At a glance
In the Utah statutes and rule read for this page, no section writes an appraisal clause or fixes appraisal day counts. Appraisal is a policy term; the 20-day appraiser clock appears in the USAA policy form quoted in Miller v. USAA (Utah 2002), not in a statute. Miller held that appraisal is not arbitration, so the Utah Arbitration Act (as it then stood) does not directly apply, and that a clause limited to the "amount of loss" does not reach extra-contractual claims. By statute, the three-year limit to sue on a first-party policy is tolled while an appraisal runs, and suit to compel payment must wait until the earliest of 60 days after proof of loss, the insurer’s waiver of proof of loss, or its denial of full payment, unless a verified complaint alleges prejudice beyond the delay itself. The claims rule (R590-190, re-adopted effective January 24, 2024) counts calendar days: 15 days to acknowledge a notice of loss, 30 days after a complete proof of loss to accept or deny, and 30 days after written proof of a covered loss and its amount to pay (missing it is an unfair claim settlement practice).
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
Umpire exempt by statute; party appraiser not addressed
Utah requires an adjuster license for anyone who adjusts insurance claims, and adjusting means directing or conducting the investigation, negotiation or settlement of a claim for an insurer, policyholder or claimant. The statute settles one point: an umpire selected by the claimant and the insurer is exempt. It also exempts an appraiser who does no adjusting and is specially employed to gather facts or give technical help to a licensed or company adjuster. It does not say whether an appraiser the insured appoints to an appraisal panel is adjusting and needs a public adjuster license. No Utah court decision or Insurance Department ruling on that was found.
an arbitrator or an umpire selected by the claimant and insurer to decide, alone or with others, whether a claim should be paid and how much should be paid
Applies to adjusting under any property policy. HB 58 (2026) rewrote the public adjuster rules but did not change § 31A-26-201.
Utah Code §§ 31A-26-201(1), (2)(b), (2)(g)(iii); § 31A-26-102(6), (9)
Contingency fees
No Utah rule on contingent-fee appraisers
No state rule found
No Utah statute, rule or decision says a contingent-fee appraiser is disqualified or partial. One statute bars an insurer or insured from paying anyone who represents them in a claim adjustment on a basis that depends on the amounts paid. Whether a party appraiser is such a person has not been decided. The same statute set lists a percentage of the claim payment as a permitted public adjuster fee, with 2026 caps of 10 percent on catastrophic claims and 20 percent on others.
an insurer or an insured may not pay a person who is representing the insurer or insured in connection with an insurance claim adjustment on any basis that is dependent, in whole or in part, upon the amounts paid an insured or claimant under an insurance policy
Section 31A-26-310 covers claim adjustment representatives generally, not appraisers by name.
Impartiality
Policy wording only; no Utah rule on disqualification
No state rule found
No Utah statute, rule or appellate decision sets who is disqualified as a party appraiser. The standard that exists comes from the policy. The USAA homeowner form in the Blakely cases asks for a competent, independent appraiser and a competent, impartial umpire. The State Farm form in the Angus case asks for a competent, disinterested appraiser. The Utah Supreme Court has held that the Utah arbitration statute does not directly apply to appraisal, so its evident-partiality rule is not a Utah appraisal rule.
each will select a competent, independent appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser's identity within 20 days of receipt of the written demand
Policy wording quoted from USAA and State Farm homeowner forms; other insurers' forms may differ.
Court decisions: Miller v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Policy wording controls; no Utah statute on picking one
No state rule found
No Utah statute or rule says how an umpire is chosen for a property appraisal. The policy decides. The USAA form in Blakely has the two appraisers pick the umpire, and if they cannot agree within 15 days either side can ask a judge of a court of record where the home is located. Utah's license statute exempts an umpire the parties selected from the adjuster license. No Utah decision on umpire qualifications was found.
you and we can ask a judge of a court of record in the state where the residence premises is located to select an umpire
Policy wording quoted from a USAA homeowner form. Miller (2002) held the old arbitration act does not directly apply to appraisal and did not decide the later Title 78B ch. 11.
Causation
No Utah ruling on whether the panel may decide causation
No state rule found
No Utah statute, rule or decision says whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. The Utah Supreme Court has held that a clause limited to the amount of loss covers the value of the injury or damage, and that the court decides the clause's scope. It did not say whether separating damage from different causes is part of setting that amount.
Court decisions: Miller v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
Coverage
Clause limited to amount of loss; court sets its scope
When a policy says the appraisers set the amount of loss, the Utah Supreme Court reads that as the value of the injury or damage, not other claims between the parties. The court, not the panel, decides the scope of the clause as a question of contract law. The case involved bad faith and other extra-contractual claims, so it does not say where the line falls between a coverage dispute and an amount-of-loss dispute.
