Skip to content
Claim King Core is free for 30 days. Start your trial

Impartiality

Must the appraisers be impartial, and what disqualifies one?

How to read this: a bold answer is what the state's law says. “Unsettled” means courts disagree or no controlling decision exists. “No state rule found” means we searched and found none.

Court decisions on this subject

Vermont Mutual Insurance Co. v. New England Property Services Group, LLC

Rhode Island Supreme Court · March 20, 2025 · No. 2023-335-Appeal (slip opinion)

A homeowner appraisal clause is arbitration under the Arbitration Act. The award was vacated for evident partiality where the contractor-assignee's sole owner served as its appraiser and the award was not unanimous. A policy saying only competent cannot shield that.

Limits: Slip opinion, no reporter cite found. Applies the Grabbert two-step test (improper interest plus causal link).

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Kennedy v. GeoVera Specialty Ins. Co.

U.S. District Court, E.D. La. · November 22, 2024 · No. 23-6395, Rec. Doc. 18

The court struck a $146,436.65 award because the insured appraiser flat fee schedule rose with his valuation, which worked like a contingency fee and made him not impartial under the policy. A neutral umpire signature did not cure it, and appraisal had to restart with impartial appraisers.

Limits: Decided on policy wording that barred appraisers paid by the award, not on the appraisal code; federal court.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

B.R.S. Real Estate, Inc. v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London

U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit · August 12, 2024 · No. 23-1531

Applying Rhode Island law, the court treated appraisal as arbitration with a strong presumption of validity. A challenge to an appraiser or umpire whose background was known before the appraisal came too late, and a lawyer may serve as umpire if otherwise qualified.

Limits: Federal court applying Rhode Island law. The lawyer-as-umpire point was an alternative ground; the main ground was that the challenge came too late.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

L & M Auto Repair, LLC v. Federated Mutual Insurance Co.

U.S. District Court, District of Kansas (magistrate judge) · January 17, 2024 · No. 6:23-cv-01203, ECF No. 20 (D. Kan. Jan. 17, 2024)

On undisputed facts, the court disqualified the insured's appraiser as not impartial under a policy calling for competent and impartial appraisers, and held a request to appoint an umpire premature until impartial appraisers had tried to agree.

Limits: A federal magistrate judge's order on an unopposed motion. It does not discuss Friday or whether Kansas enforces appraisal, and it does not mention the appraiser's fee.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Owners Insurance Co. v. HUB Multifamily, LLC

U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · November 29, 2023 · No. 1:23-cv-0060-RGJ

The court appointed a retired judge with insurance-dispute experience as umpire. General local ties do not disqualify a candidate, and a background mostly working for insureds does not either; the court preferred relevant experience and ordered the policy's equal split of umpire expenses.

Limits: Federal court; the clause calls for a competent and impartial appraiser.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

First Protective Insurance Co. v. Rike

U.S. District Court, Eastern District of North Carolina · October 12, 2023 · No. 4:22-CV-42-FL

A policy appraisal is not an arbitration under the state arbitration act, so the act's immunity and fee provisions did not protect an appraisal umpire accused of hiding prior work for the insured's side.

Limits: A federal trial court order at the pleadings stage. It did not decide that the umpire was biased or the award invalid. The Fourth Circuit affirmed in an unpublished opinion, which is not binding.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Groenig v. Safeco Insurance Co. of America

U.S. District Court, D. Idaho · September 21, 2023 · No. 1:20-cv-00538-BLW (Dkt. 77)

Appraisers set the amount only for items they were asked about and left denied roof and crawlspace items as coverage issues. The insured could sue on those items. Bad faith failed because the claim was fairly debatable, despite a complaint that the insurer's appraiser was biased.

Limits: Federal trial court summary judgment order. Not binding Idaho law.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Papagiannopoulous

U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · July 27, 2023 · No. 8:22-cv-02314-LKG (D. Md.)

An insurer asked the court to declare the insured's appraisers unqualified because of ties to the public adjuster's sister company. The court held the appraisal dispute is covered by the Federal Arbitration Act, dismissed the case, and said a challenge to an appraiser's qualifications is premature until the appraisal is complete.

Limits: Commercial property policy; Federal Arbitration Act; federal ruling that does not bind Maryland state courts.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Krafchow v. Dongbu Insurance Co.

Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals (published opinion) · February 17, 2023 · 152 Hawai‘i 248, 525 P.3d 697; Nos. CAAP-21-0000513 and CAAP-21-0000517

The appraisal clauses in a homeowners policy and two dwelling fire policies are arbitration agreements under chapter 658A. Because the panel was to set "the amount of loss", the appraiser and umpire had to value what the insured lost to the wildfire, not decide coverage or what the insurer owed. Awards that ordered payment of set amounts were vacated.

Limits: Reads policies that do not define "loss". Does not decide who decides causation. The Hawaii Supreme Court rejected certiorari on June 30, 2023.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Parrish v. State Farm Florida Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of Florida · February 9, 2023 · No. SC21-172 (Fla. 2023)

An appraiser who, or whose firm, will be paid a contingency fee as the insured's public adjuster is not "disinterested" under the policy. The court approved the Second District and disapproved the Third District's Brickell Harbour decision to the extent inconsistent.

Limits: Decides only the policy word "disinterested". Did not decide "impartial" or "independent".

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

O'Malley-Joyce v. Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · June 28, 2022 · No. 2021-0068 (Grafton)

Homeowners were paid an appraisal award, then sued for more for breach of contract and bad faith. The trial court granted summary judgment for the insurer, treating the appraisal as binding. The Supreme Court said the homeowners had not preserved their arguments, reviewed only for plain error, and found none because whether a clause without the word "binding" binds the parties is a question of first impression.

Limits: Did not decide whether the clause binds or whether payment of an award ends later claims. The homeowner policy said "impartial" and had the appraisers pick the umpire; the opinion does not discuss RSA 407:22.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

James Hamilton Properties, LLC v. Great Midwest Insurance Co.

U.S. District Court, E.D. Kentucky · June 8, 2022 · No. 21-95-DLB (Pikeville)

The court appointed an umpire over the insured's argument that KRS 417.050(2) bars arbitration in insurance contracts, enforcing the policy's court-appointment language. It said no Kentucky court has decided whether the umpire's decision is binding arbitration and reserved that question, and said an umpire's impartiality should be held to a higher standard than an appraiser's.

Limits: Federal court; reserved the binding-effect question.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.

U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · March 28, 2022 · No. 4:19-CV-186-JHM

The court vacated an appraisal award because the insured's appraiser was not impartial: his fee deal gave no pay without added recovery, he promised a referral fee to the assignee roofer, and he set out to add scope. It did not decide whether the umpire exceeded his authority on cause.

Limits: Federal summary judgment on these facts; the opinion is signed March 28, 2022 and stamped filed March 29.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Musto v. Liberty Insurance Corp.

U.S. District Court, District of Maine · November 21, 2021 · No. 1:20-cv-00188-GZS (D. Me. Nov. 21, 2021) (recommended decision), aff'd (D. Me. Jan. 11, 2022)

A federal court upheld a homeowner appraisal award signed by the insurer's appraiser and the umpire after the insured's appraiser stopped taking part. The insurer did not waive appraisal by objecting to the insured's appraiser while naming its own. Once the valid award was tendered, the contract and unfair claims practice claims failed.

Limits: Federal trial court predicting Maine law; not binding on Maine courts. Homeowner policy, not the fire policy form.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Owners Insurance Co. v. Dakota Station II Condominium Ass'n

Colorado Court of Appeals · August 26, 2021 · 2021 COA 114, 499 P.3d 1069 (No. 20CA254)

Where the policy needs at least one impartial appraiser to agree for an award to bind, an award agreed to only by a partial appraiser and the umpire is invalid. The trial court properly found that appraiser partial, and the judgment vacating a $3 million award was affirmed.

