At a glance
New York writes the appraisal clause into statute. Under Ins. Law § 3404(e), each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser within 20 days of a written demand, and if the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire within 15 days, a judge of a court of record picks one. Loss is payable 60 days after proof of loss and a filed award. Section 3408 adds the court procedure: 5 days’ written notice of an umpire application, and an order compelling a party who refuses to appraise. Since 2014 it says appraisal decides actual cash value, replacement cost and "the extent of the loss or damage," is not an arbitration, and does not decide coverage. Regulation 64 adds business-day clocks for the insurer. The statute does not say whether the 20, 15 and 5 days are calendar or business days.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: yes
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No license; only an informal Department opinion on adjuster reach
Unsettled
We found no New York statute or rule that licenses or registers an appraiser or umpire. The public adjuster definition covers acting for an insured in negotiating or effecting the settlement of a claim and does not name appraising. A 2001 informal Department opinion (mostly about auto claims) says merely performing an appraisal is not adjusting, but an adjuster's work may include appraising. That opinion is agency guidance, not binding law, and no court has ruled on the point. Someone who also negotiates or settles the claim for the insured may need a public adjuster license.
acts or aids in any manner on behalf of an insured in negotiating for, or effecting, the settlement of a claim
Property claims. The 2001 opinion is informal, mostly about motor vehicle claims, and not binding on any court.
Contingency fees
No New York rule on contingent-fee appraisers found
No state rule found
We found no statute, regulation, Department opinion or court decision that says a fee based on the size of the award disqualifies an appraiser. The law requires each appraiser to be competent and disinterested, and the Court of Appeals has said disinterested means not biased or prejudiced, not just free of a money stake in the loss. No New York court has applied that to a contingent fee. The Department's consumer page says a public adjuster's fee may not be higher than 12.5 percent of the recovery; that cap is for public adjusters, not appraisers.
Property appraisal under the standard fire policy and homeowners forms.
Court decisions: Bradshaw v Agricultural Ins. Co. of Watertown
Impartiality
Appraisers and umpire must be competent and disinterested (unbiased)
Each side's appraiser and the umpire must be competent and disinterested. The Court of Appeals has said disinterested means not biased or prejudiced, and is not limited to having no money at stake. A party appraiser may bring out facts that help the side that chose him, but he is not that side's agent and must stay fair. Repeated past work for one side can support a finding of bias. Whether an appraiser is disinterested is a question of fact for a court; the Department says neither side may simply reject the other's choice. Bare claims of bias, without proof, do not undo an award.
each shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser
Standard fire policy and homeowners forms, which must be no less favorable to the insured. The leading cases are from the 1890s but have not been overruled.
Court decisions: Bradshaw v Agricultural Ins. Co. of Watertown; Kiernan v Dutchess County Mut. Ins. Co.; Hemingway v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.; Matter of Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v Seibert
Umpire selection
Appraisers pick; after 15 days a court picks the umpire
The two appraisers first try to pick a competent and disinterested umpire. If they fail for fifteen days, either side may ask a judge of a court of record where the property is. Section 3408 sends the application to a supreme court justice or county judge in the property's county, on five days' written notice to the other side, and the court then appoints a competent and disinterested person.
it shall be made to a justice of the supreme court residing in the county or to a county judge of the county in which the lost or damaged property is or was located
Standard fire policy; homeowners forms must be no less favorable. The statute does not say whether the 15 and 5 days are calendar or business days.
N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (Appraisal); § 3408(a), (b)
Court decisions: Matter of Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v Seibert; Matter of 3041 Ocean, Inc. v Seneca Ins. Co.
Causation
Cause covered or excluded: court decides; extent of damage: appraisal
Appraisal may decide actual cash value, replacement cost, the extent of the loss and the amount of the loss. It may not decide coverage. Courts have held that when the dispute is whether a cause is covered or excluded, that must be settled in court first. Factual questions about how much repair is needed can still go to the panel.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this subsection, an appraisal shall not determine whether the policy actually provides coverage for any portion of the claimed loss or damage.
Fire and homeowners property policies under § 3408. Appellate decisions are First and Fourth Department; no Court of Appeals decision found.
Court decisions: Matter of Louati v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.; Pilkenton v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.
Coverage
Panel may not decide coverage; only the amount of a covered loss
The statute says appraisal decides values and the amount of loss for a covered loss, and does not decide whether the policy covers any part of the claim. If coverage is in dispute, appellate courts have refused to compel appraisal until that is resolved in a regular lawsuit.
