal or delay in settling a first-party claim is not a separate tort. The Court noted that RSA 407:22 gives each side appraisers whose determinations "shall be binding," and that an insured may recover attorney fees if the insurer acted in bad faith in promoting unnecessary litigation.
Limits: The remark on appraisal is a side comment, not the holding. Reaffirmed in Bell v. Liberty Mutual (2001).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mitchell v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit · September 1, 1978 · 579 F.2d 342, No. 76-2980
Mississippi awards are hard to attack and only limited reasons justify a court stepping in. An award is not voided for missing itemization without prejudice. No prejudgment interest where the refusal to pay more was not frivolous or in bad faith.
Limits: Federal court predicting Mississippi law; not binding on Mississippi courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Elberon Bathing Co. v. Ambassador Insurance Co.
New Jersey Supreme Court · June 8, 1978 · 77 N.J. 1, 389 A.2d 439
An appraisal award that used replacement cost without subtracting depreciation did not measure actual cash value and was vacated for legal misconduct. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss, not liability, and the Arbitration Act does not apply. Review of an award is narrow, but appraisers cannot make legal determinations.
Limits: A fire policy case. The court quotes the standard form clause from N.J.S.A. 17:36-5.20 but the quotation ends before the costs sentence. It does not address causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hirt v. Hervey
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · February 23, 1978 · 118 Ariz. 543, 578 P.2d 624
Decisions of an appraiser get the same finality as arbitration awards, so review is narrow and not broader than for an arbitration award.
Limits: Not an insurance case; it involved valuing land. Hanson later adopted its rule for insurance appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Sullivan v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court · February 7, 1978 · 174 Conn. 229, 384 A.2d 384
When the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire, a court must appoint one on request, even though the insurer denied liability and the appraisers disagree about how to measure actual cash value. The appraisers' job is limited to fixing the amount of loss. The chance that they might make a mistake is not a reason to refuse an umpire.
Limits: Decided under the former fire policy statute, § 38-98, whose appraisal text matches today's § 38a-307. The parties reserved waiver and estoppel from the insurer's denial for a later hearing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Commercial Union Insurance Co. v. Ryals
Supreme Court of Alabama · January 27, 1978 · 355 So. 2d 684; SC 2443
The trial court appointed the umpire, and the award treating the building as one item was confirmed. Repair cost up to actual cash value was the measure, with no depreciation held back.
Limits: Decided on the policy wording in a restaurant fire loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Augenstein v. Insurance Co. of North America
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · February 17, 1977 · 372 Mass. 30, 360 N.E.2d 320
Referees decide the amount of loss under the policy, including whether a loss happened. Their views on the policy's meaning are tentative, and a court can reexamine a disputed meaning later. Because the insurer never argued the referees misread the policy or attacked the award, the award was conclusive and the insured won.
Limits: Turns on the insurer's choice not to raise a policy-meaning issue. Later cases with a clear reservation, such as Audubon Hill, come out the other way.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Galiotti v. Travelers Indemnity Co.
Delaware Superior Court · February 11, 1975 · 333 A.2d 176
Attorney's fees under 18 Del. C. § 4102 were mandatory after a judgment against the insurer on the property coverage of an auto policy. Hanby did not bar them, because both sides skipped the appraisal clause and the insurer never invoked it. Neither could invoke it after litigating to judgment.
Limits: Trial-level decision on an auto collision policy that the court treated as property insurance.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
State Farm General Insurance Co. v. Clifton
New Mexico Supreme Court · October 18, 1974 · 86 N.M. 757, 527 P.2d 798 (1974)
In a dispute over fire insurance proceeds on a home, the court recognized a tort claim for an insurer's unreasonable delay in paying, but held it needs evidence of bad faith, such as a frivolous or unfounded refusal to pay. None was shown, so the directed verdict for the insurer stood. Delay damages were not recoverable in contract.
Limits: Not an appraisal case. The insurer filed an interpleader because several people claimed the proceeds.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.
Indiana Court of Appeals · April 17, 1974 · 160 Ind. App. 33, 309 N.E.2d 810
A person who submits to appraisal under a fire policy is bound by the award on the amount of loss unless it is tainted by fraud, collusion, partiality or manifest injustice. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss, not liability. An umpire who joins one appraiser to sign the award is an extra appraiser, and a separate valuation by the umpire is allowed.
Limits: Fire policy. Decided before Indiana's current arbitration act; the court said appraisal is not arbitration.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Keesling v. Western Fire Ins. Co. of Fort Scott, Kansas
Washington Court of Appeals · April 1, 1974 · 10 Wn. App. 841, 520 P.2d 622
An appraisal clause in a fire policy is valid and does not take jurisdiction from the courts. It sets the dollar value of damage but does not enforce itself; the insured must sue and have the award confirmed. Timeliness of a demand depends on the circumstances: the insurer's demand eight months after proof of loss and after suit began was timely, because the parties had been negotiating and the insured showed no prejudice. The suit should have been stayed, not dismissed, pending appraisal.
Limits: Fire policy, 1974 facts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of North America
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · January 24, 1974 · 456 Pa. 210, 314 A.2d 236
A fire insurer cannot refuse the appraisal clause the statute requires. Appraisal is enforceable like arbitration, is the favored way to settle a dollar-value dispute once liability is admitted, and covers only the amount of loss.
Limits: Fire policy; the court did not decide whether appraisers may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Home Indemnity Co. v. Bush
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · August 21, 1973 · 20 Ariz. App. 355, 513 P.2d 145
When the insurer elects to repair, the repair agreement governs and the policy appraisal provisions are waived. The dispute there was over the quality of repairs, not the amount of loss.
Limits: Automobile collision policy, not a property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Maryland Casualty Co. v. Hanby
Delaware Supreme Court · January 4, 1973 · 301 A.2d 286
After an appraisal award was paid, the court reversed an award of attorney's fees under 18 Del. C. § 4102. The insured had sued instead of demanding appraisal, and an appraisal award is not a judgment. It left the interest award in place and said fees were not meant to reward suing in breach of the appraisal clause.
Limits: The insured had sued before demanding appraisal. The court's point that § 4102 needs a judgment applies generally.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hala Cleaners, Inc. v. Sussex Mutual Insurance Co.
New Jersey Superior Court, Chancery Division · May 21, 1971 · 115 N.J. Super. 11, 277 A.2d 897
The insured as well as the insurer can insist that the standard fire form's appraisal procedure be followed, even where the insurer disputes liability. The court ordered the insurer to name an appraiser and kept jurisdiction to appoint an umpire if the appraisers could not agree.
Limits: A published trial court decision, not an appellate one.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Maryland Casualty Co. v. Legg
Mississippi Supreme Court · May 10, 1971 · 247 So. 2d 812, No. 46210
Once the trial court found a total fire loss, the valued policy statute applied and wrote out the appraisal requirement, so the insured's failure to name an appraiser did not bar her suit.
Limits: Total loss by fire only; cites Code 1942 § 5693, now Miss. Code § 83-13-5.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Jefferson Insurance Co. of New York v. Superior Court
Supreme Court of California · October 29, 1970 · 3 Cal.3d 398, 475 P.2d 880 (S.F. No. 22752)
Appraisers who decided a question of law, the meaning of actual cash value, exceeded their powers, and the trial court properly vacated the award. An appraiser's declaration may be used to show what the panel treated as the issue.
Limits: Standard form fire policy; the legal question was the meaning of actual cash value under the policy's average clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hanby v. Maryland Casualty Co.
Delaware Supreme Court · April 1, 1970 · 265 A.2d 28
When a fire policy sets no time to demand appraisal, the demand must come within a reasonable time. The insurer asked for appraisal after the insured sued and was not found to have waived it, so the suit was stayed. Appraisal fixes the amount of loss and the court may then decide what effect to give the findings.
Limits: Fire policy. The court expressed no opinion on how much effect the findings get.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Schipper & Block, Inc. v. Carson Pirie Scott & Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Third District · March 20, 1970 · 122 Ill. App. 2d 34
Under a lease requiring disinterested appraisers, an appraiser who had already valued the property for tax purposes was not disinterested. Disinterested means free of bias and prejudice, not only without a money interest.
Limits: Commercial lease appraisal, not insurance. One justice dissented.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Employers' Liability Assurance Corp. v. Traynor
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · May 6, 1968 · 354 Mass. 763
An insurer could not sue first to settle coverage and skip the reference. A dispute over the value of stolen items had to go to referees. Questions of final liability are decided after the reference, and the insurer's rights on them are protected.
Limits: Short opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Girard v. Atlantic Mut. Ins. Co.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit · May 1, 1967 · 198 So. 2d 444 (No. 2645)
An appraisal clause is not an arbitration clause and does not take the case from the courts. Following Branch, the appraisal binds only if the appraisers and umpire did their duty to fix actual cash value and loss, and the court can review it. A suit filed after the insured refused appraisal was premature.
Limits: Hurricane Betsy claim under the older fire policy form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Roumel v. Niagara Fire Insurance Co.
District of Columbia Court of Appeals · January 19, 1967 · 225 A.2d 658
After a fire loss the insurer demanded appraisal, then refused to go on. The court held that the refusal created no new claim; its only effect was that the insured could sue on the policy at once, and the twelve-month suit clause barred the late suit. In its reasoning it said appraisal only fixes the amount of loss, not liability or coverage, and that an award is conclusive proof of the damages while suit stays on the policy.
