In re ACE American Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Texas · May 8, 2026 · No. 25-0461 (Tex. 2026)
Ordered a trial court to compel appraisal on a water damage claim. A possible coverage dispute does not defeat the right to appraisal, an insurer's alleged bad faith in handling the claim does not excuse the insured from appraisal, and a party needs only a disagreement about the amount of loss, not an impasse, to demand it.
Limits: Commercial property policy, decided on mandamus before any appraisal. The court did not decide what the panel may do at the award stage or that no coverage disputes remain.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Nashville Communications, Inc. v. Auto-Owners (Mutual) Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, M.D. Tennessee · November 13, 2025 · No. 3:24-cv-01020, Doc. 47
The court held an award replacing the whole roof binding as to the amount of loss, with scope of work within the panel's power, but rejected a bad-faith penalty claim because the insurer had substantial legal grounds to dispute causation.
Limits: Federal trial court. Opinion signed 2025-11-12, filed 2025-11-13.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Leonard v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Ohio Court of Appeals, 12th District (Butler County) · November 10, 2025 · 2025-Ohio-5089 (Nos. CA2024-07-091, CA2024-09-113)
The court affirmed the denial of a motion to compel appraisal. Whether code required a full roof replacement and whether the policy covered it were law and coverage questions that the policy kept out of appraisal. State Farm had reasonable justification, so the bad faith claim failed.
Limits: Homeowner policy. Rests on this policy's express exclusions. The court did not decide whether causation can go to appraisal, and said the dispute was not about causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit (Indiana law) · July 25, 2025 · No. 24-1307
Predicting Indiana law, the court held an umpire acted within his authority when he decided hail, not wear and tear, damaged the roofs, and the award was binding. Appraisers may not decide liability. The policy's right-to-deny clause keeps defenses unrelated to the award but does not let the insurer refuse to pay because it disagrees on cause.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Indiana law; not binding on Indiana state courts. It notes Indiana courts have not squarely decided causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Morris v. Access Home Ins. Co.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Third Circuit · May 21, 2025 · No. 25-25 (La. App. 3 Cir. 5/21/25) (writ denied; memorandum opinion)
The policy endorsement made appraisal non-binding, and that language was not ambiguous, so the insureds could not get summary judgment on the appraisal amounts. Their concession that the appraisers could not always say which hurricane caused what damage was itself a genuine fact dispute.
Limits: Memorandum opinion on a writ application (Hurricanes Laura and Delta, LIGA after the insurer failed). The Louisiana Supreme Court declined to consider a further writ as untimely (No. 2025-CC-00989, Nov. 12, 2025), without reaching the merits.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Zhao v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Illinois Appellate Court, Second District · May 12, 2025 · 2025 IL App (2d) 240723
The court ordered appraisal of a hail claim where the insurer called the window dispute a coverage question. Coverage and law are for the court, but some causation questions are part of setting the amount of loss. A late-notice defense did not stop appraisal.
Limits: One published Second District decision on a State Farm homeowners policy. Federal courts in Illinois have gone both ways on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
3201 St. Charles Avenue Condominium Homeowners Ass'n v. Lexington Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. La. · April 30, 2025 · No. 23-2314, Rec. Doc. 28
The court said appraisers may make causation findings where an exclusion is disputed and that the insurer can still deny coverage after. An insurer could not narrow appraisal to wind damage only. But the insured waited about two and a half years after its demand, far past a reasonable time, so appraisal was denied.
Limits: Federal decision on a Hurricane Ida policy that said the insurer keeps its right to deny the claim after appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
BRE Hotels & Resorts LLC v. ACE American Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · September 11, 2024 · No. 1:24-cv-00159-MWJS-KJM, ECF No. 47
The court compelled appraisal of storm losses at two resorts. A dispute over whether the storm or old construction defects damaged tile underlayment is a factual causation question the panel may decide. Whether the policy pays to replace matching undamaged tiles is coverage, for the court. Claimed non-cooperation did not block appraisal without a showing of harm.
Limits: Federal court; did not decide whether Hawaii or New York law applied; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Holaday v. Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids, Michigan
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · August 20, 2024 · No. 1 CA-CV 23-0541 (mem. decision)
A homeowners policy limited appraisal to the amount of loss and barred it from deciding causation or whether an item is insured. The panel did not decide those issues, so it did not exceed its powers, but the trial court was wrong to confirm the award and enter judgment while causation and coverage were still open. The award is the ceiling on the amount of loss once those are decided.
Limits: Memorandum decision, not precedent under Ariz. Sup. Ct. R. 111(c). Decided on the policy wording. The court did not decide whether causation is inherently part of appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Anderson v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · August 13, 2024 · No. 1 CA-CV 23-0611 (mem. decision)
The policy let appraisers decide only the amount of loss, and the appraisers did not decide causation or coverage. The trial court was wrong to treat the award as settling them, so its confirmation order, the judgment and the fee award were vacated and the case sent back. A party need not file a separate suit before appraisal to keep these defenses.
Limits: Memorandum decision, not precedent under Ariz. Sup. Ct. R. 111(c). Decided on the policy wording. The court declined to adopt or rely on federal or out-of-state cases.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Thompson v. Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · June 25, 2024 · No. 1:22-cv-02379-JMC (D. Md.)
The court compelled appraisal of a homeowner's roof claim. Whether particular damage is covered is outside the appraisal clause, so appraisers had to itemize and the insurer could contest coverage afterward. Filing complaints and suit did not waive appraisal without actual prejudice.
Limits: Federal magistrate judge ruling; does not bind Maryland state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Bojovic v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · May 23, 2024 · Docket No. 362469 (unpublished)
Once the insurer admitted the water leak was covered, disputes over whether damage to the bathroom and sunroom came from the leak were scope-of-loss questions for the appraiser, not coverage questions for the court. The insured must still prove each loss was caused by the covered event.
Limits: Unpublished, so not binding precedent. Relies on Cantina (2024).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Detroit Club Management Corp. v. Cincinnati Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · March 25, 2024 · No. 22-13057
A dispute over which parts of a building the smoke actually damaged is a factual question for appraisers, not a coverage question for the court. Courts in the district have taken a broad view of Kwaiser.