None of the extra-contractual claims pertain to the amount of loss under the insurance contract.
Policy clauses limited to the 'amount of loss' (USAA form). A differently worded clause could reach more.
Miller v. USAA Cas. Ins. Co., 2002 UT 6, ¶¶ 51-53, 64, 44 P.3d 663 (Utah 2002)
Court decisions: Miller v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
The award
Binding or just evidence, depending on the policy terms
Utah does not treat appraisal as arbitration. The Utah Supreme Court said an appraisal result is either evidence for the trial court or an award to be enforced, depending on the policy. It also said appraisal clauses are strictly enforceable and a court must compel appraisal when one side demands it. In 1897 the court held that an appraisal which left out property the insurer's appraiser refused to value did not limit what the insured could recover, because the insurer could not profit from its own fault. No other Utah appellate grounds for setting an award aside were found.
The appraisal determination is either evidence to be considered by the trial court or an award to be enforced, depending upon the contract terms.
Policies with the USAA-style clause. Miller applied the 1996 Utah Arbitration Act and did not decide whether the current Title 78B ch. 11 reaches appraisal.
Miller v. USAA Cas. Ins. Co., 2002 UT 6, ¶¶ 35-37, 47, 44 P.3d 663 (Utah 2002)
Court decisions: Miller v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.; Stephens v. Union Assurance Society; Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
Who pays
Policy split applies; only federal courts address recovering costs
Unsettled
No Utah statute, rule or state appellate decision divides appraisal costs, so the policy does. The USAA form in Blakely has each side pay its own appraiser and split the umpire's pay and other appraisal expenses equally. The only decision on whether an insured can recover its share of appraisal costs as bad faith damages is an unpublished Tenth Circuit ruling applying Utah law, which said no because that would override the policy's cost split. It does not bind Utah courts.
Each appraiser will be paid by the party selecting that appraiser. Other expenses of the appraisal and the compensation of the umpire will be equally paid by you and us.
Policy wording from a USAA homeowner form. The 2017 decision is unpublished and not binding precedent.
Court decisions: Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
Demand and waiver
Insurer that denies and stalls cannot demand appraisal after suit
The Utah Supreme Court held in 1897 that an insurer which denied liability and refused for an unreasonable time to appraise or adjust the whole loss could not demand appraisal after the insured sued. No Utah appellate decision says when an insured's own delay waives the right, and no statute sets a deadline to demand appraisal. The suit time limit is paused while the parties conduct an appraisal. Federal courts applying Utah law have held that insureds who skipped appraisal could not recover repair costs or fees as bad faith damages, and that harm from an insured's three-year wait to demand appraisal was not foreseeable.
A claim under such a policy cannot be tied up for an unreasonable period, without fault or against the will of the claimant, by unreasonable delays on the part of the insurance company, and after it has denied liability under the policy.
Fire policy case on insurer delay and denial. Insured-side delay rests only on federal decisions applying Utah law, which do not bind Utah courts.
Court decisions: Stephens v. Union Assurance Society; Andersen v. Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids, Michigan; Angus v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.; Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
After the award is paid
Bad faith claim can survive payment; fee-only claims open
Unsettled
Paying an appraisal award ends the contract claim, but the Utah Supreme Court held that bad faith and other extra-contractual claims are outside a clause limited to amount of loss. The Tenth Circuit applied that to say paying the award does not, by itself, bar a bad faith claim or its damages. Whether fees alone can support such a claim is unsettled: an unpublished Tenth Circuit decision says no, and a D. Utah decision declined to follow it and weighed asking the Utah Supreme Court. For interest, the claims rule counts a failure to pay legal-rate interest on overdue amounts as an unfair practice. No Utah decision on interest after a timely appraisal payment was found.
USAA's compliance with the appraisal demand clause and the other express provisions of the policy does not, as a matter of law, preclude a cause of action for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing and for consequential damages resulting from any such breach.
Federal decisions apply Utah law as predictions. Utah Code § 31A-26-303(5) says the unfair claim settlement statute creates no private cause of action.
Court decisions: Miller v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.; Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.; Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.; Andersen v. Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids, Michigan; Angus v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.; Blakely v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
The two Title 31A parts read for this page, Chapter 21 Part 3 (specific clauses in contracts) and Chapter 26 Part 3 (claims), have no appraisal section. Appraisal is mentioned only in the limitation-tolling sentence and in the adjuster and assignment provisions listed below; HB 58 sets no appraisal process.
