At a glance
None of the Montana statutes checked for this page writes or requires an appraisal clause in property policies, so the appraisal terms, day counts included, come from the policy. In Garretson (1988, a private auto policy) the Montana Supreme Court held a policy appraisal of the amount of loss binding and said the parties had to complete it before suing. It also held the Montana Uniform Arbitration Act did not govern, because the Act excludes agreements relating to insurance policies. By statute, an insurer must pay or deny within 30 days of proof of loss, or 60 days when it reasonably asks for more information, with 10% interest if late. That section does not name the lines of insurance it covers.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
Adjusters need a license; no rule names appraisers or umpires
No state rule found
Montana makes it unlawful to act as an adjuster without an adjuster license, and the license covers public adjusters, who are adjusters retained by and representing the insured. Nothing in the statutes we read says an appraiser or umpire named under a policy appraisal clause must hold that license, or is exempt from it. Whether serving as an insured's appraiser counts as acting as a public adjuster is not answered by any statute or decision we found.
A person may not act as or purport to be an adjuster in this state unless the person holds an adjuster license.
Statute is about adjusters generally. Exception in 33-17-301(5) for catastrophe adjusters sent in by an insurer. Does not mention appraisers or umpires.
Contingency fees
No rule on contingent-fee appraisers
No state rule found
No Montana statute, rule, bulletin or decision we found says a party appraiser or umpire paid a percentage of the award is disqualified or allowed. The only fee rules are for public adjusters. Their contract must be written, filed with the commissioner and show the fee. It may not let the adjuster take the whole fee from the first payment, and it limits percentage commissions on quick policy-limits payments. A public adjuster must also serve with objectivity and loyalty to the insured alone. None of this mentions serving as an appraiser.
A person licensed as a public adjuster may not act as a public adjuster unless the person has a written contract with the insured.
Public adjuster fee rules only; they do not address appraisers or umpires.
Impartiality
No statute; appraisers are not agents of the side that picks them
No Montana statute sets who counts as impartial; the policy wording is the starting point. Older fire policies called for competent and disinterested appraisers and umpire. In 1908 the Montana Supreme Court held that an owner could attack an award even though she chose one appraiser, because appraisers are not the agents of the party who selects them. In 1928 it said a mistake so gross that it shows misconduct or undue partiality can set an award aside. We found no Montana decision disqualifying an appraiser for a financial interest or a contingent fee.
The appraisers are not in any sense the agents or representatives of the parties who select them.
Fire policy decisions of the Montana Supreme Court; no statute. Says nothing about fees or financial interest.
Court decisions: Carlston v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.; Lee v. Providence Washington Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Policy controls: appraisers pick; a judge picks if they cannot
No state rule found
No Montana statute covers umpire selection in property appraisal. The policy sets it. The homeowners policy in Nelson had the two appraisers choose the umpire, with a judge of a court of record choosing if they did not agree in 15 days. In Nelson a district judge did select the umpire on request. A 2026 draft bill for auto policies only would require an umpire to hold an active Montana adjuster license. It is not law.
If they cannot agree upon an umpire within 15 days, you or we may request that the choice be made by a judge of a court of record in the state where the residence premises is located.
Policy terms quoted in the opinion, not a statute. PD 45 draft is auto only and unenacted.
Court decisions: Nelson v. Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co.; Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
Causation
No ruling; 1965 case sent a fire-vs-earthquake split to appraisal
No state rule found
No Montana decision says whether appraisers may decide what caused the damage. In School District No. 1 (1965) the parties disagreed on how much of the damage the fire caused, as against an earlier earthquake and later vandalism. The Montana Supreme Court called this a dispute over how much was owed and ordered the parties to appraisal. Nobody argued that cause was outside the panel's job, and the court did not discuss it. So the case shows a cause split being sent to appraisal, but it is not a ruling on the panel's power.
Fire policy on an abandoned school. The court did not address whether cause is outside appraisal. No later Montana or D. Mont. decision found.
Court decisions: School District No. 1 of Silver Bow County v. Globe & Republic Insurance Co. of America
Coverage
Fact questions only; courts decide coverage, even after an award
Montana enforces an appraisal clause because it settles only questions of fact, such as value or quantity. A clause sending all disputes, including questions of law, to private decision is void as to the law questions. The Montana Supreme Court has decided coverage questions itself, before and after appraisal. In 1992 it ruled on whether asbestos removal in an umpire's award was covered. In 2013 it decided whether the property was insured before appraisal, then ruled on which policy valuation terms bound the appraisers. No Montana decision says in so many words that a panel may not decide coverage.
those disputes relating solely to questions of fact, such as value or quantity, were subject to arbitration.
Fire, commercial property and auto policies. Courts decided the coverage questions; none held that a panel lacks power to decide one.
Court decisions: Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.; School District No. 1 of Silver Bow County v. Globe & Republic Insurance Co. of America; Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. v. Oakland; Lincoln County Port Authority v. Allianz Global Risks US Insurance Co.; Mathews v. Glacier General Assurance Co.