Limits: Old fire-policy form, decided before D.C.'s arbitration acts. The coverage and award statements are reasoning, not the holding. Does not mention causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hendricks v. American Fire & Casualty Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · May 2, 1966 · 247 S.C. 479, 148 S.E.2d 162
An award made by the umpire and one appraiser stood. A mere mistake of judgment does not undo it, notice of the appraisers' meeting was not required on these facts, and the insured could not show a defect the pleadings had not raised.
Limits: Collision policy on a tractor; the insurer admitted the loss was covered.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
School District No. 1 of Silver Bow County v. Globe & Republic Insurance Co. of America
Montana Supreme Court · August 23, 1965 · 146 Mont. 208, 404 P.2d 889
The court upheld a fire-policy appraisal clause because it settles questions of fact only, and held an insurer's demand six days after suit, before service, came in reasonable time. It reversed a jury verdict and sent the loss, which turned on how much damage the fire caused as against an earthquake and vandalism, to appraisal.
Limits: Policy had no time limit for a demand. Timeliness is normally for the trial court. Whether appraisers may decide cause was not raised or decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fidelity-Phenix Fire Insurance Co. of New York v. Penick
Oklahoma Supreme Court · February 16, 1965 · 1965 OK 34, 401 P.2d 514 (No. 40101)
When an insurer demands appraisal but reserves the right to contest liability, appraisal is not a condition the insured must meet before suing on the policy.
Limits: The court said it was not deciding whether an insurer may litigate liability after an appraisal is completed. Rehearing denied April 20, 1965.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Quinn v. New York Fire Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Supreme Court · February 7, 1964 · 22 Wis. 2d 495, 126 N.W.2d 211
An appraisal award that does not state actual cash value when the policy requires that measure does not comply with the policy and is set aside.
Limits: Cited in Farmers (2009) and Coppins (2014) for the face-of-the-award review.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Case v. Hanover Fire Insurance Co.
Tennessee Court of Appeals · May 29, 1962 · 50 Tenn. App. 72, 359 S.W.2d 831
Without a timely objection, insurers are presumed to have named a competent and disinterested appraiser. The insured's suits were dismissed as premature because she did not take part in the appraisal.
Limits: Old fire policy. Did not define "disinterested" and did not involve fees.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Miller v. British America Assurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · April 10, 1961 · 238 S.C. 94, 119 S.E.2d 527
Appraisal clauses are valid because they leave liability to the courts. Whether the insurer demanded appraisal in time is a question for the judge, who may stay the lawsuit until appraisal is done.
Limits: Windstorm policy on a boat; the insurer admitted liability and disputed only the amount.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Childs v. Allstate Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · January 3, 1961 · 237 S.C. 455, 117 S.E.2d 867
A policy clause sending the question of liability to arbitration is not binding; a clause limited to the amount of loss is valid.
Limits: Auto uninsured motorist coverage, not property. Appraisal is discussed only in comparison.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Munn v. National Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford
Mississippi Supreme Court · October 26, 1959 · 237 Miss. 641, 115 So. 2d 54, No. 41206
Appraisers cannot decide the cause of the damage. They only value it. An appraisal is presumed correct, but a court may set it aside for gross inadequacy or excess amounting to fraud in effect, lack of authority, mistake of fact, or to prevent injustice.
Limits: Windstorm policy; decided 7 to 2, with a dissent that read the clause differently.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hartford Fire Insurance Co. v. Jones
Mississippi Supreme Court · February 2, 1959 · 235 Miss. 37, 108 So. 2d 571, No. 41012
An appraisers' report is not an arbitration award. It only fixes value. The court affirmed judgment on a report signed by one appraiser and the umpire.
Limits: House trailer fire policy; affirmed under the court's harmless-error rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Agricultural Insurance Co. v. Holter
Tennessee Supreme Court · February 8, 1957 · 201 Tenn. 345, 299 S.W.2d 15
Under the standard umpire clause, a judge's appointment of an umpire at one side's request is valid without notice to the other side, and the appraisers need not meet first.
Limits: Interprets the fire policy clause in the case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Home Insurance Co. v. Watts
Mississippi Supreme Court · January 7, 1957 · 229 Miss. 735, 91 So. 2d 722, No. 40336
The insured must make an effort to comply with the appraisal clause before suing. An insurer's later denial of liability did not waive the clause. Appraisal fixes value only. Judgment reversed and the case dismissed without prejudice.
Limits: Automobile fire policy, not a property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Harwell v. Home Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · February 6, 1956 · 228 S.C. 594, 91 S.E.2d 273
An appraisal clause that settles only the amount of loss is valid and does not oust the courts. When the policy bars suit until appraisal and the insurer demands it, an insured who refuses cannot sue until it is done.
Limits: Fire policy; the policy language on umpire selection and costs is quoted, not decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fidelity & Guaranty Insurance Corp. v. Mondzelewski
Delaware Supreme Court · October 25, 1955 · 49 Del. 395
An appraisal award binds the parties as a matter of contract unless the loss is a total loss, where the old valued-policy statute overrode the clause. The appraisers' findings were then only evidence.
Limits: Applied a valued-policy statute that we did not find in the current Title 18.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of Delmar Box Co. (Aetna Ins. Co.)
New York Court of Appeals · July 8, 1955 · 309 NY 60
Appraisal under the standard fire policy is not an arbitration agreement, so the insured could not use the arbitration law to force the insurer to appraise.
Limits: Ins. Law 3408(c) now lets a court order appraisal, but CPLR 7601 and 3408(c) still say appraisal is not an arbitration.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hartford Fire Insurance Co. v. Conner
Mississippi Supreme Court · April 11, 1955 · 223 Miss. 799, 79 So. 2d 236, No. 39572
Both sides must act in good faith to carry out an appraisal clause. An insured who ignored the insurer's written demand and sold the car could not recover on the policy.
Limits: Automobile fire policy, not a property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Batter Building Materials Co. v. Kirschner
Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors · December 21, 1954 · 142 Conn. 1, 110 A.2d 464
An arbitration right can be waived by unjustifiable delay, by going to trial, or by skipping agreed steps. On that record the court could not say the delay before the demand was unreasonable as a matter of law.
Limits: Construction contract, not insurance. Applied to an appraisal demand in Middlesex v. Clinton (1995).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Gervant v New England Fire Ins. Co.
New York Court of Appeals · March 11, 1954 · 306 NY 393
An award was set aside because the umpire and the insurer's appraiser refused to consider any evidence of value except replacement cost less depreciation. Refusing to hear relevant evidence is legal misconduct that voids an award, though courts do not review the merits. An insured not at fault need not appraise again and may sue.
Limits: Its actual cash value rule (McAnarney) concerns fire-policy valuation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 2, 1953 · 330 Mass. 283
Referees must fix the loss under the policy, not all damage whether covered or not. They properly limited the award to lightning damage and left out wind damage. Their views on coverage are tentative and do not decide liability.
Limits: No one disputed how the policy words applied. An award can still be attacked for error in reading the policy. The insured dropped a bias claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America
Supreme Court of Ohio · April 22, 1953 · 159 Ohio St. 237, 112 N.E.2d 1 (No. 33217)
The fire policy's appraisal clause binds the insurer as well as the insured. When the insurer refused to name an appraiser, that counted as a failure to agree, and the court could appoint the umpire. The insured could have the amount of loss appraised even though the insurer denied liability.
Limits: Decided under the fire policy wording quoted in the opinion, which sets 20 days for appraisers and 15 days for the umpire. The point about denial of liability comes from a treatise passage the court quoted, and a 2025 appeals court read it as about mutuality only.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hawkinson Tread Tire Service Co. v. Indiana Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Missouri · December 10, 1951 · 362 Mo. 823, 245 S.W.2d 24
An appraisal clause is for setting the amount of loss. When the real dispute is what the policy means and how it applies, appraisal is not a condition to suing, because treating it as one would turn it into arbitration.
Limits: Business interruption policy, fire era. Cited by later courts as the source of the coverage versus amount-of-loss line.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Molea v. Aetna Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · December 5, 1950 · 326 Mass. 542
Reference to three disinterested persons is a condition of suit on a standard fire policy unless waived. The burden of proving waiver or excuse is on the insured.
Limits: The insureds argued waiver through an insurer agent's conduct.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Schreiber v. Pacific Coast Fire Insurance Co.
Court of Appeals of Maryland · July 18, 1950 · 195 Md. 639, 75 A.2d 108
Other work for insurance companies does not disqualify an appraiser as a matter of law. Concealment or misrepresentation may be weighed. The award is binding, and courts do not review honest mistakes of fact or law, only plain and palpable ones.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mork v. Eureka-Security Fire & Marine Ins. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · March 17, 1950 · 230 Minn. 382, 42 N.W.2d 33
An appraisal award carries every presumption of validity and will not be vacated unless it clearly came from fraud, misfeasance, malfeasance or wrongdoing. A low award alone is not enough unless so gross it shows fraud.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Boston Ins. Co. v. A.H. Jacobson Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · July 2, 1948 · 226 Minn. 479, 33 N.W.2d 602
A court-appointed umpire was void when appointed before the dispute that appraisal settles had arisen, because a statutory appraisal must follow the statute.
Limits: Decided under the 1940s version of the statute; the time limits it describes have changed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lee v. Farmer's Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of South Dakota · April 27, 1948 · 72 S.D. 127, 32 N.W.2d 188
An award that did not state the sound value of the insured property before the fire, as the standard fire policy clause required, was invalid.
Limits: Decided under the former standard fire policy statute, for a binding award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lawler v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · August 28, 1947 · 143 Me. 40, 54 A.2d 685
Referees under the statutory fire policy must be disinterested, meaning impartial and open minded, not just free of money ties. Because the insured is forced into the process, courts must look closely. Evidence of bias let the jury set aside the referees' low figure.
