At a glance
None of the statutes or the regulation cited on this page sets appraisal day counts, so those come from the policy. Kentucky’s arbitration act does not apply to insurance contracts (KRS 417.050(2)); this page cites no ruling on whether that reaches appraisal clauses. The fixed clocks near appraisal are the regulator’s claim-handling deadlines in 806 KAR 12:095 and the 30-day payment rule in KRS 304.12-235. Two 2026 laws change who can do the work: a two-year pause on new public adjuster licences and on public adjusters negotiating with insurers, and a new limit on appraisers negotiating real-property claims for insureds.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No license named for appraisers; two laws may reach the role
No state rule found
No Kentucky law licenses or registers an appraisal-clause appraiser or umpire by name. Acting as a public adjuster needs a license, and the public adjuster definition covers paid advice or help to an insured on a first-party claim without saying anything about appraisal. Since July 15, 2026 only people certified or licensed by the state real estate appraiser board may use the title "appraiser" in relation to real property, and such an appraiser may not negotiate for an insured on a real property insurance claim, though he may advocate for his own appraisal report. We found no ruling or Department of Insurance guidance on whether serving as a policy appraiser or umpire falls under either law. New public adjuster licenses are paused for two years from April 13, 2026, and for two years from July 15, 2026 a public adjuster may not negotiate with an insurer for an insured.
renders advice or assistance to the insured in a first-party claim for loss or damages under any policy, certificate, or contract of insurance covering real or personal property
Contingency fees
No statute; one federal court vacated an award over a fee deal
Unsettled
No Kentucky statute, regulation or state court decision says whether an appraisal-clause appraiser may be paid by the outcome. In 2022 a federal court applying Kentucky law threw out an award because the insured's appraiser would get no fee unless he added to the claim, and he had also promised a referral fee to the roofer who held the claim. That court said a fee cap on an hourly rate might not be a problem by itself. A 2019 federal decision approved an insurer's appraiser and noted nothing in the record showed a contingency fee or other stake in the result. Separately, the public adjuster fee statute caps public adjuster fees at 10 percent for contracts signed on or after July 15, 2026, but it does not mention appraisers. Since July 15, 2026, a contractor whose work will be paid from property insurance proceeds may not be financially connected to an appraiser or public adjuster, or solicit contracts for appraisers, which reaches referral deals like the one in the 2022 case.
While a fee cap may not necessarily be problematic under the case law, a provision that states "should the process produce no additional settlement then no fee will be due" clearly is.
Federal courts applying Kentucky law; commercial property policy with "impartial appraiser" wording. Not a Kentucky state court ruling.
Court decisions: Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.; Veranda Gardens, LLC v. Secura Insurance
Impartiality
Must be disinterested; prior insurer work alone does not disqualify
Kentucky courts read the policy's "disinterested" or "impartial" requirement as barring an appraiser who acts like one party's employee or has a stake in the result. Having worked for insurers before does not disqualify an appraiser, and an appraiser who is merely zealous for the party who chose him is not disqualified. Federal courts applying Kentucky law add that a financial stake or party control destroys impartiality, while an earlier inspection does not. One federal court said an umpire is held to a higher standard than an appraiser.
The fact that each had on prior occasions acted as appraisers for insurance companies in adjusting fire losses does not disqualify them.
Policies that require competent and disinterested (or impartial) appraisers. Early cases are fire policies; modern decisions are federal.
Court decisions: Upington v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York; R. E. Jones & Co. v. Northern Assurance Co.; Continental Insurance Co. v. Vallandingham & Gentry; Veranda Gardens, LLC v. Secura Insurance; Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.; James Hamilton Properties, LLC v. Great Midwest Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Policy sets the method; court may appoint if appraisers deadlock
No Kentucky statute sets how an umpire is chosen, so the policy controls. The usual clause lets either side ask a judge to pick the umpire if the appraisers cannot agree. Kentucky's Court of Appeals held in 1936 that a court-appointed umpire's award was invalid because the appointment came without notice to the other side. Federal courts applying Kentucky law routinely appoint an umpire under the clause, weigh experience and ties, and have held that local ties and past insurance-industry work do not by themselves disqualify a candidate. A 2022 federal court noted that no Kentucky court has decided whether appointing an umpire counts as arbitration under KRS 417.050(2), which excludes insurance contracts, but enforced the policy language anyway.
