At a glance
Section 506 of the Insurance Company Law of 1921 (40 P.S. § 636) writes the appraisal clause into the standard fire policy: on written demand, each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser within 20 days, a judge picks the umpire if the appraisers cannot agree within 15 days, and loss is payable 60 days after proof of loss and a filed award. But § 506(3) exempts policies "of an all-risk type" from the standard form, so for most homeowner’s and commercial forms the 20, 15 and 60 days come from the policy, not the statute. Courts treat an appraisal award like a common-law arbitration award, binding unless a party was denied a hearing or fraud, misconduct, corruption or other irregularity caused an unjust award. The statute sets no deadline to challenge an award; a non-precedential Superior Court memorandum says 30 days. The Unfair Claims regulations (31 Pa. Code ch. 146) add insurer clocks for all property claims.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: yes
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser or umpire license; public adjuster law is silent
No state rule found
We found no Pennsylvania statute or rule that licenses or registers appraisal-clause appraisers or umpires. The Public Adjuster Licensing Law bars anyone from acting as a public adjuster without a license. It defines a public adjuster as someone who holds out to the public as an adjuster of claims and is paid to advise or assist the insured in adjusting them. It never mentions appraisers or umpires, so the text does not say whether a paid party appraiser for an insured needs that license. Act 77 of 2026, which takes effect April 20, 2027, amends the law (fee caps, contract rules, and auto claims taken out of the definition) and still does not mention appraisers or umpires.
No person shall, directly or indirectly, act within the Commonwealth as a public adjuster without first procuring from the Insurance Commissioner a license as a public adjuster.
Property claims. Auto physical damage appraisers have their own license, which does not apply to property appraisal.
Contingency fees
Contingent fee alone does not disqualify a "competent" appraiser
In Hozlock, a published Superior Court decision, the insured's appraiser worked for a public adjuster paid a percentage of the recovery. The court held that, absent policy language requiring impartiality, that arrangement does not by itself make the appraiser unfit. The challenger must show the arrangement caused an unjust award. The court said it was not deciding whether the word "disinterested" would change the result, and the statutory fire policy uses that word. Act 77 of 2026, in effect April 20, 2027, caps public adjuster fees at 10 percent on catastrophe claims and 20 percent on others; it does not address appraisers.
in the absence of contractual language specifically requiring impartiality, the existence of such an arrangement between an insured and his appointed appraiser does not, in and of itself, render the appraiser unfit.
Policy that required only a "competent" appraiser. No decision found on a clause saying "disinterested" or "impartial".
Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mut. Ins. Co., 745 A.2d 1261 (Pa. Super. 2000)
Court decisions: Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mutual Insurance Co.
Impartiality
Statutory form says disinterested; policy wording controls otherwise
The standard fire policy in section 506 requires each side to pick a "competent and disinterested" appraiser and umpire. Section 506(3) exempts all-risk policies, so many homeowner and commercial forms use their own words, such as "competent and impartial". Hozlock held that "competent" alone does not require a neutral party appraiser. Courts will set an award aside for fraud, misconduct, corruption or other irregularity, not just because a party appraiser leaned one way. No decision found on how "disinterested" is enforced.
each shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser selected within twenty days of such demand.
Statutory wording applies to fire policies on Pennsylvania property; all-risk policies are outside § 506(2) by § 506(3).
Court decisions: Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mutual Insurance Co.; The Mews at Byers Station Condominium Association v. Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Appraisers pick; after 15 days a court judge appoints (fire policy)
Under the standard fire policy, the two appraisers first pick a competent and disinterested umpire. If they cannot agree for 15 days, either side can ask a judge of a court of record in the state where the property sits to pick one. Section 506(3) exempts all-risk policies, so other forms use their own wording, for example "a judge of a court having jurisdiction". Pennsylvania courts have appointed umpires on request.
The appraisers shall first select a competent and disinterested umpire; and failing for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire, then, on request of the insured or this Company, such umpire shall be selected by a judge of a court of record in the state in which the property covered is located.
