At a glance
W. Va. Code § 33-17-2 adopts the 1943 New York standard fire policy as the West Virginia standard fire policy. Under its appraisal clause, on written demand each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser within 20 days, and if the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire within 15 days, a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is picks one. The statute does not say whether those counts are calendar or business days. The suit period on the fire portion is 12 months, running from the insurer’s written refusal to pay. One caveat: a multi-line policy such as a homeowner’s may word its fire portion differently if the wording is at least as favorable to the insured and the Insurance Commissioner approved it, so read the policy. The Commissioner’s 2002 letter 119-B makes an appraisal clause mandatory in fire coverage, but it now sits on the Commissioner’s historical-record page and whether it is still applied is not confirmed. No West Virginia appellate decision was found on whether appraisers may decide causation.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: yes
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser or umpire license rule found; adjuster law may reach some
No state rule found
No West Virginia statute or rule says an appraiser or umpire must hold a license to serve. The adjuster law bars anyone from acting as a public adjuster without a license. A public adjuster is anyone who, for pay and for the insured, negotiates or settles a first-party property claim, investigates or adjusts losses, or advises the insured. Appraisal is never mentioned, and no case says serving on an appraisal panel is acting as a public adjuster. Separately, a state license is required to prepare a valuation appraisal of real estate for pay. No authority says whether an insurance loss appraisal counts. A licensed adjuster may not act for both the insured and the insurer on the same claim.
No person may act or hold himself, herself, or itself out as a company adjuster, an independent adjuster, or a public adjuster in this state unless the person is licensed in accordance with this article or is exempt from licensure under this article.
Property claims. The adjuster and real estate appraiser laws are not written for insurance appraisal panels, so this is a gap in the law, not a finding that no license is needed.
Contingency fees
No rule on contingent-fee appraisers; public adjuster fees are limited
No state rule found
We found no statute, rule, bulletin or case saying a percentage or other outcome-based fee makes an appraiser or umpire not disinterested. The Commissioner does regulate public adjuster fees. Any fee must be reasonable, and no fee or deposit may be taken before the claim settles. After a catastrophe the fee may not top ten percent of the settlement. A public adjuster contract with a percentage fee must state the exact percentage. These rules cover public adjusters, not appraisers or umpires.
No public adjuster shall require, demand or accept any fee, retainer, compensation, deposit, or other thing of value, prior to settlement of a claim.
Public adjuster fee rules only. Nothing found on fees of appraisers or umpires.
Impartiality
Fire form: appraisers and umpire must be competent and disinterested
The standard fire policy that West Virginia adopts requires each side to pick a competent and disinterested appraiser, and the appraisers to pick a competent and disinterested umpire. The Supreme Court of Appeals has not defined what makes someone disinterested. In 1904 it held that an appraiser's earlier work as an appraiser does not disqualify him without proof of prejudice, and a claim that an appraiser acted as the insurers' agent failed for lack of proof. Policies may use other words, such as impartial.
each shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser selected within twenty days of such demand
Fire policies and the fire part of multi-line policies under § 33-17-2. An approved multi-line form may use wording at least as favorable to the insured. Other property policies follow their own wording.
Court decisions: Van Winkle v. Insurance Co. (Continental Fire Ins. Co.)
Umpire selection
Appraisers pick; after 15 days either side asks a judge to pick
The two appraisers choose a competent and disinterested umpire. If they cannot agree for fifteen days, either the insured or the insurer may ask a judge of a court of record in the state where the property sits to choose. The Supreme Court of Appeals has said that an insurer that invokes appraisal should use this step and not let the matter drift. Parties may also agree on another route, as they did when they used the American Arbitration Association in Smithson.
The appraisers shall first select a competent and disinterested umpire; and failing for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire, then on request of the insured or this company, such umpire shall be selected by a judge of a court of record in the state in which the property covered is located.
Fire policies and the fire part of multi-line policies under § 33-17-2. An approved multi-line form may use wording at least as favorable to the insured. Other property policies follow their own wording.
Court decisions: Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.; Wolford v. Landmark American Insurance Co.; Meadows v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.
Causation
No West Virginia decision on whether appraisers decide causation
No state rule found
We found no West Virginia statute or decision that says whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. The Supreme Court of Appeals has said an ordinary appraisal clause covers the amount of loss, and a 1932 decision said appraisers do not decide questions of law. Neither speaks to whether a dispute over which damage came from the covered event is for the panel or the court. A 2017 federal opinion noted causation evidence before a panel in a business interruption claim but did not rule on the point.
Nothing found for property policies in any court.
Court decisions: Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.; Mutual Improvement Co. v. Merchants & Business Men's Mutual Fire Insurance Co.; Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.
