At a glance
No District statute or regulation writes an appraisal clause or sets appraisal-panel days, so the policy controls. The D.C. Court of Appeals has treated a contractual appraisal as an arbitration award, but in a commercial lease case, not an insurance case. If that carries over, the Revised Uniform Arbitration Act brings fixed post-award clocks of 20 and 90 days. A separate provision says an insurance policy term with a consumer that requires binding arbitration is void, and no court has decided whether that reaches homeowners appraisal clauses. There is no fixed-day claim-handling rule in force for property claims.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser license; public adjuster license may apply (unclear)
No state rule found
D.C. licenses public insurance adjusters. The definition covers anyone who, for pay, acts or aids an insured in negotiating or settling a first-party property claim. It does not mention appraisers or umpires, and we found no statute, rule or case saying whether an appraiser named by an insured must hold the license. We found no separate appraiser or umpire registration.
No person shall, directly or indirectly, act as a public insurance adjuster without first procuring a license from the Commissioner to act as a public insurance adjuster.
Public adjuster statute only. It does not apply to insurer adjusters and employees, or to attorneys who do not regularly act as public adjusters (§ 31-1631.12).
Contingency fees
No ban on contingent appraisers; public adjuster fee cap is 10%
No state rule found
We found no D.C. statute, rule or case saying that a contingent-fee appraiser or umpire is disqualified. The only fee rule found is for licensed public insurance adjusters: they may not charge more than 10% of the client's total insurance recovery. Whether that cap reaches an appraiser who is paid as a public adjuster is not answered.
A licensee shall not charge the client a fee that exceeds 10% of the total insurance recovery of the client.
The 10% cap binds licensed public insurance adjusters only.
Impartiality
No D.C. rule; the policy wording sets the standard
No state rule found
No D.C. statute, regulation or appellate decision sets a standard for insurance appraisers or umpires, so the policy wording controls. Policy forms seen in D.C. cases ask for "competent and disinterested" or "competent and impartial" appraisers. D.C.'s arbitration act bars a neutral arbitrator with a known, direct and material interest in the outcome, but no court has said that act reaches an insurance appraisal, and a separate section voids binding arbitration terms in consumer insurance policies.
Policy wording controls. The arbitration act would matter only if a court treats appraisal as arbitration; none has for insurance. No standard fire policy is in the D.C. Code.
Umpire selection
Policy controls; no D.C. rule on choosing an umpire
No state rule found
No D.C. statute, regulation or appellate decision says how an insurance appraisal umpire is chosen. The policy controls; the forms seen in D.C. cases let the appraisers pick the umpire and, if they cannot agree, let either side ask a judge. D.C.'s arbitration act lets the Superior Court appoint an arbitrator when the agreed method fails, but no court has applied that act to an insurance appraisal.
Policy wording controls. The arbitration act would matter only if a court treats appraisal as arbitration; none has for insurance.
Causation
No D.C. rule on whether the panel decides causation
No state rule found
We found no D.C. statute, regulation or appellate decision on whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. The one D.C. appellate insurance case on appraisal said, in passing, that appraisal fixes the amount of loss and does not decide liability or coverage. It did not mention causation.
Court decisions: Roumel v. Niagara Fire Insurance Co.
Coverage
Amount only, per 1967 reasoning; no D.C. holding on coverage
Unsettled
In 1967 the D.C. Court of Appeals said appraisal is only a way to find the amount of loss and does not decide other issues such as liability and coverage. It said so as a reason in a case decided on the policy's suit deadline, not in a dispute over coverage, and no D.C. court has since applied it to a panel that reached coverage. It is a strong signal, not a holding. No statute addresses it.
appraisement is merely a method of ascertaining the amount of loss or damage and does not determine other issues such as liability and coverage.
Fire policy with a "competent and disinterested appraiser" clause. The coverage words support a side point; the case turned on the twelve-month suit clause.