Fire policies. Policies of an all-risk type are excluded from the standard form by § 506(3), so their wording controls.
Insurance Company Law of 1921 § 506(2) (40 P.S. § 636)
Court decisions: Riley v. Farmers Fire Insurance Co.; Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co. v. Krawitz
Causation
Unsettled: federal courts split; no state appellate ruling
Unsettled
No Pennsylvania state appellate court has decided whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. Federal district courts applying Pennsylvania law are not uniform. Currie (2014), following Williamson (2012), treats a disagreement over the extent of damage, or over whether a covered peril caused some of it, as an amount-of-loss question for the panel. Banks (1992) refused appraisal where the insurer said some of the damage was not covered. These are federal trial-court decisions that do not bind state courts.
when the parties merely disagree over the extent of damage or whether a covered peril is the cause of certain damage, that is a dispute regarding the amount of loss and is proper for appraisal.
Federal district court decisions applying Pennsylvania law; not binding on Pennsylvania state courts. No state appellate decision found.
Court decisions: Currie v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.; Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of North America; Moran Industries, Inc. v. Erie Insurance Exchange
Coverage
Panel sets amount of loss only; coverage goes to the court
Pennsylvania's Supreme Court treats appraisal as resolving only actual cash value and the amount of loss, with every other issue left for negotiation or a lawsuit. The Superior Court applied that rule to a homeowner fire claim in McGourty (1997). Appraisal fits where the insurer admits liability and the only dispute is the dollar value. Later non-precedential memoranda repeat that coverage disputes are outside appraisal.
An appraisal is limited to determining the amount of the loss with all other issues reserved for settlement by either negotiation or litigation
Property appraisal clauses generally; Ice City was a fire policy and McGourty a homeowner fire claim.
Court decisions: Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of North America; McGourty v. Pennsylvania Millers Mutual Insurance Co.; Professional, Inc. v. Mutual Benefit Insurance Co.; Post River Road, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
The award
Binding; vacated only for denied hearing, fraud or irregularity
Courts review an appraisal award the way they review a common-law arbitration award. It is binding and may not be vacated or modified unless a party was denied a hearing or fraud, misconduct, corruption or other irregularity caused an unjust award. An honest mistake of judgment, of fact or law, is not enough, and unless the agreement limits them, appraisers are the final judges of law and fact. A challenge must be filed within 30 days; after that the court must confirm the award on request. A court may still check whether the panel went beyond the questions given to it.
is binding and may not be vacated or modified unless it is clearly shown that a party was denied a hearing or that fraud, misconduct, corruption or other irregularity caused the rendition of an unjust, inequitable or unconscionable award.
Policies with ordinary appraisal clauses (common-law arbitration standard). The 30-day rule comes from Riley, a published decision applying 7342(b).
Court decisions: Patriotic Order Sons of America Hall Ass'n v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.; Riley v. Farmers Fire Insurance Co.; Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mutual Insurance Co.; The Mews at Byers Station Condominium Association v. Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co.; Moran Industries, Inc. v. Erie Insurance Exchange; Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co. v. Krawitz
Who pays
Fire policy: each pays own appraiser; umpire and costs split equally
The standard fire policy says each side pays the appraiser it picked, and the expenses of appraisal and the umpire are shared equally. Section 506(3) exempts all-risk policies, so a homeowner or commercial form can say something different. Some forms found in decisions (for example the commercial form in Mews) say nothing about costs, so read the policy.
Each appraiser shall be paid by the party selecting him and the expenses of appraisal and umpire shall be paid by the parties equally.
Fire policies. All-risk policies are excluded by § 506(3), so the policy wording controls those.