Limits: Federal, commercial policy, not binding on state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
American Coastal Insurance Co. v. San Marco Villas Condominium Ass'n
Supreme Court of Florida · February 1, 2024 · No. SC2021-0883 (Fla. 2024)
A trial court has discretion over the order in which coverage and amount-of-loss issues are decided. It may compel appraisal while a coverage defense such as fraud is still open. Coverage defenses stay outside appraisal and are decided in court.
Limits: Did not decide whether the trial court abused its discretion on the facts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cantina Enterprises II Inc. v. Property-Owners Insurance Co.
Michigan Court of Appeals · January 18, 2024 · 349 Mich App 682; 28 NW3d 800 (Docket No. 363105)
Partial payments waived the policy's 60-day proof-of-loss deadline. Where the insurer admitted the fire was covered, a fight over which items count as business personal property was an amount-of-loss question and the court had to order appraisal and name an umpire. Agency bulletins are advisory only.
Limits: Published. Read narrowly by Maksym (2026).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Groenig v. Safeco Insurance Co. of America
U.S. District Court, D. Idaho · September 21, 2023 · No. 1:20-cv-00538-BLW (Dkt. 77)
Appraisers set the amount only for items they were asked about and left denied roof and crawlspace items as coverage issues. The insured could sue on those items. Bad faith failed because the claim was fairly debatable, despite a complaint that the insurer's appraiser was biased.
Limits: Federal trial court summary judgment order. Not binding Idaho law.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Montler v. Belfor USA Group, Inc. (First American Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co.)
Washington Court of Appeals, Division III (unpublished) · August 31, 2023 · No. 39497-2-III, 28 Wn. App. 2d 1006 (unpublished)
The trial court did not have to enforce appraisal awards that expressly left coverage out while causation and coverage of mold damage were still disputed. Awards are otherwise binding on the amount of loss absent proof of bias. The insurer's delay in naming an appraiser did not violate IFCA, and the Olympic Steamship fee award was reversed because the insured obtained nothing beyond what she had already been paid.
Limits: Unpublished, nonbinding. The court did not decide whether appraisers may decide causation. Review denied 2024 (No. 102421-5).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Krafchow v. Dongbu Insurance Co.
Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals (published opinion) · February 17, 2023 · 152 Hawai‘i 248, 525 P.3d 697; Nos. CAAP-21-0000513 and CAAP-21-0000517
The appraisal clauses in a homeowners policy and two dwelling fire policies are arbitration agreements under chapter 658A. Because the panel was to set "the amount of loss", the appraiser and umpire had to value what the insured lost to the wildfire, not decide coverage or what the insurer owed. Awards that ordered payment of set amounts were vacated.
Limits: Reads policies that do not define "loss". Does not decide who decides causation. The Hawaii Supreme Court rejected certiorari on June 30, 2023.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · January 25, 2023 · No. 1:19-cv-04875-JPH-MG, Dkt. 94 (reconsideration denied 2023-08-18, Dkt. 111)
The umpire's finding that hail caused the roof damage, and its dollar value, were binding. The policy's "right to deny the claim" clause keeps other defenses alive but does not let the insurer ignore the award because it disagrees on cause. The court said earlier S.D. Indiana decisions leaving causation to the court came before Villas.
Limits: Federal trial court. Affirmed by the Seventh Circuit on 2025-07-25 (No. 24-1307).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Estate of Mattingly v. State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · January 18, 2023 · No. 3:21-cv-274-RGJ, 2023 WL 320004
The court compelled appraisal and let the panel decide whether a June 2019 hailstorm caused the damage, and its amount, even though the policy did not say the panel decides cause. The panel could not include damage outside the policy period.
Limits: Federal court; the filed stamp reads January 19, 2023, the order is dated January 18.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cunningham v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Oregon · December 27, 2022 · No. 6:21-cv-00264-MK (D. Or.)
After an appraisal award, the insurer could still decide what the policy covered. The appraisers' statements about which damage they priced were evidence, and a fact question on coverage survived. The good-faith claim failed because State Farm acted timely and denied loss it believed was excluded.
Limits: Federal summary judgment ruling by a magistrate judge. It did not decide whether appraisers may make causation findings.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Haddock v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · November 1, 2022 · 638 F. Supp. 3d 748 (No. 4:21-cv-12395)
Predicting Michigan law, the court held that appraisers may, and must, decide whether claimed damage came from the covered cause of loss once the insurer admits a covered loss. True coverage defenses are still for the court first.
Limits: Federal prediction of Michigan law; not binding on Michigan courts. Amended opinion; the original of 2022-10-25 differed only in a statutory citation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Point-O-Woods, LLC v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · August 31, 2022 · No. 2:22-cv-54-KS-MTP
Motion to compel appraisal denied without prejudice. The court said appraisal cannot decide causation or coverage, only value, and that disputed causation and coverage should be decided first.
Limits: Federal district court, Hurricane Zeta apartment-complex claim; reads Kuehn narrowly and disagrees that appraisal may go first.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Westview Village v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Ohio · August 22, 2022 · No. 1:22-cv-00549, 2022 WL 3584263
A federal judge applying Ohio law predicted the Ohio Supreme Court would let an appraisal panel decide causation when the policy does not take it out. He relied on Saba's reference to the "extent" of the loss.
Limits: Federal court prediction of Ohio law; no state court has decided it. The policy there did not define "amount of loss" or exclude causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Mudd's Furniture Showrooms, Inc.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · March 28, 2022 · No. 4:19-CV-186-JHM
The court vacated an appraisal award because the insured's appraiser was not impartial: his fee deal gave no pay without added recovery, he promised a referral fee to the assignee roofer, and he set out to add scope. It did not decide whether the umpire exceeded his authority on cause.
Limits: Federal summary judgment on these facts; the opinion is signed March 28, 2022 and stamped filed March 29.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Brewer v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District · March 8, 2022 · 641 S.W.3d 445 (No. WD84331)
A dispute over how much damage there was and what repairs it needs, where the insurer says parts are not covered, is a coverage dispute. The appraisal clause does not reach it, so appointing an umpire was wrong. The court dismissed the umpire petition without prejudice as premature.
Limits: Rental dwelling policy. Coverage issues must be settled first; appraisal may follow.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Klass v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court · January 11, 2022 · 341 Conn. 735, SC 20451
When the insurer concedes a covered peril, the extent of its duty to replace undamaged adjacent items so they match is part of the amount of loss and goes to appraisal. The court said coverage is a legal question for the courts, treated causation as a different question, and declined to take sides in the out-of-state split on whether appraisers may decide causation.