Limits: Decided under the earlier "three disinterested men" referee wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Orr v. Farmers Mutual Hail Insurance Co. of Missouri
Supreme Court of Missouri · April 21, 1947 · 356 Mo. 372, 201 S.W.2d 952
People chosen to decide a loss by arbitration or appraisal must not be interested, biased or prejudiced. An award made with the insurer's adjuster as its arbitrator was void.
Limits: Crop hail policy with an arbitration clause, not a property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kearns v. Firemen's Insurance Co. of Newark
New Jersey Supreme Court (pre-1948, reported in N.J.L.) · May 18, 1945 · 133 N.J.L. 50, 42 A.2d 581
An appraisal award was admissible in the insured's suit and conclusive between the parties until vacated, even though it carried a handwritten note about lightning. If the award was wrong, a direct proceeding against it was the remedy.
Limits: Decided under the pre-1954 standard form. That court sat below the Court of Errors and Appeals, which was then the state's court of last resort.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Upington v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York
Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · September 29, 1944 · 298 Ky. 210, 182 S.W.2d 648
Appraisers who had often worked for insurers were not disqualified. An award binds the parties like a judgment unless fraud, mistake or going beyond the panel's authority is shown by clear and convincing evidence. The panel may set the amount of loss but not decide what property the policy covers.
Limits: Fire policies with a separate arbitration agreement; four consolidated appeals.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
F. & M. Skirt Co. v. Rhode Island Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 1, 1944 · 316 Mass. 314
Referees may find that no loss happened, because deciding the amount includes deciding it was zero. They may not decide whether a loss was covered or the policy was in force.
Limits: Its remark on coverage was later clarified in Fox as about ultimate liability.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nicholas v. Granite State Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · February 9, 1943 · 125 W. Va. 349, No. 9385
Under the valued policy statute, when a house is a total loss by fire the insurer has no right to demand appraisal of the amount. The only jury question was whether the loss was total or partial.
Limits: Dwelling fire policy; the rule comes from Hinkle (1912) and the statute now numbered 33-17-9, which excludes cases where two or more insurers cover the same interest. Not tested since in a case found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Branch v. Springfield Fire & Marine Ins. Co.
Louisiana Supreme Court · November 3, 1941 · 198 La. 720, 4 So. 2d 806 (No. 34232)
The court upheld appraisal clauses but read them strictly. An award binds the insured only if the appraisers did the duties the policy required. Where the policy required them to set sound value and they did not, the award was void and the court decided the loss itself.
Limits: Windstorm policy on an older form. The court did not reach the argument that the insurer appraiser was not disinterested.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hetherington v. Continental Insurance Co. of New York
Illinois Appellate Court · October 27, 1941 · 311 Ill. App. 577, 37 N.E.2d 366
Courts set aside an appraisal award when fraud, misconduct, or palpable or gross error or mistake clearly appears. A palpably excessive amount can support an inference of fraud or mistake.
Limits: Auto collision policy, decided in 1941.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Chambers v. Home Insurance Co. of New York
Alabama Court of Appeals · June 30, 1939 · 29 Ala. App. 34, 191 So. 642
An insurer that denies all liability under the policy waives the appraisal clause and cannot plead it against the insured's suit, because the dispute is no longer about the amount of loss.
Limits: Intermediate court, 1939. The insurer can undo the effect by retracting the denial.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hanover Fire Insurance Co. v. Drake
Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · April 28, 1938 · 170 Va. 257, 196 S.E. 664
The appraisal requirement is for the insurer's benefit and can be waived by its conduct. Where the appraisal failed through the insurer's fault, the insured could sue without an award.
Limits: Fire policy; about waiver of an award as a condition to suit, not delay in demanding appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McIntosh v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · April 6, 1938 · 106 Mont. 434, 78 P.2d 82
The court may look at how an appraisal award was reached and may undo it when the method was wrong. It reversed an award that applied depreciation to repair cost.
Limits: Fire policies. The court did not analyze bias or waiver.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
National Union Fire Insurance Co. v. Ozburn
Court of Appeals of Georgia · December 4, 1937 · 57 Ga. App. 90, 194 S.E. 756 (No. 26359)
A fire policy's appraisal provision is not a condition to the insured's recovery where the insurer takes no steps to require appraisal. Once appraisers are demanded under the policy, complying is a condition to suit.
Limits: 1937 fire policy on business stock and fixtures. Later treatment not traced.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Agricultural Insurance Co. of Watertown v. Biltz
Nevada Supreme Court · February 5, 1937 · 57 Nev. 370, 64 P.2d 1042
A fire appraisal award was properly set aside because the appraiser and umpire did not let the insured present evidence, which was beyond their authority. An award is otherwise final even if it contains errors of law or fact.
Limits: Fire policy; decided before Nevada had an arbitration act. The court did not decide the insurer's claim that the insured's appraiser was chosen unfairly.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ex parte Birmingham Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Alabama · January 14, 1937 · 233 Ala. 370, 172 So. 99
An insured who wrongfully prevents an award, or sues on the policy before an award is made, can be barred from the policy suit when the insurer was not at fault.
Limits: Mandamus case about moving a suit to the equity docket. The rule comes from the court's reasoning.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Camden Fire Insurance Association v. Cahill
Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · October 30, 1936 · 266 Ky. 362, 98 S.W.2d 462
An award was invalid where the insured's counsel had a court appoint the umpire without notice to the insurer. The court may appoint only after the policy's 15-day wait and after reasonable notice, even though the policy did not require notice.
Limits: Automobile theft and damage policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ciapanna v. Lincoln Fire Insurance Co.
Oregon Supreme Court · April 21, 1936 · 153 Or 395, 56 P2d 1113
An insured's refusal or delay in agreeing to appraisal did not forfeit his claim on a fire policy unless the insurer was substantially prejudiced. The insured's later offer to appraise was timely.
Limits: 1936 decision on policy wording; the insured's delay, not the insurer's conduct.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Smith v. Home Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · January 3, 1936 · 178 S.C. 436, 183 S.E. 166
An award was set aside as tainted when the insurer's adjuster took part in the appraisers' talks while the insured was led away. The insured did not have to return a payment made to his lender before suing, and punitive damages went to the jury.
Limits: Truck fire policy. The court said payment made directly to the insured would ordinarily have to be returned or tendered.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
L.D. Jennings Co. v. North River Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · April 18, 1935 · 175 S.C. 407, 179 S.E. 621
An appraiser who helped prepare the insured's proof of loss is not disqualified as a matter of law. Partiality was a question for the jury, and without evidence of it the award stood.
Limits: The court said it does not approve of naming someone who has already given an opinion on the damage. One justice dissented.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Franklin Fire Insurance Co. v. Brewer
Mississippi Supreme Court · February 18, 1935 · 173 Miss. 317, 159 So. 545, No. 31500
The valued policy statute writes out a policy's appraisal requirement when the insured building is totally destroyed by fire. The appraisal clause still applies to a partial loss.
Limits: Old statute numbering (Code 1930 § 5183); suggestion of error overruled Apr. 1, 1935, 160 So. 387.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Young v. New York Underwriters Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Carolina · October 10, 1934 · 207 N.C. 188
An award made under the policy is presumed valid unless there is fraud, mistake, duress or another impeaching circumstance. An interested appraiser is one who is biased or has some money interest in the result. Past work as an appraiser for insurance companies, which the insured knew of and accepted, was not enough.
Limits: A fire policy case. It did not involve a contingent fee.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Glens Falls Insurance Co. of New York v. Garner
Supreme Court of Alabama · June 7, 1934 · 229 Ala. 39, 155 So. 533
An award is final unless the appraisers were guilty of fraud, partiality or corruption. The insured's appraiser, a lawyer, was competent and not shown to be partial, and the umpire was competent and disinterested.
Limits: Old fire-policy case, called arbitration in the opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
L.D. Jennings Co. v. North River Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · February 7, 1934 · 171 S.C. 548, 172 S.E. 700
An allegation that the insured's appraiser took the insured's figures without checking them and, with the umpire, fixed the award without submitting any differences stated a defense of partiality and bias.
Limits: Decided on a demurrer; it did not find the facts true.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bryson v. American Eagle Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · October 16, 1933 · 132 Me. 172
The appraisal clause only sets the amount of loss and leaves liability to the courts. By joining the referees' proceeding, the insurer did not waive its defense that a policy condition was broken.
Limits: Earlier standard policy wording with referees.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Robinson v. Lumbermen's Mutual Casualty Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · March 16, 1933 · 110 Pa. Super. 396, 168 A. 321
An appraisal agreement could be revoked by either side before an award. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss; other defenses stay open.
Limits: Predates Ice City (1974), which calls appraisal agreements irrevocable.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mutual Improvement Co. v. Merchants & Business Men's Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · May 17, 1932 · 112 W. Va. 291, No. 7315
The court upheld a fire appraisal award that gave sound value and loss under three views of who owned a party wall. It said the appraisers were not required to settle questions of law, only to find the sound value and the loss.
Limits: Decided in 1932 on a written submission. Not about causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McKenzie v. Fidelity-Phenix Fire Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · October 10, 1931 · 133 Kan. 721, 3 P.2d 477
The appraisal clause does not apply to a total loss under the valued-policy law, but a total-loss dispute the parties agree to submit is binding. An insured who agreed to appraisal and accepted the award's payment is bound unless fraud or mutual mistake is shown.
Limits: Written appraisal agreement among several insurers; fire policies, 1931.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Patriotic Order Sons of America Hall Ass'n v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · September 28, 1931 · 305 Pa. 107, 157 A. 259
An appraisal award covering everything submitted is final. It cannot be set aside for an honest mistake of judgment, of fact or law; only fraud or a plain, palpable mistake such as a miscalculation will do.