Demand and waiver
No set deadline; whether suing waives appraisal is unsettled
Unsettled
Section 506 sets no deadline to demand appraisal; policy wording can (one commercial form required a demand within 60 days of proof of loss). Older decisions let either side revoke appraisal before an award, and Dudzinski (1927) held an insured revoked it by suing. In 1974 the Supreme Court called appraisal clauses "valid, enforceable and irrevocable" and ordered an insurer to appraise. Santos (1993) held an insurer's slow handling did not forfeit its right to appraisal. Whether filing suit or litigating waives appraisal now rests only on non-precedential memoranda: one said suit did not revoke it, another sent a waiver finding back undecided.
are valid, enforceable and irrevocable, save upon such grounds as exist in law or in equity for the revocation of any other type of contract.
Published decisions from 1925 to 1993 plus non-precedential memoranda (2020 on auto policies, 2022 on a commercial property policy).
Court decisions: Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of North America; Santos v. Insurance Placement Facility; Dudzinski v. Great American Insurance Co.; Robinson v. Lumbermen's Mutual Casualty Co.; Chauvin v. Superior Fire Insurance Co.; Professional, Inc. v. Mutual Benefit Insurance Co.; Post River Road, LLC v. Aspen Specialty Insurance Co.
After the award is paid
Unsettled: only non-precedential rulings on claims after payment
Unsettled
No published Pennsylvania decision says what timely payment of an appraisal award does to bad faith, interest or fee claims. We found no first-party prompt-payment interest statute for property claims; interest, punitive damages and attorney fees come from the bad faith statute, 42 Pa.C.S. 8371, only if a court finds bad faith. In Mews (2019, non-precedential) the insurer paid the award, and the court held a bad faith claim built on the appraisers' conduct cannot replace the narrow test for setting an award aside. In Belleza (2022, non-precedential) no prejudgment interest was added because the insured had agreed appraisal would resolve her claims.
In an action arising under an insurance policy, if the court finds that the insurer has acted in bad faith toward the insured, the court may take all of the following actions:
Property policies. The two decisions are non-precedential memoranda; no published Pennsylvania decision found on what payment of an award does to these claims.
Court decisions: The Mews at Byers Station Condominium Association v. Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co.; Belleza v. Erie Insurance
Deadlines
Fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No insurer may issue a fire policy on Pennsylvania property "unless such policy contains the following provisions." The appraisal clause is one of them: on written demand, "each shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser selected within twenty days of such demand." If the appraisers fail "for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire," a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located selects one on request of the insured or the company. An itemized written award of any two, when filed with the company, determines the amount of actual cash value and loss. Each side pays its own appraiser, and umpire and appraisal expenses are split equally.
Caveat for most homeowner’s and commercial policies: § 506(3) says the standard form does not apply to, among others, perpetual, reinsurance, "all-risk type", aircraft and motor-vehicle policies. Section 506(4) lets a fire policy, with the Insurance Commissioner’s approval, add other insurance and modify the wording "to accommodate additional property coverages and perils." So for all-risk forms the 20, 15 and 60 days are policy language. The policy itself should be read.
Courts apply the common-law arbitration standard to appraisal awards: an award of a nonjudicial arbitrator may not be vacated or modified unless it is "clearly shown that a party was denied a hearing or that fraud, misconduct, corruption or other irregularity caused the rendition of an unjust, inequitable or unconscionable award."
42 Pa.C.S. § 7341; Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mut. Ins. Co., 745 A.2d 1261 (Pa. Super. 2000)
A nonjudicial arbitration agreement is conclusively presumed to be common law unless it is in writing and expressly provides for the statutory arbitration subchapter.
Appraisal clauses are valid and enforceable. "For purposes of enforceability, we see no distinction between arbitration and appraisal." "When appraisal is rejected by the insurance carrier, or is otherwise made unavailable to the insured, the insured’s appraisal obligation is satisfied and he is entitled to bring suit."
Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of N. America, 456 Pa. 210, 314 A.2d 236 (1974)
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in Pennsylvania. § 506(2) (40 P.S. § 636) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days. The Claim King counts every deadline here in calendar days, weekends and holidays included, and never moves a date that falls on a weekend or holiday. Calendar days give the earlier date; if business days apply, the real deadline may be later than the date shown. Check the policy's appraisal clause and confirm with your own counsel before relying on a date.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser and notifies the other. Not mandatory for all-risk forms (§ 506(3)) | 20 days(calendar or business not stated) | Written appraisal demand from either side | Insured and insurer | § 506(2) (40 P.S. § 636) |
| The appraisers agree on an umpire; after 15 days either party may ask a judge of a court of record where the property is located to pick one | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Both appraisers selected | The two appraisers | § 506(2) |
| Award deadline: § 506 sets none | Not applicable | Not applicable | § 506(2) | |
| Insurer’s option to repair, rebuild or take the property: notice of intent | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of proof of loss | Insurer | § 506(2) (Company’s options) |
| Loss payable once the proof of loss is received and the loss is fixed by written agreement or a filed award | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss received and the loss ascertained | Insurer | § 506(2) (When loss payable) |
| Sworn proof of loss, unless extended in writing | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | The loss | Insured | § 506(2) (Requirements in case loss occurs) |
| Suit on the policy: 12 months from the inception of the loss | Inception of the loss | Insured | § 506(2) (Suit) | |
| Petition to vacate or modify an appraisal award. The statute sets no vacatur deadline. § 7342(b) speaks of an application to confirm made more than 30 days after an award, and a non-precedential Superior Court memorandum says a party opposing appraisal must file within 30 days | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | The award | Party challenging the award | 42 Pa.C.S. § 7342(b); Moran Industries, Inc. v. Erie Ins. Exchange, No. 1835 MDA 2014 (Pa. Super. 2015) (non-precedential) |
| Confirm the award: on a party’s application made more than 30 days after the award, the court "shall enter an order confirming the award" | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Award; application made more than 30 days after it | Either party | 42 Pa.C.S. § 7342(b) |
Who can serve
Under § 506, both appraisers and the umpire must be "competent and disinterested."
In Hozlock (a published Superior Court decision), "competent" and "disinterested" mean different things. Where the policy used only "competent," a party-appointed appraiser could be "somewhat partial." A contingency-fee agreement alone does not disqualify an appraiser; the challenger must show the partiality actually caused an unjust award. The court noted the statutory form says "competent and disinterested" and expressed no view on whether that wording would change the result.
Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mut. Ins. Co., 745 A.2d 1261 (Pa. Super. 2000)
Under the Public Adjuster Licensing Law, a public adjuster must disclose in writing any financial interest in another party to the claim, "ownership of or compensation expected to be received from a construction firm, building appraisal firm," and the contract must say the insured may rescind within three calendar days after signature. The Act does not mention appraisers or umpires, so it says nothing either way about a public adjuster serving as one.
Act of Dec. 20, 1983, P.L. 260, No. 72, §§ 3.1, 5(a.2) (63 P.S. § 1601 et seq.)
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Pennsylvania. 31 Pa. Code § 146.6 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge notice of claim within 10 working days (unless paid first) | 10 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of notice | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.5(a) |
| Respond to an Insurance Department inquiry within 15 working days | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of the inquiry | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.5(b) |
| Reply to other pertinent claimant communications within 10 working days | 10 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.5(c) |
| Provide claim forms and instructions within 10 working days | 10 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Claim notice | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.5(d) |
| Complete the investigation, unless it cannot reasonably be done | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Notification of claim | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.6 |
| Written explanation while the investigation is incomplete, every 45 days | 45 days(calendar or business not stated) | After the first 30 days | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.6 |
| Accept or deny a first-party claim within 15 working days | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of properly executed proofs of loss | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.7(a)(1) |
| Notice that more time is needed within 15 working days | 15 working days(the rule does not define a working day) | Receipt of proofs of loss | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.7(c)(1) |
| Follow-up letters while still undecided: first 30 days after the initial notice, then every 45 days | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | The initial more-time notice | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.7(c)(1) |
| Before settlement talks continue with a claimant who has no attorney, warn of an expiring time limit: at least 30 days before for a first-party claimant, 60 days for a third-party claimant | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Before the believed expiry | Insurer | 31 Pa. Code § 146.7(e) |
| Pay after an award. Chapter 146 sets no payment deadline | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss plus a filed award | Insurer | § 506(2) |
Court decisions
Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of N. America, 456 Pa. 210, 314 A.2d 236
Pennsylvania Supreme Court (published), 1974
Appraisal clauses are "valid, enforceable and irrevocable," like arbitration clauses. "When appraisal is rejected by the insurance carrier, or is otherwise made unavailable to the insured, the insured’s appraisal obligation is satisfied and he is entitled to bring suit." Dismissal of the complaint reversed and remanded.