"The period of limitation is tolled during the period in which the parties conduct an appraisal or arbitration procedure prescribed by the insurance policy", by law, or as agreed to by the parties. Last amended by Chapter 185, 2023 General Session.
A policy may not "provide that no action may be brought, subject to permissible arbitration provisions in contracts," and may not deprive Utah courts of jurisdiction over an action against the insurer "except as provided in permissible arbitration provisions".
The 20-day selection period and the "competent, independent appraiser" wording come from the policy. The USAA clause quoted in Miller read: "each will select a competent, independent appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser's identity within 20 days of receipt of the written demand." If the appraisers failed "to agree within a reasonable time," they submitted their differences to the umpire.
Miller considered the Utah Arbitration Act, Utah Code Ann. §§ 78-31a-1 to -20, as it stood in 2002, and held that neither the Act nor the court’s arbitration case law "directly applies to appraisal." Miller did not decide whether the later-enacted arbitration statute in Title 78B, Chapter 11 reaches appraisal.
R590-190 mentions appraisal only in its automobile total-loss section, which lets an insurer "conclude the loss settlement under the appraisal section of the policy"; it sets no appraisal process or day counts.
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in Utah. Utah Code § 31A-21-313(4) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, or issue the award: no day count is fixed by the statutes and rule read. The USAA form quoted in Miller gave 20 days to name an appraiser, a policy term | Set by the policy | Parties and the appraisal panel | No Utah statute or rule found; Miller (Utah 2002) | |
| Suit on a first-party policy: three years after the inception of the loss, and a policy may not shorten it below the statutory period | Inception of the loss | Insured | Utah Code § 31A-21-313(1)(a), (3)(a); § 31A-21-314(2)(c) | |
| The suit period is tolled while the parties conduct an appraisal or arbitration procedure, whether prescribed by the policy, by law, or agreed | Appraisal under the policy, by law, or by agreement | Runs for the insured | Utah Code § 31A-21-313(5) (Ch. 185, 2023) | |
| No suit to compel payment until the earlier of 60 days after proof of loss, the insurer’s waiver of proof of loss, or its denial of full payment, unless a verified complaint alleges prejudice other than the delay itself | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss furnished as required under the policy | Insured | Utah Code § 31A-21-313(4)(a) |
| Rescind a public adjuster contract by written notice; not available once the adjuster has effected an acceptable settlement | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Entering into the contract | Insured | Utah Code § 31A-26-311 |
| Public adjuster returns anything of value the insured gave under the contract after rescission | 15 business days | Public adjuster’s receipt of the notice of rescission | Public adjuster | Utah Code § 31A-26-401(2)(b), as amended by HB 58 (2026), effective May 6, 2026 |
Who can serve
Nothing in the statutes and rule read for this page sets qualifications for property appraisers or umpires. "Competent, independent" is the wording of the policy quoted in Miller.
Licensing: an umpire or arbitrator "selected by the claimant and insurer" is exempt from the adjuster license. An "appraiser" is among those exempt when an individual who does not do insurance adjusting is "specially employed to obtain facts about a loss for or furnish technical assistance to a licensed adjuster or a company adjuster".
Contingent pay: an insurer or insured "may not pay a person who is representing the insurer or insured in connection with an insurance claim adjustment" on any basis dependent on the amounts paid. The ban expressly covers employees, independent contractors and public adjusters. It does not bar arrangements based on overall profitability, on discovering fraudulent claims, or conforming to a commissioner order or rule. Separately, § 31A-26-402(1)(c) lists a percentage of the amount an insurer pays as a method of public adjuster compensation.
Public adjusters (HB 58, 2026, effective May 6, 2026): a public adjuster may not charge more than "10% for a catastrophic insurance claim settlement" or "20% for a non-catastrophic" settlement, and may not accept a fee or other compensation before settlement of the claim. No percentage compensation on a claim where the insurer, within 72 hours after the day the loss is reported, pays or commits in writing to pay the policy limit; the adjuster is then entitled to reasonable compensation based on time and expenses. A public adjuster may not represent or act as a company or independent adjuster on the same claim, and may not allow an appraiser, contractor, roofing company, inspector or similar person to obtain the insured’s signature on the contract.
Utah Code §§ 31A-26-402(4), (6)(c)-(d), 31A-26-405(13), (16)
An independent adjuster or public adjuster may not accept a fee or other valuable consideration for referring an insured to a third party, "including an attorney, appraiser, umpire, construction company, contractor, repair firm, or salvage company" (enacted 2017). A person licensed concurrently as both an independent and a public adjuster may not represent both the insurer and the insured in the same transaction.