Limits: Fire policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hill v. Star Insurance Co. of America
Supreme Court of North Carolina · March 25, 1931 · 200 N.C. 502, 157 S.E. 599
Disinterested means no money interest in the result and no bias or prejudice. Evidence that the insurer's appraiser was regularly hired by the insurers' adjustment bureau, unknown to the insured, and that the award was signed on a false assurance and was grossly low, was enough for a jury to set the award aside for fraud.
Limits: A fire insurance case from 1931. It did not involve a contingent fee.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Equitable Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Stieffens
Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · June 12, 1930 · 154 Va. 281, 153 S.E. 731
A proper award bars suit on the original claim and is set aside only for errors on its face, misconduct, palpable mistake or fraud, proved by the challenger. An appraiser who had often worked for the insurer's adjusting bureau, paid by the day, was not disqualified.
Limits: Applied statutes since repealed and replaced; fire policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Doherty v. Automobile Insurance Co. of Hartford
Supreme Court of South Dakota · October 15, 1929 · 55 S.D. 607, 227 N.W. 71
After the parties agreed to appraisal and the insurer paid the award within the time the policy allowed, the insured could not recover the statutory penalty or interest.
Limits: Based on a 1919 fire-insurance penalty statute no longer in force and the old 60-day payment term.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cleveland v. Home Insurance Co. of New York
South Carolina Supreme Court · May 1, 1929 · 150 S.C. 289, 148 S.E. 49
An award that did not follow the submission was invalid. Notice of the appraisers' meeting is not usually needed, but may be when evidence is needed. A mistake of judgment does not undo an award absent fraud or partiality.
Limits: Fire policy with a valued-policy statute; the notice and mistake points are partly in passing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hurst v. Hope
Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · March 21, 1929 · 152 Va. 405, 147 S.E. 222
An appraiser retained for a single engagement is not in the employment of the party; only regular, continuous employment disqualifies. Appraisers should act independently on their own judgment.
Limits: Analyzed a since-repealed statute; fee dispute between an appraiser and the insured. Mentions percentage fees without ruling on them.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Marshall v. American Alliance Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · February 9, 1929 · 127 Kan. 564, 274 P. 243
An appraisal award on a fire policy is presumed valid and is set aside only if made without authority or through fraud, mistake or misconduct. Evidence of an appraiser's or umpire's interest and unfair methods was properly used to attack the award.
Limits: Fire policy, pre-1997 and pre-2018. The opinion does not set a separate test for disinterest.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Melton Bros. v. Philadelphia Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals · February 4, 1929 · 104 N.J. Eq. 153, 144 A. 726
The court reversed a decree voiding an appraisal award. An attacking party must prove invalidity by clear proof, substantial compliance with the appraisal procedure is enough, and an appraiser is not disqualified just for being zealous for the side that named him.
Limits: Decided under an appraisal agreement and an older fire policy form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Automobile Ins. Co. of Hartford v. Lloyd
Supreme Court of Wyoming · January 17, 1929 · 40 Wyo. 44, 273 P. 681
Fire policy. The insurer's appraiser left, a district judge named an umpire, and the insured's appraiser and the umpire made an award without notice to the insurer's appraiser. The court treated the insurer's attack on that award as moot because the jury had decided the loss without it. It said appraisal terms can fail through no demand, waiver, or the insurer's fault.
Limits: The court did not rule on whether the award or the umpire appointment was valid, and did not decide any notice rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Insurance Co. of North America v. Baker
Colorado Supreme Court · May 21, 1928 · 84 Colo. 53, 268 P. 585 (No. 11,862)
An insurer that denies all liability under the policy waives its right to appraisal. Appraisal also assumes a real, good-faith disagreement over the amount of loss; where the insurer's adjuster only tried to create a disagreement, the insurer had no right to demand appraisal.
Limits: 1928 fire policy case. It addresses a denial of all liability, not a partial denial or delay.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lee v. Providence Washington Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · April 20, 1928 · 82 Mont. 264, 266 P. 640
An appraisal award on a fire loss is presumed valid and is not set aside for every error. The court affirmed setting one aside where the umpire and one appraiser took an extra 10% deduction that had no basis in fact or law.
Limits: Fire policy. The court found the appraisers acted in good faith and did not analyze their impartiality.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Schwartzman v. London & Lancashire Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Missouri · February 4, 1928 · 318 Mo. 1089, 2 S.W.2d 593
An appraisal was void where the court-picked umpire had an indirect interest in the result. Anyone directly or indirectly interested in the outcome is disqualified.
Limits: Fire policy asking for disinterested and impartial appraisers; the property and umpire appointment were in Minnesota.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Siegel v. Insurance Co. of North America
Supreme Court of North Dakota · February 1, 1928 · 56 N.D. 841, 219 N.W. 467 (rehearing 1928-05-22)
An appraisal award was ineffective because the appraiser and umpire had not agreed on every item. When the appraisal failed without fault of the insured, the insured could sue and prove the loss with other evidence.
Limits: Old policy wording; the insurer had repudiated the faulty appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dechant v. Globe & Rutgers Fire Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Supreme Court · January 10, 1928 · 194 Wis. 579, 217 N.W. 322
A large gap between the appraisers' award and a jury's later figure was not enough to set the award aside without evidence of fraud or bad faith. Appraisals are not to be lightly set aside.
Limits: Short opinion. The Supreme Court cited it in Farmers (2009).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McInnes v. Southern Home Insurance Co. of the Carolinas
South Carolina Supreme Court · December 9, 1927 · 142 S.C. 348, 140 S.E. 696
An award that left out the sound value the policy and submission required did not bind the insured.
Limits: Windstorm policy; strict-compliance rule for the form of the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Crouch v. Franklin National Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · December 6, 1927 · 104 W. Va. 605, No. C. C. 405
Where a fire policy says either side may demand appraisal in writing, the insured does not have to demand it before suing. An insurer that never asked for appraisal before suit could not use the clause to block the suit.
Limits: Fire policy of 1927; certified questions on pleading. The no-demand point is in the court syllabus.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
United States Fire Insurance Co. of New York v. Green
Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · November 29, 1927 · 222 Ky. 298, 300 S.W. 874
An award was set aside where the umpire did not take part in the disputed items and the insured was kept out of the appraisal. Appraisers must proceed with due regard for the parties' rights and do enough work to reach a correct figure.
Limits: Fire policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Gouin v. Northwestern National Ins. Co.
Washington Supreme Court · September 21, 1927 · 145 Wash. 199, 259 P. 387
A fairly and honestly made fire-policy award binds both sides and cannot be attacked just because a party thinks it unjust. Appraisers may pick the umpire right after they are appointed, the insured has no more voice in that than the insurer, and appraisers need not take evidence. An award that left out city-required code-upgrade costs stood: the court said the award would seem binding whatever items it covered, and in any case the policy did not cover those costs.
Limits: Fire policy, 1927.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kaufman Jewelry Co. v. Insurance Co. of State of Pa.
Minnesota Supreme Court · August 5, 1927 · 172 Minn. 314, 215 N.W. 65
Awards are presumed valid, but one is void when the umpire never considered the main issue it depended on, even with no fraud.
Limits: Rehearing denied Oct. 7, 1927. Applied an earlier form of the standard policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dudzinski v. Great American Insurance Co.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · April 22, 1927 · 90 Pa. Super. 540
An insured who refused the insurer's appraisal demand and sued had revoked the appraisal clause, which named no particular appraisers, and could recover.
Limits: Predates Ice City (1974), which calls appraisal clauses irrevocable; Professional (2020) distinguished it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Maravas v. American Equitable Assurance Corp.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · February 1, 1927 · 82 N.H. 533, 136 A. 364
The old referee clause is optional for the insured, and if the parties agree to a reference they are bound by a proper award. An award that decides none of the questions sent to the appraisers is void. The appraisers there said they could not tell whether the damage came from the fire, so the question went to the jury.
Limits: Pre-1960 referee clause. It does not say whether a panel may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fire Association of Philadelphia v. Agresta
Supreme Court of Ohio · December 14, 1926 · 115 Ohio St. 426, 154 N.E. 723 (No. 19763)
A written demand by one party is what makes appraisal a condition of suit. The insurer could have demanded appraisal and did not, so the insured could sue without one.
Limits: Fire policy requiring a written demand by either party.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mattox v. Seaboard Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Carolina · November 24, 1926 · 192 N.C. 612
An insurer's denial of liability can waive the policy's notice, proof of loss and appraisal conditions, so the insured may sue at once; the evidence of denial went to the jury.
Limits: A standard fire policy on a car. Short per curiam opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McLaughlin v. Orient Ins. Co.
Washington Supreme Court · March 18, 1926 · 138 Wash. 82, 244 P. 254
Where there was evidence that the umpire and the insurer's appraiser reached a low award arbitrarily and with a perfunctory review, the jury could disregard the award and set the loss itself. The court affirmed a jury verdict nearly double the award.
Limits: Fire policy on lodging-house furnishings.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mound City Roofing Tile Co. v. Springfield Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
Missouri Court of Appeals · September 29, 1925 · 218 Mo. App. 395, 277 S.W. 349
Appraisers who went beyond their job by valuing all the buildings in a lump sum made an award with no binding force. The court called appraisal on the insurer's demand a prerequisite to suit.