The court had no power to act until after the expiration of fifteen days and should not then have acted except after reasonable notice to appellant so that it could be properly represented.
Camden involved an auto policy; the rest are federal courts applying Kentucky law to commercial property policies.
Court decisions: Camden Fire Insurance Association v. Cahill; Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (umpire appointed); Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC; James Hamilton Properties, LLC v. Great Midwest Insurance Co.; Owners Insurance Co. v. HUB Multifamily, LLC
Causation
Federal courts let panel decide cause; no state ruling
Unsettled
No Kentucky state court has decided whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. Federal courts applying Kentucky law have repeatedly allowed the panel to decide both cause and amount of loss, even where the policy does not say so, so long as the panel values only damage from the event at issue. In 2023 a federal court sent a hail dispute to appraisal on that basis. A 2022 federal court did not decide an insurer's argument that the umpire had no authority to decide cause. Some other states treat cause as a coverage question for the court.
the court may let the appraiser determine both the cause of loss and the amount of loss
Federal courts applying Kentucky law, commercial property policies. Not a Kentucky state court ruling.
Court decisions: Motorists Mutual Insurance Co. v. Post; Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (umpire appointed); Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co.; Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.; Upington v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York
Coverage
Court decides coverage; panel sets the amount of loss
The panel sets the amount of loss, and the court decides what the policy covers. Kentucky's Court of Appeals held in 1944 that an appraisal panel may decide the amount of loss but not which property the policy covers, and an award is void to the extent it strays into coverage. Federal courts applying Kentucky law follow this: the court decides legal coverage questions, such as whether the policy requires matching undamaged shingles, and the policies in those cases say the insurer keeps its right to deny the claim after appraisal.
the appraisers and umpire were authorized to determine the amount of loss and damages but were not authorized to determine what property was covered by the terms of the policies
State rule from a 1944 fire policy case; modern application is by federal courts on commercial property policies.
Court decisions: Upington v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York; Motorists Mutual Insurance Co. v. Post; Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (umpire appointed); Nationwide General Insurance Co. v. 1616 Gardiner Lane, Inc.; Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
The award
Binding absent fraud or mistake; clear proof needed to set aside
Kentucky treats an appraisal award as binding on the parties, like a court judgment, unless it was made through fraud or mistake or outside the panel's authority, and the challenger must show it by clear and convincing evidence. Simply thinking the amount is too low is not enough. Older cases set awards aside where the panel was not properly formed or did not give the insured a fair chance to be heard. A 2022 federal court vacated an award because the insured's appraiser was not impartial. Kentucky's arbitration act, with its own challenge rules, excludes insurance contracts, and one federal court said no Kentucky court has decided whether a policy's "decision agreed to by any two will be binding" language makes an umpire's ruling arbitration.
Courts look with favor upon arbitration of controversies and regard an award as binding on the parties, in the absence of fraud or mistake and when made within the scope of the agreement, as is a judgment of a court.
State rule from 1944 fire policy case; later federal decisions apply it to commercial and homeowners policies.
Court decisions: Upington v. Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York; United States Fire Insurance Co. of New York v. Green; Camden Fire Insurance Association v. Cahill; Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.; James Hamilton Properties, LLC v. Great Midwest Insurance Co.; Ball v. Liberty Mutual Group Inc.; Patrick v. Liberty Mutual Group, Inc.
Who pays
Policy wording controls; usual clause splits umpire cost
No state rule found
We found no Kentucky statute, regulation or decision that divides appraisal costs, so the policy decides. The standard clause quoted in Kentucky decisions has each side pay its own appraiser and split the umpire and other appraisal expenses equally, and a federal court applied that wording when it appointed an umpire in 2023. We found no case where a court was asked to shift these costs.