Limits: Published appeals court opinion. The motion was brought under the Colorado Uniform Arbitration Act; the opinion does not decide whether that Act governs appraisals.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hart v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.

U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · August 21, 2021 · 556 F. Supp. 3d 735 (No. 2:20-cv-10573)

Applying Michigan law, nine add-on appraisal conditions in a State Farm homeowners form were void as contrary to the statute. These included advance itemized documentation, a ban on demanding appraisal after suing, extra notice before asking a judge for an umpire, mandatory professional licenses for appraisers, and bars on appraisers with a financial interest.

Limits: Federal district court, not binding on Michigan state courts. It kept the bar on an umpire with a financial interest.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Church of the Nativity v. GuideOne Specialty Mut. Ins. Co.

U.S. District Court, District of Minnesota · August 9, 2021 · No. 21-cv-1398 (D. Minn.)

An appraiser was not shown biased just because he had been paid by the insurer for an earlier appraisal of the same property.

Limits: A federal trial court order, not binding on Minnesota courts. It applied the policy's impartial appraiser clause.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Parko Properties, LLC v. Mercer Insurance Co. of New Jersey

New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · November 19, 2020 · No. A-4137-17T2 (unpublished)

The trial court decided coverage first, then sent only the amount of loss to appraisal, and the appraisers agreed on a figure. The insurer did not act in bad faith. The insured could still recover fees, costs and interest under the offer-of-judgment rule after the appraisal, because appraisal is not court-annexed arbitration.

Limits: Unpublished and not precedent under R. 1:36-3. A commercial collapse claim. The footnote on waiver of challenges to an appraiser is a passing remark.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Sinclair Wyoming Refining Co. v. Infrassure, Ltd.

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · August 17, 2020 · 970 F.3d 1317 (10th Cir. 2020), No. 19-8018

The court upheld confirmation of a $60.4 million appraisal award on a Wyoming refinery fire. It found no fraud, bias, bad faith or misconduct, including on a claim that the umpire was not disinterested.

Limits: Federal appeals court. New York law governed the appraisal under the policy, so it does not state Wyoming law.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

State Farm Florida Insurance Co. v. Valenti

Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal · December 11, 2019 · 285 So. 3d 963 (Fla. 4th DCA 2019), No. 4D19-205

An insured's public adjuster, who held an assignment of 20% of the recovery and had hired on that basis, could not later serve as the insured's disinterested appraiser.

Limits: Decided on its facts, before Parrish; Parrish now controls the contingency-fee point.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Owners Insurance Co. v. Dakota Station II Condominium Ass'n

Colorado Supreme Court · June 24, 2019 · 2019 CO 65, 443 P.3d 47 (No. 17SC583)

A policy that calls for an impartial appraiser requires one who is unbiased, disinterested and unswayed by personal interest, so the appraiser may not advocate for the side that picked him or her. A fee cap tied to a percentage of the award did not make the appraiser partial as a matter of law on those facts.

Limits: Turns on the policy word "impartial". The fee cap never applied in that case, so a straight percentage-of-award fee was not decided.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Veranda Gardens, LLC v. Secura Insurance

U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · June 11, 2019 · No. 3:18-cv-611-DJH-RSE, 2019 WL 2438788

The insurer's appraiser was impartial. An appraiser is not impartial if a party directs him or he has a financial stake, but doing the earlier inspection is not enough, and nothing in the record showed a contingency fee.

Limits: Federal court applying Kentucky law.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

The Mews at Byers Station Condominium Association v. Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co.

Superior Court of Pennsylvania · April 16, 2019 · No. 1047 EDA 2018

An award was upheld after the insurer paid it. Review is limited to a denied hearing or fraud, misconduct or irregularity in the process. A bad faith claim based on the appraisers' conduct cannot replace that standard, and the confirmed award fixed the amount for the contract claim.

Limits: Non-precedential memorandum; commercial property policy that required "competent and impartial" appraisers.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Prosight-Syndicate 1110 at Lloyds v. RST Westwick, LLC

U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · January 28, 2019 · No. 3:17-cv-885-CWR-LRA

An award signed by the insured's appraiser and the umpire was upheld. A consultant the umpire asked for, splitting his fee, and private talks between one appraiser and the umpire did not void it where the policy did not forbid them.

Limits: Federal district court predicting Mississippi law; commercial hail claim.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Kellogg v. Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co.

Connecticut Supreme Court · August 22, 2017 · 326 Conn. 638, 165 A.3d 1228

A trial court wrongly vacated a homeowner appraisal award after weighing the evidence itself. Where the submission is unrestricted, a court may vacate only on the statutory grounds, and a challenge for misconduct is limited to whether a party was denied a full and fair hearing. Disagreeing with the amount is not a ground. The panel's reading of the policy on depreciation was not a manifest disregard of the law.

Limits: Restorationist policy with an unrestricted arbitration clause. No one claimed the umpire or appraisers were partial.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

North Glenn Homeowners Ass’n v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.

Iowa Court of Appeals · July 6, 2017 · No. 16-0912

The court enforced the award. Appraisal does not violate due process. The causation finding was binding because no fraud, mistake or misfeasance was shown. An appraiser who testified elsewhere that he would say what his client asked was not shown to be partial, because appraisers may act as advocates.

Limits: Policy said "competent and impartial". Decided before Walnut Creek and before chapter 522F.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point

U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · November 18, 2016 · No. 1:13-cv-1453-SEB-DML, Dkt. 61 (adopting Dkt. 55 report and recommendation of 2016-01-28)

The district judge adopted a magistrate judge's recommendation and set aside an appraisal award. The umpire had refused the insured's engineering evidence, and the process was unfair to the insured. The report also cites a federal decision treating a contingency-paid appraiser as not impartial.

Limits: Federal trial court. Fact-heavy, decided on the whole process rather than one rule.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

St. Croix Trading Co./Direct Logistics, LLC v. Regent Insurance Co.

Wisconsin Court of Appeals (published) · May 24, 2016 · 2016 WI App 49, 370 Wis. 2d 248, 882 N.W.2d 487

The court affirmed vacatur of an appraisal award because the panel exceeded its authority by deciding which losses were covered. The panel's task was to value the property and the amount of loss. The court said no Wisconsin case was on point and did not decide whether panels may decide causation or whether the insurer's appraiser was impartial.

Limits: Commercial policy that kept the insurer's right to deny the claim. Does not decide causation, impartiality or bad faith (n.1).

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

McElroy v. Evanston Insurance Co.

U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · May 6, 2016 · No. 3:14-cv-180-CWR-FKB

Summary judgment for the insurer. An award agreed by two of three is presumed correct under Munn. A claim that the insured's appraiser was unlicensed or incompetent did not undo an award the other appraiser and the umpire agreed on.

Limits: Federal district court; commercial warehouse fire claim; assumed the license point was true without deciding it.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Thomas v. Standard Fire Insurance Co.

Tennessee Court of Appeals · February 17, 2016 · No. E2015-01224-COA-R3-CV, 2016 WL 638559

Homeowners were bound by the umpire's $132,793.95 award, because they only challenged the amount. The appraisal clause is not an arbitration agreement and needs no separate initials.

Limits: Unpublished (Westlaw cite only). Homeowners did not challenge the umpire's qualifications.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (umpire appointed)

U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · September 30, 2015 · No. 3:14-cv-40-DJH-DW, 2015 WL 5793951

The court appointed an experienced umpire over bias objections. It said cause and amount of loss are for the umpire and the scope of coverage is for the court, and refused to instruct the umpire that cosmetic matching was required.

Limits: Federal court; the Sixth Circuit affirmed in 2018.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Botai v. Safeco Insurance Co. of Illinois

U.S. District Court, D. Idaho (magistrate judge) · July 24, 2015 · No. 2:14-CV-00445-EJL-REB (Dkt. 16)

Compelled appraisal and stayed all claims, including bad faith, until the award. Made no findings on the insureds' claim that the insurer's appraiser was not disinterested.