Roumel v. Niagara Fire Ins. Co., 225 A.2d 658, 659 (D.C. 1967)
Court decisions: Roumel v. Niagara Fire Insurance Co.
The award
Binding as to amount; challenge grounds unsettled for insurance
Unsettled
The award fixes the amount. In 1967 the D.C. Court of Appeals held that after an award the insured still sues on the policy, and the award is conclusive proof of the damages. In contract appraisals (a ground lease), the court has held that an agreed appraiser's value binds unless the appraisers acted from fraud, mistake or bias, exceeded their authority or misunderstood their duties. In 2006 it held a binding lease appraisal is an arbitration award, which can be set aside only on the arbitration act's grounds, moved for within 90 days. No court has said whether an insurance appraisal is arbitration. If it were, D.C. Code 16-4403(c) voids binding arbitration terms in consumer insurance policies unless both sides choose arbitration after the dispute arises.
Thus, even after an award is rendered, the insured's right of action is on the policy, the award being merely conclusive proof of the damages involved.
Roumel is the only D.C. appellate insurance case. Doggett (ground lease) and Washington Automotive (commercial lease) are not insurance cases.
Court decisions: Roumel v. Niagara Fire Insurance Co.; Washington Automotive Co. v. 1828 L Street Associates; Doggett v. McLachlen Bancshares Corp.
Who pays
No statute; policy controls who pays
No state rule found
We found no D.C. statute, regulation or insurance case dividing appraiser, umpire and appraisal costs. The policy controls. If the Revised Uniform Arbitration Act applies, a neutral's fees and expenses are paid as the award provides. We found no D.C. decision applying that to an insurance appraisal.
Section 16-4421 applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration. No standard fire policy is codified in D.C. Code Title 31.
Demand and waiver
No demand deadline; one-year suit clause may bar late appraisal suit
Unsettled
No D.C. statute sets a deadline to demand appraisal, so the policy controls. In 1967 the D.C. Court of Appeals held that when an insurer demands appraisal and then refuses to go on, the only effect is that the insured may sue on the policy at once, and the policy's suit deadline keeps running. The court added that an insurer's conduct in dragging out talks could stop that deadline from running. Federal trial courts applying D.C. law have enforced one-year suit clauses against insureds who sued to appoint an umpire or compel appraisal.
The weight of authority holds that the only effect of appellee's failure to comply was that appellants were able to sue forthwith on the policy.
Only Roumel binds D.C. courts. The two federal rulings are non-binding predictions of D.C. law. No D.C. case decides waiver of appraisal by delay or by litigating.
Court decisions: Roumel v. Niagara Fire Insurance Co.; Des Longchamps v. Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co.; Gardner v. Erie Insurance Co.
After the award is paid
No D.C. bad-faith tort; no case on claims after paid award
No state rule found
We found no D.C. statute or decision on what happens to interest, bad-faith or fee claims after an insurer pays an appraisal award. The D.C. Court of Appeals has refused to recognize a separate tort of bad faith in claim handling; that conduct is handled as breach of contract and of the implied duty of good faith. The unfair claim practices statute reaches only a general business practice and states no private right of action. Interest on a contract judgment runs from judgment unless more is needed to fully compensate; on a liquidated debt carrying interest, it runs from the due date.
Disputes relating to the respective obligations of the parties to an insurance contract should generally be addressed within the principles of law relating to contracts, and bad faith conduct can be compensated within those principles.
Choharis was a homeowners water-loss claim, not an appraisal case.
Court decisions: Choharis v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No statutory appraisal clause or standard fire policy was found in D.C. Code Title 31, including the chapters on fire, casualty and marine insurance (ch. 25), marine insurance (ch. 26), casualty rates (ch. 27), unfair trade practices (ch. 22A) and public adjusters (ch. 16A). Appraisal in the District comes from the policy, not from a statute.