Limits: Homeowner's wind loss and the matching statute, § 38a-316e. The coverage line is a footnote the parties agreed to, not a holding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Axis Surplus Ins. Co. v. Condor Corp.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit · December 7, 2021 · No. 21-1022 (8th Cir.)
Applying Minnesota law, a dispute over whether hail damage came before or during the policy period is part of the amount of loss, so the appraisers decide it.
Limits: A federal decision on Minnesota law, not binding on Minnesota courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
BonBeck Parker, LLC v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of America
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · October 1, 2021 · 14 F.4th 1169 (No. 20-1192)
Applying Colorado law, the phrase "amount of loss" in a commercial hail policy unambiguously includes causation disputes, so an appraisal panel could decide whether hail caused the disputed roof damage.
Limits: Federal court predicting Colorado law because the Colorado Supreme Court has not ruled; does not bind Colorado state courts. Commercial property policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hart v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan · August 21, 2021 · 556 F. Supp. 3d 735 (No. 2:20-cv-10573)
Applying Michigan law, nine add-on appraisal conditions in a State Farm homeowners form were void as contrary to the statute. These included advance itemized documentation, a ban on demanding appraisal after suing, extra notice before asking a judge for an umpire, mandatory professional licenses for appraisers, and bars on appraisers with a financial interest.
Limits: Federal district court, not binding on Michigan state courts. It kept the bar on an umpire with a financial interest.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
DC Plastic Products Corp. v. Westchester Surplus Lines Insurance Co.
United States District Court, District of New Jersey · May 19, 2021 · Civil Action No. 17-13092 (SRC) (unpublished)
The court ordered appraisal of the amount of a Superstorm Sandy property loss and said it would appoint an umpire if the appraisers could not agree. Outstanding coverage issues did not have to be decided first, because appraisers cannot decide liability and the insurer kept its right to deny.
Limits: A federal district court applying New Jersey law, unpublished, on a commercial policy whose wording let a court appoint the umpire.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hill v. Auto-Owners (Mutual) Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, E.D. Tennessee · November 30, 2020 · No. 4:19-cv-78, Doc. 39, 2020 WL 7034321
Following Batts, the court held that causation and coverage are for the courts, not the umpire, while admitting it is hard to separate them from the appraised loss.
Limits: Federal trial court on a motion to dismiss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Parko Properties, LLC v. Mercer Insurance Co. of New Jersey
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · November 19, 2020 · No. A-4137-17T2 (unpublished)
The trial court decided coverage first, then sent only the amount of loss to appraisal, and the appraisers agreed on a figure. The insurer did not act in bad faith. The insured could still recover fees, costs and interest under the offer-of-judgment rule after the appraisal, because appraisal is not court-annexed arbitration.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent under R. 1:36-3. A commercial collapse claim. The footnote on waiver of challenges to an appraiser is a passing remark.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit (Indiana law) · November 8, 2019 · 942 F.3d 824
The appraisal clause was unambiguous and the signed award was binding. The umpire settled the dispute the parties put to him, the amount of hail damage, and did not decide coverage. The mere presence of a coverage dispute does not undo an award.
Limits: Federal appeals court applying Indiana law. Not a decision of an Indiana court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Walnut Creek Townhome Ass’n v. Depositors Insurance Co.
Iowa Supreme Court · June 1, 2018 · 913 N.W.2d 80 (No. 16-0121)
Appraisers may decide the factual cause of damage to work out the amount of loss. Coverage questions go to the court. The award is presumptively binding on the parties and the court. A policy sentence reserving the insurer’s right to deny the claim was unenforceable to the extent it changed the standard fire policy wording.
Limits: Opinion amended August 10, 2018. Preexisting damage and anti-concurrent-cause questions were left for the trial court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Matter of Louati v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.
Appellate Division, First Department · May 31, 2018 · 161 AD3d 701, 2018 NY Slip Op 03908
Whether water damage came from a covered burst pipe or an excluded cause must be settled before appraisal. Factual disputes about how much tile needed replacing belong in appraisal.
Limits: Dismissal was without prejudice to a new proceeding after coverage is decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Greenbrier Hotel Corp. v. Lexington Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. West Virginia · November 29, 2017 · No. 5:14-cv-15201 (Doc. 93)
The court refused to vacate a business interruption appraisal award. It said West Virginia has not recently set the test, read older cases to allow vacatur for fraud, corruption, partiality, misconduct, clerical or plain errors or an award outside the clause, and would not second-guess the panel's method. Because the insurers paid the award promptly and the insured did not substantially prevail, Hayseeds damages were refused.
Limits: Federal court predicting West Virginia law. Commercial property policies. Mentions causation evidence but does not rule on whether a panel may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kellogg v. Middlesex Mutual Assurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court · August 22, 2017 · 326 Conn. 638, 165 A.3d 1228
A trial court wrongly vacated a homeowner appraisal award after weighing the evidence itself. Where the submission is unrestricted, a court may vacate only on the statutory grounds, and a challenge for misconduct is limited to whether a party was denied a full and fair hearing. Disagreeing with the amount is not a ground. The panel's reading of the policy on depreciation was not a manifest disregard of the law.
Limits: Restorationist policy with an unrestricted arbitration clause. No one claimed the umpire or appraisers were partial.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Glenn Homeowners Ass’n v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Iowa Court of Appeals · July 6, 2017 · No. 16-0912
The court enforced the award. Appraisal does not violate due process. The causation finding was binding because no fraud, mistake or misfeasance was shown. An appraiser who testified elsewhere that he would say what his client asked was not shown to be partial, because appraisers may act as advocates.
Limits: Policy said "competent and impartial". Decided before Walnut Creek and before chapter 522F.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
In re Appointment of Umpire for Hayes Family Trust v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit · January 4, 2017 · 845 F.3d 997 (10th Cir. 2017), No. 15-6164
Under Oklahoma law an award binds only the party that invoked appraisal and settles only the amount of loss, not coverage or causation. When the insurer paid an award it had not invoked and the insured accepted, the dispute over the amount was settled, so the trial court rightly vacated its judgment confirming the award. Fees and interest under 36 O.S. 3629(B) need a judgment.
