At a glance
Vermont has no standard fire policy statute and no statutory appraisal clause; appraisal and its day counts come from the policy. Two Vermont rules limit what that clause can do. 8 V.S.A. § 3663 voids any policy condition "making an award by appraisers" a condition precedent to suing on the policy. And the Department of Financial Regulation’s form-filing requirements say appraisal "may not be both binding and mandatory"; binding appraisal is approvable only when both parties agree to it. Fire losses are payable 60 days after the insurer receives satisfactory proofs (§ 3868). The Fair Claims Practices regulation sets business-day clocks: 10 to acknowledge, 15 to accept or deny after proofs of loss, and 10 to pay after a settlement is agreed.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No rule names appraisal-clause appraisers or umpires
No state rule found
Vermont licenses adjusters, public adjusters and "appraisers". The licensed "appraiser" is defined as a person who, for pay, appraises loss under automobile policies for insurers. A "public adjuster" is defined as a person who investigates claims or negotiates settlement of claims for the insured, or who advertises or solicits business as such an adjuster. Neither definition mentions an appraiser or umpire serving under a property policy appraisal clause, and no court or Department ruling applies them to one.
“Appraiser” means any person who, for compensation, appraises the loss or damage under policies of automobile insurance on the behalf of the insurers under such policies.
The "appraiser" license in the statute is for automobile loss appraisal for insurers. The public adjuster definition is worded around negotiating or investigating claims for the insured.
Contingency fees
No Vermont rule on contingent-fee appraisers
No state rule found
No Vermont statute, regulation or court decision says a contingent-fee appraiser is disqualified or allowed. The licensing law only requires licensed adjusters and appraisers to keep a record of any fee or other pay they receive, and sets no cap or ban.
A statement of any fee, commission, or other compensation received or to be received by the adjuster, workers’ compensation adjuster, public adjuster, or appraiser on account of such investigation, adjustment, or appraisal.
Impartiality
Policy wording controls; no statute for loss appraisal
No state rule found
No Vermont statute or regulation requires the party appraisers in a loss appraisal to be impartial or disinterested, and no Vermont court has decided what disqualifies one. The only place the statutes say "disinterested" is the separate pre-loss valuation of a building, which is not appraisal of a loss. Check the policy wording.
The owner of a building and the insurance company or agent shall each file with the Commissioner a list of not less than three disinterested persons competent to act as appraisers of the building described in the notice.
Section 3964 covers only the Commissioner-run pre-loss valuation of a building, not policy appraisal after a loss.
Umpire selection
Policy wording controls; no statutory umpire process
No state rule found
Vermont has no statute that says how an umpire is chosen after a loss or that a court may appoint one. The word "umpire" does not appear in the insurance chapters read. The appraisal clause in the policy decides. The statute does have a third appraiser picked by the Commissioner, but only for the pre-loss valuation of a building.
in case these two cannot agree, he or she shall select a third competent and disinterested person who shall act as third appraiser only as to matters regarding which the two appraisers first appointed cannot agree.
Section 3964 is the pre-loss valuation, not policy appraisal.
Causation
No Vermont statute or decision on panel deciding causation
No state rule found
No Vermont statute, regulation or court decision says whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. The policy wording controls.
Coverage
No Vermont decision on whether appraisers may decide coverage
No state rule found
No Vermont court has said whether an appraisal panel may decide coverage or only the amount of loss. The Department of Financial Regulation’s form guidance for homeowner policies says a decision agreed by two appraisers will set the amount of loss or coverage, but that is the Department’s comment on policy forms, not a rule on what a panel may decide.
A decision agreed upon by any two appraisers will set the amount of loss or coverage.
The DFR note is guidance for homeowner form filings. It says it is not a comprehensive list of requirements.
The award
Award can't be made a condition to suing on the policy
A Vermont fire or other listed policy may not make an appraisers’ award a condition to suing on the policy, and any such clause is void. The Department of Financial Regulation also tells insurers a homeowner policy’s appraisal may not be both binding and mandatory, and binding appraisal is approvable only if both sides agree to it. The Vermont arbitration act does not apply to arbitration agreements in insurance contracts. No Vermont court decision on grounds for vacating an appraisal award was found.
nor a condition or clause making an award by appraisers, fixing the amount of loss by the insured or beneficiary in such policy or contract, a condition precedent to bringing or maintaining an action on such policy or contract. Any such conditions or clauses shall be null and void.