Coverage
Amount of loss only; coverage and policy defenses are not appraised
The Supreme Court of Appeals has said that under an ordinary appraisal clause the only issue is the amount of the loss, and coverage and policy defenses are not addressed in appraisal. A 1932 decision likewise held that appraisers are not asked to settle questions of law, and upheld an award that gave values under three views of who owned a party wall. In Smithson the statement supported the court's ruling that appraisal is not arbitration and did not bar a later suit.
Under an ordinary appraisal clause, the only issue is the amount of the loss. Questions concerning policy defenses or coverage are not addressed in appraisals.
Said about an ordinary appraisal clause in a fire-loss policy on a truck and drilling rig (Smithson) and a fire policy on a building (Mutual Improvement).
Court decisions: Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.; Mutual Improvement Co. v. Merchants & Business Men's Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
The award
Award binds on amount of loss; modern grounds to vacate not set
Unsettled
Under the standard fire policy, a written, itemized award signed by any two of the appraisers and umpire fixes the actual cash value and the loss. The Supreme Court of Appeals has not set a modern test for challenging an award. Cases from 1901 to 1905 voided an award where the umpire went beyond his authority, refused to set one aside for a mere mistake of judgment, and said an award in a suit at law cannot be attacked for misconduct that does not show on its face. A 2017 federal court read these to allow vacatur for fraud, corruption, partiality, misconduct, clerical or plain errors, or an award outside the clause, and refused to re-weigh expert methods.
may be vacated for fraud, corruption, partiality, or other misconduct on the part of the appraiser, as well as for clerical errors, readily apparent factual or legal errors, or an award beyond the scope of the appraisal clause.
Binding effect comes from the fire form. The vacatur test is a federal prediction of West Virginia law plus 1901-1905 state decisions on fire policy appraisals.
Court decisions: Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.; Van Winkle v. Insurance Co. (Continental Fire Ins. Co.); Billmyer v. Hamburg-Bremen Fire Insurance Co.; Providence Washington Insurance Co. v. Board of Education of Morgantown School District; Mutual Improvement Co. v. Merchants & Business Men's Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Who pays
Each side pays its appraiser; umpire and expenses split equally
Under the standard fire policy each side pays the appraiser it picked, and the parties split the cost of the umpire and the appraisal equally. A policy that does not use the standard wording follows its own terms. In a later suit where the insured substantially prevails, the insurer can also owe the insured's reasonable attorney fees, including fees from the appraisal.
Each appraiser shall be paid by the party selecting him and the expenses of appraisal and umpire shall be paid by the parties equally.
Fire policies and the fire part of multi-line policies under § 33-17-2. An approved multi-line form may use wording at least as favorable to the insured. Other property policies follow their own wording.
Court decisions: Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.; Hayseeds, Inc. v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Demand and waiver
Fire form sets no demand deadline; insurer conduct can waive appraisal
The fire form lets either side demand appraisal in writing and sets no deadline for the demand. The Supreme Court of Appeals held in 1927 that the insured need not demand appraisal before suing, and in 1916 that an adjuster who built the proof of loss without demanding appraisal waived it. In 1991 it faulted an insurer that invoked appraisal for not using the policy's steps, noting that courts elsewhere apply waiver and estoppel to appraisal. A federal court enforced a policy that set a 60-day window and found no waiver. On a total loss of insured real property by fire, a 1943 decision held the insurer cannot demand appraisal. We found no West Virginia appellate decision on losing appraisal through litigation conduct.
the insured is not bound to demand such appraisal as a condition precedent to instituting an action to recover for the loss under the policy
Fire policies. The 1927 and 1916 decisions are about fire policies of that era. The total-loss limit follows the fire valued policy statute, which does not apply where two or more insurers cover the same interest.
Court decisions: Crouch v. Franklin National Insurance Co.; Houseman v. Globe & Rutgers Fire Insurance Co.; Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.; Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.; Nicholas v. Granite State Fire Insurance Co.
After the award is paid
Paying the award does not bar Hayseeds claims if insured prevailed
In Smithson the Supreme Court of Appeals held that settling the loss through appraisal does not bar a later first-party bad-faith suit if the insured substantially prevailed in the appraisal on the amount of loss. The insured can recover reasonable attorney fees, including those spent in the appraisal, and prejudgment interest on the policy proceeds from the date of loss until paid. In Greenbrier (2017) a federal court went the other way on its facts: the insurers paid the amount they agreed on and then the $57,000 awarded, the insured did not substantially prevail, and the Hayseeds claim failed.
a first-party suit based on Hayseeds will not be barred by the settlement of the loss in an appraisal proceeding under the fire insurance policy if the insured substantially prevailed in the appraisal proceeding over the amount of the loss
First-party property claims by the insured. Smithson was a commercial policy on a truck and drilling rig. Greenbrier is a federal court applying West Virginia law.