The award
Binding on amount of loss; set aside only for fraud, bad-faith error
Montana treats an appraisal award as binding on the amount of loss unless it is set aside. The court presumes an award is valid and does not undo it for every error. It sets one aside only when it was made without authority or came from fraud, mistake or misconduct. An arbitrary 10% deduction with no basis in fact or law was enough in 1928, and an award made without letting the owner be heard did not bind her in 1908. The appraisers must follow the policy's measure of loss, such as actual cash value, and the court will correct an award that does not. The Uniform Arbitration Act does not apply to insurance policies.
an award made by the appraisers is supported by every reasonable intendment and presumption, and it should not be vacated unless it was made without authority, or was the result of fraud or mistake, or of the misfeasance or malfeasance of the appraisers.
Fire, commercial property and auto policies. No statute sets the grounds for setting aside a policy appraisal award.
Court decisions: Lee v. Providence Washington Insurance Co.; Solem v. Connecticut Fire Insurance Co.; McIntosh v. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.; Carlston v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.; Lincoln County Port Authority v. Allianz Global Risks US Insurance Co.; Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
Who pays
No statute; the policy decides who pays
No state rule found
No Montana statute or rule divides appraisal costs. The policy controls. The auto policy in Garretson had each side pay its own appraiser and split other expenses and the umpire equally. The Nelson homeowners policy, as quoted, did not say. A 2026 draft bill for auto policies would shift costs to the insurer in some cases. It is not law.
Each appraiser shall be paid by the party selecting that appraiser. Other expenses of the appraisal and the compensation of the umpire shall be shared equally.
Quote is the policy wording the court set out, for a private auto policy. It is not a statute.
Court decisions: Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
Demand and waiver
Demand within a reasonable time; suit does not by itself waive it
Montana asks whether the demand came within a reasonable time after the disagreement over the amount of loss. The main factors are harm from the delay and whether good-faith talks had broken down. A policy limit on suing does not set the deadline. In 1965 an insurer's demand six days after suit was filed, before service, was not too late, and the court sent the case to appraisal. In 1988 an insurer that demanded appraisal a month after suit was filed was entitled to it. An insurer does not lose the right by leaving appraisal out of its answer. The insured need not demand appraisal before suing if the insurer has not.
it is inferred that the parties contemplated that such demand must be made within a reasonable time after disagreement has arisen as to the amount of loss.
Fire policy (1965); auto and homeowners policies (1988, 1990). No Montana decision after 1990 found.
Court decisions: School District No. 1 of Silver Bow County v. Globe & Republic Insurance Co. of America; Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.; Dunn v. Way
After the award is paid
No Montana rule on paid awards; reasonable-basis defense exists
No state rule found
We found no Montana decision or statute on what paying an appraisal award does to interest, claim-handling or fee claims. By statute an insurer must pay or deny within 30 days of proof of loss, or 60 if it reasonably asks for more information, or pay 10% yearly interest on a claim it owes. Montana courts hold that ordinary prejudgment interest runs only once the amount is fixed by agreement, appraisal or judgment. An insured's claim for unfair claim handling fails if the insurer had a reasonable basis to contest the claim or its amount. Montana lets an insured recover attorney fees when the insurer forces a lawsuit to get the policy's full benefit, but no case applies that to a paid award.
An insurer may not be held liable under this section if the insurer had a reasonable basis in law or in fact for contesting the claim or the amount of the claim, whichever is in issue.
General claim-handling, interest and fee rules; none written for appraisal. 33-18-232 does not name the lines of insurance it covers.
Court decisions: Nelson v. Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co.; Dunn v. Way; Lincoln County Port Authority v. Allianz Global Risks US Insurance Co.; Solem v. Connecticut Fire Insurance Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
The property insurance provisions in Title 33, chapter 24, part 1 (sections 33-24-101 to 33-24-105 and 33-24-110) do not mention appraisal, and none requires an appraisal clause in a property policy.
Property policies covering Montana risks must carry a conformity clause, so the policy must "conform to the minimum requirements of Montana law."
The Uniform Arbitration Act’s enforcement of agreements to arbitrate future disputes does not apply to any "agreement concerning or relating to insurance policies or annuity contracts", except contracts between insurance companies. In Garretson, an auto policy case decided under an earlier subsection number, the Court held this exclusion took the policy outside the Act.
A contract term that restricts a party from enforcing its rights in the ordinary courts, or limits the time to do so, is void. Agreements enforceable under the Uniform Arbitration Act are excepted. Garretson held that sending a pure question of fact, such as the value of a loss, to appraisal does not oust the courts, so the appraisal clause there was upheld.
No appraisal wording or day count was found in the statutes read; the policy supplies it. The policy quoted in Nelson set 20 days after a written request to choose an appraiser and 15 days to agree on an umpire, then a judge on request. Loss was payable 60 days after proof of loss and an agreement, a final judgment, or the filing of an appraisal award. Those are policy terms, not law.