Section 3663 names fire, life, accident, liability and burglary policies. The DFR guidance is for homeowner and dwelling form filings, not a regulation with force of law on its own.
Who pays
Policy wording controls; no statute on loss appraisal costs
No state rule found
No Vermont statute or regulation divides the fees of appraisers and the umpire in a post-loss appraisal. The policy wording decides. The only statute on who pays appraisers is for the pre-loss valuation of a building, where each side pays its own appraiser and the third is paid equally.
Each of the two appraisers first appointed shall be paid by the party nominating him or her and the third appraiser shall be paid by the parties equally.
Section 3965 covers only the Commissioner-run pre-loss valuation, not policy appraisal.
Demand and waiver
Insurer's denial of liability can waive it; jury decides (1903)
No Vermont statute sets a deadline to demand appraisal. In 1903 the Vermont Supreme Court affirmed a verdict for an insured who never sought the policy's arbitration of the loss amount. The parties agreed that denial of liability can sometimes waive that clause, and the court held the trial judge properly let the jury decide whether it had. Today 8 V.S.A. 3663 voids any clause making an appraisal award a condition to suing, so waiver matters less. No later Vermont decision on waiving appraisal was found.
It is admitted that in some circumstances denial of liability will amount to a waiver of the arbitration clause.
The 1903 case concerned a fire policy on Massachusetts property and an arbitration clause for the amount of loss. The court did not rule that waiver happened, only that the jury could decide.
Stoddard v. Cambridge Mutual Fire Insurance Co., 75 Vt. 253 (1903); 8 V.S.A. § 3663.
Court decisions: Stoddard v. Cambridge Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
After the award is paid
No rule on paying an award; first-party bad faith is allowed
No state rule found
No Vermont statute or decision says whether paying an appraisal award ends interest, bad-faith or fee claims. Vermont does allow a first-party bad-faith claim against an insurer that denies or delays a claim without a reasonable basis. In an auto arbitration case, the insurer paid the award within a month and the bad-faith claim was still decided on its merits, and lost because the claim was fairly debatable.
We now hold that such an action lies in Vermont, within the parameters noted in Booska.
Bushey is an underinsured-motorist arbitration case, not property appraisal. It is cited only for first-party bad faith generally.
Court decisions: Bushey v. Allstate Insurance Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No statute prescribes an appraisal clause. Chapter 105 (Fire and Casualty Insurance) has no standard-policy form, and the appraisers it provides for are in the pre-loss valuation in §§ 3961-3968. That subchapter is a different process: an agreed pre-loss valuation of a building for coinsurance, using appraisers and a "third appraiser" named by the Commissioner. It is not post-loss appraisal.
Fire and other listed policies may not contain a clause limiting suit to "a period less than 12 months from the occurrence of the loss", or a clause "making an award by appraisers, fixing the amount of loss by the insured or beneficiary in such policy or contract, a condition precedent to bringing or maintaining an action on such policy or contract". Any such clause is "null and void". Added 1967; no later amendment shown.
The DFR homeowner’s filing guidance (revised February 29, 2024, listed as a "Department Requirement"): "Appraisal may not be both binding and mandatory." "Binding appraisal is not permitted if the process can be demanded unilaterally, as it may deprive the insured access to the judiciary system. Binding appraisal is approvable only if both parties agree to the appraisal process." The right to sue "may not be conditioned upon the insured's compliance with the provisions of the Appraisal Condition," and it also says mandatory binding arbitration is not permitted if either side can demand it unilaterally. The document says it is not a comprehensive list of requirements.
DFR Homeowner’s and Dwelling Property Personal Liability Requirements (rev. 2/29/2024)(PDF)
The common 20-day appraiser and 15-day umpire periods, and "competent and disinterested" or "impartial", are policy terms in Vermont. No statute or regulation sets days to name an appraiser, pick an umpire or issue an award.
