At a glance
We found no Alabama statute or regulation that prescribes an appraisal clause: the Homeowners Bill of Rights Act and the Insurance Department claims-practices rule do not mention appraisal. So the steps, deadlines and qualifications come from the policy. The Alabama Supreme Court limits appraisers to the amount of loss and leaves coverage and causation to the courts. Appraisal is not arbitration in Alabama, so a denied motion to compel appraisal cannot be appealed right away.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser license; Alabama does not license public adjusters
No state rule found
We found no Alabama statute or rule that requires a license or registration to serve as a property appraisal appraiser or umpire. The adjuster license law covers independent adjusters who work for insurers, and it says it does not let anyone who is not a lawyer practice law. The Department of Insurance says on its licensing page that Alabama does not license or recognize public adjusters. No statute or decision we found says whether acting for an insured in appraisal is the practice of law. Ask a lawyer.
This chapter shall not be construed to permit persons not licensed as attorneys to engage in activities constituting the practice of law.
The independent adjuster license is for people acting on behalf of an insurer. The Department of Insurance statement is its own web page, not a rule or ruling.
Contingency fees
No Alabama rule on contingent-fee appraisers found
No state rule found
We found no Alabama statute, rule, department bulletin or court decision saying that an appraiser paid a share of the award, or otherwise paid by result, is disqualified or partial in a property appraisal. The only contingent-fee statute we found bars licensed real estate appraisers from result-based fees on real estate appraisal assignments; it does not address insurance appraisal panels. Where a policy asks for a "disinterested" appraiser, the Alabama Supreme Court has said that word means more than having no money interest: the appraiser must not be biased. No Alabama decision has applied that to a contingent fee.
Property appraisal only.
Impartiality
Policy wording controls; "disinterested" bars a biased appraiser
No Alabama statute sets who may be an appraiser, so the policy wording decides. Where the policy asks for "competent and disinterested" appraisers, the Alabama Supreme Court has held that each party's appraiser must be impartial, not a partisan for the side that named him. An appraiser the insurer had hired in many cases raised a jury question, and an insurer that knowingly names a biased appraiser and hides it commits a fraud that frees the insured from the appraisal. In 1934 the court tested an insured's appraiser, a lawyer, under the same wording and found him competent and not partial. In 1985 a federal appeals court applying Alabama law held that a policy asking only for an impartial umpire did not require impartial party appraisers, and that Alabama's arbitration oath statute does not govern appraisals.
In their selection it is not contemplated that they shall represent either party to the controversy or be a partisan in the cause of either
Turns on policy wording. The Alabama cases are old fire policies saying "competent and disinterested". The 1985 case is a federal court applying Alabama law to a policy that named only an impartial umpire.
Court decisions: Glens Falls Insurance Co. of New York v. Garner; Southeast Nursing Home, Inc. v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Policy wording controls; a judge picks if appraisers cannot agree
No state rule found
We found no Alabama statute or rule on how an umpire is chosen in a property appraisal, so the policy decides. The policies in the Alabama cases have the two appraisers pick the umpire, and let either side ask a judge of a court of record to pick one if they cannot agree within 15 days. Alabama courts have enforced that: in Ryals the trial court appointed the umpire, and in Garner the appraisers picked one whom the court found competent and disinterested.
An umpire was appointed by the trial court.
We found no Alabama standard fire policy statute, so these are policy terms, not state-set rules.
Court decisions: Commercial Union Insurance Co. v. Ryals; Glens Falls Insurance Co. of New York v. Garner
Causation
Causation disputes go to the courts, not the appraisal panel
The Alabama Supreme Court held that appraisers decide only the amount of loss. When the insured and insurer disagreed about what caused some of the damage, the court said that question belonged to the courts and the trial court should not have sent it to appraisal. A concurring justice in 2013 repeated that appraisal is for the amount of loss when both sides agree on what the covered loss is.
The determination of the causation of these matters is within the exclusive purview of the courts, not the appraisers.
Homeowner policy with "amount of loss" wording. A policy that expressly gives the panel more power was not before the court.
Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 984 So. 2d 382 (Ala. 2007)
Court decisions: Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Ex parte Tower Insurance Co. of New York (In re Cullman Bowling Center, LLC v. Tower Insurance Co. of New York)
Coverage
Panel sets amount of loss only; coverage is for the courts
In Rogers the Alabama Supreme Court adopted the rule that appraisers decide only the amount of loss, meaning the money value of the property damage. Questions of coverage and liability are for the courts. It found no ambiguity in "the amount of loss" that would let an appraisal include coverage questions.
Questions of coverage and liability should be decided only by the courts, not appraisers.
Based on policy wording limited to the "amount of loss". The 2013 Cullman Bowling order denied mandamus with no majority opinion; only a concurrence repeated the Rogers rule.
Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 984 So. 2d 382 (Ala. 2007)
Court decisions: Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Ex parte Tower Insurance Co. of New York (In re Cullman Bowling Center, LLC v. Tower Insurance Co. of New York)
The award
Binding if two agree; attack for fraud, partiality or no hearing
Where two of the three agree, the Alabama cases treat the award as final. In 1934 the Alabama Supreme Court said an award stands unless the appraisers were guilty of fraud, partiality or corruption, whether the award came under the arbitration statute or at common law. In 1983 it held that an appraisal differs from arbitration and is not bound by the arbitration statute's procedures, but upheld setting an award aside where the insured got no notice or chance to be heard and the umpire alone filled in the figure. In 2023 it held that an appraisal clause is not an arbitration clause under the Federal Arbitration Act, so an order refusing appraisal cannot be appealed right away.
It may be stated broadly that, when parties submit their matters in controversy to arbitration, and an award is made pursuant to the agreement of submission, such award is final, unless the arbitrators are guilty of fraud, partiality, or corruption in making it.
Garner calls the proceeding arbitration. Yother was an auto theft policy. The arbitration statute's award rules (Ala. Code 6-6-14, 6-6-15) apply to an appraisal only if the parties meant to arbitrate.
Court decisions: Glens Falls Insurance Co. of New York v. Garner; Casualty Indemnity Exchange v. Yother; Great American Insurance Co. v. Crystal Shores Owners Association, Inc.; Commercial Union Insurance Co. v. Ryals
Who pays
Policy wording controls; usual clause splits umpire costs equally
No state rule found
We found no Alabama statute or rule on who pays appraisal costs, so the policy decides. The clauses in the Alabama cases, from 1890s fire policies to modern homeowner and commercial policies, have each side pay its own appraiser and split the umpire and other appraisal expenses equally.
the parties thereto shall pay the appraisers respectively selected by them, and shall bear equally the expenses of the appraisal and umpire.
The quote is fire policy wording quoted by the court, shown as an example of the common clause, not a state rule.
Demand and waiver
Delay waives only with substantial prejudice; denying liability waives
An insurer that invokes appraisal late waives it only if the other side shows substantial prejudice, a heavy burden (Rogers: nearly two years after the loss and 14 months into the suit, no waiver). An insured who waits 15 months after the claim is paid and the repairs are done waived appraisal (Jadick). An insurer that denies liability altogether cannot then rely on the appraisal clause (Chambers, 1939). An insured who has not met the policy's post-loss duties cannot yet demand appraisal (Adair).
we hold that waiting until 15 months after an insurance claim has been paid in full and after the damaged property has been repaired to seek an appraisal of the damaged property is so prejudicial to the insurer that it amounts to a waiver of the insured party's right to an appraisal.
Time limits for a demand come from the policy, not Alabama law. Jadick is a Court of Civil Appeals decision; Rogers is the Supreme Court test.
Court decisions: Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Jadick v. Nationwide Property & Casualty Insurance Co.; Chambers v. Home Insurance Co. of New York; Ex parte Birmingham Fire Insurance Co.; Baldwin Mutual Insurance Co. v. Adair
After the award is paid
No Alabama rule on paid awards; bad faith needs no arguable reason
No state rule found
We found no Alabama statute or decision saying what happens to a bad-faith, interest or attorney's-fee claim after an insurer pays an appraisal award. Alabama has no insurance-specific prompt-payment interest or fee statute for property claims. A general statute makes contracts to pay money bear interest from the day payment was due, and no case we found applies it to the time before an appraisal award. The unfair claims statute targets refusals frequent enough to be a general business practice. Alabama bad faith is a tort: the insured must show no reasonably legitimate or arguable reason for refusing to pay, so a real dispute over the amount of loss can defeat it.
A bad-faith-refusal-to-investigate claim cannot survive where the trial court has expressly found as a matter of law that the insurer had a reasonably legitimate or arguable reason for refusing to pay the claim at the time the claim was denied.
General Alabama bad-faith law, not specific to appraisal. Southeast Nursing Home is a federal court applying Alabama law and predates later Alabama bad-faith decisions.
Court decisions: State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Brechbill; Southeast Nursing Home, Inc. v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
We found no Alabama statute or rule that requires or prescribes an appraisal clause. The Homeowners Bill of Rights Act (Act 2012-510) and the Department of Insurance claims-practices rule (chapter 482-1-125) do not mention appraisal.
Ala. Code §§ 27-22-41 to -43; Ala. Admin. Code ch. 482-1-125
The days that commonly apply come from the policy, not from state law. For example, the State Farm homeowner's clause quoted in Rogers gives each side 20 days after receiving a written demand to name an appraiser, and gives the appraisers 15 days to agree on an umpire before either side can ask a judge to pick one. Read the days from the policy form.
State Farm homeowner's policy, as quoted in Rogers v. State Farm (Ala. 2007)
The policy in Rogers calls for a "competent, disinterested appraiser" and a "competent, impartial umpire." The commercial form in Crystal Shores reads "competent and impartial appraiser."
Appraisal timelines
No fixed appraisal deadlines in statute or regulation.
Who can serve
We found no Alabama statute or rule that sets appraiser or umpire qualifications. "Competent, disinterested" or "competent and impartial" comes from the policy wording (see the Basis above).