In the event of a covered loss, whenever an insured or insurer fails to proceed with an appraisal upon demand of the other, either party may apply to the court in the manner provided in subsection (a) of this section for an order directing the other to comply with such demand.
Fire and homeowners property policies under § 3408.
Court decisions: Pilkenton v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.; Matter of Louati v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.; Matter of Perry v Hanover Ins. Group
The award
Award of any two is binding; set aside for fraud, bias or misconduct
A written, itemized award signed by any two of the three, once filed with the insurer, sets actual cash value and loss, and the statute makes it binding on both sides. Courts presume the award is valid and do not review whether the panel got the numbers right. They set it aside for fraud, corruption, bias, or misconduct such as refusing to hear relevant evidence. If an award is set aside through no fault of the insured, the insured need not appraise again and may sue on the policy.
An award in writing, so itemized, of any two when filed with this Company shall determine the amount of actual cash value and loss.
Fire and homeowners policies. The law says appraisal is not enforced as an arbitration, yet Perry lets a court confirm or vacate an award under CPLR 7601. Whether arbitration-law grounds apply is unsettled.
Court decisions: Gervant v New England Fire Ins. Co.; Hemingway v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.; Matter of Stanz v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.; Matter of Delmar Box Co. (Aetna Ins. Co.); Matter of Perry v Hanover Ins. Group
Who pays
Each pays its own appraiser; umpire and expenses split equally
Under the statutory appraisal clause each appraiser is paid by the party who chose that appraiser. The umpire's fee and the expenses of the appraisal are shared equally. We found no statute on attorney's fees for the appraisal itself. Homeowners forms may restate the clause but cannot be less favorable to the insured.
Each appraiser shall be paid by the party selecting him and the expenses of appraisal and umpire shall be paid by the parties equally.
Standard fire policy; homeowners forms must be no less favorable to the insured.
Demand and waiver
No set deadline; refusing or stalling appraisal frees the other side
The statute sets no deadline for demanding appraisal. Each side must take part in good faith. If one side refuses to go ahead with an appraisal or to finish it, the other side is freed from it and may sue on the policy; today it may instead ask a court to order appraisal. The policy also says the insurer does not give up any policy defense by taking part in appraisal. We found no appellate decision on losing the right to appraise through delay or litigation.
No provision, stipulation or forfeiture shall be held to be waived by any requirement or proceeding on the part of this Company relating to appraisal
Standard fire policy and homeowners forms. Suit on the policy must start within 24 months after the loss.
Court decisions: Uhrig v Williamsburgh City Fire Ins. Co.; Kiernan v Dutchess County Mut. Ins. Co.; Matter of Stanz v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.
After the award is paid
Cashing the award checks can settle the claim in full
An appellate court held that insureds who cashed the insurer's checks for the exact amount of the appraisal award made a full accord and satisfaction, which ended their claim, even though the checks said nothing about it. Another appellate court let a commercial insured go forward with a claim for extra losses and legal fees caused by the insurer holding back payments until the award and not paying in full what the panel set. We found no statute on interest or fees after an award is paid on time.
plaintiffs' negotiation of defendant's checks following the resolution of the formal dispute process constituted a full accord and satisfaction of plaintiffs' claim
Hemingway is a homeowners fire claim in the Third Department. BioEnergy is a commercial claim decided on a motion to dismiss.
Court decisions: Hemingway v State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.; Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's v BioEnergy Dev. Group LLC
Deadlines
Fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
The standard fire policy in subsection (e) is the "standard fire insurance policy of the state of New York." Section 3404(b) bars issuing a fire policy on New York property that does not conform. The appraisal clause is part of that form. Wording checked against newyork.public.law.
Policies under the readable-policy law (§ 3102), such as homeowners forms, are exempt from the exact form. With the superintendent’s approval, their fire terms must be "no less favorable to the insured than those contained in the standard fire policy." A homeowners policy may restate the appraisal clause in its own words, but not on worse terms.
On the written demand of either side, "each shall select a competent and disinterested appraiser." Each must notify the other of the appraiser "within twenty days of such demand." The appraisers "shall first select a competent and disinterested umpire." If they fail "for fifteen days to agree upon such umpire," a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located selects one on request of either side. The appraisers appraise and, failing to agree, submit "their differences, only, to the umpire." An itemized written award of any two, filed with the company, determines the amount of actual cash value and loss. Each side pays its own appraiser, and the umpire and appraisal expenses are split equally. Wording checked against newyork.public.law.