Limits: Fire era; coinsurance dispute. The prerequisite remark sits beside the 1909 law, which the opinion does not discuss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Concordia Fire Insurance Co. of Milwaukee v. Barkett
Oklahoma Supreme Court · June 2, 1925 · 110 Okla. 177, 236 P. 890 (1925 OK 433)
An insurer that denies liability before demanding appraisal waives the appraisal provision.
Limits: Fire policy decision from before the current statute.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Chauvin v. Superior Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · March 20, 1925 · 283 Pa. 397, 129 A. 326
An insured who made a good-faith effort at appraisal, where the appraisers failed to agree, had done what the policy asked and could sue without naming a second set of appraisers.
Limits: Fire policy on the statutory form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Reineke v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York
Supreme Court of North Dakota · December 31, 1924 · 52 N.D. 324, 202 N.W. 657
An insured who named an appraiser after a real disagreement over the amount of loss complied with the policy, even though proof of loss came later. The insurer's claim at trial that the appraiser was biased came too late.
Limits: 1924 policy wording. Does not say what makes an appraiser disqualified.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Globe & Rutgers Fire Ins. Co. v. Hornor
Arkansas Supreme Court · October 27, 1924 · 166 Ark. 102, 265 S.W. 351
Where an appraisal under the policy was held and the court named the umpire, the award stood unless shown to result from fraud, mistake or misconduct.
Limits: Decided after Kempner without discussing the jury-trial statute; the insured was relying on the award, not resisting it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Caledonian Insurance Co. v. North Dutch Reformed Church
New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals · May 19, 1924 · 96 N.J. Eq. 342, 124 A. 703
The insurer could not set aside an award by an umpire whom a court had appointed when the appraisers could not agree. An award stands without actual fraud or clear proof of injustice, and the court will not weigh the umpire's experience.
Limits: Decided under a 1920s statute and policy form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Atlas Assurance Co. v. Williams
Court of Appeals of Georgia · January 16, 1924 · 31 Ga. App. 536, 121 S.E. 135 (No. 14962)
The fire policy's appraisal stipulation did not make appraisal a condition to suing, and even if it had, the insurer waived it by failing to demand appraisal.
Limits: 1924 fire policy; tied to the 60 days then allowed for payment of the loss. Later treatment not traced.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mississippi Fire Insurance Co. v. Dixon
Mississippi Supreme Court · December 3, 1923 · 133 Miss. 570, 98 So. 101, No. 23641
If the insurer flatly denies liability before suit, there is no disagreement about the amount to appraise, and the insured need not appraise first. The right to appraisal can be waived by not demanding it.
Limits: Household furniture fire policy; old case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Di Re v. Fire Ass'n of Philadelphia
Minnesota Supreme Court · July 13, 1923 · 156 Minn. 281, 194 N.W. 755
An appraisal award carries every presumption of validity, and fraud or bias must be pleaded with specific facts, but specific claims that the umpire was biased and chosen by fraud were enough to go forward.
Limits: Applied the 1913 form of the standard policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hexter v. Equitable Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · July 7, 1923 · 123 Me. 77
Appraisers' extra, unauthorized statement about who pays what was ignored as surplusage. The valid parts of the award stood and the insured recovered.
Limits: Automobile fire policy with appraisers under an agreement of submission.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
National Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford v. Pinnell
Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · June 5, 1923 · 199 Ky. 624, 251 S.W. 651
An insurer that wants appraisal must act with reasonable promptness and in good faith. Where both sides tried in good faith for months to set up appraisal and failed, the insured could sue on the policy. The policy quoted had each side pay its own appraiser and split umpire and appraisal expenses equally.
Limits: Truck fire policy. The court did not rule on the cost-splitting clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cowles v. Connecticut Fire Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · May 12, 1923 · 113 Kan. 532, 215 P. 308
If the two appraisers cannot agree on an umpire and the insured is not at fault, the insured need not propose new appraisers and may sue on the policy. An insurer's appraiser who arbitrarily rejects every local umpire candidate cannot rely on the failed appraisal.
Limits: Fire policy, pre-1997 and pre-2018.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Oakes v. Franklin Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · March 16, 1923 · 122 Me. 361, 120 A. 53
The standard policy's referee process is more than a quick look and guess. To get a conclusive award, the parties need notice and a full chance to be heard by disinterested, impartial referees.
Limits: Earlier referee wording; not a modern appraisal-clause case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wellington v. Mid-West Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · February 10, 1923 · 112 Kan. 687, 212 P. 892
The court treated the policy's appraisal as a condition that had to be met before suing on the policy, and allowed evidence of the appraisal only to show that condition was met.
Limits: The policy covered a truck against fire, issued by a mutual association. It left open whether the insurer waived a right by requiring appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Salganik v. United States Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · November 8, 1922 · 80 N.H. 450, 118 A. 815
Under the old standard fire policy, referees appointed by the court found the amount of loss and the insurer took part without objection. The award was a completed arbitration and bound the parties on the amount of loss. It did not decide whether the policy was void for the insured's fraud, which the insurer could still try to a jury.
Limits: Decided under the pre-1960 referee clause, not the appraiser-and-umpire clause in RSA 407:22 today.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Graff v. National Liberty Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · November 6, 1920 · 107 Kan. 648, 193 P. 356
An appraisal that left out part of the insured property, done without notice to the insured, did not bind her; the agreement sent the appraisers only the amount of loss, not whether the occupancy condition was met. By tendering the appraised amount, the insurer waived its policy defenses.
Limits: Turned on the wording of one written submission. Fire policy, pre-1997 and pre-2018.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Security Printing Co. v. Westchester Fire Insurance Co.
St. Louis Court of Appeals (Missouri) · May 4, 1920 · 204 Mo. App. 390, 221 S.W. 430
Under the 1909 law the policy clause could not force the insured into appraisal, but the insured could agree to one after the loss. An award that did not value the classes of property the agreement listed was void, and the insurer had to prove the agreement was followed.
Limits: Fire era; the 1909 law was later repealed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bradbury v. Insurance Company of Pennsylvania
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · June 5, 1919 · 118 Me. 191
An insurer that carelessly offered referee nominees who were not disinterested was at fault, so the insured could sue without starting a new appraisal. Bias or partisanship of referees can be inferred from their conduct and award.
Limits: Decided on a pleading challenge under the earlier referee wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Goldstein v. National Fire Ins. Co. of Hartford
Washington Supreme Court · April 3, 1919 · 106 Wash. 346, 180 P. 409
Appraisal provisions in fire policies are valid and enforceable, and refusing a demand can bar recovery. Settlement talks and advisory estimates did not waive appraisal unless the insured was misled to its injury. The case quotes the standard form: competent and disinterested appraisers and umpire, each side pays its own appraiser, umpire and expenses shared equally.
Limits: 1919 policy on the New York standard form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
R. E. Jones & Co. v. Northern Assurance Co.
Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · January 14, 1919 · 182 Ky. 701, 207 S.W. 459
An insured could not set aside an award because the insurers' appraiser had worked for insurance companies before and argued hard for them. The rule requiring disinterested and impartial appraisers does not reach an appraiser who is only zealous for the side that chose him.
Limits: Fire policy and separate arbitration agreement.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Insurance Co. of North America v. Kempner
Arkansas Supreme Court · January 14, 1918 · 132 Ark. 215, 200 S.W. 986
A policy clause binding the parties to appraisal is void by statute. An agreed appraisal is then an ordinary submission that either side may revoke in writing before the award, whatever the reason.
Limits: Decided under the statute's predecessor. The insured had objected that the insurer's appraiser was not disinterested.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Firemen's Ins. Co. v. Davis
Arkansas Supreme Court · October 29, 1917 · 130 Ark. 576, 198 S.W. 127
A fire policy appraisal condition that blocked suit until an appraisal was done ran against the statute protecting the right to a jury on questions of fact. The insured won without appraising.
Limits: Decided under the statute's predecessor (Kirby's Digest 4382). The headnote is worded confusingly; the opinion text controls.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Boutross v. Palatine Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · May 12, 1917 · 100 Kan. 574, 164 P. 1069
An appraisal award is prima facie conclusive on the matters submitted. One appraiser cannot block an award by withdrawing, and the insurer that pleads fraud carries the burden of proving it.
Limits: Fire policy, pre-1997 and pre-2018.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Drake v. Continental Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · February 6, 1917 · 78 N.H. 604
The parties submitted the amount of a fire loss to arbitrators, who made a written award after a hearing. The insured could not recover more than the award.
Limits: A one-paragraph decision under the pre-1960 referee clause, decided without briefs.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Milwaukee Mechanics' Insurance Co. v. Sewell
Oklahoma Supreme Court · October 17, 1916 · 66 Okla. 210, 168 P. 660 (1916 OK 887)
A petition alleging the appraisers made a mistake of fact in the award states a claim, so an award can be challenged for mistake. By joining the appraisal and pleading the award, the insurers waived the 60-day proof-of-loss requirement.
Limits: Pre-statute policy. Commissioner's opinion adopted by the court; rehearing denied November 6, 1917.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Young v. Pennsylvania Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Missouri · July 3, 1916 · 269 Mo. 1, 187 S.W. 856
An appraisal award is conclusive on the amount of loss unless fraudulently procured, and the insured may plead fraud in reply and have a jury decide it. The 1909 law against forced arbitration was meant to void forced appraisal clauses, but it did not reach this 1907 policy.
Limits: Fire era. The 1909 law was later repealed; its words survive in a Department rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Houseman v. Globe & Rutgers Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · June 3, 1916 · 78 W. Va. 586
An adjuster who makes up the proof of loss from the insured's data, with values listed, and does not demand an appraisal, waives the policy's appraisal provision.