Limits: Federal court predicting Oklahoma law. The reporter cite 845 F.3d 997 is confirmed by the court's April 19, 2017 order in No. 15-6231, not printed on the slip opinion.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
St. Croix Trading Co./Direct Logistics, LLC v. Regent Insurance Co.
Wisconsin Court of Appeals (published) · May 24, 2016 · 2016 WI App 49, 370 Wis. 2d 248, 882 N.W.2d 487
The court affirmed vacatur of an appraisal award because the panel exceeded its authority by deciding which losses were covered. The panel's task was to value the property and the amount of loss. The court said no Wisconsin case was on point and did not decide whether panels may decide causation or whether the insurer's appraiser was impartial.
Limits: Commercial policy that kept the insurer's right to deny the claim. Does not decide causation, impartiality or bad faith (n.1).
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Co. v. C.F.L.P. 1, LLC (umpire appointed)
U.S. District Court, W.D. Kentucky · September 30, 2015 · No. 3:14-cv-40-DJH-DW, 2015 WL 5793951
The court appointed an experienced umpire over bias objections. It said cause and amount of loss are for the umpire and the scope of coverage is for the court, and refused to instruct the umpire that cosmetic matching was required.
Limits: Federal court; the Sixth Circuit affirmed in 2018.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Moran Industries, Inc. v. Erie Insurance Exchange
Superior Court of Pennsylvania · September 29, 2015 · No. 1835 MDA 2014
A panel that limited a collapse loss to one side of a building stayed within its authority. An umpire's averaging mistake is not a ground to vacate, and appraisers are final judges of law and fact unless the submission limits them.
Limits: Non-precedential memorandum.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lee v. California Capital Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist., Div. 3 · June 18, 2015 · 237 Cal.App.4th 1154, 188 Cal.Rptr.3d 753 (No. A136280)
A court may order appraisal of items where coverage or causation is disputed, as long as the panel only values them and the award does not decide coverage. It was error to make the panel value items that inspection showed were undamaged or never existed, and confirmation was reversed.
Limits: Also states the vacatur grounds in Code Civ. Proc. 1286.2 are exclusive.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cedar Bluff Townhome Condo. Ass'n v. Am. Fam. Mut. Ins. Co.
Minnesota Supreme Court · December 17, 2014 · 857 N.W.2d 290 (No. A13-0124)
Questions of fact that are mere incidents of the amount of loss, such as a reasonable color match for replacement siding, can be decided by the appraisal panel. The award for full siding replacement was affirmed.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Dixon
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District · December 16, 2014 · 450 S.W.3d 831 (No. ED101609)
Appraisal applies only to a dispute over the amount of a covered loss. Where the insurer said the concrete damage was wear and tear, not hail, that was a coverage dispute and appraisal could not settle it. The arbitration ban for insurance contracts was part of the reasoning.
Limits: Summary judgment for the insurer reversed and remanded on a limited record.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point
U.S. District Court, S.D. Indiana · September 3, 2014 · 44 F. Supp. 3d 813
The court let the insured demand appraisal even though the insurer said most roof damage came from poor construction, not a storm. It reasoned that an appraiser cannot set the storm-damage amount without separating storm from non-storm damage. It also noted the policy lets the insurer deny the claim after appraisal. The court said Indiana courts had not spoken authoritatively on this.
Limits: Federal trial court order on a motion to dismiss. No state appellate decision on causation was found.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Currie v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Pennsylvania · August 19, 2014 · No. 13-6713, 2014 WL 4081051
A dispute over how much damage a storm caused, or whether a covered peril caused part of it, is an amount-of-loss dispute for appraisal, not a coverage dispute. State Farm's refusal to appraise could not be excused as a coverage issue at summary judgment.
Limits: Federal court applying Pennsylvania law; not binding on state courts. Treats an insurer's exclusion argument as a true coverage dispute.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
German Automotive of Tinton Falls, Inc. v. Harleysville Insurance Co. of New Jersey
New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division · July 29, 2014 · No. A-2571-13T3 (unpublished)
A policy appraisal clause limited to the 'amount of loss' is not an arbitration agreement and does not cover disputes about the extent of damage, the scope of work or the cause of the damage. Insureds who litigated for 21 months before moving to compel arbitration had waived any such right.
Limits: Unpublished and not precedent under R. 1:36-3. A garage owners policy; the motion sought arbitration, not an order for appraisal alone.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Glenn Homeowners Ass’n v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Iowa Court of Appeals · July 16, 2014 · 854 N.W.2d 67 (No. 13-0859)
Causation is part of the definition of loss, so appraisers must consider it. Once a party demands appraisal, the appraisal goes forward and other rulings wait. The appraisal does not decide coverage.
Limits: Interlocutory appeal. Whether an award is conclusive depends on the damage, the causes and the form of the award.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Lam v. Allstate Indemnity Co.
Court of Appeals of Georgia (whole court) · March 26, 2014 · 327 Ga. App. 151, 755 S.E.2d 544 (No. A13A1733)
Where the insurer admitted wind damaged some shingles but the parties disagreed how much of the roof the wind damaged, the majority held that was a coverage dispute, not a proper basis for appraisal.
Limits: Decided four to three. The dissent would have treated it as a dispute over the amount of covered loss.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Pilkenton v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.
Appellate Division, Fourth Department · December 27, 2013 · 112 AD3d 1327, 2013 NY Slip Op 08709
Appraisal under section 3408(c) applies to a covered loss. While a lawsuit over whether the loss is covered was pending, the court refused to order appraisal.
Limits: Short memorandum decision.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Artist Building Partners v. Auto-Owners Mutual Insurance Co.
Tennessee Court of Appeals · November 21, 2013 · 435 S.W.3d 202
A panel may decide matters that the policy and the parties expressly sent to it, including the repair time frame and business income loss, and that decision is binding.
Limits: Commercial fire loss. The panel had express agreement to decide these issues.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ex parte Tower Insurance Co. of New York (In re Cullman Bowling Center, LLC v. Tower Insurance Co. of New York)
Supreme Court of Alabama · August 23, 2013 · 140 So. 3d 456; No. 1120228
The court denied the insurer's mandamus petition against an order appointing an umpire, with no opinion. A concurring justice said Rogers means coverage disputes are not for appraisers or umpires.
Limits: No majority opinion; the concurrence is not controlling.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
McDonnell v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.
