At a glance
Va. Code § 38.2-2105 sets out the provisions each fire policy must contain, including the appraisal clause: on written demand, each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser within 20 days, and if the appraisers fail for 15 days to agree on an umpire, a judge of a court of record picks one. Section 38.2-2121 sets out how to ask the circuit court, on 21 days’ notice to the parties. Loss is payable 60 days after proof of loss once the loss is fixed by agreement or a filed award. These counts are policy wording the statute requires, and the statutes do not say whether they are calendar or business days. Since July 1, 2026, a public adjuster who is working or has worked the claim may not serve as appraiser or umpire. In 2025 the Court of Appeals of Virginia held, in a published opinion, that the appraisal clause in one policy was not an agreement to arbitrate under the Virginia Uniform Arbitration Act. One caveat: an insurer may use a Commission-approved readable form that words the clause differently, but it cannot be less favorable to the insured.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: yes
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No license named for appraisers; a PA on the claim cannot serve
No state rule found
We found no Virginia statute that requires a license or registration to serve as an appraiser or umpire. The public adjuster licensing law covers people who investigate, negotiate or advise a policyholder to settle a first-party property claim for pay. Whether paid work as a party appraiser counts as public adjusting is not answered in the text we read. Since July 1, 2026, a public adjuster who is adjusting or has adjusted any part of the claim may not act as appraiser or umpire on it. The oath in 38.2-2122 applies to every appraiser and umpire.
No public adjuster may act as an appraiser or umpire pursuant to the appraisal provisions of an insurance policy if that public adjuster or the public adjuster's firm is adjusting or has adjusted all or any part of the claim on property subject to that appraisal provision.
Property policies. The public adjuster bar in 38.2-1845.12(T) took effect July 1, 2026.
Contingency fees
No rule found on contingent-fee appraisers
No state rule found
We found no Virginia statute, regulation or decision saying a contingent-fee appraiser or umpire is disqualified or allowed. The statute asks that appraisers be competent and disinterested. In 1929 the Supreme Court noted that party appraisers were then sometimes paid five percent of the award, but it did not rule on whether that kind of fee is allowed. Public adjusters must state the exact percentage in their contract when paid a share of the proceeds; that rule covers public adjusters, not appraisers as such.
If the consideration is based on a share of the insurance proceeds, the exact percentage shall be specified.
The quoted fee rule covers public adjusters only, not appraisers.
Court decisions: Hurst v. Hope; Tiger Fibers, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
Impartiality
Competent and disinterested; sworn not employed by either side
The standard fire policy requires each appraiser and the umpire to be competent and disinterested. Before acting, each must swear not to be directly or indirectly employed by the insured, the insurer or any other insurer, and not to be related to the insured or an insurer officer. The Supreme Court reads employment narrowly: in 1929 it held that being hired for a single appraisal is not employment, and in 1930 that an appraiser who had often done appraisal work for the insurer's adjusting bureau, paid by the day, was not disqualified. A federal court in 2008 said only a party's permanent employees are disqualified.
each appraiser and umpire shall, before acting as such, take an oath that he is not directly or indirectly in the employment of the insured, the insurer, or any other insurer, that he is not related to the insured or any officer of the insurer, and that he will faithfully discharge the duties imposed upon him.
Fire policies and fire policies combined with other coverage (Va. Code 38.2-2100). An approved readable form may word it differently but not less favorably to the insured.
Court decisions: Hurst v. Hope; Equitable Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Stieffens; Tiger Fibers, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Appraisers pick; after 15 days a circuit judge appoints
The two appraisers first select a competent and disinterested umpire. If they fail for 15 days to agree, either side may ask the circuit court judge where the property was located. A copy of the application must first go to the other side. After 21 days notice to all parties, the judge appoints a competent and disinterested person. The umpire takes the 38.2-2122 oath. Since 2022 there is no citizenship or residency requirement.
the judge shall upon twenty-one days' notice to all parties appoint a competent and disinterested person to serve as umpire in determining the amount of loss or damage sustained.
Fire policies and fire policies combined with other coverage (Va. Code 38.2-2100). An approved readable form may word it differently but not less favorably to the insured.
Causation
Unsettled: trial courts split by facts; no appellate ruling
Unsettled
No Virginia appellate court has decided whether appraisers may decide what caused the damage. Trial and federal courts draw a line by the facts. In 2009 a Fairfax circuit court sent a dispute to appraisal where the insurer admitted the event caused all the damage and the fight was over how much had to be repaired. In 2021 a Winchester circuit court held appraisal does not reach items the insurer says were wear and tear rather than hail damage. A 2003 federal court treated an insurer's denial that a storm caused the loss as a coverage dispute outside appraisal. In 2025 the Court of Appeals, in a case where the insurer said most damage was weathering, called appraisal a process meant to resolve value, without ruling on causation.