New § 31A-26-403.1 (HB 58) lets a property policy prohibit assignment of a right or benefit to a property repair contractor, roofing company, disaster clean up company, "appraiser, inspector, or other person hired to remedy the damage" that is the subject of the claim. A policy may not prohibit assignment to a "policy adjuster".
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge a notice of loss, unless payment is made within 15 days or the insurer reasonably explains the failure to acknowledge. R590-190 defines "Day" as "calendar day" | 15 calendar days | Receipt of the notice of loss | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-6(1); R590-190-3(4) |
| Substantive response to a claimant when one has been requested | 15 calendar days | Claimant’s request for a response | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-6(3) |
| Provide claim forms, instructions and reasonable assistance so a first party claimant can comply with the policy | 15 calendar days | Receipt of a notice of loss | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-6(4) |
| Complete the investigation and notify the first party claimant of acceptance or denial, unless the investigation cannot reasonably be completed in that time | 30 calendar days | Receipt of a complete proof of loss | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-10(2)(a) |
| Notice to the first party claimant that more time is needed, with the reasons | 30 calendar days | Receipt of the proof of loss | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-10(2)(b) |
| Letter giving the reasons more time is needed while the investigation is incomplete, then one within every 45 days after. Not required when the first party claimant is represented by legal counsel or a public adjuster | 45 calendar days | Sending the initial notification, then each later letter | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-10(2)(c) |
| Tell a claimant not represented by counsel or a public adjuster the date the statute of limitation or other time limit expires, at least 60 days before it expires | 60 calendar days | Negotiations continuing for settlement of the claim | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-10(3) |
| Deliver or mail the amount owed on a first or third party claim; failing to is an unfair claim settlement practice. If proof of the entire loss is lacking, a partial amount supported by written proof or investigation is due within 30 days, and payment is not overdue if the insurer has reasonable evidence to dispute its responsibility | 30 calendar days | Insurer’s receipt of written proof of a covered loss and its amount | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-9(21) |
| Matching on a replacement cost policy: no day count; where repaired or replaced items do not match in color, texture, or size the insurer must repair or replace items to conform to "a reasonably uniform appearance" | Repair or replacement leaves a mismatch | Insurer | Utah Admin. Code R590-190-13(1)(a)(ii) | |
| Timely payment, general duty: no day count in the statute; the commissioner may prescribe by rule the periods within which payment is timely | Valid first-party claim | Insurer | Utah Code § 31A-26-301(1)(a), (b)(iii) (amended by HB 58, effective May 6, 2026) |
Court decisions
Miller v. USAA Cas. Ins. Co., 2002 UT 6, 44 P.3d 663 (No. 20000268, decided Jan. 11, 2002)
Utah Supreme Court, 2002
Published opinion. Appraisal "is not arbitration"; it is an informal, independent valuation, and an appraisal determination "is not necessarily binding and enforceable in court". Whether it is evidence or an enforceable award depends on the contract terms. Neither the then-current Utah Arbitration Act nor the court’s arbitration case law "directly applies to appraisal." Because the policy’s appraisal clause was limited to the amount of loss, only the contractual claim was covered by it, not the extra-contractual claims; dismissing those claims as precluded by the appraisal result denied the insureds their day in court under the Utah Constitution (due process and open courts). The court reversed the order and remanded; it declined to decide whether the appraisal award had to be confirmed and left that to the district court on remand.
Recent and pending changes
HB 58 (2026 General Session), "Insurance Code Modifications," was signed by the Governor on March 17, 2026 and takes effect May 6, 2026. Among many insurance code changes it rewrote the public adjuster law: contracts filed with the department, compensation methods, the 72-hour policy-limits rule, the 10% and 20% fee caps, assignment-of-benefits limits naming appraisers, trust accounts, standards of conduct and record retention. It does not amend § 31A-21-313 or set any appraisal process.
R590-190 sections 1 to 10 and 12 to 14 were adopted in full effective January 24, 2024 (Utah State Bulletin 2024-03); section 11 (automobile) was later amended. § 31A-21-313 was last amended in 2023 (Ch. 185).
Sources
- Utah Code Title 31A, chapter 21, part 3 (§§ 31A-21-301 to -316)Official
- Utah Code Title 31A, chapter 26, part 2 (§ 31A-26-201)Official
- Utah Code Title 31A, chapter 26, part 3 (§§ 31A-26-301 to -313)Official
- HB 58 (2026), enrolled, insurance code modificationsOfficial
- Utah Admin. Code R590-190, unfair property, casualty, and title claims settlement practices (Office of Administrative Rules)Official
- Miller v. USAA Cas. Ins. Co., 2002 UT 6, 44 P.3d 663 (Utah 2002), Caselaw Access Project copySecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.