Limits: Federal trial court order, not binding Idaho law. Used the Idaho Uniform Arbitration Act only for guidance and did not decide whether appraisal is arbitration.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Zurich American Insurance Co. v. Omni Health Solutions, LLC

Court of Appeals of Georgia · July 2, 2015 · 332 Ga. App. 723, 774 S.E.2d 782 (No. A15A0170)

An umpire's partiality is a ground for setting aside an award, and the trial judge has discretion. An award both party appraisers signed in writing stayed binding. An award only the insurer's appraiser and the umpire signed, after the umpire joined a firm doing work for the insurer, was properly set aside.

Limits: Commercial property policy that said impartial; the parties had jointly asked the superior court for a new umpire.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Texas Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance Co. v. Sampley

Court of Appeals of Texas, Amarillo (7th Dist.) · May 26, 2015 · No. 07-13-00151-CV (Tex. App.-Amarillo May 26, 2015, pet. denied) (mem. op.)

Texas law does not require a party appraiser to be disinterested unless the policy says so. A policy that asks only for a competent appraiser let the insured use a body shop employee whose shop would be paid from the result.

Limits: Personal auto hail claim; memorandum opinion. Policies under 28 TAC 5.9804 (on or after March 1, 2027) now require disinterested appraisers.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Florida Insurance Guaranty Association v. Hanse

Florida Fifth District Court of Appeal · November 21, 2014 · 150 So. 3d 1272 (Fla. 5th DCA 2014), No. 5D13-4501

Insureds could not name their own attorney as their disinterested appraiser. An attorney owes a duty of loyalty to the client.

Limits: About attorneys, not public adjusters. Parrish cites the same Fifth District line (Branco, 148 So. 3d 488).

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Shree Hari Hotels, LLC v. Society Insurance

U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · September 5, 2013 · No. 1:11-cv-01324-JMS-DKL, Dkt. 156 (2013 WL 4777212)

An appraiser paid hourly with a fee capped at 10% of the claim payment had a financial interest in the outcome and was not "impartial". The award was set aside and could not be used at trial.

Limits: A single federal trial court order. No Indiana state court has decided it. The policy said "competent and impartial".

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Dufrene v. Certain Interested Underwriters at Lloyd's of London

Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fifth Circuit · March 27, 2012 · 91 So. 3d 397, 11-CA-1002

The trial court could appoint an umpire and set fair-process rules, such as no one-sided contact with the umpire. A challenger must show an appraiser honesty or integrity is suspect to remove him. The award was binding because the umpire and appraiser did their duties, and the challenger carried the burden. The court called the issue before the umpire the amount of damage, not causation.

Limits: Hurricane Katrina wind claim; the policy said a decision of any two is binding. The causation remark came in a ruling on excluding documents, not a holding on appraiser power.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Liberty Mutual Group, Inc. v. Wright

U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · March 5, 2012 · Civ. No. DKC 12-0282, 2012 WL 718857 (D. Md.)

When the appraisers could not agree on an umpire, the insurer asked the federal court to appoint one. The court held the appraisal clause is an arbitration agreement under the Federal Arbitration Act and kept the umpire appointment before it.

Limits: Federal ruling on a homeowner policy under the Federal Arbitration Act; the court did not pick the umpire in this opinion.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

White v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.

Michigan Court of Appeals · July 28, 2011 · 293 Mich App 419 (Docket No. 298083)

A public adjuster on a 10 percent contingency contract could serve as the insured's appraiser, because independent does not mean impartial. The other side must be told about the fee deal. Appraisers are not quasi-judges, so the insurer's due-process challenge failed.

Limits: Published. The appraiser was paid hourly (capped) for the appraisal. Did not decide whether a policy may add "disinterested".

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group

Ohio Court of Appeals, 9th District (Summit County) · May 25, 2011 · 2011-Ohio-2502 (C.A. No. 25643)

The trial court could appoint an umpire under the policy but had no power to bar the panel from considering causation. The appeals court called the causation question a matter of substantial debate and declined to decide it.

Limits: Commercial property policy. Resolved on the limits of the court's power, not on whether panels may decide causation.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Matter of Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v Seibert

New York Supreme Court, Monroe County · February 10, 2011 · 31 Misc 3d 523, 2011 NY Slip Op 21060

In a proceeding to appoint an umpire, the court appointed one and refused to limit what the umpire decides or to rule whether a party's appraiser is competent and disinterested.

Limits: Trial court decision.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Mahnke v. Superior Court

California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist. · December 21, 2009 · 180 Cal.App.4th 565, 103 Cal.Rptr.3d 197 (No. B216110)

The disclosure and disqualification rules in Code Civ. Proc. 1281.9 and 1281.91 apply to the umpire, not to party-selected appraisers. A party appraiser can still be challenged for a substantial business relationship, and any challenge should come at the first reasonable opportunity.

Limits: Writ proceeding; reinstated the insureds' appraiser.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Kuehn v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.

U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · August 17, 2009 · No. 1:08CV577 LTS-RHW, 2009 WL 2567485

An appraisal award was upheld. Appraisers may not decide disputed causation, but Munn does not bar an appraisal where both sides' appraisers agree on what is in and out. Awards are presumed valid and set aside only for fraud, substantial mistake or lack of authority.

Limits: Federal district court predicting Mississippi law; Hurricane Katrina homeowner claim.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Farmers Automobile Insurance Association v. Union Pacific Railway Co. (Donaubauer)

Wisconsin Supreme Court · July 10, 2009 · 2009 WI 73, 319 Wis. 2d 52, 768 N.W.2d 596

A valid appraisal clause binds both sides even without the word binding. Awards are presumptively valid and are set aside only for fraud, bad faith, a material mistake, or a panel that did not understand or finish its task. Review usually stops at the face of the award, and the court said appraisal is not governed by the arbitration statute.

Limits: Homeowner fire loss. The court said it need not decide how far Lynch reaches (para. 36) and left the Court of Appeals' ruling on the bad faith claim in place (n.2).

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Firemen's Insurance Co. of Washington, D.C. v. Birch Pointe Condominium Ass'n

Delaware Court of Chancery · May 29, 2009 · C.A. No. 4313-VCP (letter opinion)

An insured's appraiser whose employer did paid construction work for the insured while he served was not impartial. Naming him broke the policy, the umpire he helped choose was void, and the court appointed a new umpire.

Limits: Unreported trial-level opinion on a businessowners policy. It turned on a business tie, not a contingent fee.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Firemen's Insurance Co. of Washington, D.C. v. Birch Pointe Condominium Ass'n

Delaware Superior Court · December 17, 2008 · C.A. No. 08C-04-081 JAP (memorandum opinion)

The appraisal clause is an agreement to arbitrate. Because the Uniform Arbitration Act gave the Court of Chancery the power to appoint when the agreed method fails, the Superior Court said it lacked jurisdiction and let the case move to Chancery. It found the insured breached the clause by naming a tied appraiser.

Limits: Unreported trial-level opinion that predates the 2009 amendment of 10 Del. C. § 5702.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Tiger Fibers, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.

U.S. District Court, E.D. Virginia · August 15, 2008 · 571 F. Supp. 2d 712

Under the Virginia statute a disinterested appraiser can have no personal interest in the outcome. Only permanent employees of a party are disqualified, not independent contractors retained for the job. The insurer reimburses the insured's appraisal costs when the insurer invokes appraisal.

Limits: Federal court applying Virginia law. Does not address contingent fees.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Harris v. American Modern Home Insurance Co.

United States District Court, Eastern District of Missouri · May 30, 2008 · 571 F. Supp. 2d 1066

An appraiser paid a flat fee plus 15 percent of the award had a direct financial interest and was not disinterested as the law and the policy required. With his other ties to the insured, that made his award void.

