At a glance
Neither R.C. 3929.25 (fire and lightning insurance on buildings) nor the claim-handling rule, Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54, mentions appraisal, appraisers or umpires, so appraisal terms come from the policy. The fixed clocks in the rule are: 15 days to acknowledge a claim, 21 days to accept or deny after proof of loss, and 10 days to pay after acceptance. In One Church v. Brotherhood Mutual (2026), the Ohio Supreme Court held that a binding appraisal award can be challenged only for fraud or mistake, and that mistake must be pleaded with particularity.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser license found; adjuster license law may reach paid work
No state rule found
We found no Ohio statute or rule that licenses appraisers or umpires as such. Ohio licenses public insurance adjusters. The statute defines one as a person who, for pay, helps an insured negotiate or settle a property claim. The text does not mention appraisers or umpires, and no court or department decision says whether serving as a paid appraiser for an insured is covered. Attorneys, insurer employees and independent adjusters representing an insurer are exempt.
acts on behalf of or aids in any manner, an insurer or insured or another in negotiating for, or effecting the settlement of a claim or claims for loss or damage under any policy of insurance covering real or personal property
Statute covers property claims for real or personal property. Whether it reaches a paid appraiser is not answered in any source we found.
Contingency fees
No Ohio rule bars a percentage fee; adjuster contracts must show fee
No state rule found
We found no Ohio statute, rule, department bulletin or court decision saying a contingent-fee appraiser is or is not disqualified. The public adjuster rule sets no fee cap but requires the contract to set out the fee conspicuously. It also bars a public adjuster from holding an interest in the damaged property or in repair work. The policy wording on "competent and disinterested" or "impartial" would be the starting point.
must conspicuously set out the fee
The rule governs public insurance adjuster contracts, not appraisers by name.
Impartiality
Policy sets the standard; bias must be proven, not suspected
No Ohio statute sets who may be a party appraiser; the policy wording ("competent and disinterested" or "impartial") is the standard. The Ohio Supreme Court held in Ries that an award stands unless the challenger proves misconduct or interest. A suspicion that the insurer's appraiser was partisan and aimed for a low number was not enough. The Sixth District later refused to remove an umpire because the insurer showed no "evident partiality", which means more than an appearance of bias.
There is room for suspicion that the appraiser selected by the insurer was partisan and conceived it to be his duty to obtain a low estimate, but the proof does not show either misconduct or interest.
Fire and homeowner policies with this wording. Cousino concerned an umpire in a binding appraisal treated as arbitration. No Ohio ruling defines what interest disqualifies a party appraiser.
Court decisions: Royal Insurance Co. v. Ries; Cousino v. Stewart; Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group; Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America
Umpire selection
Policy method first; court appoints if panel deadlocks or refuses
No statute writes the clause. The policy sets the method, usually that the two appraisers pick the umpire and a judge picks one if they cannot agree. The Ohio Supreme Court held in Saba that this binds the insurer too. When the insurer refused to name an appraiser, that counted as a failure to agree, and the court could appoint the umpire. Hull shows a trial court appointing one under such a clause.
The appraisers shall first select a competent and disinterested umpire: and failing for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire, then, on request of the insured or this company, such umpire shall be selected by a judge of a court of record in the state in which the property covered is located.
Applies to policies with this clause, as in the fire policy form quoted in Saba. The quote is policy wording, not a statute. The 15 days is a policy term.
Court decisions: Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America; Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group; Cousino v. Stewart
Causation
Ohio courts have not decided; federal courts predict panels may
Unsettled
No Ohio Supreme Court decision says whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. An Ohio appellate court called it a matter of substantial debate and declined to decide it. A federal court in Ohio predicted the Ohio Supreme Court would let panels decide causation when the policy does not forbid it. The Twelfth District did not reach the question, but enforced a policy that excluded coverage and law questions.
There is substantial debate over whether, and to what extent, appraisers and umpires may consider causation when determining the amount of loss to a structure.
No controlling state decision. Westview is a federal court predicting Ohio law and binds no Ohio court.
Court decisions: Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group; Westview Village v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Coverage
Amount of loss only; liability and coverage stay with the court
The Ohio Supreme Court has long treated the standard clause as an appraisal of the amount of loss, with liability left to the courts (Ries, 1909). An insurer's denial of liability is not by itself a denial of the amount of loss (Carnahan, 1900). The Twelfth District enforced a policy that excludes law and coverage questions and denied an insured's motion to compel appraisal of a full roof replacement. Parties can agree to more: the Sixth District treated a binding submission that included coverage as arbitration.
Under the plain language of the appraisal clause, issues of law and coverage are specifically excluded from the purview of an appraisal.