The application for an umpire goes to a justice of the supreme court residing in the county, or to a county judge, where the property is or was. It must be on five days’ notice in writing to the other party, and an insured may serve that notice on any local agent of the insurer. If the appraisers fail to agree on an umpire and notice was served, the court appoints "a competent and disinterested person" on an affidavit of the failure. Wording checked against newyork.public.law.
If either side refuses to proceed with a demanded appraisal of a covered loss, the other may apply for an order compelling compliance. Appraisal determines "the actual cash value, the replacement cost, the extent of the loss or damage and the amount of the loss or damage," and not as an arbitration. It does not decide whether the policy provides coverage. "Extent of the loss or damage" was added by L. 2014, ch. 451, signed November 21, 2014. Wording checked against newyork.public.law.
A court may enforce a valuation or appraisal agreement as an arbitration agreement under CPLR article 75, but that section does not apply to the standard fire policy. An action to enforce the fire-policy appraisal clause under § 3408 "shall not be enforced as an arbitration agreement." So fire-policy appraisal is compelled under § 3408, not as an article 75 arbitration. Wording checked against newyork.public.law.
The 20-day and 15-day periods, the "competent and disinterested" standard, the court-selected umpire and the equal split of costs are statutory form wording. Added terms seen in homeowners forms, such as a demand that names the appraiser or venue clauses, are policy language. Under § 3404(f)(1) they cannot be less favorable to the insured than the form.
The Department of Financial Services’ consumer guidance says appraisal "is not available for disputes involving the cause of the damage." That is the Department’s reading. Section 3408(c) is the statute.
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in New York. N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days. The Claim King counts every deadline here in calendar days, weekends and holidays included, and never moves a date that falls on a weekend or holiday. Calendar days give the earlier date; if business days apply, the real deadline may be later than the date shown. Check the policy's appraisal clause and confirm with your own counsel before relying on a date.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Each side names a competent and disinterested appraiser and notifies the other | 20 days(calendar or business not stated) | Written appraisal demand by either party | Insured and insurer | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (Appraisal) |
| The appraisers agree on an umpire. The form says only "failing for fifteen days to agree," and does not fix the start more precisely | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Not fixed more precisely by the form | The two appraisers | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (Appraisal) |
| Court selects the umpire on request once the 15 days run: no day count | The appraisers’ failure to agree | Justice of the supreme court or county judge where the property is located | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e); § 3408(a), (b) | |
| Written notice to the other side of an umpire application; an insured may serve any local agent of the insurer | 5 days(calendar or business not stated) | Before the court application is heard | Applying party | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3408(a) |
| Order compelling a refusing party to appraise: no day count | Refusal to proceed with a demanded appraisal of a covered loss | Either party applies; the court orders | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3408(c) | |
| Award deadline: neither the statute nor the form sets one | Not applicable | Not applicable | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) | |
| Sworn proof of loss, unless the insurer extends the time in writing | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | The loss | Insured | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (Requirements in case loss occurs) |
| Loss payable once proof of loss is received and the loss is fixed by written agreement or by filing the award with the insurer | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss received and the loss ascertained | Insurer | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (When loss payable) |
| Suit on the policy: 24 months from the inception of the loss | Inception of the loss | Insured | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (Suit) |
Who can serve
Both appraisers and the umpire must be "competent and disinterested." A court-appointed umpire must be too. Neither statute defines the words.
A 2005 opinion of the Department’s Office of General Counsel says § 3404 "does not specifically permit an insured or insurer to reject the other’s choice of appraiser." A challenge goes to a court, and whether an appraiser is competent and disinterested is a question of fact the Department does not decide.
We found no statute or Department opinion requiring a license to act as an appraiser or umpire. The Department’s 2001 informal opinion, written about motor vehicle claims, says "merely performing an appraisal does not amount to the negotiating, investigating and adjusting of claims," so an appraiser who only appraises need not hold an adjuster license. One who also negotiates or settles claims may need one.