Because Assurance denied coverage, it was not required to submit to an appraisal process pursuant to Virginia Code § 38.2-2105.
Property policies. Federal and circuit court authority only; none binds Virginia courts. The 2025 appellate remark is not a holding on causation.
Court decisions: HHC Associates v. Assurance Co. of America; Coates v. Erie Insurance Exchange; Church Mutual Ins. Co., S.I. v. Ephesus Richmond Seventh-Day Adventist Church
Coverage
Courts decide coverage; no Virginia appellate ruling yet
Unsettled
No Virginia appellate court has decided whether appraisers can decide coverage. A federal court in 2003 read the statute to apply only when the parties disagree on the amount of loss, not whether coverage exists, and circuit courts in 2009 and 2021 agreed coverage is for the courts. In 1911 the Supreme Court quoted with approval the U.S. Supreme Court's view that an award settles the amount of loss only, not the insurer's liability, but that was not a ruling on coverage. In 2025 the Court of Appeals described appraisal as a process meant to resolve a disagreement over value, also without ruling on coverage.
No Virginia court has considered whether § 38.2-2105 applies to coverage disputes. However, a reading of the plain language of the statute compels the conclusion that the provision is triggered only when the parties disagree as to the amount of loss, not the existence of coverage.
Property policies. Federal and circuit authority, plus appellate comment that is not a holding.
Court decisions: HHC Associates v. Assurance Co. of America; Coates v. Erie Insurance Exchange; North British & Mercantile Insurance Co. v. Robinett & Green; Church Mutual Ins. Co., S.I. v. Ephesus Richmond Seventh-Day Adventist Church
The award
Award binding; set aside only for fraud, misconduct or plain mistake
The statute says a written, itemized award of any two of the appraisers and umpire, filed with the insurer, determines the actual cash value and loss. The Supreme Court held in 1930 that a proper award bars suit on the original claim and is set aside only for errors apparent on its face, misconduct by the appraisers, a palpable mistake or fraud, and the challenger carries the burden. In 2025 the Court of Appeals held that the appraisal clause in one policy was not an agreement to arbitrate, so the circuit court could not modify the award under the Virginia Uniform Arbitration Act. It left open whether that Act can ever reach an appraisal.
It will not be set aside except for errors apparent on its face, misconduct on the part of the arbitrators, some palpable mistake or fraud in one of the parties
Fire policies and fire policies combined with other coverage (Va. Code 38.2-2100). An approved readable form may word it differently but not less favorably to the insured.
Court decisions: Equitable Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Stieffens; Church Mutual Ins. Co., S.I. v. Ephesus Richmond Seventh-Day Adventist Church
Who pays
Each side pays its appraiser; umpire and expenses split equally
The standard fire policy says each appraiser is paid by the party who picked him, and the expenses of the appraisal and the umpire are shared equally. If the insurer made the written demand, the insurer must reimburse the insured for the reasonable cost of the insured's appraiser and the insured's half of the umpire cost.
Each appraiser shall be paid by the party selecting him and the expenses of appraisal and umpire shall be paid by the parties equally; provided, however, if the written demand is made by this Company, then the insured shall be reimbursed by this Company for the reasonable cost of the insured's appraiser and the insured's portion of the cost of the umpire.
Fire policies and fire policies combined with other coverage (Va. Code 38.2-2100). An approved readable form may word it differently but not less favorably to the insured.
Va. Code 38.2-2105 (Appraisal)
Court decisions: Tiger Fibers, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
Demand and waiver
Insurer can waive by delay or fault; waiver must be knowing
The statute sets no deadline for demanding appraisal. In 1911 the Supreme Court held an insurer could demand appraisal at any time in the 60 days after proof of loss, that waiver must be made knowingly and clearly, and that an insured who ignored a timely demand could not sue. In 1890 it said an insurer that waited until nearly the end of the one-year suit period had waived the award requirement. In 1938 it held an insurer whose own appraiser quit could not rely on the missing award. These cases applied older policy wording; we found no modern appellate decision on waiver by delay or by litigation conduct.
It is equally as clear that the insurer was given the right at any time within the sixty days after the proof of loss was delivered, to demand an appraisal, which it did.
Fire policies and fire policies combined with other coverage (Va. Code 38.2-2100). An approved readable form may word it differently but not less favorably to the insured.