Limits: Federal trial court applying Missouri law; homeowner wind and hail claim. No Missouri state court has ruled on contingent fees.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hall v. Farmers Alliance Mutual Insurance Co.

Idaho Supreme Court · February 13, 2008 · 145 Idaho 313, 179 P.3d 276; No. 32326

The insurer demanded appraisal but the process was never finished. Because the insurer did not follow its own appraisal process and both appraisers put the loss above the policy limit, the court upheld the award of the limit and would not let the insurer pay only actual cash value.

Limits: Homeowners policy. The appraisal wording is quoted only in a footnote; the court made no ruling on umpire selection or costs.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co.

Indiana Court of Appeals · August 25, 2006 · 856 N.E.2d 713 (published by order of Oct. 26, 2006)

A court order that only named an umpire did not bar a later suit. The insured alleged a biased umpire who had known the insurer's appraiser for years and said he could ignore the insured's documents. That was enough to ask a court to set the award aside.

Limits: Reversed a summary judgment. It did not decide the umpire was in fact biased.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

McGinity v. Pawtucket Mutual Insurance Co.

Rhode Island Supreme Court · June 13, 2006 · 899 A.2d 504

An arbitrator who was the insurer's lawyer and did not disclose it created evident partiality where he reached a very different amount than the other two arbitrators, so the award was vacated.

Limits: Uninsured-motorist arbitration, not property appraisal.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Cousino v. Stewart

Ohio Court of Appeals, 6th District (Fulton County) · November 23, 2005 · 2005-Ohio-6245 (Nos. F-05-011, F-05-004)

Under a homeowner policy, the court selected the umpire when the appraisers could not agree. Because the parties agreed to a binding resolution that also reached coverage questions, the court treated it as arbitration and confirmed the award. An insurer seeking to remove the umpire had to show evident partiality, which means more than an appearance of bias.

Limits: Turned on the parties' letters making the appraisal binding and broader than the amount of loss. Ries (Ohio 1909) treats the standard clause as an appraisal, not an arbitration.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

General Star Indemnity Co. v. Spring Creek Village Apartments Phase V, Inc.

Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston (14th Dist.) · November 30, 2004 · 152 S.W.3d 733 (Tex. App.-Houston [14th Dist.] 2004, no pet.), No. 14-02-00998-CV

A party appraiser whose fee grew with the size of the award raised a fact question about whether he was impartial. If a jury finds he was not, the award does not follow the policy and is not binding.

Limits: Commercial windstorm policy requiring a competent and impartial appraiser; a summary judgment ruling, not a flat ban on contingent fees. Link is a free copy on hallapproved.com, not the court's site.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Harleysville Mutual Insurance Co. v. Narron

North Carolina Court of Appeals · December 31, 2002 · 155 N.C. App. 362, 574 S.E.2d 490, No. COA02-137

A policy appraisal award is presumed valid and binding unless there is fraud, duress or other impeaching circumstances. An umpire's private meeting with one appraiser after joint meetings did not void the award, and the Uniform Arbitration Act did not apply to a policy appraisal that does not call for it.

Limits: Decided on the policy's appraisal wording and the facts. It does not discuss what disinterested means.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Allstate Indemnity Co. v. Jellerson

Maine Superior Court (Cumberland County) · August 29, 2001 · No. CV-00-693

A trial court held a repair shop owner could serve as the insured's "qualified appraiser" because he had no stake in the outcome. It said the old Maine cases on "disinterested" referees dealt with different policy words.

Limits: Trial court order, not binding. Automobile policy using "qualified appraiser," not the fire policy clause.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Calandro v. Allstate Insurance Co.

Connecticut Appellate Court · June 5, 2001 · 63 Conn. App. 602, 778 A.2d 212

The trial court found that a public adjusting firm broke the policy's disinterested appraiser requirement by naming its own employee, who had worked on the claim, as the insureds' appraiser, and by not withdrawing the choice promptly. The appellate court affirmed the judgment against the insurer's claim for losses it said that conduct caused.

Limits: The disinterested finding was the trial court's. The appeal was about the insurer's CUTPA claim against the adjuster, so the appellate court did not decide what disinterested means.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Michael v. Aetna Life & Casualty Insurance Co.

California Court of Appeal, 2nd Dist. · May 30, 2001 · 88 Cal.App.4th 925, 106 Cal.Rptr.2d 240 (No. B131509)

Two earlier cases for the insurer, both over before this one began, were not a substantial business relationship, so the party appraiser did not have to disclose them and the award was confirmed.

Limits: Applied the disclosure rule as it stood before the 2001-02 amendments, which Mahnke (2009) later held do not reach party appraisers.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

County Forest Products, Inc. v. Green Mountain Agency, Inc.

Maine Supreme Judicial Court · August 17, 2000 · 2000 ME 161, 758 A.2d 59

The insurers argued the insured's appraiser was not disinterested. Because they wrote that they would accept a representative of his firm, the court held they waived the objection and upheld the award. It also upheld bad faith and attorney fees where the insurers did not pay the award within 60 days or dispute it.

Limits: Did not decide whether the appraiser was actually disinterested. Commercial fire policy with an appraisal clause required by section 3002.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mutual Insurance Co.

Superior Court of Pennsylvania · January 31, 2000 · 745 A.2d 1261

Appraisal is reviewed like common-law arbitration. Where the policy said only "competent", an appraiser paid under a contingency arrangement was not unfit by that fact alone.

Limits: Did not decide whether the word "disinterested" would change the result.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Auto-Owners Insurance Co. v. Allied Adjusters & Appraisers, Inc.

Michigan Court of Appeals · November 5, 1999 · 238 Mich App 394; 605 NW2d 685 (Docket No. 202933)

Since the 1990 statute, an appraiser need only be independent and may lean toward the side that hired him. The umpire must be impartial. An appraiser who was the adjuster on the claim is not disqualified.

Limits: Per curiam. Published.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Minot Town & Country v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of North Dakota · December 22, 1998 · 1998 ND 215, 587 N.W.2d 189

A policy appraisal is not an arbitration, so North Dakota's Uniform Arbitration Act did not apply and the award stood. Appraisal fixes the amount of loss only, leaving liability for later decision.

Limits: The insured's argument that the insurer's appraiser was not impartial was not decided, because it was raised under the Arbitration Act. The policy kept the insurer's right to deny the claim.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

General Casualty Co. v. Tracer Industries, Inc.

Illinois Appellate Court, Fourth District · December 18, 1996 · 285 Ill. App. 3d 418, 674 N.E.2d 473

The court upheld a fire appraisal award. It gave substantial deference to appraisers and would set one aside only for fraud, mistake or gross error shown on the face of the award. A court-appointed umpire's membership in a local business group was not a disqualifying conflict.

Limits: Commercial fire policy; one justice dissented. No objection to the umpire was made until after his report.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Gebers v. State Farm General Insurance Co.

California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist., Div. 4 · October 6, 1995 · 38 Cal.App.4th 1648, 45 Cal.Rptr.2d 725 (No. A068089)

A party-selected appraiser must be disinterested, and a policy cannot weaken the statute's word. The insurer's appraiser was then its paid expert witness and did not say so, so the award was voided and a new appraisal required.

Limits: Disclosure analysis relied on arbitration rules before the 2001-02 amendments.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.

U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · January 19, 1995 · 904 F. Supp. 1142; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK

Under Hawaii law a binding appraisal clause is an arbitration agreement. The panel decides the value of the property before the storm and the damage it caused, and may consider code-upgrade costs, but may not decide coverage or liability.

Limits: Federal court applying the Federal Arbitration Act and Hawaii law; not binding on Hawaii state courts.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Equity Mutual Insurance Co. v. Campbell

Missouri Court of Appeals · November 8, 1994 · 886 S.W.2d 221

An appraisal award is conclusive on the amount unless fraudulently procured. Skipping some inspection steps was not fraud. Challenges to an appraiser or umpire should be made when they are named, not after the award.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Meineke v. Twin City Fire Insurance Co.

Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · September 20, 1994 · 181 Ariz. 576, 892 P.2d 1365

Arizona treats appraisal like arbitration. The insurer waived appraisal by filing an answer without demanding it and by delaying its demand, so the refusal to compel appraisal was affirmed. Where a policy gives no time to demand appraisal, the demand must come within a reasonable time, and waiver is not favored.

Limits: Two-to-one decision with a dissent. Review denied April 25, 1995. The policy was a homeowners-type policy that asked for a "competent" appraiser, with a one-year suit limit. It applies arbitration law to appraisal but does not itself decide impartiality or umpire questions.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

London v. Trinity Companies

Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals, Division 3 · April 12, 1994 · 1994 OK CIV APP 59, 877 P.2d 620 (No. 80077)

The insured demanded appraisal, the insurer paid the award, and the insured cashed the checks. The award bound the insured who invoked it because there was no fraud, collusion or other improper action. An insurer asking its appraiser to pay close attention to its own lower estimate was advisory only and not bad faith. Summary judgment for the insurer on the contract and bad-faith claims was affirmed.

Limits: Memorandum opinion of an intermediate court; its weight as precedent depends on how it was released for publication. The bad-faith ruling also rested on undocumented living-expense claims.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hemingway v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.

Appellate Division, Third Department · November 12, 1992 · 187 AD2d 814

Insureds who cashed checks for the exact appraisal award made a full accord and satisfaction of their claim. Their conclusory claims that the umpire was partial did not overcome the presumption that the appraisal was valid.

Limits: Homeowners fire claim decided on summary judgment.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Emmons v. Lake States Insurance Co.

Michigan Court of Appeals · April 6, 1992 · 193 Mich App 460; 484 NW2d 712 (Docket No. 125869)

The court refused to set aside an award or remove a court-appointed umpire who had worked for insurers for thirty years. The person attacking an umpire or appraiser must prove partiality. Review is limited to bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake.

Limits: Decided under former 500.2832, which required disinterested persons.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Grabbert

Rhode Island Supreme Court · April 23, 1991 · 590 A.2d 88

A party-appointed arbitrator on a 10 percent contingent fee had an improper financial interest, but the award stood because there was no proof the fee caused the result. Evident partiality needs an improper interest plus a causal link.

Limits: Uninsured-motorist arbitration, not property appraisal. Applied to property appraisal in Vermont Mutual (2025).

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Central Life Insurance Co. v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.

Iowa Supreme Court · February 20, 1991 · 466 N.W.2d 257 (No. 89-1611)

Awards are presumed valid and stand unless fraud, mistake or misfeasance is shown. An appraiser paid a percentage of the settled loss is interested as a matter of law, so the award was voided with no showing of harm. Waiver needs knowledge of the facts, and advocacy alone does not disqualify an appraiser. A judge had no power to name an umpire on an informal request with no case filed. The insurer’s challenge to the award was fairly debatable, so the insured’s bad-faith verdict was set aside.

Limits: Commercial fire policy. The umpire-appointment point predates chapter 522F.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Rawlings v. Amco Insurance Co.

Nebraska Supreme Court · April 21, 1989 · 231 Neb. 874, 438 N.W.2d 769 (No. 87-966)

A homeowners policy clause that lets either side demand appraisal of the amount of loss is void, because a promise made before any dispute to give up the courts is against public policy. An insured's refusal to appraise did not entitle the insurer to summary judgment. The Department's approval of the policy form did not change that.

Limits: Decides the pre-dispute policy clause only. It does not say what happens when both sides agree to appraisal after a dispute arises. The opinion's umpire, cost and qualification terms are quoted policy language, not rules.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Binkewitz v. Allstate Insurance Co.

New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · February 4, 1988 · 222 N.J. Super. 501, 537 A.2d 723

A homeowner fire policy's appraisal clause comes from N.J.S.A. 17:36-5.20. Statements made about a nominated appraiser during the appraisal are protected only by a qualified privilege, because appraisal has no presiding officer, oaths or formal evidence.

Limits: A defamation case. The court assumed the public adjuster named as appraiser was competent and disinterested and did not decide whether he was.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Bainter v. United Pacific Ins. Co.

Washington Court of Appeals, Division III · January 7, 1988 · 50 Wn. App. 242, 748 P.2d 260

An appraisal award is conclusive as to the amount of loss, but evidence of bias, prejudice or lack of disinterestedness can raise a fact question for a jury. The insureds alleged bias but produced no evidence, so the trial court properly confirmed the award, including the living-expense award. The court had appointed the umpire when the appraisers could not agree.

Limits: Homeowner policy that called for a competent, independent appraiser and impartial umpire; the cost-split clause is quoted, not decided.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Southeast Nursing Home, Inc. v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · January 24, 1985 · 750 F.2d 1531; No. 83-7131

Applying Alabama law, a policy that named only an impartial umpire did not require the party appraisers to be impartial, so the insurer's choice of an allegedly partial appraiser did not waive appraisal. Appraisals are governed by the policy, not Alabama's arbitration statute. The insurer had a lawful basis to insist on appraisal, so the bad-faith claim failed.

Limits: Federal court applying Alabama law (Erie guess), 1985, before later Alabama bad-faith decisions.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Erickson v. Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of North Dakota · October 28, 1981 · 311 N.W.2d 579

An umpire appointed by a district court fixed the amount of a windstorm loss under a standard-form clause. The insurer, by going through appraisal, conceded the cause, and had to pay the award.

Limits: The court noted the clause provided for appraisal, not arbitration, but decided on summary judgment based on the insurer's admissions. It did not decide whether a panel may decide cause on its own.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Figi v. New Hampshire Insurance Co.

California Court of Appeal · July 30, 1980 · 108 Cal.App.3d 772, 166 Cal.Rptr. 774

An umpire who did business with the insurer's appraiser while the appraisal was pending was interested as a matter of law. Appraisers are held to a higher impartiality standard than arbitrators generally, and the confirming judgment was reversed.

Limits: Does not address fees paid to an appraiser. Past business with the insurer does not automatically disqualify an appraiser.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Silverman v. Fireman's Fund American Insurance

Nevada Supreme Court · January 3, 1980 · 96 Nev. 30, 604 P.2d 805

An insurance appraisal fell under the state arbitration act, which then expressly named appraisals. The insured sued about five months after the award without moving to vacate within 90 days, so the suit was barred.

Limits: Decided under the 1969 act, which is no longer in force. The current act does not mention appraisals.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Mitchell v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.

U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit · September 1, 1978 · 579 F.2d 342, No. 76-2980

Mississippi awards are hard to attack and only limited reasons justify a court stepping in. An award is not voided for missing itemization without prejudice. No prejudgment interest where the refusal to pay more was not frivolous or in bad faith.

Limits: Federal court predicting Mississippi law; not binding on Mississippi courts.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Elberon Bathing Co. v. Ambassador Insurance Co.

New Jersey Supreme Court · June 8, 1978 · 77 N.J. 1, 389 A.2d 439

An appraisal award that used replacement cost without subtracting depreciation did not measure actual cash value and was vacated for legal misconduct. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss, not liability, and the Arbitration Act does not apply. Review of an award is narrow, but appraisers cannot make legal determinations.

Limits: A fire policy case. The court quotes the standard form clause from N.J.S.A. 17:36-5.20 but the quotation ends before the costs sentence. It does not address causation.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.

Indiana Court of Appeals · April 17, 1974 · 160 Ind. App. 33, 309 N.E.2d 810

A person who submits to appraisal under a fire policy is bound by the award on the amount of loss unless it is tainted by fraud, collusion, partiality or manifest injustice. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss, not liability. An umpire who joins one appraiser to sign the award is an extra appraiser, and a separate valuation by the umpire is allowed.