The Department licenses public adjusters, who "represent you, not the insurance company." Their contracts can be cancelled until midnight of the third business day after signing, and they may not solicit between 6 p.m. and 8 a.m. No statute, regulation or Department opinion was found on whether a public adjuster on the claim can be a "disinterested" appraiser.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in New York. 11 NYCRR 216.6 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge the claim | 15 business days | Notification of a claim | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.4(a) |
| Reply to other pertinent communications. This rule does not apply where a public adjuster represents the claimant (11 NYCRR 216.2(d)). | 15 business days | Receipt of the communication | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.4(b) |
| Answer a Department inquiry about a claim | 10 business days | Receipt of the Department’s inquiry | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.4(d) |
| Begin investigating. This rule does not apply where a public adjuster represents the claimant (11 NYCRR 216.2(d)). | 15 business days | Receiving notice of the claim | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.5(a) |
| Accept or reject the claim in writing; 30 business days if arson is suspected | 15 business days | Receipt of a properly executed proof of loss and all items the insurer requested | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.6(c) |
| Notify the insured that more time is needed, with reasons | 15 business days | Receipt of the proof of loss or the requested information | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.6(c) |
| Follow-up letters while the claim stays unsettled and is not in litigation or arbitration; then every 90 days | 90 days(calendar or business not stated) | The first letter saying more time is needed | Insurer | 11 NYCRR 216.6(c) |
| Pay the loss after an appraisal award is filed | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Proof of loss plus the filed award | Insurer | N.Y. Ins. Law § 3404(e) (When loss payable) |
Court decisions
Matter of Stanz v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 221 A.D.3d 1479, 2023 NY Slip Op 05832
Appellate Division, Fourth Department, 2023
A memorandum decision. The trial court set the award aside for the court-appointed umpire’s errors, not the insureds’ fault, so it could not send the matter back to the umpire and appraisers. Quoting Gervant (1954), insureds in that position "need not submit to any further appraisement but may sue on the policy."
Matter of Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v Seibert, 31 Misc 3d 523, 2011 NY Slip Op 21060
New York Supreme Court (trial court), 2011
A trial court decision, 31 Misc 3d 523 (Feb. 10, 2011). It denied the insurer’s request to limit appraisal to actual cash value, and the insured’s request for an unrestricted umpire, as both were "beyond the scope of the application to appoint an umpire." The umpire decides the amount of loss under the policy terms and Insurance Law § 3408.
Recent and pending changes
Sections 3404 and 3408 show no change since 2014–2015. The Senate’s site lists its latest revisions as March 6, 2015 (§ 3404) and November 28, 2014 (§ 3408). The last amendment to § 3408 is L. 2014, ch. 451, signed November 21, 2014.
S8262 (Bailey) and A8536 (Weprin), 2025-2026 session, would add Ins. Law § 3465, "Appraisals", overriding §§ 3404 and 3408: an appraiser selected within 15 business days of the request, an umpire within 15 days, an onsite inspection scheduled within 30 days, a status update 60 days after the inspection, the umpire’s final appraisal within 30 days, and no appraiser who worked on the claim before. Both were last referred to the insurance committee on January 7, 2026, as of November 15, 2026.
Sources
- N.Y. Insurance Law § 3404, standard fire policyOfficial
- N.Y. Insurance Law § 3408, appraisal of loss; umpire on failure to agreeOfficial
- N.Y. CPLR 7601, specific enforcement of valuation or appraisal agreementsOfficial
- 11 NYCRR Part 216 (Regulation 64), the state’s online NYCRR on Westlaw, which it labels unofficial (text read on Cornell LII)Secondary
- DFS Office of General Counsel Opinion 05-04-24, appraisal clauseOfficial
- DFS Office of General Counsel Opinion 01-02-09, appraiser and adjuster licensingOfficial
- DFS: adjusters, appraisers and umpires (consumer page)Official
- Matter of Stanz v New York Cent. Mut. Fire Ins. Co. (4th Dep’t 2023), court reporterOfficial
- Merrimack Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v Seibert (Sup. Ct. 2011), court reporterOfficial
- Wording of Ins. Law § 3404 checked against newyork.public.law (secondary)Secondary
- Wording of Ins. Law § 3408 checked against newyork.public.law (secondary)Secondary
- Wording of CPLR 7601 checked against newyork.public.law (secondary)Secondary
- 11 NYCRR 216.4 text, Cornell LII (secondary)Secondary
- 11 NYCRR 216.5(a) text, Cornell LII (secondary); 216.6(c) is on the 216.6 page thereSecondary
- S8262 (2025-2026), New York State Senate bill pageOfficial
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.