Limits: Fire policy of 1916; the point concerns goods saved from the fire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Springfield Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Hays & Son
Oklahoma Supreme Court · March 21, 1916 · 57 Okla. 266, 156 P. 673 (1916 OK 352)
An insurer must demand appraisal, if at all, within a reasonable time, which in no event runs past 60 days after it receives proof of loss.
Limits: Pre-statute fire policy; the 1957 statute sets no demand deadline.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Providence-Washington Insurance Co. v. Kennington
Mississippi Supreme Court · March 15, 1916 · 111 Miss. 244, 71 So. 378
The two appraisers could not agree on an umpire and gave up. The policy had no fallback for a second try, so the insured, who had named a competent and disinterested appraiser in good faith, could sue on the policy.
Limits: Automobile fire policy; old case; modern policies let a judge pick the umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Second Society of Universalists in Boston v. Royal Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 28, 1915 · 221 Mass. 518
General claims of fraud, bias or prejudice without specific facts do not justify a court inquiry into an award. A low award honestly made is not a ground to set it aside. An award so grossly and palpably low that it shows fraud or bias can be.
Limits: Old case. No later decision revisiting it was found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kirkham v. German American Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · July 7, 1914 · 92 Kan. 941
An award may be set aside where appraisers refused to consider part of the loss, aimed to keep the award low, and confined the umpire; each party is entitled to each arbitrator's independent judgment.
Limits: Fire policy, 1914.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Oakes v. Pine Tree State Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · June 3, 1914 · 112 Me. 52
An insurer's flat denial of all liability waived the policy's requirement that the amount of loss be fixed by referees before suit. The statute's specific waiver rule was not the only way to waive.
Limits: Earlier policy and statute versions requiring referees as a condition precedent to suit.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Harowitz v. Concordia Fire Insurance Co.
Tennessee Supreme Court · April 15, 1914 · 129 Tenn. 691, 168 S.W. 163
Following Hickerson, an insurer that in effect denied all liability and made no specific objection to the proof of loss had no right to demand appraisal; appraisers must be impartial.
Limits: Fire policy case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hanley v. Aetna Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · September 11, 1913 · 215 Mass. 425
Referees under the standard fire policy are not a court. They may use their own inspection and judgment and may decide what evidence to admit, so refusing evidence did not void the award.
Limits: Decided long ago. Augenstein later lists refusal to hear relevant evidence as a possible ground to impeach.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Aetna Insurance Co. v. Jester
Oklahoma Supreme Court · January 21, 1913 · 37 Okla. 413, 132 P. 130 (1913 OK 45)
Appraisers must hear the parties' evidence, and an award from a fair appraisal binds the parties. An insurer that defended the first award waived its right to a second appraisal. The court noted that appraisers must act impartially but did not decide the claim that the company's appraiser was biased.
Limits: Decided on a pre-statute policy form.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ross v. German Alliance Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · December 9, 1911 · 86 Kan. 145, 119 P. 366
The court upheld a trial court's finding that an award was unfair and fixed the loss itself. An insurer appraiser's long record of insurer work was not itself a disqualification but could be weighed with his conduct, and the court said appraisers value the fire loss and do not decide the insurer's liability.
Limits: One justice dissented. The trial court's factual findings carried the result. Fire policy with competent and disinterested wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North British & Mercantile Insurance Co. v. Robinett & Green
Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · November 16, 1911 · 112 Va. 754, 72 S.E. 668
Where the policy makes appraisal a condition of suit, an insured who ignored the insurer's timely demand could not sue. The insurer could demand appraisal any time within 60 days after proof of loss, and waiver must be knowing and clear.
Limits: Older fire policy wording with a 60-day payment period. Its remark that awards settle amount only, not liability, quotes the U.S. Supreme Court and is not a coverage holding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Amusement Syndicate Co. v. Prussian National Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · July 7, 1911 · 85 Kan. 367
Where neither side sought appraisal for over a year after a fire, the insurer could not defeat the insured's suit for lack of an appraisal; its own inaction could be treated as a waiver.
Limits: Fire policy on lost rents, 1911.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
J. M. Winchester v. North British & Mercantile Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of California · May 25, 1911 · 160 Cal. 1, 116 P. 63 (L.A. No. 2753)
Where the policy made the loss payable 60 days after proof of loss and any appraisal, the insurer waived its right to appraisal by letting 60 days pass after receiving proof of loss without demanding one, and the insured could sue on the policy.
Limits: Older policy form, before the current standard form; turned on the policy's payment timing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Levi v. Palatine Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · December 6, 1910 · 75 N.H. 551, 78 A. 617
Under the old standard fire policy, a sworn statement of loss and appraisal by referees were not essential to suing on the policy, and the insurer could not have forced the insured into referees.
Limits: Pre-1960 form and an earlier statute. Does not address the appraisal clause in RSA 407:22.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Solem v. Connecticut Fire Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · June 6, 1910 · 41 Mont. 351, 109 P. 432
An appraisal award, unless set aside, binds both sides and fixes the amount of loss. The court cut a jury verdict down to the award, with interest from 60 days after the appraisers' return.
Limits: Fire policy; parties had signed a separate submission agreement.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Jerrils v. German American Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · April 9, 1910 · 82 Kan. 320, 108 P. 114
The insurer cannot gain an advantage where its own appraiser's bad faith causes the failure to agree on an umpire or award. The opinion also prints the policy wording that each side pays its own appraiser and splits umpire and appraisal expenses.
Limits: Fire policy, pre-1997 and pre-2018. The cost wording is policy text, not a holding on costs.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Gragg v. Northwestern National Insurance Co.
Kansas City Court of Appeals (Missouri) · March 7, 1910 · 140 Mo. App. 685, 126 S.W. 766
An insurer that ignored the insured's requests for appraisal could not later rely on the appraisal clause. Whether it waived or refused appraisal was for the jury, and interest ran from the earlier date.
Limits: Fire era; the S.W. cite is from a secondary listing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mason v. Fire Association of Philadelphia
Supreme Court of South Dakota · June 26, 1909 · 23 S.D. 431, 122 N.W. 423
Appraisers and the umpire must act with judicial impartiality and give each side notice and a chance to present evidence. The court upheld vacating an award made by a biased appraiser who refused to hear the insured and did not state sound value.
Limits: Fire policy era; predates SDCL 21-25A-3 and the approved nonbinding clause. No mention of fee arrangements.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Royal Insurance Co. v. Ries
Supreme Court of Ohio · April 27, 1909 · 80 Ohio St. 272 (No. 11173)
The standard fire policy clause is an appraisal of the amount of loss, not an arbitration. Appraisers need not hear evidence. The award stands unless the challenger proves misconduct or interest; suspicion that the insurer's appraiser was partisan was not enough.
Limits: Fire policy wording of that era. An award shown to be void, or set aside, does not bind.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Shawnee Fire Insurance Co. v. Pontfield
Court of Appeals of Maryland · March 22, 1909 · 110 Md. 353, 72 A. 835
If an insured acts in good faith and the appraisal fails without the insured's fault, including because the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire, the insured may sue on the policy without an award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rolfe v. Patrons' Androscoggin Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · December 30, 1908 · 105 Me. 58, 72 A. 732
An award is presumed valid. A party who says it was signed by mistake must prove it by clear and convincing evidence, and the insured here did not.
Limits: Earlier referee wording; equity action to set aside an award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dunton v. Westchester Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · September 15, 1908 · 104 Me. 372, 71 A. 1037
The standard policy's referees decide only the amount of damage. Who owns the property, and the insurer's general liability, are for the courts. The referees were right to refuse to hear evidence on title.
Limits: Decided under the earlier standard policy wording ("amount of loss or damage"), which was a condition precedent to suit. Does not mention causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Carlston v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
Montana Supreme Court · March 28, 1908 · 37 Mont. 118, 94 P. 756
Appraisers who must value a totally destroyed building have to give the owner notice and a fair chance to present her claim, or the award does not bind her. Appraisers are not agents of the party who chose them.
Limits: Total loss of a dwelling under a fire policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fire Association v. Allesina
Oregon Supreme Court · April 30, 1907 · 49 Or 316, 89 P 960
A court of equity may set aside an appraisal award, and block a suit on it, if the winner got the award by fraud or false testimony.
Limits: Decided under an older fire policy form; the court treated the appraisers as arbitrators.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fire Association of Philadelphia v. Appel
Supreme Court of Ohio · February 26, 1907 · 76 Ohio St. 1 (No. 9955)
When one appraiser quit partway through, through no fault of either side, the party who chose him had to name another. An insurer that refused and demanded a whole new appraisal instead waived the appraisal condition, and the insured could sue.
Limits: Turns on the insurer's conduct after an appraisal had begun.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bernhard v. Rochester German Insurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors · December 18, 1906 · 79 Conn. 388, 65 A. 134
When appraisers could not reach an award through no fault of the insured, and the insurer refused to recognize any liability, the insured was excused from going further with appraisal and could sue on the policy.
Limits: Fire policy era case with old policy wording; sixty-day payment term.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Home Insurance Co. v. M. Schiffs' Sons
Court of Appeals of Maryland · June 16, 1906 · 103 Md. 648
Under a clause where an award by any two decides, the third person is a third arbitrator, not an umpire. If the parties limit the umpire to the points of difference, an award by one appraiser and the umpire covering matters the appraisers agreed on is not valid, and the insured may sue on the policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Young v. Aetna Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · March 22, 1906 · 101 Me. 294, 64 A. 584
Referees on a fire loss must be disinterested in the broad sense: no relationship or money interest, and no bias or partisanship. An insurer's referee who acted as the company's representative made the award unenforceable against the insured.