Limits: Fire policy. Decided before Indiana's current arbitration act; the court said appraisal is not arbitration.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Keesling v. Western Fire Ins. Co. of Fort Scott, Kansas

Washington Court of Appeals · April 1, 1974 · 10 Wn. App. 841, 520 P.2d 622

An appraisal clause in a fire policy is valid and does not take jurisdiction from the courts. It sets the dollar value of damage but does not enforce itself; the insured must sue and have the award confirmed. Timeliness of a demand depends on the circumstances: the insurer's demand eight months after proof of loss and after suit began was timely, because the parties had been negotiating and the insured showed no prejudice. The suit should have been stayed, not dismissed, pending appraisal.

Limits: Fire policy, 1974 facts.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Schipper & Block, Inc. v. Carson Pirie Scott & Co.

Illinois Appellate Court, Third District · March 20, 1970 · 122 Ill. App. 2d 34

Under a lease requiring disinterested appraisers, an appraiser who had already valued the property for tax purposes was not disinterested. Disinterested means free of bias and prejudice, not only without a money interest.

Limits: Commercial lease appraisal, not insurance. One justice dissented.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hendricks v. American Fire & Casualty Co.

South Carolina Supreme Court · May 2, 1966 · 247 S.C. 479, 148 S.E.2d 162

An award made by the umpire and one appraiser stood. A mere mistake of judgment does not undo it, notice of the appraisers' meeting was not required on these facts, and the insured could not show a defect the pleadings had not raised.

Limits: Collision policy on a tractor; the insurer admitted the loss was covered.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Case v. Hanover Fire Insurance Co.

Tennessee Court of Appeals · May 29, 1962 · 50 Tenn. App. 72, 359 S.W.2d 831

Without a timely objection, insurers are presumed to have named a competent and disinterested appraiser. The insured's suits were dismissed as premature because she did not take part in the appraisal.

Limits: Old fire policy. Did not define "disinterested" and did not involve fees.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 2, 1953 · 330 Mass. 283

Referees must fix the loss under the policy, not all damage whether covered or not. They properly limited the award to lightning damage and left out wind damage. Their views on coverage are tentative and do not decide liability.

Limits: No one disputed how the policy words applied. An award can still be attacked for error in reading the policy. The insured dropped a bias claim.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America

Supreme Court of Ohio · April 22, 1953 · 159 Ohio St. 237, 112 N.E.2d 1 (No. 33217)

The fire policy's appraisal clause binds the insurer as well as the insured. When the insurer refused to name an appraiser, that counted as a failure to agree, and the court could appoint the umpire. The insured could have the amount of loss appraised even though the insurer denied liability.

Limits: Decided under the fire policy wording quoted in the opinion, which sets 20 days for appraisers and 15 days for the umpire. The point about denial of liability comes from a treatise passage the court quoted, and a 2025 appeals court read it as about mutuality only.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Schreiber v. Pacific Coast Fire Insurance Co.

Court of Appeals of Maryland · July 18, 1950 · 195 Md. 639, 75 A.2d 108

Other work for insurance companies does not disqualify an appraiser as a matter of law. Concealment or misrepresentation may be weighed. The award is binding, and courts do not review honest mistakes of fact or law, only plain and palpable ones.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Lawler v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.

Maine Supreme Judicial Court · August 28, 1947 · 143 Me. 40, 54 A.2d 685

Referees under the statutory fire policy must be disinterested, meaning impartial and open minded, not just free of money ties. Because the insured is forced into the process, courts must look closely. Evidence of bias let the jury set aside the referees' low figure.

Limits: Decided under the earlier "three disinterested men" referee wording.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Orr v. Farmers Mutual Hail Insurance Co. of Missouri

Supreme Court of Missouri · April 21, 1947 · 356 Mo. 372, 201 S.W.2d 952

People chosen to decide a loss by arbitration or appraisal must not be interested, biased or prejudiced. An award made with the insurer's adjuster as its arbitrator was void.

Limits: Crop hail policy with an arbitration clause, not a property policy.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Upington v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York

Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · September 29, 1944 · 298 Ky. 210, 182 S.W.2d 648

Appraisers who had often worked for insurers were not disqualified. An award binds the parties like a judgment unless fraud, mistake or going beyond the panel's authority is shown by clear and convincing evidence. The panel may set the amount of loss but not decide what property the policy covers.

Limits: Fire policies with a separate arbitration agreement; four consolidated appeals.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Branch v. Springfield Fire & Marine Ins. Co.

Louisiana Supreme Court · November 3, 1941 · 198 La. 720, 4 So. 2d 806 (No. 34232)

The court upheld appraisal clauses but read them strictly. An award binds the insured only if the appraisers did the duties the policy required. Where the policy required them to set sound value and they did not, the award was void and the court decided the loss itself.

Limits: Windstorm policy on an older form. The court did not reach the argument that the insurer appraiser was not disinterested.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Smith v. Home Insurance Co.

South Carolina Supreme Court · January 3, 1936 · 178 S.C. 436, 183 S.E. 166

An award was set aside as tainted when the insurer's adjuster took part in the appraisers' talks while the insured was led away. The insured did not have to return a payment made to his lender before suing, and punitive damages went to the jury.

Limits: Truck fire policy. The court said payment made directly to the insured would ordinarily have to be returned or tendered.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

L.D. Jennings Co. v. North River Insurance Co.

South Carolina Supreme Court · April 18, 1935 · 175 S.C. 407, 179 S.E. 621

An appraiser who helped prepare the insured's proof of loss is not disqualified as a matter of law. Partiality was a question for the jury, and without evidence of it the award stood.

Limits: The court said it does not approve of naming someone who has already given an opinion on the damage. One justice dissented.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Young v. New York Underwriters Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of North Carolina · October 10, 1934 · 207 N.C. 188

An award made under the policy is presumed valid unless there is fraud, mistake, duress or another impeaching circumstance. An interested appraiser is one who is biased or has some money interest in the result. Past work as an appraiser for insurance companies, which the insured knew of and accepted, was not enough.

Limits: A fire policy case. It did not involve a contingent fee.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Glens Falls Insurance Co. of New York v. Garner

Supreme Court of Alabama · June 7, 1934 · 229 Ala. 39, 155 So. 533

An award is final unless the appraisers were guilty of fraud, partiality or corruption. The insured's appraiser, a lawyer, was competent and not shown to be partial, and the umpire was competent and disinterested.

Limits: Old fire-policy case, called arbitration in the opinion.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

L.D. Jennings Co. v. North River Insurance Co.

South Carolina Supreme Court · February 7, 1934 · 171 S.C. 548, 172 S.E. 700

An allegation that the insured's appraiser took the insured's figures without checking them and, with the umpire, fixed the award without submitting any differences stated a defense of partiality and bias.

Limits: Decided on a demurrer; it did not find the facts true.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hill v. Star Insurance Co. of America

Supreme Court of North Carolina · March 25, 1931 · 200 N.C. 502, 157 S.E. 599

Disinterested means no money interest in the result and no bias or prejudice. Evidence that the insurer's appraiser was regularly hired by the insurers' adjustment bureau, unknown to the insured, and that the award was signed on a false assurance and was grossly low, was enough for a jury to set the award aside for fraud.

Limits: A fire insurance case from 1931. It did not involve a contingent fee.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Equitable Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Stieffens

Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · June 12, 1930 · 154 Va. 281, 153 S.E. 731

A proper award bars suit on the original claim and is set aside only for errors on its face, misconduct, palpable mistake or fraud, proved by the challenger. An appraiser who had often worked for the insurer's adjusting bureau, paid by the day, was not disqualified.

Limits: Applied statutes since repealed and replaced; fire policy.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Cleveland v. Home Insurance Co. of New York

South Carolina Supreme Court · May 1, 1929 · 150 S.C. 289, 148 S.E. 49

An award that did not follow the submission was invalid. Notice of the appraisers' meeting is not usually needed, but may be when evidence is needed. A mistake of judgment does not undo an award absent fraud or partiality.