As provided by the insurance policy, each party shall pay one-half of the expenses of the umpire.
Policy wording; no statute found.
Court decisions: Owners Insurance Co. v. HUB Multifamily, LLC; National Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford v. Pinnell
Demand and waiver
Ask promptly and in good faith; old cases say before suit
No Kentucky statute sets a deadline to demand appraisal, so the policy governs. Kentucky's highest court held that an insurer that wants appraisal must act with reasonable promptness and in good faith, that an insurer that misuses the clause waives it, and that failure to appraise is no defense to a suit unless the insurer asked for appraisal before suit. Those decisions have not been overruled. Modern federal courts applying Kentucky law have let an insurer invoke appraisal after the insured sued, one calling the demand "proper and timely," and ordered appraisal on an insured's motion during a suit. We found no Kentucky decision since 1944 on losing appraisal by delay or by litigation conduct.
Unless the insurer asks for the arbitration or appraisal before suit brought, the failure to appraise is not a defense.
Binding rule from fire policy cases of 1903 and 1923; the modern decisions are federal and do not bind Kentucky courts.
Court decisions: Continental Insurance Co. v. Vallandingham & Gentry; National Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford v. Pinnell; Patrick v. Liberty Mutual Group, Inc.; Ball v. Liberty Mutual Group Inc.; Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (motion to rescind appraisal); Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
After the award is paid
Paying award ended contract claim; interest and fee issue open
Unsettled
No Kentucky state court has said what paying an appraisal award does to interest, bad-faith or fee claims. Federal courts applying Kentucky law have held that an insurer that invoked appraisal and paid the award as the policy required did not breach the contract, so the insured recovered no further benefits, costs or pre-judgment interest, and a bad-faith claim failed where the insurer paid promptly after the award. KRS 304.12-235 adds 12 percent interest if the insurer made no good-faith settlement attempt within 30 days of proof of loss, and attorney fees if the delay had no reasonable foundation. We found no decision applying that statute to an appraisal award paid after the 30 days.
the value of the final settlement shall bear interest at the rate of twelve percent (12%) per annum from and after the expiration of the thirty (30) day period
Statute applies to first-party claims; decisions are federal courts applying Kentucky law to homeowners and commercial policies.
Court decisions: Patrick v. Liberty Mutual Group, Inc.; Ball v. Liberty Mutual Group Inc.; Arla v. Peerless Insurance Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
KRS 304.14-140 requires an insurance contract to contain the standard or uniform provisions the Insurance Code requires for that kind of insurance, and lets the commissioner waive or approve substitutes. None of the statutes cited on this page prescribes an appraisal clause.
The regulation recognizes policy appraisal in the auto total-loss section: the insurer "may conclude the loss settlement as prepared for under the appraisal provision of the insurance contract," binding on both parties but not a waiver of other rights.
The arbitration act carves out insurance: "This chapter does not apply to: … (2) Insurance contracts," except arbitration between insurers. Effective June 27, 2019. No ruling was found on whether this carve-out reaches appraisal clauses or only removes the chapter’s procedures.
Statute versus policy. No statute or regulation cited on this page sets a day count for naming an appraiser, choosing an umpire or issuing an award, so those terms come from the policy. A federal court has appointed an umpire when appraisers deadlocked, and federal courts in Kentucky have let appraisers decide both cause and amount of loss, with coverage left to the court (see the cases).
Appraisal timelines
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, issue an award: none of the sources cited here fixes a day count; the policy sets them | Set by the policy | Parties and the panel | No Kentucky statute or regulation cited on this page | |
| Court appoints an umpire when the appraisers deadlock, on petition: no day count. The Sixth Circuit presumed this power, citing a 1936 Kentucky case | The appraisers fail to agree on an umpire | Court | Cincinnati Specialty v. C.F.L.P. 1 (6th Cir. 2018), citing Camden Fire Ins. Ass’n v. Cahill, 98 S.W.2d 462 (Ky. 1936) | |
| Confirm or vacate an award: no statutory clock cited here; the arbitration chapter does not apply to insurance contracts (KRS 417.050(2)) | Not applicable | Not applicable | KRS 417.050(2) | |
| Suit against a foreign insurer: a policy may not limit the time to sue to less than 1 year from when the cause of action accrues. Applies to foreign insurers only | Accrual of the cause of action | Insured | KRS 304.14-370 |
Who can serve
No statute or regulation cited on this page sets qualifications for an appraisal-clause appraiser or umpire.