The Revised Uniform Arbitration Act, D.C. Code §§ 16-4401 to 16-4432 (D.C. Law 17-111, effective February 27, 2008), governs an agreement to arbitrate "whenever made" on or after July 1, 2009. Washington Automotive Co. v. 1828 L Street Assocs. held that a contractual appraisal "is an arbitration award enforceable under the District of Columbia Arbitration Act." That was a commercial lease case, not insurance, decided under the earlier act (D.C. Code § 16-4301 and following).
D.C. Code § 16-4403(e); Washington Automotive, 906 A.2d 869 (D.C. 2006)
Section 16-4403(c) says: "Any provision in an insurance policy with a consumer that requires binding arbitration is void and unenforceable." A consumer policy may allow arbitration if "the decision to arbitrate is made by the parties at the time a dispute arises" and is not a condition of continued coverage, and if the parties elect to arbitrate, the chapter applies. How this fits a homeowners appraisal clause is open: a clause either side invokes after a dispute arises might be read as permitted, while one that binds the insured in advance might be void. No case was found.
The appraisal terms are contract language. In Des Longchamps, the court quoted the Allstate clause on a D.C. home: either party "may make written demand for an appraisal"; each picks "a competent and impartial appraiser"; the appraisers "select a competent and impartial umpire"; and if they cannot agree, the parties "can ask a judge" to select one. The parts quoted contain no day counts.
Des Longchamps v. Allstate, 102 F. Supp. 3d 299 (D.D.C. 2015)
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in District of Columbia. D.C. Code § 16-4420(b), does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, or issue the award: no day count is fixed by statute or regulation | Written appraisal demand; the policy controls | Parties and the appraisal panel | None found | |
| Court appoints an umpire when the agreed method fails or the appointee cannot act. Applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration under the Revised Uniform Arbitration Act, which rests on Washington Automotive, a lease case, not insurance | No agreed method, the agreed method fails, or the appointee fails or is unable to act with no successor | Superior Court, on motion of a party | D.C. Code § 16-4411(a) | |
| Award deadline: none fixed; it is the time set by the agreement, otherwise as the court orders, and an objection to a late award is waived unless made before notice of the award. Applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration (Washington Automotive, a lease case) | Set by the agreement or the court | Appraisal panel | D.C. Code § 16-4419(b) | |
| Ask the panel to modify or correct the award; the other parties then have 10 days from receiving notice to object. Applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration (Washington Automotive, a lease case, not insurance) | 20 days(calendar or business not stated) | Movant receives notice of the award | Party asking for the change | D.C. Code § 16-4420(b), (c) |
| Move to vacate the award (for corruption, fraud or other undue means, 90 days from when the ground was known or should have been known). Applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration (Washington Automotive, a lease case, not insurance) | 90 days(calendar or business not stated) | Movant receives notice of the award, or of a modified or corrected award | Party challenging the award | D.C. Code § 16-4423(c) |
| Move the court to modify or correct the award. Applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration (Washington Automotive, a lease case, not insurance) | 90 days(calendar or business not stated) | Movant receives notice of the award, or of a modified or corrected award | Party asking for the change | D.C. Code § 16-4424(a) |
| A consumer’s motion to vacate or modify an award under a consumer arbitration agreement, regardless of the 90 days. Applies only if appraisal is treated as arbitration (Washington Automotive, a lease case, not insurance) | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Consumer receives notice of a motion to confirm the award | Consumer | D.C. Code § 16-4424(d) |
Who can serve
No D.C. statute sets appraiser or umpire qualifications. "Competent and impartial" is policy wording.
If the Revised Uniform Arbitration Act applies, a neutral arbitrator (the umpire) may not have a "known, direct, and material interest in the outcome" or a "known, existing, and substantial relationship with a party." Disclosure is required before accepting appointment and continues afterwards. A neutral who does not disclose such an interest or relationship "is presumed to act with evident partiality," a ground for vacating the award.
Public adjusters: the fee may not exceed 10% of the total insurance recovery, and the insured may cancel the contract until midnight on the 3rd business day after signing. The chapter does not mention appraisers or umpires, and no D.C. rule on a public adjuster acting as appraiser was found.