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in Vermont. 8 V.S.A. § 3868 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, or issue the award: no day count is fixed by statute or regulation; the policy controls | Set by the policy | Parties and the appraisal panel | No Vermont statute or regulation | |
| Fire loss due and payable, and the insured may sue after this period. | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Insurer’s receipt of satisfactory proofs | Insurer | 8 V.S.A. § 3868 |
| Deliver proof of loss after the insurer’s written notice; the policy is not void for missing proof until then | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | The insured’s receipt of the insurer’s written notice that proof is required | Insured | 8 V.S.A. § 3867 |
| Insurer’s notice of defects in a proof of loss | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the proof of loss | Insurer | 8 V.S.A. § 3867 |
| Correct defects in a proof of loss | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | The insured’s receipt of the insurer’s written notice of defects | Insured | 8 V.S.A. § 3867 |
| Contractual suit limit: a policy may not set it shorter than 12 months from the loss | Occurrence of the loss | Insured | 8 V.S.A. § 3663 | |
| Appraisal award as a precondition to suit: void | Not applicable | Not applicable | 8 V.S.A. § 3663 | |
| Not appraisal: the Commissioner sets a time and place for a pre-loss valuation not later than 15 days after the request | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Insured’s request for a valuation | Commissioner | 8 V.S.A. § 3963 |
Who can serve
No statute or regulation sets qualifications for property appraisers or umpires in policy appraisal. In the separate pre-loss valuation, each side lists at least three "disinterested persons competent to act as appraisers".
In the licensing chapter, "appraiser" means a person who appraises loss under automobile policies for insurers. The chapter as read does not mention property appraisers or umpires in policy appraisal.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Vermont. 8 V.S.A. § 3868 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge receipt of the claim notice. Reg. I-79-2 states its counts in business days and applies to all lines except workers’ compensation, title and surety | 10 business days | Claim notice | Insurer or its agent with claim authority | Reg. I-79-2 § 5.A(PDF) |
| Reply to a claimant’s communication raising questions | 10 business days | The communication | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 5.B(PDF) |
| Respond to a DFR inquiry | 15 business days | The inquiry | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 5.C(PDF) |
| Accept or deny a first-party claim | 15 business days | Receipt of properly executed proofs of loss | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 6.A(PDF) |
| Notice that more time is needed, with reasons. Claims governed by § 3868 (fire) are excluded from this subsection | 15 business days | Receipt of the proofs of loss | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 6.C(PDF) |
| Warning that a time limit may expire, to an unrepresented first-party claimant, 30 business days before expiry | 30 business days | Continuing negotiation | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 6.E(PDF) |
| Mail payment after settlement is agreed, unless a court order or law requires delay. | 10 business days | Agreement on settlement | Insurer, to the claimant and/or loss payee | Reg. I-79-2 § 6.G(PDF) |
| Fire loss due and payable | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Satisfactory proofs | Insurer | 8 V.S.A. § 3868 |
| Matching: no day count; like kind and quality for a "reasonably uniform appearance", at no cost to the insured beyond the deductible | Partial loss where replacements do not match | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 8.A.6(PDF) | |
| Copy of the completed appraisal or estimate, "if requested": no day count. Here "appraisal" means the adjuster’s estimate, not policy appraisal | Claimant’s request | Insurer | Reg. I-79-2 § 8.A.1(PDF) |
Recent and pending changes
The DFR homeowner’s filing requirements were revised February 29, 2024. The appraisal and suit-condition positions above are in that revision.
DFR Homeowner’s and Dwelling Property Personal Liability Requirements (rev. 2/29/2024)(PDF)
Reg. I-79-2 was revised effective July 1, 2018, replacing the 1979 version. That revision includes the matching rule in § 8.A.6.
§ 3663 (1967) and the §§ 3961-3968 valuation sections show no recent amendments.
Sources
- 8 V.S.A. chapter 105, fire and casualty insurance (legislature’s unofficial convenience copy)Official
- 8 V.S.A. § 3663, minimum limitation on actions; void policy provisions (legislature’s unofficial convenience copy)Official
- 8 V.S.A. chapter 131, licensing requirements (§§ 4791, 4800, 4803) (legislature’s unofficial convenience copy)Official
- DFR Regulation I-79-2 (Revised Eff. 7/1/18), Fair Claims PracticesOfficialPDF · no web page version found
- DFR Homeowner’s and Dwelling Property Personal Liability Requirements (revised 2/29/2024)OfficialPDF · no web page version found
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.