Limits: Decided under the earlier "three disinterested men" referee wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Leu v. Commercial Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Dakota · February 26, 1906 · 15 N.D. 360, 107 N.W. 59
A fire policy clause that makes appraisal a step before the insured can sue for the amount of loss is valid. A complaint that does not allege an award or a waiver of the appraisal step does not state a claim.
Limits: Decided on pleading rules under 1906 policy wording; does not address waiver by an insurer's conduct.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Grady v. Home Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · January 26, 1906 · 27 R.I. 435, 63 A. 173
Under the standard fire policy, appraisal is a condition that must be met before suit. When an award fails without the insurer's fault, the insured must go through a new appraisal before suing.
Limits: The policy expressly barred suit until appraisal; the court said the result would differ if the insurer caused the failure.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Niagara Fire Ins. Co. v. Boon
Arkansas Supreme Court · June 24, 1905 · 76 Ark. 153, 88 S.W. 915
Every reasonable presumption favors an appraisal award, and it is set aside only for lack of authority, fraud, mistake or misconduct of the appraisers.
Limits: Arose before the jury-trial statute, as Kempner later said; not good authority for binding awards today.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
National Fire Ins. Co. v. O'Bryan
Arkansas Supreme Court · April 29, 1905 · 75 Ark. 198, 87 S.W. 129
Whether a fire-policy appraiser is competent and disinterested is for the jury. An appraiser who earlier estimated the loss for the insured was not disqualified by that alone.
Limits: Fire-policy clause from the era of binding appraisals.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Commercial Union Assurance Co. v. Parker
Illinois Appellate Court · March 17, 1905 · 119 Ill. App. 126
A court of equity set aside a fire appraisal award signed by one appraiser and the umpire without the insured's appraiser taking part. Illinois courts set awards aside for fraud, corrupt practices, mistake or willful misconduct.
Limits: Fire policy of 1902; decided on the evidence at trial.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Billmyer v. Hamburg-Bremen Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · January 24, 1905 · 57 W. Va. 42
A valid award under a fire policy that limits the submission to the amount of loss is final on that amount, but does not stop an action on the policy. The court said an award cannot be impeached in an action at law for misconduct that does not appear on its face.
Limits: Decided in 1905 on an award outside the statute; the law and equity distinction may not matter today.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Van Winkle v. Insurance Co. (Continental Fire Ins. Co.)
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · March 15, 1904 · 55 W. Va. 286, 47 S.E. 82
The court refused to set aside a fire-loss appraisal award. An appraiser's earlier work as an appraiser did not disqualify him without proof of prejudice, the insured never offered the evidence he said was refused, and a mistake of judgment is not enough to void an award.
Limits: Suit in equity under a fire policy appraisal clause and a written submission. Decided in 1904.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Continental Insurance Co. v. Vallandingham & Gentry
Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · September 25, 1903 · 116 Ky. 287, 76 S.W. 22
An insurer relying on appraisal must in good faith name a competent, disinterested appraiser. An appraiser who acted more like the insurer's employee than a neutral person did not qualify, but serving insurers before did not itself show bias. An insurer that misuses the clause waives it, and failure to appraise is no defense unless the insurer asks for appraisal before suit.
Limits: Fire policy; decided before modern court-appointment statutes.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Connecticut Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford v. Cohen
Court of Appeals of Maryland · June 29, 1903 · 97 Md. 294, 55 A. 675
A party-named appraiser is not the party's agent and must act independently on his own judgment. If appraisal fails to produce an umpire without the insured's fault, the insured may still sue on the policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Insurance Co. of North America v. Hegewald
Supreme Court of Indiana · April 3, 1903 · 161 Ind. 631, 66 N.E. 902
A fire-loss appraisal award was set aside. The insurer picked an appraiser who was its own employee and acted on its directions, and the umpire was biased too. "Disinterested" means more than having no money at stake: the appraiser must be fair and unprejudiced.
Limits: Fire policy that required "competent and disinterested" appraisers. The court did not say how that applies to every modern policy wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Stoddard v. Cambridge Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Vermont Supreme Court · March 13, 1903 · 75 Vt. 253
The insured sued on a fire policy without first having the amount of loss fixed by the policy's arbitrators. The parties agreed denial of liability can sometimes waive that clause, and the court held it was proper to let the jury decide whether the insurer's denial did.
Limits: Property was in Massachusetts and the record on appeal was incomplete. The clause was called arbitration. Vermont law now voids clauses making an award a condition to suit.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Phoenix Insurance Co. v. Zlotky
Nebraska Supreme Court · December 3, 1902 · 66 Neb. 584, 92 N.W. 736
A fire policy condition that made suit depend on first completing an appraisal could not bar the insured's suit, following an earlier rule that such clauses oust the courts of jurisdiction. The court rejected the argument that appraising only the amount of loss is different.
Limits: Fire-policy era case, consistent with Rawlings. The insureds refused the insurers' demand to appraise and still recovered.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hartford Fire Insurance Co. v. Hon
Nebraska Supreme Court · December 3, 1902 · 66 Neb. 555, 92 N.W. 746 (No. 12,089)
A fire policy clause sending the amount of loss to appraisers cannot be enforced and either side may revoke it any time before the appraisal is held. The court rejected the view that appraising only the amount differs from arbitrating the whole claim, and noted a party may agree to arbitrate a question after it arises.
Limits: Fire-policy era; consistent with Rawlings.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Christianson v. Norwich Union Fire Ins. Soc'y
Minnesota Supreme Court · December 6, 1901 · 84 Minn. 526, 88 N.W. 16
An award was properly set aside where a referee openly acted as the insurer's representative and referees gathered evidence privately. Referees must be disinterested and act impartially.
Limits: Decided under an early form of the standard policy. It did not involve a fee arrangement.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Providence Washington Insurance Co. v. Board of Education of Morgantown School District
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · March 25, 1901 · 49 W. Va. 360
When an umpire or arbitrator goes beyond his authority, his award is void, whether the excess was intentional or a mistake. The court applied that to a fire-loss appraisal.
Limits: Decided in 1901 on a written submission agreement.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Westenhaver Bros. v. German American Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · December 22, 1900 · 113 Iowa 726
A party who intentionally prevents or unreasonably delays the choice of an umpire waives the appraisal. When the appraisers fail to agree through no one's fault, the insured must name a new appraiser and continue rather than sue.
Limits: Fire policy that made appraisal a condition precedent to suit.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Phoenix Insurance Co. v. Carnahan
Supreme Court of Ohio · November 13, 1900 · 63 Ohio St. 258
An appraisal condition in a fire policy is valid and, where suit depends on it, the insured must comply or show a legal excuse. An insurer's denial of liability is not a denial of the amount of loss and does not waive appraisal unless it makes appraisal pointless. An insured who ignored the insurer's demand could not recover.
Limits: Fire policy of that era, which made appraisal a condition precedent to suit.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Harrison v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · October 8, 1900 · 112 Iowa 77
An insured who gave up an appraisal and sued waived the right to demand it again after the suit failed. The insurer, whose appraiser stalled, had also lost the right to insist on appraisal before suit.
Limits: Involved a separate written agreement to arbitrate the loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Schouweiler v. Merchants' Mutual Insurance Association
Supreme Court of South Dakota · February 1, 1899 · 11 S.D. 401, 78 N.W. 356
An insurer that ignored the insured's requests to name an appraiser and then agreed to a separate arbitration waived the policy's appraisal condition.
Limits: Arose under an 1895 mutual insurer statute similar to today's SDCL 58-35-49. Predates SDCL 21-25A-3.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Pretzfelder v. Merchants Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Carolina · November 22, 1898 · 123 N.C. 164
When an appraisal the insurers demanded fell through without the insured's fault, the insured could sue on the policy without going through another appraisal, and the insurers' demand for appraisal waived proof of loss.
Limits: Old fire policy case; follows the court's first decision in the same case (116 N.C. 491).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Stemmer v. Scottish Union & National Insurance Co.
Oregon Supreme Court · June 23, 1898 · 33 Or 65, 52 P 498
Each side must pick an impartial appraiser, but a party's appraiser may be friendly to that party. Prior work for insurers did not disqualify him, and failing to object when the ground is known waives it. Absent fraud or misconduct, the award is final.
Limits: The parties submitted the loss under the policies by written agreement, before the current statute.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Read & Traversy v. State Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · October 19, 1897 · 103 Iowa 307
A party who intentionally prevents or unreasonably delays the agreed appraisal cannot use the lack of an appraisal as a defense. A policy that does not make appraisal a condition precedent does not bar suit.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Stephens v. Union Assurance Society
Utah Supreme Court · October 6, 1897 · 16 Utah 22, 50 P. 626 (Utah 1897)
An insurer that denied liability and refused to appraise property the fire totally destroyed could not demand appraisal after the insured sued. The partial appraisal did not limit the damages, because the insurer could not profit from its own fault.
Limits: Fire policy on personal property; decided on the insurer's denial and delay, not on delay by the insured.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Caledonian Fire Insurance Co. of Scotland v. Traub
Court of Appeals of Maryland · June 23, 1897 · 86 Md. 86, 37 A. 782
An insurer that demanded appraisal and offered to pay the award could be found to have waived the policy's proof-of-loss requirement. An award by one appraiser and the umpire is valid only if made after the appraisers finally disagreed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Davis v. Imperial Ins. Co.
Washington Supreme Court · December 18, 1896 · 16 Wash. 241, 47 P. 439
An insurer's demand for appraisal made nearly a year after the fire and after the insured had sued on the policy came too late.