Alaska Supreme Court · April 26, 2013 · 299 P.3d 715 (Alaska 2013), Nos. S-14378, S-14407
The mandatory appraisal statute covers disputes over the value of a loss to property, not personal injury claims. In explaining why appraisal differs from arbitration, the court remarked that coverage, causation and liability are not resolved by appraisal.
Limits: An uninsured-motorist injury case, not a property claim. The remark about coverage and causation supports the holding; it is not itself a ruling on what a property appraisal panel may decide.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Audubon Hill South Condominium Ass'n v. Community Ass'n Underwriters of America, Inc.
Massachusetts Appeals Court · September 20, 2012 · 82 Mass. App. Ct. 461, 975 N.E.2d 458
A reference award of the amount of loss did not decide coverage. The insurer had reserved coverage in writing seven times, cited § 101E, and the referees stayed out of it. The court then decided the loss fell under an earth movement exclusion.
Limits: Different facts from Augenstein, where the insurer reserved nothing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Quade v. Secura Ins.
Minnesota Supreme Court · June 12, 2012 · 814 N.W.2d 703 (No. A10-0714)
Deciding the amount of loss includes deciding what caused it, such as separating storm damage from earlier wear. Whether damage is excluded is a coverage question for the court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kochendorfer v. Metropolitan Property & Casualty Ins. Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Washington · April 11, 2012 · No. C11-1162-MAT
Applying Washington law, the court confirmed an appraisal award for a house fire and granted summary judgment for the insured on the awarded loss-of-use, code-upgrade and remediation amounts, because the insurer challenged amounts rather than coverage and showed no unfairness in the appraisal. Coverage questions stay with the court.
Limits: Federal magistrate judge order; not binding on Washington courts. An earlier order confirming the award is dated November 22, 2011.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dufrene v. Certain Interested Underwriters at Lloyd's of London
Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fifth Circuit · March 27, 2012 · 91 So. 3d 397, 11-CA-1002
The trial court could appoint an umpire and set fair-process rules, such as no one-sided contact with the umpire. A challenger must show an appraiser honesty or integrity is suspect to remove him. The award was binding because the umpire and appraiser did their duties, and the challenger carried the burden. The court called the issue before the umpire the amount of damage, not causation.
Limits: Hurricane Katrina wind claim; the policy said a decision of any two is binding. The causation remark came in a ruling on excluding documents, not a holding on appraiser power.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange
Supreme Court of South Dakota · July 6, 2011 · 2011 S.D. 35, 800 N.W.2d 726
The insured invoked the policy's appraisal clause and an umpire set the repair cost. The court held the appraisal clause does not change the loss-settlement terms: the insurer pays actual cash value until repairs are done, and the claim stays open for newly found damage. The clause there said an appraisal decision was not binding.
Limits: Did not decide whether appraisal may be demanded or how SDCL 21-25A-3 applies. The policy language, not the court, supplied the nonbinding rule.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. v. Sadler
Supreme Court of North Carolina · June 16, 2011 · 365 N.C. 178, 711 S.E.2d 114, No. 267PA10
The policy's appraisal process decides only the amount of loss, not coverage. The insurer may still cut or deny an award under exclusions and limits, and the trial court must first resolve fact questions about what the covered loss is.
Limits: Based on the policy's own wording, which barred appraisal from deciding causation or coverage. It does not cite G.S. 58-44-16. Does not say what happens when a policy is silent on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hull v. Motorists Insurance Group
Ohio Court of Appeals, 9th District (Summit County) · May 25, 2011 · 2011-Ohio-2502 (C.A. No. 25643)
The trial court could appoint an umpire under the policy but had no power to bar the panel from considering causation. The appeals court called the causation question a matter of substantial debate and declined to decide it.
Limits: Commercial property policy. Resolved on the limits of the court's power, not on whether panels may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hahn v. Allstate Insurance Co.
Rhode Island Supreme Court · March 31, 2011 · 15 A.3d 1026
An insurer must go to appraisal when the dispute is the amount or extent of loss and it does not deny coverage for the loss. Causation and amount were treated as intertwined. A real coverage dispute can be litigated, but the insurer must say specifically why.
Limits: Fire loss; the insurer did not deny the claim as a whole.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
LeBlanc v. Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Co.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Oklahoma · March 23, 2011 · No. CIV-10-00503-HE, 2011 WL 1107126 (W.D. Okla.)
Predicting how Oklahoma's Supreme Court would rule from Massey, the court held an umpire went beyond what Oklahoma allows by deciding what caused the damage. The amount the umpire set to repair the house could be used, but causation stayed for the court. The invoking party, not only the other side, may challenge an award.
Limits: Unpublished federal trial court order on a homeowner policy, not binding on Oklahoma state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kirkwood v. California State Automobile Association Inter-Insurance Bureau
California Court of Appeal, 1st Dist. · February 28, 2011 · 193 Cal.App.4th 49
Appraisers have no power to interpret the policy or the governing statutes. The court upheld denying a motion to compel appraisal so a declaratory relief action on the depreciation method could go first.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
North Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. v. Sadler
North Carolina Court of Appeals · May 18, 2010 · 204 N.C. App. 145, 693 S.E.2d 266, No. COA09-1054
The insurer did not name an appraiser within 20 days of the insured's demand or for a month after, so the trial court properly appointed an umpire without an appraiser for the insurer. Appraisers who considered the known cause of damage while valuing the loss did not exceed their role.
Limits: Reversed in full by the supreme court in 2011 on the coverage issue; the umpire ruling was not discussed but the judgment fell. The umpire was appointed in 2006, before the 2013 notice and hearing rules in G.S. 58-44-35.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Coates v. Erie Insurance Exchange
Fairfax County Circuit Court · November 4, 2009 · 79 Va. Cir. 440
Where the insurer admitted the event was covered and the dispute was how much had to be repaired, the dispute was about amount of loss and the insurer had to go to appraisal. Coverage questions remain for the courts.
Limits: Trial court opinion, not binding. Relied on out-of-state decisions. The insurer there did not dispute what caused the damage.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kuehn v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Mississippi · August 17, 2009 · No. 1:08CV577 LTS-RHW, 2009 WL 2567485
An appraisal award was upheld. Appraisers may not decide disputed causation, but Munn does not bar an appraisal where both sides' appraisers agree on what is in and out. Awards are presumed valid and set aside only for fraud, substantial mistake or lack of authority.