Public adjusters, 2026: for two years from April 13, 2026, no public adjuster licence applications are accepted and no licences issued. Holders of a temporary or apprentice licence in effect on that date may still apply, and existing licences may be renewed.
Public adjusters, 2026: for two years beginning July 15, 2026, "a public adjuster shall not negotiate with an insurer on behalf of an insured in the adjustment or settlement of a claim." Section 14 of the Act applies the section to contracts entered into on or after its effective date. None of these public adjuster sections mentions appraisal or umpires, so whether "negotiate" covers appraisal advocacy is not addressed.
A public adjuster must give written disclosure of any financial interest with any other party to the claim, may take no part in repairs, may not engage in activities reasonably construed as a conflict of interest (including accepting any remuneration), and may have no financial interest in or affiliation with salvage, repair or other businesses that obtain business from a claim the adjuster has a contract to adjust.
Public adjuster fees may be based only on settlement proceeds actually received by the insured and collected after the insured receives them; the adjuster "may charge a reasonable fee that does not exceed ten percent (10%)" of the proceeds a fee may be based on. If the insurer pays or commits in writing to pay the policy limit before the contract is signed or its rescission period ends, the adjuster may take no percentage fee and is entitled only to reasonable compensation for time and expenses. The insured may rescind within 5 business days after the physical copy of the contract is provided to the insured or, for a contract arising from a declared state of emergency, within 10 days after the contract is executed.
Appraisers, effective July 15, 2026: it is unlawful, unless certified or licensed by the board, to "use the title 'real property appraiser,' 'real estate appraiser,' 'real property damage appraiser,' or 'appraiser' in relation to real property or federally related transactions." "An appraiser shall not negotiate, or advertise to negotiate, on behalf of any insured on any insurance claim relating to real property," though an appraiser may "advocate for his or her appraisal report."
KRS 324A.030(1)(d), (15) (HB 355, 2026 Ky. Acts ch. 172 § 6)
The chapter does not apply "in the settlement of an insurance claim" to licensed staff or independent adjusters or "any other representative of an insurance company." That exemption covers the insurer’s side only. The statute does not say how the title limit and the negotiation bar apply to a policyholder’s appraisal-clause appraiser, and it does not use the word "umpire."
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Kentucky. KRS 304.12-235(1) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The regulation defines "days" as "any day, Monday through Friday, except holidays." An unqualified "days" in 806 KAR 12:095 therefore means business days; sections that say "calendar" mean calendar days | Not applicable | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 1(5) | |
| Acknowledge receipt of a claim notice, unless paid within the period | 15 business days | Notification of the claim | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 5(1) |
| Reply to a Department of Insurance inquiry | 15 business days | Receipt of the inquiry | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 5(2) |
| Reply to other pertinent claimant communications | 15 business days | Receipt of the communication | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 5(3) |
| Offer any payment due on a first-party claim | 30 calendar days | Receipt of proof of loss | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 6(1)(a) |
| Notify the claimant that more time is needed to accept or deny | 30 calendar days | Receipt of proofs of loss | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 6(1)(c) |
| Letter giving the reasons the investigation is still incomplete: at 45 days, then every 45 days | 45 calendar days | The insurer’s initial notification that more time is needed | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 6(1)(d) |
| No direct settlement negotiation with an unrepresented first-party claimant whose rights a time limit may affect unless the insurer gave written notice of the limit at least 30 calendar days before it expires | 30 calendar days | Expiration of the statute or policy limit | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 6(3) |