Court decisions: Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.; Hayseeds, Inc. v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.
Deadlines
Fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No fire policy on West Virginia property may be issued "unless it conforms as to all provisions and the sequence thereof with" the New York standard fire policy, 1943 edition, which the statute designates as the West Virginia standard fire policy. The section does not apply to a multi-line policy whose fire portion has language "at least as favorable to the insured" and which the Commissioner has approved. It is not required for casualty insurance, marine insurance or growing crops. This is statute; it was last amended in 1957.
The appraisal wording of the 1943 form, as the Commissioner reproduced it: each side "shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser selected within twenty days of such demand." If the appraisers fail "for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire," then on request of the insured or the insurer a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located selects one. A written, itemized award of any two, filed with the insurer, determines the actual cash value and loss. Each side pays its own appraiser, and the umpire and appraisal expenses are split equally. This is the statutory form.
Informational Letter 119-B (July 2002) replaced 119-A because 119-A conflicted with § 33-17-2. It says an appraisal clause is mandatory in fire-only policies, using the standard wording, and in multi-line policies that include fire coverage, using the standard wording "or language at least as favorable." In other property and casualty policies appraisal is optional, but if included it must meet the same standard. Caveat: the Commissioner’s index page now lists Informational Letters as maintained for historical record, and whether the Commissioner still applies 119-B in form review is not confirmed.
W. Va. Insurance Commissioner, Informational Letter 119-B (2002)(PDF)
For a homeowner’s policy, the statute and the form give the floor and the approved policy gives the actual wording. A multi-line form may use different wording only if it is at least as favorable to the insured as the 1943 form and the Commissioner approved it. Read the policy.
In Wolford, a theft-loss case, the Supreme Court of Appeals reversed the denial of a Rule 60(b) motion for relief from a summary judgment for the insurer. One ground for the judgment was that the insured had frustrated the appraisal process. Under a policy clause letting either side ask a judge to pick the umpire, either side could have made that request, and a trial-worthy issue existed. It is a per curiam opinion.
Wolford v. Landmark Am. Ins. Co., 196 W. Va. 528, 474 S.E.2d 458 (1996) (per curiam)
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in West Virginia. W. Va. Code § 33-17-2 (adopts the 1943 form) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days. The Claim King counts every deadline here in calendar days, weekends and holidays included, and never moves a date that falls on a weekend or holiday. Calendar days give the earlier date; if business days apply, the real deadline may be later than the date shown. Check the policy's appraisal clause and confirm with your own counsel before relying on a date.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name your appraiser and notify the other side | 20 days(calendar or business not stated) | Written appraisal demand by either side | Insured and insurer | W. Va. Code § 33-17-2 (adopts the 1943 form); form wording as reproduced in Informational Letter 119-B(PDF) |
| The appraisers agree on an umpire; after 15 days either party may ask a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | The appraisers have been selected and are to choose an umpire (the form does not say when the 15 days start) | The two appraisers | W. Va. Code § 33-17-2 (adopts the 1943 form); form wording as reproduced in Informational Letter 119-B(PDF) |
| Award deadline: the 1943 form sets none | Not applicable | Appraisal panel | Informational Letter 119-B (1943 form wording)(PDF) | |
| Suit on the fire portion of the policy: 12 months from the insurer’s written notice that it declines to pay | Insurer’s written refusal to pay the loss | Insured | Meadows v. Employers’ Fire Ins. Co., 171 W. Va. 337, 298 S.E.2d 874 (1982) | |
| Suit on coverages other than fire and marine: a policy may not set less than 2 years (marine: not less than 1 year from the event) | Accrual of the cause of action | Insured | W. Va. Code § 33-6-14 (does not apply to the standard fire insurance policy); State ex rel. Erie v. Beane (W. Va. 2016) (memorandum decision) |
Who can serve
The standard fire policy requires "competent and disinterested" appraisers and umpire. The adjuster licensing sections read (§§ 33-12B-1 and -2) never mention appraisers or umpires, and no license requirement for serving as one was found.
An individual licensed in more than one adjuster class "shall not act as an adjuster representing the interests of the insured and the insurer with respect to the same claim." A public adjuster appointed by the insurer may not charge that claimant a fee.
No West Virginia statute, rule, bulletin or case was found on whether a public adjuster or a contingency-fee appraiser can be "disinterested." W. Va. Code § 33-12B-2 sets no public adjuster fee cap.