Limits: Federal district court predicting Mississippi law; Hurricane Katrina homeowner claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
State Farm Lloyds v. Johnson
Supreme Court of Texas · July 3, 2009 · 290 S.W.3d 886 (Tex. 2009), No. 06-1071
A hail damage dispute over how much of a roof was damaged is an amount of loss question for the appraisers. Every appraisal involves some causation, appraisers set the amount of loss but not liability, and appraisal should usually go forward before a court steps in.
Limits: Homeowners policy. The court did not decide whether the resulting award would be binding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rogers v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Supreme Court of Alabama · October 12, 2007 · 984 So. 2d 382; No. 1051458
Appraisers decide only the amount of loss. Coverage and causation disputes belong to the courts. An insurer that invoked appraisal almost two years after the loss and 14 months into the suit did not waive it, because the insureds did not show substantial prejudice.
Limits: Homeowner policy with "amount of loss" wording. Two justices dissented in part on causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kacha v. Allstate Insurance Co.
California Court of Appeal, 4th Dist., Div. 1 · June 1, 2006 · 140 Cal.App.4th 1023, 45 Cal.Rptr.3d 92 (No. D046961)
A panel exceeds its powers by deciding whether claimed items were damaged by the fire, which is causation and coverage. The insured did not waive the rule by agreeing to an award form, and holding the insurer's checks without cashing them did not bar him. The award was ordered vacated.
Limits: Wildfire loss under a standard form homeowners policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Motorists Mutual Insurance Co. v. Post
U.S. District Court, E.D. Kentucky · October 20, 2005 · No. 04-487-JBC, 2005 WL 2674987
The court ordered appraisal and let the panel decide both cause and amount of loss, limited to damage from the named wind and ice storms. Whether the policy covers an event is for the court.
Limits: Federal court applying Kentucky law; the denial rested on fact-sensitive defenses the court could not decide yet.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Kendall Lakes Townhomes Developers, Inc. v. Agricultural Excess & Surplus Lines Insurance Co.
Florida Third District Court of Appeal · October 5, 2005 · 916 So. 2d 12 (Fla. 3d DCA 2005), No. 3D04-3094
The insurer had not wholly denied coverage, so the appraisal panel could decide causation. But the umpire went beyond the task the trial court set and made coverage findings, so the order affirming the award was reversed and appraisal was sent to a new umpire.
Limits: Turned on the trial court's order limiting the umpire's role; does not set a general test for vacating awards.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
HHC Associates v. Assurance Co. of America
U.S. District Court, E.D. Virginia · April 17, 2003 · 256 F. Supp. 2d 505
Section 38.2-2105 appraisal applies when the parties disagree on the amount of loss, not whether coverage exists. An insurer that denied the whole claim as wear and tear rather than storm damage did not act in bad faith by refusing appraisal.
Limits: Federal court predicting Virginia law; it noted no Virginia court had decided the point. Its footnote on appraisers weighing causation summarizes a Delaware case.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
AIU Insurance Co. v. Lexes
Delaware Supreme Court · January 15, 2003 · 815 A.2d 312
A party may sue to decide whether appraisers had authority to award more than the policy limits or for items the policy excludes, even when the policy makes appraisal binding. That is a question of law for the court. The court did not disturb the appraisers' valuations.
Limits: Automobile policy. It cites Didimoi for the cause-of-loss point without adopting it.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Johnson v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Florida · September 26, 2002 · 828 So. 2d 1021 (Fla. 2002), Nos. SC01-91 & SC01-321
If the insurer wholly denies a covered loss, whether a covered cause produced the damage is a question for the court. If the insurer admits a covered loss and disputes the amount, the cause of the damage is for the appraisal panel.
Limits: Turns on whether the insurer wholly denies coverage or only disputes amount. San Marco (2024) says Johnson did not decide the order of coverage and appraisal.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Western National Mutual Insurance Co. v. University of North Dakota
Supreme Court of North Dakota · April 16, 2002 · 2002 ND 63, 643 N.W.2d 4
North Dakota's statutes codify the efficient proximate cause rule for property damage when a covered and an excluded peril both contribute. The court also upheld prejudgment interest on a certain amount and attorney fees to an insured who won coverage in court.
Limits: Not an appraisal case. Decided a coverage dispute for the court.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Co. v. Batts
Tennessee Court of Appeals · May 15, 2001 · 59 S.W.3d 142
An appraisal clause in a homeowners policy is not an arbitration agreement. The appraisers may set the amount of the loss but not decide coverage, liability or whether a peril caused a loss.
Limits: Applies to the homeowners form in the case. Published.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
CIGNA Insurance Co. v. Didimoi Property Holdings, N.V.
U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware · August 11, 2000 · 110 F. Supp. 2d 259
Applying Delaware law to a commercial property policy, the court held 'amount of loss' includes whether the fire caused the damage, so the appraisers may decide cause. Coverage and exclusion questions stay with the court.
Limits: Federal trial court, so not binding on Delaware courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Rastelli Brothers, Inc. v. Netherlands Insurance Co.
United States District Court, District of New Jersey · June 28, 1999 · 68 F. Supp. 2d 440 (D.N.J. 1999)
A property policy's appraisal clause covers only the amount of loss, not coverage, and the insurer kept its right to deny the claim. Where the insurer disputed only coverage, not the amount, the court declined to force appraisal under the Federal Arbitration Act.
Limits: A federal court applying New Jersey law, not a New Jersey court. Decided on the policy's own wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Minot Town & Country v. Fireman's Fund Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Dakota · December 22, 1998 · 1998 ND 215, 587 N.W.2d 189
A policy appraisal is not an arbitration, so North Dakota's Uniform Arbitration Act did not apply and the award stood. Appraisal fixes the amount of loss only, leaving liability for later decision.
Limits: The insured's argument that the insurer's appraiser was not impartial was not decided, because it was raised under the Arbitration Act. The policy kept the insurer's right to deny the claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · April 24, 1998 · 27 F. Supp. 2d 1211; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK
After the award was confirmed, the insurer could still contest mitigation, coverage and causation for the second period. A bad-faith claim for unreasonable delay may reach the time before, during and after appraisal, up to payment. The unfair claims statute gives no private right of action, but violations can be evidence of bad faith.