| Tender payment once liability is affirmed and the amount is not in dispute. The sentence says "days" (defined in § 1(5) as Monday through Friday except holidays); the next sentence, on multiple coverages, says "calendar days" | 30 business days | Affirmation of liability | Insurer | 806 KAR 12:095 § 6(5) |
| Pay the claim. The statute says "days" without saying calendar or business | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Notice and proof of claim furnished in the form the policy requires | Insurer | KRS 304.12-235(1) |
| Interest on a late settlement: 12% a year from the end of the 30 days, with attorney’s fees if the delay lacked a reasonable foundation | No good-faith attempt to settle within 30 days | Insurer | KRS 304.12-235(2)–(3) | |
| Unfair claims practices: no day counts, only "reasonably promptly" and "reasonable time" | Not applicable | Insurer | KRS 304.12-230 |
Court decisions
Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Ins. Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC, No. 17-6498
Sixth Circuit, unpublished ("not recommended for full-text publication"), 2018
Affirmed the Western District of Kentucky rulings that appointed one of the insurer’s umpire candidates after bias objections and denied the insured’s motion to "rescind" the appraisal clause. The district court and insurer had cited FAA § 5 to appoint. The panel noted an earlier Sixth Circuit holding that the FAA did not apply to an identical clause, assumed it did not apply here, and presumed the court’s authority to appoint anyway, citing Camden Fire Ins. Ass’n v. Cahill (Ky. 1936) among other state cases (footnote 1). The opinion does not mention KRS 417.050.
Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., No. 3:21-cv-274-RGJ (2023 WL 320004)
Federal district court (W.D. Ky.), memorandum opinion and order, 2023
Granted the estate’s motion to compel appraisal. Noting that federal courts in Kentucky have said the court may let the appraiser decide both cause and amount of loss, the court said this is so "even if the appraisal provision does not expressly say" so, and ordered the panel to decide whether a June 17, 2019 hailstorm caused the damage and, if so, to value only that damage. The order is dated January 18, 2023; the insurer’s denial rested on the damage falling outside the policy period.
Recent and pending changes
HB 568 (2026 Ky. Acts ch. 141), signed April 13, 2026, emergency in part (Sections 1, 2, 3, 10, 11 and 12 took effect on signing): a two-year pause on new public adjuster licences from April 13, 2026, a two-year ban on public adjusters negotiating with insurers from July 15, 2026, contract and rescission rules, and fees capped at 10% of the proceeds a fee may be based on. The final free conference report was adopted April 1, 2026, 91-0 in the House and 33-1 in the Senate.
HB 355 (2026 Ky. Acts ch. 172): vetoed April 10, 2026, veto overridden April 14, 2026. It amended KRS 324A.030 effective July 15, 2026: the "appraiser" title restriction, the insurance-claim exemption for insurer-side adjusters, and the bar on appraisers negotiating for insureds.
Sources
- KRS 304.12-235, time to pay claimsSecondary
- KRS 304.12-230, unfair claims settlement practicesSecondary
- KRS 304.14-370, limits on suit against foreign insurersSecondary
- KRS 304.14-140, policy provisionsSecondary
- KRS 417.050, arbitration act exclusionsSecondary
- KRS 304.9-430, public adjuster licensing, on Justia (2025 text, before the 2026 amendments)Secondary
- KRS 304.9-433, public adjuster contracts and rescission, on Justia (2025 text, before the 2026 amendments)Secondary
- KRS 304.9-4331, public adjuster conduct, on Justia (2025 text, before the 2026 amendments)Secondary
- KRS 304.9-4333, public adjuster fees, on Justia (2025 text, before the 2026 amendments)Secondary
- KRS 324A.030, real property appraisers, on Justia (2025 text, before the 2026 amendments)Secondary
- 806 KAR 12:095, unfair claims settlement practices for property and casualty insuranceOfficial
- HB 568 (2026 Regular Session)Official
- HB 355 (2026 Regular Session)Official
- Cincinnati Specialty v. C.F.L.P. 1 (6th Cir. 2018), No. 17-6498, on JustiaSecondary
- Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto (W.D. Ky. 2023), order on JustiaSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.