Homeowner and fire policies. Leonard turned on an express law and coverage exclusion. Where amount of loss ends and coverage begins on causation is still open.
Court decisions: Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Royal Insurance Co. v. Ries; Phoenix Insurance Co. v. Carnahan; Cousino v. Stewart; Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America; Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group
The award
Binding unless fraud or mistake is pleaded with particular facts
A binding appraisal award is conclusive between the parties. A court will set it aside only for fraud or a manifest mistake, something more than an error of judgment. A mistake must be pleaded with particularity under Civ.R. 9(B). A later "hidden damage" claim that really attacks the award needs the same showing. The Tenth District had gone the other way and was reversed.
Binding appraisal may be challenged only on grounds of fraud or mistake.
Policies where the appraisal result is binding on the parties. Slip opinion, subject to formal revision.
Court decisions: One Church v. Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Co.; Royal Insurance Co. v. Ries; Cousino v. Stewart; Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America
Who pays
No Ohio statute; policy controls; usual form splits umpire costs
No state rule found
We found no Ohio statute or rule on appraisal costs. The old fire policy form quoted in Saba has each side pay its own appraiser and split the expenses of appraisal and the umpire equally. In Hull, the trial court ordered the same split under a commercial policy, and that part of the order stood on appeal.
the expenses of appraisal and umpire shall be paid by the parties equally.
Quote is the policy wording reported in Saba, not a statute.
Court decisions: Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America; Royal Insurance Co. v. Ries; Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group
Demand and waiver
Must be demanded in writing; a party who blocks it loses it
Under the usual clause, appraisal is a condition of suit only after one side demands it in writing. If neither side demanded it, the insured may sue without one (Agresta, 1926). An insured who ignores the insurer's demand cannot sue (Carnahan, 1900). An insurer's denial of liability does not waive appraisal unless it makes appraisal pointless. An insurer that refused to continue an appraisal and insisted on starting over waived it (Appel, 1907). No Ohio decision sets a deadline to demand appraisal or finds it waived by suing first.
A written request for an appraisement is a condition precedent to such appraisal and award, and, there not having been a written request by either party, the appraisal and award became unnecessary, under the conditions of the policy, in order to entitle the plaintiff to recover.
Fire policy clauses that require a written demand. Trial courts have compelled appraisal after suit was filed, but no Ohio appeals court has ruled on waiver by delay or by suing.
Court decisions: Fire Association of Philadelphia v. Agresta; Phoenix Insurance Co. v. Carnahan; Fire Association of Philadelphia v. Appel; Saba v. Homeland Insurance Co. of America; Stewart v. Farmers Insurance of Columbus, Inc.
After the award is paid
Paid award is final unless fraud or mistake is pleaded with detail
When the insurer paid a binding appraisal award and the insured cashed it, the insured's later suit for more money was dismissed because it attacked the award without pleading fraud or mistake with particularity. The complaint included contract and bad faith claims. We found no Ohio prompt-payment interest statute for property claims. The department's claim rule says it creates no private lawsuit. Bad faith turns on whether the insurer had reasonable justification.
Because we find that One Church is challenging the appraisal, One Church’s claim of breach of contract is not sufficiently pleaded absent a claim of fraud or mistake.
Property policy with a binding appraisal that the insurer paid. Attorney fees and statutory interest after payment: no Ohio decision found.
Court decisions: One Church v. Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Co.; Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Stewart v. Farmers Insurance of Columbus, Inc.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No statute or regulation prescribes an appraisal clause. R.C. 3929.25, on fire and lightning insurance on buildings, covers valuation and payment of a total loss and says nothing about appraisal, appraisers or umpires.
The unfair claims settlement practices rule does not contain the words "appraisal", "appraiser" or "umpire".
Appraisal wording comes from the policy, not a statute. The Farmers policy quoted in Stewart has each side appoint "a competent and disinterested appraiser", the appraisers or a judge of a court having jurisdiction select an umpire, and an award in writing by any two appraisers is binding.
Stewart v. Farmers Ins. of Columbus, Inc., 2026-Ohio-1451 (8th Dist.)
Courts enforce the clause as a contract. A policy can carve questions of law and coverage out of appraisal, and the Twelfth District enforced that carve-out.
Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 2025-Ohio-5089 (12th Dist.)
A binding appraisal may be challenged only on grounds of fraud or mistake, and mistake must be pleaded with particularity.
One Church v. Brotherhood Mut. Ins. Co., 2026-Ohio-2764(PDF)
Appraisal timelines
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, or issue the award: no day count appears in R.C. 3929.25 or Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54 | Set by the policy, if at all; the Farmers policy quoted in Stewart states no day count | Parties and the appraisal panel | R.C. 3929.25; Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54 | |
| Challenge a binding appraisal award: no day count, only fraud or a specific mistake pleaded with particularity | Not applicable | Party challenging the award | One Church v. Brotherhood Mut. Ins. Co., 2026-Ohio-2764(PDF) |
Who can serve
Neither R.C. 3929.25 nor Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54 sets qualifications for appraisers or umpires. "Competent and disinterested" is policy wording, quoted in Stewart.