No West Virginia appellate decision was found on whether appraisers may decide causation, or on vacating an award for umpire or appraiser partiality.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in West Virginia. 114CSR14 § 6.12 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge the claim, unless paid in full within the period | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Notification of claim (notice to an agent counts) | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 5.1 |
| Reply to other pertinent communications from a claimant | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of the communication | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 5.3 |
| Respond to a Commissioner inquiry | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Date on the inquiry | Insurer or licensee | 114CSR14 § 5.2 |
| Have procedures to begin the investigation of a claim | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of notice of claim | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 6.2.a |
| Tell a first-party claimant which items, statements and forms are needed | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Notice of claim | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 6.2.b |
| Deny in writing or make a written offer | 10 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Completion of the investigation | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 6.3 |
| Written delay notice when acceptance or denial takes more than 30 days: within 15 working days after the 30 calendar days expire, then every 45 calendar days | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | The end of 30 calendar days after the first-party proof of loss is received | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 6.7 (relieved where there is a reasonable basis, supported by specific information available to the Commissioner, that the claimant fraudulently caused or contributed to the loss) |
| Pay an amount finally agreed in settlement | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of the agreement, or the claimant’s performance of any condition, whichever is later | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 6.11 |
| Warn an unrepresented first-party claimant about a time limit: at least 30 days before it expires | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | An approaching statute of limitations or policy time limit | Insurer | 114CSR14 § 6.12 |
| Acknowledge communications; affirm or deny within a reasonable time after proof of loss: no day count | Not applicable | Insurer | W. Va. Code § 33-11-4(9)(b), (e) |
Court decisions
Meadows v. Employers’ Fire Ins. Co., 171 W. Va. 337, 298 S.E.2d 874
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, 1982
Under the standard fire policy adopted by § 33-17-2, "the twelve-month time period for bringing suit commences to run when the insurance company notifies the insured in writing that it declines to pay the loss."
Sizemore v. State Farm Gen. Ins. Co., 202 W. Va. 591, 505 S.E.2d 654, No. 24436
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia (signed opinion), 1998
The fire portion of an approved multi-line policy counts as a standard fire insurance policy, so it is exempt from the two-year minimum suit period in § 33-6-14, as long as its language is at least as favorable to the insured and approved. The one-year limit therefore applied.
State ex rel. Erie Ins. Prop. & Cas. Co. v. Beane, No. 15-0968
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia (memorandum decision, not a signed opinion), 2016
A homeowner’s policy with no fire portion that qualifies as a standard fire policy cannot use a one-year suit limit on a snow-damage claim; the clause is void under § 33-6-14. The court denied the insurer’s petition for a writ of prohibition.
Wolford v. Landmark Am. Ins. Co., 196 W. Va. 528, 474 S.E.2d 458, No. 22947
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia (per curiam), 1996
A theft-loss case with a policy appraisal clause letting either side ask a judge to pick the umpire. The court reversed the denial of the insured’s Rule 60(b) motion against a summary judgment for the insurer. On appraisal, either side could have asked a judge to make the selection, and the insured showed a trial-worthy issue.
Recent and pending changes
HB 5521 (2026), relating to public adjusters, would have amended §§ 33-12B-1 and -3 and added new sections (a 10% fee cap, no fee before settlement, contract terms with a 3-business-day rescission right). Its engrossed text has no appraisal or umpire provision. It passed the House on 3/4/2026 and its last action was referral to Banking and Insurance in the Senate on 3/5/2026. The bill history shows no action after that, and it was not enacted.
HB 5392 (2026), the West Virginia Public Adjuster Professional Standards Reform Act, was introduced and referred to Government Organization, then Finance, on 2/10/2026. The bill history shows no further action.
The code page for § 33-17-2 lists no change since 1957, and the Secretary of State’s record for 114CSR14 lists no filing after the rule that took effect 4/24/2006.
W. Va. Code § 33-17-2 (history note); 114CSR14 (Secretary of State record)
Sources
- W. Va. Code § 33-17-2, the West Virginia standard fire policyOfficial
- W. Va. Code § 33-6-14, policy conditions voided (minimum suit period)Official
- W. Va. Code § 33-11-4, unfair trade practicesOfficial
- W. Va. Code § 33-12B-2, adjuster licensingOfficial
- 114CSR14, Unfair Trade Practices (Secretary of State rule page, with the filed rule text)Official
- Informational Letter 119-B, Arbitration and Appraisal Provisions – Homeowners (2002, listed on the Commissioner’s historical-record page)OfficialPDF · no web page version found
- HB 5521 (2026) bill statusOfficial
- HB 5392 (2026) bill statusOfficial
- Meadows v. Employers’ Fire Ins. Co. (W. Va. 1982), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Sizemore v. State Farm (W. Va. 1998), on JustiaSecondary
- State ex rel. Erie v. Beane (W. Va. 2016), memorandum decision on JustiaSecondary
- Wolford v. Landmark American (W. Va. 1996), on JustiaSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.