Limits: Fire policy with a valued-policy statute; the notice and mistake points are partly in passing.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hurst v. Hope

Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia · March 21, 1929 · 152 Va. 405, 147 S.E. 222

An appraiser retained for a single engagement is not in the employment of the party; only regular, continuous employment disqualifies. Appraisers should act independently on their own judgment.

Limits: Analyzed a since-repealed statute; fee dispute between an appraiser and the insured. Mentions percentage fees without ruling on them.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Marshall v. American Alliance Insurance Co.

Kansas Supreme Court · February 9, 1929 · 127 Kan. 564, 274 P. 243

An appraisal award on a fire policy is presumed valid and is set aside only if made without authority or through fraud, mistake or misconduct. Evidence of an appraiser's or umpire's interest and unfair methods was properly used to attack the award.

Limits: Fire policy, pre-1997 and pre-2018. The opinion does not set a separate test for disinterest.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Melton Bros. v. Philadelphia Fire & Marine Insurance Co.

New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals · February 4, 1929 · 104 N.J. Eq. 153, 144 A. 726

The court reversed a decree voiding an appraisal award. An attacking party must prove invalidity by clear proof, substantial compliance with the appraisal procedure is enough, and an appraiser is not disqualified just for being zealous for the side that named him.

Limits: Decided under an appraisal agreement and an older fire policy form.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Lee v. Providence Washington Insurance Co.

Montana Supreme Court · April 20, 1928 · 82 Mont. 264, 266 P. 640

An appraisal award on a fire loss is presumed valid and is not set aside for every error. The court affirmed setting one aside where the umpire and one appraiser took an extra 10% deduction that had no basis in fact or law.

Limits: Fire policy. The court found the appraisers acted in good faith and did not analyze their impartiality.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Schwartzman v. London & Lancashire Fire Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of Missouri · February 4, 1928 · 318 Mo. 1089, 2 S.W.2d 593

An appraisal was void where the court-picked umpire had an indirect interest in the result. Anyone directly or indirectly interested in the outcome is disqualified.

Limits: Fire policy asking for disinterested and impartial appraisers; the property and umpire appointment were in Minnesota.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

McLaughlin v. Orient Ins. Co.

Washington Supreme Court · March 18, 1926 · 138 Wash. 82, 244 P. 254

Where there was evidence that the umpire and the insurer's appraiser reached a low award arbitrarily and with a perfunctory review, the jury could disregard the award and set the loss itself. The court affirmed a jury verdict nearly double the award.

Limits: Fire policy on lodging-house furnishings.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Reineke v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York

Supreme Court of North Dakota · December 31, 1924 · 52 N.D. 324, 202 N.W. 657

An insured who named an appraiser after a real disagreement over the amount of loss complied with the policy, even though proof of loss came later. The insurer's claim at trial that the appraiser was biased came too late.

Limits: 1924 policy wording. Does not say what makes an appraiser disqualified.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Di Re v. Fire Ass'n of Philadelphia

Minnesota Supreme Court · July 13, 1923 · 156 Minn. 281, 194 N.W. 755

An appraisal award carries every presumption of validity, and fraud or bias must be pleaded with specific facts, but specific claims that the umpire was biased and chosen by fraud were enough to go forward.

Limits: Applied the 1913 form of the standard policy.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Oakes v. Franklin Fire Insurance Co.

Maine Supreme Judicial Court · March 16, 1923 · 122 Me. 361, 120 A. 53

The standard policy's referee process is more than a quick look and guess. To get a conclusive award, the parties need notice and a full chance to be heard by disinterested, impartial referees.

Limits: Earlier referee wording; not a modern appraisal-clause case.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Bradbury v. Insurance Company of Pennsylvania

Maine Supreme Judicial Court · June 5, 1919 · 118 Me. 191

An insurer that carelessly offered referee nominees who were not disinterested was at fault, so the insured could sue without starting a new appraisal. Bias or partisanship of referees can be inferred from their conduct and award.

Limits: Decided on a pleading challenge under the earlier referee wording.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Goldstein v. National Fire Ins. Co. of Hartford

Washington Supreme Court · April 3, 1919 · 106 Wash. 346, 180 P. 409

Appraisal provisions in fire policies are valid and enforceable, and refusing a demand can bar recovery. Settlement talks and advisory estimates did not waive appraisal unless the insured was misled to its injury. The case quotes the standard form: competent and disinterested appraisers and umpire, each side pays its own appraiser, umpire and expenses shared equally.

Limits: 1919 policy on the New York standard form.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

R. E. Jones & Co. v. Northern Assurance Co.

Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · January 14, 1919 · 182 Ky. 701, 207 S.W. 459

An insured could not set aside an award because the insurers' appraiser had worked for insurance companies before and argued hard for them. The rule requiring disinterested and impartial appraisers does not reach an appraiser who is only zealous for the side that chose him.

Limits: Fire policy and separate arbitration agreement.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Insurance Co. of North America v. Kempner

Arkansas Supreme Court · January 14, 1918 · 132 Ark. 215, 200 S.W. 986

A policy clause binding the parties to appraisal is void by statute. An agreed appraisal is then an ordinary submission that either side may revoke in writing before the award, whatever the reason.

Limits: Decided under the statute's predecessor. The insured had objected that the insurer's appraiser was not disinterested.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Providence-Washington Insurance Co. v. Kennington

Mississippi Supreme Court · March 15, 1916 · 111 Miss. 244, 71 So. 378

The two appraisers could not agree on an umpire and gave up. The policy had no fallback for a second try, so the insured, who had named a competent and disinterested appraiser in good faith, could sue on the policy.

Limits: Automobile fire policy; old case; modern policies let a judge pick the umpire.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Second Society of Universalists in Boston v. Royal Insurance Co.

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 28, 1915 · 221 Mass. 518

General claims of fraud, bias or prejudice without specific facts do not justify a court inquiry into an award. A low award honestly made is not a ground to set it aside. An award so grossly and palpably low that it shows fraud or bias can be.

Limits: Old case. No later decision revisiting it was found.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Kirkham v. German American Insurance Co.

Kansas Supreme Court · July 7, 1914 · 92 Kan. 941

An award may be set aside where appraisers refused to consider part of the loss, aimed to keep the award low, and confined the umpire; each party is entitled to each arbitrator's independent judgment.

Limits: Fire policy, 1914.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Harowitz v. Concordia Fire Insurance Co.

Tennessee Supreme Court · April 15, 1914 · 129 Tenn. 691, 168 S.W. 163

Following Hickerson, an insurer that in effect denied all liability and made no specific objection to the proof of loss had no right to demand appraisal; appraisers must be impartial.

Limits: Fire policy case.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Aetna Insurance Co. v. Jester

Oklahoma Supreme Court · January 21, 1913 · 37 Okla. 413, 132 P. 130 (1913 OK 45)

Appraisers must hear the parties' evidence, and an award from a fair appraisal binds the parties. An insurer that defended the first award waived its right to a second appraisal. The court noted that appraisers must act impartially but did not decide the claim that the company's appraiser was biased.

Limits: Decided on a pre-statute policy form.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Ross v. German Alliance Insurance Co.

Kansas Supreme Court · December 9, 1911 · 86 Kan. 145, 119 P. 366

The court upheld a trial court's finding that an award was unfair and fixed the loss itself. An insurer appraiser's long record of insurer work was not itself a disqualification but could be weighed with his conduct, and the court said appraisers value the fire loss and do not decide the insurer's liability.

Limits: One justice dissented. The trial court's factual findings carried the result. Fire policy with competent and disinterested wording.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Mason v. Fire Association of Philadelphia

Supreme Court of South Dakota · June 26, 1909 · 23 S.D. 431, 122 N.W. 423

Appraisers and the umpire must act with judicial impartiality and give each side notice and a chance to present evidence. The court upheld vacating an award made by a biased appraiser who refused to hear the insured and did not state sound value.