The appraiser oath is policy practice, not law. In Des Longchamps the record showed a "Declaration of Appraisers" in which the appraisers swore to "act with strict impartiality" and that they were "not interested in said property or the insurance thereon."
No D.C. statute, regulation or case was found that addresses contingency-fee appraisers.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The District has no fixed-day claim-handling rule in force for property claims. The statute asks only that the insurer "acknowledge and act reasonably promptly" on claim communications, and it is unfair only when done often enough to be a general business practice | Communication received | Insurer | D.C. Code § 31-2231.17(b)(2) | |
| Affirm or deny coverage "within a reasonable time", with no day count | Proof of loss statements completed, or the insurer’s investigation completed | Insurer | D.C. Code § 31-2231.17(b)(5) | |
| Suit on the policy within one year, where the policy says so (the Allstate form ran it from the inception of the loss). The court enforced that limit, and the insured’s ongoing appraisal did not excuse a late suit, because the form made appraisal optional | Inception of the loss, per the Allstate form | Insured | Des Longchamps (D.D.C. 2015), quoting Martinez v. Hartford, 429 F. Supp. 2d 52, 56 (D.D.C. 2006) |
Court decisions
Washington Automotive Co. v. 1828 L Street Assocs., 906 A.2d 869 (D.C. 2006)
D.C. Court of Appeals (Sept. 14, 2006), published, 2006
A contractual appraisal in a commercial lease, not an insurance policy, "is an arbitration award enforceable under the District of Columbia Arbitration Act." Confirmation was affirmed because the landlord had not met "the high burden to set it aside."
Des Longchamps v. Allstate Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., 102 F. Supp. 3d 299 (D.D.C. 2015)
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (May 4, 2015), a federal trial-court ruling, 2015
The homeowner’s suit asking the court to appoint an umpire was time-barred by the policy’s one-year "Action Against Us" clause, which ran from the inception of the loss. Under that form "appraisal is not required under the policy," so the appraisal negotiations did not excuse the late filing. Quoting Martinez, such suit limits are "generally enforceable under District of Columbia law."
Recent and pending changes
No 2024 to 2026 D.C. Council bill or Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking rule on property claim handling or appraisal was found.
A 2020 emergency rule, 26-A DCMR § 5002, set 15 business days to acknowledge and begin investigating, and 15 business days (30 for fire damage) to accept or reject, with extensions of up to 30 business days each. It covered only protest-damage property and casualty claims filed from May 30, 2020, and was to expire October 10, 2020 unless superseded by a final rule. The official DCMR chapter today lists only §§ 5000 and 5001, so it is not a rule in force.
26-A DCMR § 5002 (emergency, adopted June 12, 2020); 26-A DCMR ch. 50(PDF)
The consumer-insurance arbitration ban in § 16-4403 dates from D.C. Law 17-111 (effective February 27, 2008), and the official code shows no amendment since.
Sources
- D.C. Code Title 31, Insurance and Securities, chapter list, D.C. CouncilOfficial
- D.C. Code § 16-4403, Revised Uniform Arbitration Act, D.C. CouncilOfficial
- D.C. Code § 16-4423, vacating an award, D.C. CouncilOfficial
- D.C. Code ch. 44, Revised Uniform Arbitration Act, full text, D.C. CouncilOfficial
- D.C. Code § 31-2231.17, unfair claim settlement practices, D.C. CouncilOfficial
- D.C. Code § 31-1631.08, public adjuster contracts and fees, D.C. CouncilOfficial
- 26-A DCMR ch. 50, Unfair Trade Practices, section list, D.C. Office of DocumentsOfficial
- 26-A DCMR § 5002, emergency and proposed rule (June 2020), DISBOfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Des Longchamps v. Allstate (D.D.C. 2015), on JustiaSecondary
- Washington Automotive v. 1828 L Street Assocs. (D.C. 2006), full text on HallApprovedSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.