Court decisions: North British & Mercantile Insurance Co. v. Robinett & Green; Tilley v. Connecticut Fire Insurance Co.; Hanover Fire Insurance Co. v. Drake
After the award is paid
No rule found on effect of paying an award
No state rule found
We found no Virginia statute or decision on what paying an appraisal award does to later bad-faith or fee claims. The fee statute lets an insured who sues over coverage or liability recover costs and attorney fees only if the court finds the insurer, not acting in good faith, denied coverage or failed or refused to pay. A claim would turn on that. We found no statutory prompt-payment interest rule that speaks to an appraisal award.
However, these costs and attorney's fees shall not be awarded unless the court determines that the insurer, not acting in good faith, has either denied coverage or failed or refused to make payment to the insured under the policy.
Property policies. The statute is general, not specific to appraisal.
Deadlines
Fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
The standard fire policy chapter "applies only to contracts or policies of fire insurance" and to fire insurance combined with other coverages, so it reaches package policies that include fire.
On written demand of either side, "each shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser" and notify the other "within twenty days of such demand." If the appraisers fail "for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire," a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located selects one on request of the insured or the insurer. An itemized written award of any two, filed with the insurer, determines the actual cash value and loss. The loss is payable 60 days after proof of loss once it is fixed by agreement or a filed award. Subsection A says each policy "shall contain" these provisions, so the timelines are policy wording the statute requires, not freestanding statutory deadlines, subject to § 38.2-2107.
If the appraisers fail to agree on an umpire within 15 days, either side may apply in writing to the circuit court judge where the property was at the time of loss, after delivering a copy to the other side (the insurer’s registered agent, or the insured). On 21 days’ notice to all parties, the judge appoints a "competent and disinterested person to serve as umpire."
Before acting, each appraiser and umpire swears that he or she is not directly or indirectly employed by the insured, the insurer or any other insurer, is not related to the insured or to an officer of the insurer, and will faithfully perform the duties. A 2022 amendment removed the requirement that appraisers and umpires be Virginia citizens and residents.
Caveat for readable forms: an insurer may use a policy that "deviates in language" from the standard forms if it is "in no respect less favorable to the insured" and the Commission approved it before issuance. A form may therefore word the appraisal clause differently, but it cannot be less favorable to the insured than the standard form. Read the policy.
In Church Mutual, the Court of Appeals held that the appraisal clause in that policy was not an agreement to arbitrate, so the circuit court correctly ruled it lacked jurisdiction under the Virginia Uniform Arbitration Act provision the insurer invoked to modify or correct the award (Code § 8.01-581.011). The court decided on the wording of that contract and left open whether the Act could ever reach an appraisal.
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in Virginia. Va. Code § 38.2-2105 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days. The Claim King counts every deadline here in calendar days, weekends and holidays included, and never moves a date that falls on a weekend or holiday. Calendar days give the earlier date; if business days apply, the real deadline may be later than the date shown. Check the policy's appraisal clause and confirm with your own counsel before relying on a date.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser and notifies the other | 20 days(calendar or business not stated) | Written appraisal demand from either side | Insured and insurer | Va. Code § 38.2-2105 (Appraisal) |
| The appraisers agree on an umpire; after 15 days either party may ask a judge to pick one | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Not stated: the text says only that the appraisers "first select" an umpire and fail for 15 days to agree | The two appraisers | Va. Code §§ 38.2-2105, 38.2-2121 |
| Court appoints the umpire after notice to all parties (21 days’ notice) | 21 days(calendar or business not stated) | Written application to the circuit court where the property was, after the 15 days lapse and a copy is delivered to the other side | Circuit court judge | Va. Code § 38.2-2121 |
| Oath before acting as appraiser or umpire: no day count | Before acting | Each appraiser and umpire | Va. Code § 38.2-2122 | |
| Award deadline: the statute sets none | Not applicable | Not applicable | Va. Code § 38.2-2105 | |
| Loss payable once the proof of loss is received and the loss is fixed by written agreement or a filed award | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss received and the loss ascertained | Insurer | Va. Code § 38.2-2105 (When loss payable) |
| Sworn proof of loss, unless the insurer extends the time in writing | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | The loss | Insured | Va. Code § 38.2-2105 (Requirements in case loss occurs) |
| Suit on the policy: 2 years from the inception of the loss | Inception of the loss | Insured | Va. Code § 38.2-2105 (Suit) | |
| Modify or correct the award under the Virginia Uniform Arbitration Act: the circuit court had no jurisdiction to do so for the appraisal in Church Mutual | Not applicable | Not applicable | Church Mutual (Va. Ct. App. 2025); Va. Code § 8.01-581.011 |
Who can serve
Appraisers and the umpire must be "competent and disinterested" and must take the § 38.2-2122 oath. None of these sections requires a license, and since 2022 (2022 c. 666) there is no residency or citizenship requirement.