Limits: Federal court applying Hawaii law; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · September 26, 1997 · 27 F. Supp. 2d 1208; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK
The court confirmed an appraisal award in its entirety and refused to confirm only the part that favored the insured. Judicial review of the award is extremely narrow, and the panel’s time-period categories stayed within its authority.
Limits: Federal court under the Federal Arbitration Act; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wailua Associates v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
U.S. District Court, District of Hawaii · January 19, 1995 · 904 F. Supp. 1142; Civ. No. 94-00446 ACK
Under Hawaii law a binding appraisal clause is an arbitration agreement. The panel decides the value of the property before the storm and the damage it caused, and may consider code-upgrade costs, but may not decide coverage or liability.
Limits: Federal court applying the Federal Arbitration Act and Hawaii law; not binding on Hawaii state courts.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Massey v. Farmers Insurance Group
Oklahoma Supreme Court · June 2, 1992 · 1992 OK 80, 837 P.2d 880 (No. 75279)
An umpire's award under the statutory fire policy binds the party that demanded appraisal but not the party forced into it, because binding that party would deny its right to a jury. The court approved the view that appraisers decide only the amount of damage, and that awards generally cannot decide the cause of a loss.
Limits: Answered a certified question from the Tenth Circuit. The case involved no coverage or causation dispute. Two justices concurred in the result only. Corrected June 22, 1992; rehearing denied September 23, 1992.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Smithson v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · November 22, 1991 · 186 W. Va. 195, 411 S.E.2d 850, No. 20073
Paying a loss through an appraisal does not bar a first-party bad-faith suit if the insured substantially prevailed in the appraisal. An ordinary appraisal clause decides only the amount of loss, not coverage or policy defenses. The insurer that invoked appraisal could have asked a judge to name an umpire after fifteen days and instead let the matter drift, and the court noted that courts apply waiver and estoppel to appraisal.
Limits: Commercial policy on a truck and drilling rig. The coverage statement is reasoning, not the main holding.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Auto-Owners Insurance Co. v. Kwaiser
Michigan Court of Appeals · August 5, 1991 · 190 Mich App 482; 476 NW2d 467 (Docket No. 128236)
Appraisal replaces a court fight over the amount of loss. A court, not the appraisers, decides coverage, and it does so before appraisal if the parties disagree. Review of an award is limited to bad faith, fraud, misconduct or manifest mistake. The appraisers' amount for personal property they never saw stood, because that was about how to measure the loss.
Limits: Published. Mixed on causation: it kept an exclusion fight for the court but treated what items are in the loss as the appraisers' call.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Molodyh v. Truck Insurance Exchange
Oregon Supreme Court · November 3, 1987 · 304 Or 290, 744 P2d 992
Statutory appraisal is optional until one side demands it. After a demand, it is required before suit on the amount of loss, but the award binds only the party that demanded it, so the other keeps a jury trial. Appraisal fixes the amount of loss, not the insurer's liability.
Limits: Interprets former ORS 743.648 for fire policies. A footnote carries the scope statement.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Wausau Insurance Co. v. Herbert Halperin Distribution Corp.
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland · July 8, 1987 · 664 F. Supp. 987 (D. Md. 1987)
Maryland enforces appraisal clauses, but whether policy exclusions limit coverage is a contract question for the court, not appraisers. Disputes over how much repair the covered damage requires can be amount-of-loss questions for appraisal.
Limits: Federal ruling; the judge said the question was not easy and no clear answer was presented by the authorities.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hanson v. Commercial Union Insurance Co.
Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One · June 10, 1986 · 150 Ariz. 283, 723 P.2d 101
An appraisal panel under a fire policy has only the powers the policy gives it, here to appraise actual cash value and loss to each item. It has no power to decide coverage, deductibles or offsets, interest, or attorney and professional fees. Appraisal awards get arbitration-level finality but not for matters outside that power. Judgment confirming the award was reversed.
Limits: Fire policy whose clause called for competent and disinterested appraisers and umpire. The case was sent back for the court to decide whether the insurer waived its objection. It did not address causation as such.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Safeco Insurance Co. v. Sharma
California Court of Appeal · October 16, 1984 · 160 Cal.App.3d 1060, 207 Cal.Rptr. 104 (No. B004997)
Appraisers may decide only the value of the loss, not whether the insured lost what he claimed. A panel that decided the identity of stolen paintings exceeded its powers and the judgment confirming the award was reversed.
Limits: Theft loss on a standard form policy.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Erickson v. Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of North Dakota · October 28, 1981 · 311 N.W.2d 579
An umpire appointed by a district court fixed the amount of a windstorm loss under a standard-form clause. The insurer, by going through appraisal, conceded the cause, and had to pay the award.
Limits: The court noted the clause provided for appraisal, not arbitration, but decided on summary judgment based on the insurer's admissions. It did not decide whether a panel may decide cause on its own.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v. Wright
Nevada Supreme Court · June 24, 1981 · 97 Nev. 308, 629 P.2d 1202
Appraisers and an umpire went beyond their powers when they decided coverage (code upgrade costs) while setting the loss. The court affirmed vacating the award. Appraisers decide the amount of loss, not coverage.
Limits: Decided under the repealed arbitration act. Does not decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Elberon Bathing Co. v. Ambassador Insurance Co.
New Jersey Supreme Court · June 8, 1978 · 77 N.J. 1, 389 A.2d 439
An appraisal award that used replacement cost without subtracting depreciation did not measure actual cash value and was vacated for legal misconduct. Appraisal fixes only the amount of loss, not liability, and the Arbitration Act does not apply. Review of an award is narrow, but appraisers cannot make legal determinations.
Limits: A fire policy case. The court quotes the standard form clause from N.J.S.A. 17:36-5.20 but the quotation ends before the costs sentence. It does not address causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Sullivan v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Connecticut Supreme Court · February 7, 1978 · 174 Conn. 229, 384 A.2d 384
When the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire, a court must appoint one on request, even though the insurer denied liability and the appraisers disagree about how to measure actual cash value. The appraisers' job is limited to fixing the amount of loss. The chance that they might make a mistake is not a reason to refuse an umpire.