Limits: Fire policy era; predates SDCL 21-25A-3 and the approved nonbinding clause. No mention of fee arrangements.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Royal Insurance Co. v. Ries

Supreme Court of Ohio · April 27, 1909 · 80 Ohio St. 272 (No. 11173)

The standard fire policy clause is an appraisal of the amount of loss, not an arbitration. Appraisers need not hear evidence. The award stands unless the challenger proves misconduct or interest; suspicion that the insurer's appraiser was partisan was not enough.

Limits: Fire policy wording of that era. An award shown to be void, or set aside, does not bind.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Carlston v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.

Montana Supreme Court · March 28, 1908 · 37 Mont. 118, 94 P. 756

Appraisers who must value a totally destroyed building have to give the owner notice and a fair chance to present her claim, or the award does not bind her. Appraisers are not agents of the party who chose them.

Limits: Total loss of a dwelling under a fire policy.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Young v. Aetna Insurance Co.

Maine Supreme Judicial Court · March 22, 1906 · 101 Me. 294, 64 A. 584

Referees on a fire loss must be disinterested in the broad sense: no relationship or money interest, and no bias or partisanship. An insurer's referee who acted as the company's representative made the award unenforceable against the insured.

Limits: Decided under the earlier "three disinterested men" referee wording.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

National Fire Ins. Co. v. O'Bryan

Arkansas Supreme Court · April 29, 1905 · 75 Ark. 198, 87 S.W. 129

Whether a fire-policy appraiser is competent and disinterested is for the jury. An appraiser who earlier estimated the loss for the insured was not disqualified by that alone.

Limits: Fire-policy clause from the era of binding appraisals.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Van Winkle v. Insurance Co. (Continental Fire Ins. Co.)

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · March 15, 1904 · 55 W. Va. 286, 47 S.E. 82

The court refused to set aside a fire-loss appraisal award. An appraiser's earlier work as an appraiser did not disqualify him without proof of prejudice, the insured never offered the evidence he said was refused, and a mistake of judgment is not enough to void an award.

Limits: Suit in equity under a fire policy appraisal clause and a written submission. Decided in 1904.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Continental Insurance Co. v. Vallandingham & Gentry

Court of Appeals of Kentucky (then Kentucky's highest court) · September 25, 1903 · 116 Ky. 287, 76 S.W. 22

An insurer relying on appraisal must in good faith name a competent, disinterested appraiser. An appraiser who acted more like the insurer's employee than a neutral person did not qualify, but serving insurers before did not itself show bias. An insurer that misuses the clause waives it, and failure to appraise is no defense unless the insurer asks for appraisal before suit.

Limits: Fire policy; decided before modern court-appointment statutes.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Connecticut Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford v. Cohen

Court of Appeals of Maryland · June 29, 1903 · 97 Md. 294, 55 A. 675

A party-named appraiser is not the party's agent and must act independently on his own judgment. If appraisal fails to produce an umpire without the insured's fault, the insured may still sue on the policy.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Insurance Co. of North America v. Hegewald

Supreme Court of Indiana · April 3, 1903 · 161 Ind. 631, 66 N.E. 902

A fire-loss appraisal award was set aside. The insurer picked an appraiser who was its own employee and acted on its directions, and the umpire was biased too. "Disinterested" means more than having no money at stake: the appraiser must be fair and unprejudiced.

Limits: Fire policy that required "competent and disinterested" appraisers. The court did not say how that applies to every modern policy wording.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Christianson v. Norwich Union Fire Ins. Soc'y

Minnesota Supreme Court · December 6, 1901 · 84 Minn. 526, 88 N.W. 16

An award was properly set aside where a referee openly acted as the insurer's representative and referees gathered evidence privately. Referees must be disinterested and act impartially.

Limits: Decided under an early form of the standard policy. It did not involve a fee arrangement.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Stemmer v. Scottish Union & National Insurance Co.

Oregon Supreme Court · June 23, 1898 · 33 Or 65, 52 P 498

Each side must pick an impartial appraiser, but a party's appraiser may be friendly to that party. Prior work for insurers did not disqualify him, and failing to object when the ground is known waives it. Absent fraud or misconduct, the award is final.

Limits: The parties submitted the loss under the policies by written agreement, before the current statute.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Kiernan v Dutchess County Mut. Ins. Co.

New York Court of Appeals · October 6, 1896 · 150 NY 190

An award was set aside where the insurer's appraiser, presented as an impartial business man, was a career insurance adjuster biased toward insurers who dominated the other appraiser. Under the non-waiver clause, acts relating only to the appraisal were set aside in deciding waiver.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Hickerson & Co. v. Insurance Companies

Tennessee Supreme Court · February 13, 1896 · 96 Tenn. 193, 33 S.W. 1041

Appraisers act in a quasi-judicial role and must be impartial. An insurer cannot demand appraisal while denying all liability, and its appraiser's unreasonable demands over the umpire excused the insured from appraisal.

Limits: Fire policy case. Its view that an appraisal demand waives the insurer's liability defenses predates modern policy wording.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Glover v. Rochester-German Ins. Co.

Washington Supreme Court · February 12, 1895 · 11 Wash. 143, 39 P. 380

Appraisers required to be competent and disinterested must be indifferent between the parties and impartial judges. The court upheld setting aside an award where the insurer's appraiser was found biased and dominated the umpire, and held the insured had not waived the objection by failing to raise it during the appraisal.

Limits: Fire policy on merchandise, 1893 loss.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Home Fire Insurance Co. v. Bean

Nebraska Supreme Court · November 8, 1894 · 42 Neb. 537, 60 N.W. 907

An insurer could not defeat the insured's suit by pleading that no appraisal had taken place, because such a provision is void under an earlier Nebraska decision. The insurer's demand for arbitration also waived the insured's proofs of loss.

Limits: The insurer said it had replaced its first appraiser as not disinterested, but the court did not rule on that. Pre-Rawlings fire-policy case.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Niagara Fire Insurance Co. v. Bishop

Illinois Supreme Court · October 29, 1894 · 154 Ill. 9

A party's appraiser is not its agent just because that party picked him, but one who acts so plainly for that party that he is its agent makes that party answerable. The insurer's appraiser unreasonably held out for a distant umpire the other appraiser did not know, so the insured could sue without an award.

Limits: Fire policy of 1891 with a competent and disinterested appraiser clause; decided on the facts found by the trial judge.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

German Insurance Co. v. Eddy

Nebraska Supreme Court · March 29, 1893 · 36 Neb. 461, 54 N.W. 856 (Nos. 5014-5016)

When insured real property is totally destroyed, the valued policy act fixes the loss at the policy amount and the policy's appraisal clause yields to it, so there is nothing to appraise except perhaps the debris.

Limits: The insured also alleged the insurer's appraiser was its employee and prejudiced, but the court did not rule on that. The valued policy law is now Neb. Rev. Stat. § 44-501.02.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Bradshaw v Agricultural Ins. Co. of Watertown

New York Court of Appeals · January 31, 1893 · 137 NY 137

Disinterested means not biased or prejudiced, not only free of a money stake. A party appraiser may bring out facts helpful to his side but is not its agent and must stay fair. An award was set aside where the insurer falsely called its appraiser impartial and he was biased.

Limits: The award fell because of the false statement about the appraiser together with his bias and a grossly low award.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Chandos v. American Fire Insurance Co.

Wisconsin Supreme Court · January 31, 1893 · 84 Wis. 184, 54 N.W. 390

The court enforced an appraisal award. A claim that the insurer's appraisers were not impartial failed for lack of any evidence. Failing to pick the umpire before starting did not void the award. The appraisers' view of which items fell within the policy's general property description was final, and the insured could not complain about items she never put before them.

Limits: Fire policy era case with a clause requiring competent and impartial appraisers and a sworn award.

Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026

Other subjects