Since July 1, 2026: "No public adjuster may act as an appraiser or umpire pursuant to the appraisal provisions of an insurance policy" if the adjuster or the adjuster’s firm "is adjusting or has adjusted all or any part of the claim." A public adjuster may also have no financial interest in the claim beyond the contracted pay, and the full fee must be in the written contract, with the exact percentage if it is a share of the insurance proceeds.
In a footnote, Church Mutual quotes Hurst v. Hope, 152 Va. 405, 408-09 (1929), which analyzed a since-repealed statute, for the idea that the persons chosen to make an appraisement "should act independently and upon their own judgment."
Church Mutual (Va. Ct. App. 2025), n.9, quoting Hurst v. Hope
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Virginia. Va. Code § 38.2-2105 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge a claim, unless it is paid within the period | 15 calendar days | Notice of claim | Insurer | 14VAC5-400-50(A) |
| Reply to other pertinent claimant communications | 15 calendar days | Receipt of a communication that reasonably calls for a reply | Insurer | 14VAC5-400-50(C) |
| Answer a Bureau of Insurance inquiry | 15 calendar days | Receipt of the inquiry | Insurer | 14VAC5-400-50(B) |
| Accept or deny a first-party claim, or give written reasons more time is needed | 15 calendar days | Receipt of a properly executed proof of loss | Insurer | 14VAC5-400-60(A) |
| If the investigation is not finished, written notice explaining why more time is needed, repeated every 45 days | 45 calendar days | Notification of the first-party claim | Insurer | 14VAC5-400-60(B) |
| Denial in writing with reasons: no day count | Denial | Insurer | 14VAC5-400-70(A), (B) | |
| Pay after agreement or a filed award | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss plus ascertainment of the loss | Insurer | Va. Code § 38.2-2105 |
| Detailed explanation when cutting an adjuster’s loss estimate of $3,000 or more: no day count | Any reduction of an estimate of $3,000 or more | Insurer | Va. Code § 38.2-510(D), 2026 c. 672 |
Court decisions
Church Mutual Ins. Co., S.I. v. Ephesus Richmond Seventh-Day Adventist Church, Record No. 0628-24-2
Court of Appeals of Virginia (published), 2025
The insurer asked the Richmond circuit court to modify an appraisal award of about $1.69 million under the Virginia Uniform Arbitration Act; the circuit court sustained the church’s demurrer and dismissed. The policy used "arbitration" in other provisions but not in its appraisal clause, and the Court of Appeals held, based on the contract’s language, that the circuit court correctly ruled it lacked jurisdiction under the statute pleaded. It affirmed in part and vacated the circuit court’s factual findings, and left open whether the Act can ever cover an appraisal.
Recent and pending changes
2026 c. 672 (HB 808) added § 38.2-510(D): an insurer cutting a loss estimate of $3,000 or more must give the policyholder a detailed explanation of each reducing change and a list of all changes with who made them, and keep every version. The Governor approved it April 13, 2026, and it took effect July 1, 2026.
Section 38.2-2131 lists 2025 cc. 120 (HB 1628) and 134 (SB 1154) in its history: an insured may not assign the duties, rights or benefits of a fire or package-policy claim without the insurer’s written consent, and a contrary provision is void. The insured may still direct or make payment to a service provider or vendor for reasonable services or materials for covered items.
2022 c. 666 (HB 606) removed the citizenship and residency requirement for appraisers and umpires. The Legislature’s own bill summary says so; the act was approved April 11, 2022 and took effect July 1, 2022.
The history notes of § 38.2-2105 (last amended 1986) and § 38.2-2121 (last amended 1992) list no later change. The public adjuster conduct rules in § 38.2-1845.12 list a 2026 amendment. 2026 c. 142 (HB 437), approved April 6, 2026 and effective July 1, 2026, added subsection (T), which bars a public adjuster who is adjusting or has adjusted the claim from acting as appraiser or umpire.
Sources
- Va. Code § 38.2-2100, scope of the fire policy chapterOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-2105, standard fire policy provisionsOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-2107, simplified and readable policiesOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-2121, court appointment of an umpireOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-2122, oath of appraisers and umpiresOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-2131, assignment of claimsOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-1845.12, public adjuster conductOfficial
- Va. Code § 38.2-510, unfair claim settlement practicesOfficial
- 14VAC5-400, Rules governing unfair claim settlement practicesOfficial
- Church Mutual v. Ephesus (Va. Ct. App. 2025), on JustiaSecondary
- HB 606 (2022), bill summary and history, Virginia Legislative Information SystemOfficial
- HB 808 (2026), bill summary and history, Virginia Legislative Information SystemOfficial
- Church Mutual v. Ephesus (Va. Ct. App. 2025), opinion on vacourts.govOfficialPDF · no web page version found
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.