Appraisal timelines
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, issue an award: no day count was found in the statutes read. The policy sets them (the policy in Nelson used 20 days after a written request, 15 days for the umpire, then a judge on request) | Set by the policy | The parties and the panel | Policy terms quoted in Nelson v. Farmers Union, 2003 MT 101 | |
| Uniform Arbitration Act: does not apply to agreements concerning or relating to insurance policies, so its procedures are not the route for a policy appraisal | Not applicable | Party challenging the award | § 27-5-114(2)(c), MCA; Garretson, 761 P.2d 1288 (Mont. 1988) | |
| Contract term limiting the time to enforce rights: void, except agreements enforceable under the Uniform Arbitration Act | Not applicable | Insured | § 28-2-708, MCA |
Who can serve
None of the Montana statutes read for this page sets qualifications for property appraisers or umpires. "Competent" is policy wording: the Garretson policy called for a "competent, independent appraiser" and the Nelson policy for a "competent appraiser".
A public adjuster needs a written contract with the insured, filed with the commissioner. The contract may not let the adjuster collect the entire fee from the first payment rather than as a percentage of each payment. If the insurer pays or commits in writing to pay policy limits within 72 hours after the loss is reported, the adjuster may not take a percentage commission on the total paid. The adjuster must disclose in writing any financial interest in firms on the claim, including any "building appraisal firm". The section does not mention serving as appraiser or umpire.
A public adjuster must act "with objectivity and loyalty to the interest of the insured alone." The section does not mention serving as appraiser or umpire.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Montana. § 33-18-232(1), MCA does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pay or deny the claim. The statute says "days", not business days | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the proof of loss | Insurer | § 33-18-232(1), MCA |
| Pay or deny when the insurer reasonably asks for more information. Exceptions: the insurer told the insured why it has not paid in full, or reasonably believes fraud occurred and reported it to the commissioner | 60 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the proof of loss | Insurer | § 33-18-232(1), MCA |
| Interest on a late claim is 10% a year from the due date (30 or 60 days after proof of loss), if over $5. Compliance or noncompliance cannot ground a private action under §§ 33-18-201 or 33-18-242 and is not admissible in one. The section does not name the lines of insurance it covers | Noncompliance where the insurer is liable | Insurer | § 33-18-232(2), (3), MCA | |
| Acknowledge communications, affirm or deny coverage, explain a denial: no fixed day count, only "reasonably promptly" and "within a reasonable time". Violations count only when done "with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice" | Not applicable | Insurer | § 33-18-201(2), (5), (14), MCA |
Court decisions
Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau Mut. Ins. Co., 234 Mont. 103, 761 P.2d 1288
Montana Supreme Court, 1988
Published opinion on a private auto policy. Although the policy did not say so, its wording indicated the appraisal was "intended to generate a valuation which is final and binding". Appraisal is for the amount of loss, a pure question of fact. The Uniform Arbitration Act did not govern because of the insurance exclusion. The parties had to comply with the appraisal process before filing a complaint. Summary judgment for the insurer was affirmed.
Nelson v. Farmers Union Mut. Ins. Co., 2003 MT 101, 315 Mont. 268, 68 P.3d 689
Montana Supreme Court, 2003
Published opinion. A district judge was asked to select the umpire and did. A joint appraisal the insureds rejected, saying it omitted replacement labor costs, was not an agreement and no appraisal award was filed, so the policy’s 60-day payment period did not start. The court did not address vacatur or the Arbitration Act.
Recent and pending changes
An unofficial draft (PD 45, as of 3/6/2026) prepared for the Economic Affairs Interim Committee would require an appraisal right in automobile policies only. It would set 10 business days to name experts, 10 business days to agree on an umpire, 15 business days for the umpire’s decision, and payment within 10 business days of the final award. It would also require an umpire to hold an active Montana adjuster licence. It is a draft with no bill number. It does not touch homeowner’s or commercial property.
§ 33-18-201 was amended by Chapter 229, Laws of 2025. Its current text includes subsection (15), failing to provide a claims list on request as required by § 33-15-1126, which has nothing to do with appraisal.
Sources
- MCA Title 33, chapter 24, part 1 (property insurance, general provisions), section indexOfficial
- MCA 33-24-105, conformity with Montana lawOfficial
- MCA 33-18-201, unfair claim settlement practicesOfficial
- MCA 33-18-232, time to pay or deny a claimOfficial
- MCA 33-17-302, public adjuster contracts and feesOfficial
- MCA 33-17-303, public adjuster dutiesOfficial
- MCA 27-5-114, Uniform Arbitration Act exclusionsOfficial
- MCA 28-2-708, contract terms restricting legal remediesOfficial
- PD 45, draft automobile appraisal bill, Economic Affairs Interim Committee, 3/6/2026OfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Garretson v. Mountain West Farm Bureau (Mont. 1988), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Nelson v. Farmers Union Mut. Ins. Co., 2003 MT 101, on HallApprovedSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.