Limits: Decided under the former fire policy statute, § 38-98, whose appraisal text matches today's § 38a-307. The parties reserved waiver and estoppel from the insurer's denial for a later hearing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Augenstein v. Insurance Co. of North America
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · February 17, 1977 · 372 Mass. 30, 360 N.E.2d 320
Referees decide the amount of loss under the policy, including whether a loss happened. Their views on the policy's meaning are tentative, and a court can reexamine a disputed meaning later. Because the insurer never argued the referees misread the policy or attacked the award, the award was conclusive and the insured won.
Limits: Turns on the insurer's choice not to raise a policy-meaning issue. Later cases with a clear reservation, such as Audubon Hill, come out the other way.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ice City, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of North America
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · January 24, 1974 · 456 Pa. 210, 314 A.2d 236
A fire insurer cannot refuse the appraisal clause the statute requires. Appraisal is enforceable like arbitration, is the favored way to settle a dollar-value dispute once liability is admitted, and covers only the amount of loss.
Limits: Fire policy; the court did not decide whether appraisers may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Jefferson Insurance Co. of New York v. Superior Court
Supreme Court of California · October 29, 1970 · 3 Cal.3d 398, 475 P.2d 880 (S.F. No. 22752)
Appraisers who decided a question of law, the meaning of actual cash value, exceeded their powers, and the trial court properly vacated the award. An appraiser's declaration may be used to show what the panel treated as the issue.
Limits: Standard form fire policy; the legal question was the meaning of actual cash value under the policy's average clause.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Roumel v. Niagara Fire Insurance Co.
District of Columbia Court of Appeals · January 19, 1967 · 225 A.2d 658
After a fire loss the insurer demanded appraisal, then refused to go on. The court held that the refusal created no new claim; its only effect was that the insured could sue on the policy at once, and the twelve-month suit clause barred the late suit. In its reasoning it said appraisal only fixes the amount of loss, not liability or coverage, and that an award is conclusive proof of the damages while suit stays on the policy.
Limits: Old fire-policy form, decided before D.C.'s arbitration acts. The coverage and award statements are reasoning, not the holding. Does not mention causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
School District No. 1 of Silver Bow County v. Globe & Republic Insurance Co. of America
Montana Supreme Court · August 23, 1965 · 146 Mont. 208, 404 P.2d 889
The court upheld a fire-policy appraisal clause because it settles questions of fact only, and held an insurer's demand six days after suit, before service, came in reasonable time. It reversed a jury verdict and sent the loss, which turned on how much damage the fire caused as against an earthquake and vandalism, to appraisal.
Limits: Policy had no time limit for a demand. Timeliness is normally for the trial court. Whether appraisers may decide cause was not raised or decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Munn v. National Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford
Mississippi Supreme Court · October 26, 1959 · 237 Miss. 641, 115 So. 2d 54, No. 41206
Appraisers cannot decide the cause of the damage. They only value it. An appraisal is presumed correct, but a court may set it aside for gross inadequacy or excess amounting to fraud in effect, lack of authority, mistake of fact, or to prevent injustice.
Limits: Windstorm policy; decided 7 to 2, with a dissent that read the clause differently.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Harwell v. Home Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
South Carolina Supreme Court · February 6, 1956 · 228 S.C. 594, 91 S.E.2d 273
An appraisal clause that settles only the amount of loss is valid and does not oust the courts. When the policy bars suit until appraisal and the insurer demands it, an insured who refuses cannot sue until it is done.
Limits: Fire policy; the policy language on umpire selection and costs is quoted, not decided.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · June 2, 1953 · 330 Mass. 283
Referees must fix the loss under the policy, not all damage whether covered or not. They properly limited the award to lightning damage and left out wind damage. Their views on coverage are tentative and do not decide liability.
Limits: No one disputed how the policy words applied. An award can still be attacked for error in reading the policy. The insured dropped a bias claim.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Hawkinson Tread Tire Service Co. v. Indiana Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Missouri · December 10, 1951 · 362 Mo. 823, 245 S.W.2d 24
An appraisal clause is for setting the amount of loss. When the real dispute is what the policy means and how it applies, appraisal is not a condition to suing, because treating it as one would turn it into arbitration.
Limits: Business interruption policy, fire era. Cited by later courts as the source of the coverage versus amount-of-loss line.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Mutual Improvement Co. v. Merchants & Business Men's Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · May 17, 1932 · 112 W. Va. 291, No. 7315
The court upheld a fire appraisal award that gave sound value and loss under three views of who owned a party wall. It said the appraisers were not required to settle questions of law, only to find the sound value and the loss.
Limits: Decided in 1932 on a written submission. Not about causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Cleveland v. Home Insurance Co. of New York
South Carolina Supreme Court · May 1, 1929 · 150 S.C. 289, 148 S.E. 49
An award that did not follow the submission was invalid. Notice of the appraisers' meeting is not usually needed, but may be when evidence is needed. A mistake of judgment does not undo an award absent fraud or partiality.
Limits: Fire policy with a valued-policy statute; the notice and mistake points are partly in passing.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Maravas v. American Equitable Assurance Corp.
Supreme Court of New Hampshire · February 1, 1927 · 82 N.H. 533, 136 A. 364
The old referee clause is optional for the insured, and if the parties agree to a reference they are bound by a proper award. An award that decides none of the questions sent to the appraisers is void. The appraisers there said they could not tell whether the damage came from the fire, so the question went to the jury.
Limits: Pre-1960 referee clause. It does not say whether a panel may decide causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Ross v. German Alliance Insurance Co.
Kansas Supreme Court · December 9, 1911 · 86 Kan. 145, 119 P. 366
The court upheld a trial court's finding that an award was unfair and fixed the loss itself. An insurer appraiser's long record of insurer work was not itself a disqualification but could be weighed with his conduct, and the court said appraisers value the fire loss and do not decide the insurer's liability.
Limits: One justice dissented. The trial court's factual findings carried the result. Fire policy with competent and disinterested wording.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026
Dunton v. Westchester Fire Insurance Co.
Maine Supreme Judicial Court · September 15, 1908 · 104 Me. 372, 71 A. 1037
The standard policy's referees decide only the amount of damage. Who owns the property, and the insurer's general liability, are for the courts. The referees were right to refuse to hear evidence on title.
Limits: Decided under the earlier standard policy wording ("amount of loss or damage"), which was a condition precedent to suit. Does not mention causation.
Read the decisionChecked November 15, 2026