The public adjuster rule does not mention appraisal, appraisers or umpires, and sets no fee cap. A contract must "conspicuously set out the fee", and a contract form may not be used until 30 days after it is filed with the superintendent.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge the claim (payment, or sending forms and instructions, also counts) | 15 calendar days | Notification of the claim | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(F)(2); days are calendar days under (C)(5) |
| Respond to a claimant communication that calls for a response (does not apply once suit is filed) | 15 calendar days | Receipt of the communication | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(F)(3) |
| Respond to a Department of Insurance inquiry about a claim | 21 calendar days | Receipt of the inquiry | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(F)(4) |
| Accept or deny the claim, or say why more time is needed | 21 calendar days | Receipt of properly executed proof of loss | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(G)(1) |
| Written status letter every 45 days while the investigation continues | 45 calendar days | After an extension notice | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(G)(1) |
| Present information to the Department’s fraud division when the insurer reasonably believes the claimant fraudulently caused or contributed to the loss | 60 calendar days | Receipt of the proof of loss | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(G)(1) |
| Warn an unrepresented claimant before a statute of limitation or policy time limit runs out: at least 60 days before expiry | 60 calendar days | Approaching expiry of the limit | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(G)(5) |
| Pay an undisputed, determined claim (exceptions apply) | 10 calendar days | Acceptance of the claim | Insurer | Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54(G)(6) |
Court decisions
One Church v. Brotherhood Mut. Ins. Co., 2026-Ohio-2764 (No. 2024-1329)(PDF)
Ohio Supreme Court (published, 6-1), 2026
A church that took payment of a binding appraisal award could not later recover more for "hidden" damage without pleading a specific appraiser mistake with particularity. A court interferes only for an error "so palpably wrong that it undermines the intent of the agreement", not an ordinary error of judgment. The decision reversed the Tenth District and reinstated the dismissal. Read from the slip opinion; Justice Fischer dissented.
Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 2025-Ohio-5089 (Nos. CA2024-07-091, CA2024-09-113)
Ohio Court of Appeals, 12th District (Butler County), 2025
The denial of the insured’s motion to compel appraisal was affirmed. Whether the Residential Code of Ohio required a full roof replacement and whether the policy covered one were "questions of law and questions of policy coverage, not factual issues", and the policy’s appraisal clause expressly excluded them. The court read Saba as holding "that appraisal clauses are binding on both insureds and insurers". Read from the court’s published opinion (decided 11/10/2025). The policy was not in the record, so the court worked from the clause as cited in State Farm’s denial letter; summary judgment for State Farm was also affirmed.
Stewart v. Farmers Ins. of Columbus, Inc., 2026-Ohio-1451 (No. 115049)
Ohio Court of Appeals, 8th District (Cuyahoga County), 2026
An auto total-loss case (released 4/23/2026). Class certification was reversed and the case remanded because a completed, court-ordered binding appraisal had already resolved the named plaintiff’s valuation claim. The trial court had applied the Saba criteria to find the appraisal clause mandatory.
Saba v. Homeland Ins. Co. of America, 159 Ohio St. 237
Ohio Supreme Court (published), 1953
The standard fire policy’s appraisal clause binds the insurer as well as the insured: appraisers are selected on the demand of either party, and "the provisions are not revocable by either." The trial court’s appointment of an umpire on the insured’s application, after the insurers refused to name appraisers, was affirmed.
Recent and pending changes
One Church (decided July 23, 2026) is the main recent development. It holds that a binding appraisal can be challenged only for fraud or mistake, and that mistake must be pleaded with particularity.
One Church v. Brotherhood Mut. Ins. Co., 2026-Ohio-2764(PDF)
Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54 shows an effective date of 2/14/2022. Its five-year review is due 2/27/2027.
Sources
- R.C. 3929.25, fire and lightning insurance on buildingsOfficial
- Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-54, unfair property/casualty claims settlement practicesOfficial
- Ohio Adm.Code 3901-1-24, public adjustersOfficial
- One Church v. Brotherhood Mutual (Ohio 2026), slip opinionOfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Stewart v. Farmers Ins. of Columbus (Ohio App. 8th Dist. 2026), on CourtListenerSecondary
- Saba v. Homeland Ins. Co. of America (Ohio 1953), on CourtListenerSecondary
- Leonard v. State Farm (Ohio App. 12th Dist. 2025), on CourtListenerSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.