Ala. Code §§ 27-22-41 to -43; Ala. Admin. Code ch. 482-1-125 (neither mentions appraisal)
Alabama's statute defining the practice of law includes anyone who "as a vocation, enforces, secures, settles, adjusts, or compromises defaulted, controverted, or disputed accounts, claims, or demands" between persons with neither of whom he or she is in privity or in the relation of employer and employee. The statute does not mention appraisers or insurance, and this page does not say whether it reaches claim representation. Ask a lawyer.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Alabama. r. 482-1-125-.06(2) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurer acknowledges a first-party claim (unless it pays the claim within that time) | 15 calendar days | Notice of the claim (notice to the insurer's producer counts) | Insurer | Ala. Admin. Code r. 482-1-125-.06(1); "days" are calendar days under r. 482-1-125-.03(c) |
| Insurer provides claim forms, instructions or reasonable assistance | 15 calendar days | Notice of the claim | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.06(4); r. 482-1-125-.03(c) |
| Insurer replies to other pertinent written communications from a first-party claimant that ask for a response | 15 calendar days | The communication (the rule does not say from when the 15 days run) | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.06(3); r. 482-1-125-.03(c) |
| Insurer answers an Insurance Department inquiry about a claim (the rule says "working days") | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the inquiry | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.06(2) |
| Insurer tells the claimant whether the claim is accepted or denied, or says it needs more time and why (30 days, or the number of days in the policy) | 30 calendar days | Receipt of properly executed proofs of loss | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.07(1)-(2); r. 482-1-125-.03(c) |
| If the investigation is still open, insurer tells the claimant why more time is needed, 45 days after the first notice and every 45 days after that (no longer applies once the claim is in litigation) | 45 calendar days | The initial notification that more time is needed | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.07(2); r. 482-1-125-.03(c) |
| On an unresolved claim, insurer sends written notice of the limitations expiry date and its effect (claimant not represented by counsel) | 45 calendar days | The date the limitations period may expire, counted back; the rule says "approximately forty-five (45) calendar days before" | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.07(4) |
| Insurer tenders payment (30 days, or the time in the policy). The rule has no appraisal-specific wording | 30 calendar days | Liability accepted, amount of the claim agreed, and any documents needed to complete the settlement received | Insurer | r. 482-1-125-.07(6); r. 482-1-125-.03(c) |
Court decisions
Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 984 So. 2d 382
Alabama Supreme Court, 2007
The court adopted the rule that appraisers decide only the amount of loss and that coverage and liability questions are for the courts. Where the parties disagreed on what caused some of the damage, that was "within the exclusive purview of the courts," so the trial court erred in sending it to appraisal (reversed and remanded). On waiver it applied the arbitration test, which needs substantial prejudice to the other side: State Farm invoked appraisal almost 2 years after the loss and 14 months into the suit, and the insureds did not show substantial prejudice, so there was no waiver.
Baldwin Mut. Ins. Co. v. Adair, 181 So. 3d 1033
Alabama Supreme Court, 2014
The court reversed and remanded an April 2011 trial-court order, in a long-running injunction case, that found a disagreement and ordered appraisal for 14 insureds. Insureds must comply with their post-loss obligations under the policy before invoking appraisal; absent a duty to pay, there cannot be a genuine disagreement over the amount of a payment.
Great American Ins. Co. v. Crystal Shores Owners Ass'n, No. SC-2023-0092
Alabama Supreme Court (per curiam; decided December 22, 2023), 2023
Whether federal or Alabama law defines "arbitration" for the Federal Arbitration Act, the appraisal clause was not a clause calling for arbitration. So the denial of the insurer's motion to invoke appraisal was not an order denying a motion to compel arbitration, and the court dismissed the appeal as taken from a nonfinal judgment. Three justices concurred only in the result. The U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari (No. 23-1051) on May 20, 2024.
Casualty Indem. Exch. v. Yother, 439 So. 2d 77, as quoted in Crystal Shores
Alabama Supreme Court, 1983
The court agreed that an appraisal "is distinguishable from arbitration and is not subject to the various procedural requirements" imposed on the arbitration process.
Recent and pending changes
The claims-practices rule on this page was last amended effective May 16, 2020, according to the history note in both copies we read. We did not find a later amendment, but we cannot search every Department notice.
Sources
- Alabama Administrative Code, chapter 482-1-125 (claims practices), Legislative Services AgencyOfficial
- Alabama Administrative Code, r. 482-1-125-.07, on Cornell LIISecondary
- Code of Alabama § 34-3-6 (who may practice as attorneys), Alabama LegislatureOfficial
- Code of Alabama §§ 27-22-41 to -43 (Homeowners Bill of Rights Act), Alabama LegislatureOfficial
- Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. (Ala. 2007), slip opinion on JustiaSecondary
- Baldwin Mut. Ins. Co. v. Adair (Ala. 2014), opinion on FindLawSecondary
- Great American Ins. Co. v. Crystal Shores Owners Ass'n (Ala. 2023), opinion on JustiaSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.