Santos v. Insurance Placement Facility, 426 Pa. Super. 226, 626 A.2d 1177
Pennsylvania Superior Court (published), 1993
After a fire the insurer demanded appraisal and the insureds sued instead, arguing it had forfeited appraisal by delay under the Unfair Insurance Practices Act regulations. The court declined to read those regulations into the policy, found no breach of the duty of fair dealing and no forfeiture, and held appraisal was the proper way to set the amount of loss. Summary judgment for the insurer was affirmed.
Hozlock v. Donegal Cos./Donegal Mut. Ins. Co., 745 A.2d 1261
Pennsylvania Superior Court (published, so it is precedential), 2000
Appraisal is reviewed like common-law arbitration under 42 Pa.C.S. § 7341. Under a clause that said only "competent," a party’s appraiser need not be neutral, and a contingency fee alone does not disqualify an appraiser. The umpire did not have to hold a hearing where the policy did not require one. Denial of the petition to vacate was affirmed.
Moran Industries, Inc. v. Erie Ins. Exchange, No. 1835 MDA 2014
Pennsylvania Superior Court (non-precedential memorandum), 2015
A petition to vacate or modify an appraisal award is due within 30 days. Unless the clause restricts them, appraisers are final judges of law and fact, and treating a collapse as limited to one side of the building was within the appraisers’ authority to set the amount of loss. An umpire’s honest averaging error is not a ground to vacate. Reversed, with judgment for the insured for $500,471. Because it is a non-precedential memorandum, it is not binding authority.
Belleza v. Erie Ins., No. 668 WDA 2021
Pennsylvania Superior Court (non-precedential memorandum), 2022
The insured could not add prejudgment interest to an umpire’s appraisal award: she had agreed the appraisal would resolve her claims and never raised interest. The court also applied § 7342(b) to the entry of judgment on the award in deciding it could hear the appeal. Affirmed. Because it is a non-precedential memorandum, it is not binding authority.
Recent and pending changes
Act 86 of 2026 (HB 2473, signed October 22, 2026) repeals obsolete insurance laws: the Flood Insurance Education and Information Act and §§ 635.1(d), 635.6(c) and 2194 of the 1921 Act. It does not touch § 506 or appraisal.
Act 55 of 2018 amended 42 Pa.C.S. §§ 7341 and 7342, effective July 1, 2019.
Sources
- Insurance Company Law of 1921, § 506 (40 P.S. § 636), standard fire policy (whole Act; search the page for Section 506)Official
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 7341, common-law arbitration awardsOfficial
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 7342, confirmation of common-law awardsOfficial
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 7302, common law and statutory arbitrationOfficial
- 31 Pa. Code § 146.5, failure to acknowledge pertinent communicationsOfficial
- 31 Pa. Code § 146.6, prompt investigation of claimsOfficial
- 31 Pa. Code § 146.7, standards for prompt, fair and equitable settlementsOfficial
- Public Adjuster Licensing Law (Act 72 of 1983)Official
- HB 2473 (2025-2026 session), Act 86 of 2026Official
- Ice City v. Insurance Co. of N. America (Pa. 1974), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Santos v. Insurance Placement Facility (Pa. Super. 1993), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Hozlock v. Donegal Mut. Ins. Co. (Pa. Super. 2000), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Moran Industries v. Erie Ins. Exchange (Pa. Super. 2015, non-precedential), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Belleza v. Erie Ins. (Pa. Super. 2022, non-precedential), on HallApprovedSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.