Limits: Decided with Davis v. Atlas Assurance Co., 16 Wash. 232. Short per curiam opinion; Keesling (1974) treats suit as only one circumstance.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Connecticut Fire Insurance Co. v. O'Fallon
Nebraska Supreme Court · December 2, 1896 · 49 Neb. 740, 69 N.W. 118 (No. 6719)
After a fire loss the parties signed a written agreement sending the amount of loss to named appraisers, who made an award. The award binds both sides unless there was fraud or mistake, the party attacking it must plead and prove that, and a party who wants to back out must do so before the award is made.
Limits: Common-law arbitration of a post-loss agreement, decided before the Uniform Arbitration Act (1987). No later Nebraska case applying it was found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Springfield Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Payne
Kansas Supreme Court · October 10, 1896 · 57 Kan. 291, 46 P. 315
An appraisal award made honestly and fairly binds the parties, but not if an appraiser who never saw destroyed property was given no chance to learn its value. Appraisal is not a condition before suit where neither side made the written demand the policy called for.
Limits: Fire policy and a written appraisal agreement, 1896.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kiernan v Dutchess County Mut. Ins. Co.
New York Court of Appeals · October 6, 1896 · 150 NY 190
An award was set aside where the insurer's appraiser, presented as an impartial business man, was a career insurance adjuster biased toward insurers who dominated the other appraiser. Under the non-waiver clause, acts relating only to the appraisal were set aside in deciding waiver.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Caledonian Insurance Co. of Scotland v. Julius Traub & Brother
Court of Appeals of Maryland · June 18, 1896 · 83 Md. 524, 35 A. 13
An award made by one appraiser and the umpire after the other appraiser withdrew was invalid, because the clause requires the appraisers to act together and the umpire to decide only their differences. An insured who causes the appraisal to fail cannot recover on the policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Aetna Insurance Co. v. McLead
Kansas Supreme Court · June 6, 1896 · 57 Kan. 95
Appraisal clauses that give no number of arbitrators or way to choose them, so either side could block appraisal by refusing every choice, are inoperative and do not bar suit.
Limits: Policy wording of the 1890s; modern clauses set a method.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Manufacturers & Builders Fire Insurance Co. v. Mullen
Nebraska Supreme Court · May 20, 1896 · 48 Neb. 620, 67 N.W. 445
An arbitration award on a fire loss was not usable against the insured, because the person who signed the agreement for her had not been shown to have authority, and the umpire signed with one arbitrator without any showing that the arbitrators had a difference to resolve.
Limits: Concerns a written arbitration agreement on a fire loss, not a standard appraisal clause. Included only for the rule that an umpire may act only on matters the arbitrators disagree on.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hickerson & Co. v. Insurance Companies
Tennessee Supreme Court · February 13, 1896 · 96 Tenn. 193, 33 S.W. 1041
Appraisers act in a quasi-judicial role and must be impartial. An insurer cannot demand appraisal while denying all liability, and its appraiser's unreasonable demands over the umpire excused the insured from appraisal.
Limits: Fire policy case. Its view that an appraisal demand waives the insurer's liability defenses predates modern policy wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Liverpool & London & Globe Insurance Co. v. Hall
Kansas Court of Appeals · July 6, 1895 · 1 Kan. App. 18
An insurer that defends on the insured's refusal of appraisal must plead and prove both its demand and an actual disagreement over the amount of loss.
Limits: Fire policy; decided by the Court of Appeals that sat 1895 to 1901.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Chapman v. Rockford Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Supreme Court · March 5, 1895 · 89 Wis. 572, 62 N.W. 422
Where the policy makes appraisal a condition of suit and a party properly demands it, the insured cannot sue until the appraisal is done or waived. A party that misuses the process to delay or cut down an honest claim, including by refusing to agree on an umpire, waives the appraisal condition, and the other side may sue.
Limits: Fire policy era case under the standard policy wording of the time.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Glover v. Rochester-German Ins. Co.
Washington Supreme Court · February 12, 1895 · 11 Wash. 143, 39 P. 380
Appraisers required to be competent and disinterested must be indifferent between the parties and impartial judges. The court upheld setting aside an award where the insurer's appraiser was found biased and dominated the umpire, and held the insured had not waived the objection by failing to raise it during the appraisal.
Limits: Fire policy on merchandise, 1893 loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Home Fire Insurance Co. v. Bean
Nebraska Supreme Court · November 8, 1894 · 42 Neb. 537, 60 N.W. 907
An insurer could not defeat the insured's suit by pleading that no appraisal had taken place, because such a provision is void under an earlier Nebraska decision. The insurer's demand for arbitration also waived the insured's proofs of loss.
Limits: The insurer said it had replaced its first appraiser as not disinterested, but the court did not rule on that. Pre-Rawlings fire-policy case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Niagara Fire Insurance Co. v. Bishop
Illinois Supreme Court · October 29, 1894 · 154 Ill. 9
A party's appraiser is not its agent just because that party picked him, but one who acts so plainly for that party that he is its agent makes that party answerable. The insurer's appraiser unreasonably held out for a distant umpire the other appraiser did not know, so the insured could sue without an award.
Limits: Fire policy of 1891 with a competent and disinterested appraiser clause; decided on the facts found by the trial judge.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kahn v. Traders Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Wyoming · December 1, 1893 · 4 Wyo. 419, 34 P. 1059
Fire policy on a stock of goods. The insurer called the policy void, never asked for appraisal, and raised it only after the insured closed his case. The court held the insurer had waived the appraisal condition, that an appraisal defense must be pleaded, and that a dispute over how much stock was burned was not one over sound value and damage that the clause covered.
Limits: Old decision on an old policy form. The court assumed, without deciding, that appraisal was a condition precedent.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
German Insurance Co. v. Eddy
Nebraska Supreme Court · March 29, 1893 · 36 Neb. 461, 54 N.W. 856 (Nos. 5014-5016)
When insured real property is totally destroyed, the valued policy act fixes the loss at the policy amount and the policy's appraisal clause yields to it, so there is nothing to appraise except perhaps the debris.
Limits: The insured also alleged the insurer's appraiser was its employee and prejudiced, but the court did not rule on that. The valued policy law is now Neb. Rev. Stat. § 44-501.02.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bradshaw v Agricultural Ins. Co. of Watertown
New York Court of Appeals · January 31, 1893 · 137 NY 137
Disinterested means not biased or prejudiced, not only free of a money stake. A party appraiser may bring out facts helpful to his side but is not its agent and must stay fair. An award was set aside where the insurer falsely called its appraiser impartial and he was biased.
Limits: The award fell because of the false statement about the appraiser together with his bias and a grossly low award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Chandos v. American Fire Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Supreme Court · January 31, 1893 · 84 Wis. 184, 54 N.W. 390
The court enforced an appraisal award. A claim that the insurer's appraisers were not impartial failed for lack of any evidence. Failing to pick the umpire before starting did not void the award. The appraisers' view of which items fell within the policy's general property description was final, and the insured could not complain about items she never put before them.
Limits: Fire policy era case with a clause requiring competent and impartial appraisers and a sworn award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Gotthelf
Nebraska Supreme Court · October 5, 1892 · 35 Neb. 351, 53 N.W. 137
An award that names no amount and gives no way to work one out is void. Whether people called arbitrators were only taking an inventory was for the jury. An insurer that pleads an agreed submission and award has waived proof of loss.
Limits: Fire-policy era; stock of goods.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Capitol Insurance Co. v. Wallace
Kansas Supreme Court · April 9, 1892 · 48 Kan. 400, 29 P. 755
Where no disagreement over the amount arose and neither side made a written request for appraisal, the insured did not need an appraisal before suing.
Limits: Fire policy, 1892. A rehearing was denied in 1893 (50 Kan. 453).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hanover Fire Insurance Co. v. B. C. Lewis & Sons
Supreme Court of Florida · June 15, 1891 · 28 Fla. 209, 10 So. 297 (Fla. 1891)
An appraisal award on the amount of a fire loss binds both sides when the policy and submission make it binding. A party can avoid it only by pleading and proving fraud or another ground that voids it in law. A party cannot escape it just by saying it will not abide by it.
Limits: Very old; still the Supreme Court's statement on grounds, but modern courts rarely cite it. Not found overruled.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Tilley v. Connecticut Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · April 10, 1890 · 86 Va. 811, 11 S.E. 120
An insurer that did not ask for an award until nearly the end of the one-year suit period waived the award requirement by its delay.
Limits: Decided on a demurrer to the declaration; the 1911 Robinett decision described it as a pleading case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
German-American Insurance Co. v. Etherton
Nebraska Supreme Court · January 15, 1889 · 25 Neb. 505
A policy term barring suit until an appraisal award fixes the loss is void because it ousts the courts. The insured need not plead an appraisal to sue; an appraisal actually completed is a defense the insurer must plead.
Limits: The leading Nebraska case behind Rawlings. Fire-policy era.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hall v. Norwalk Fire Insurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors · July 20, 1888 · 57 Conn. 105, 17 A. 356
Policy appraisal of a fire loss is binding and favored. If appraisers act in good faith, neither side can avoid the award by showing errors of judgment on the facts. An expert appraiser's own inquiry into local labor prices was not a reason to set the award aside without a showing of prejudice.
Limits: Old policy wording that called the appraisers arbitrators and kept liability questions out of the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Uhrig v Williamsburgh City Fire Ins. Co.
New York Court of Appeals · February 9, 1886 · 101 NY 362
Each side must act in good faith to complete the appraisal. If one side refuses to go on with or finish it, the other is freed from the clause and may sue on the policy; an insured cannot be tied up forever by a failed appraisal.
Limits: Decided before Ins. Law 3408(c) allowed a court order compelling appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026