At a glance
Massachusetts calls its appraisal process a "reference" and the people who decide it "referees". In plain English, this is Massachusetts’ version of appraisal, and it is not the usual two appraisers and an umpire. G.L. c. 175 § 99 makes a reference of the amount of loss to three disinterested referees a condition precedent to suit on the standard fire policy, and a majority’s written award is "conclusive and final" on the amount. Sections 100 to 101H set short clocks: on the insured’s written demand the insurer has 10 days to submit three names, each side has 10 days to pick from the other’s list, and the two referees have 10 days to agree on a third before the Commissioner of Insurance appoints one. The referees must meet within 10 days of the third’s appointment. Suit must be filed within 2 years of the loss, but not less than 90 days after a valid award, and a request for a reference alone does not stop that clock. The reference fixes only the amount of loss and waives no coverage defense. The statutes set no deadline for the award.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: yes
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
Public adjuster license to act for the insured; no referee license
Massachusetts has no referee license. The statute asks only that a referee be disinterested, a resident and willing. Anyone who, for pay and not as a lawyer, solicits an insured or agrees to represent the insured in the assessment, negotiation, settlement, appraisal or reference of a property loss is a public insurance adjuster and needs that license. Acting without one is a crime, punishable by a fine of up to $10,000 or up to 6 months in jail. The statute does not say whether a referee, who must be disinterested and is picked from names the other side supplies, counts as representing the insured.
performs services pursuant to an agreement, engagement or undertaking to represent the insured in connection with the assessment of damages, negotiation, settlement, appraisal or reference of a loss
Fire, homeowners, commercial multi-peril and other property policies. Lawyers acting in the usual course of their profession are carved out of § 162.
Contingency fees
No Massachusetts rule on contingent-fee referees
No state rule found
No statute, regulation, bulletin or court decision says whether a referee paid a percentage of the award is disqualified. The statute only requires a referee to be disinterested. The public adjuster statute assumes percentage fees exist, because it protects the adjuster's lien for an agreed percentage fee on the proceeds. It does not say whether that fee makes the person partial as a referee.
Property reference under G.L. c. 175 §§ 99-101H.
Impartiality
Referees must be disinterested; work for a side in past 4 months bars
Every referee must be disinterested, a Massachusetts resident and willing to serve. A person who served as referee for either side in the prior four months is disqualified unless the other side agrees in writing. A person already nominated in the same case cannot be named in an application to the Commissioner. No court has defined 'disinterested' beyond this. An award can be attacked for fraud, bias or prejudice only with specific facts.
shall be disinterested, a resident of the commonwealth and willing to act as referee
Fire policies in the standard form and policies that carry the § 99 reference clause. Applies to all three referees.
Court decisions: Second Society of Universalists in Boston v. Royal Insurance Co.; Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.
Umpire selection
Two party referees pick a third; Commissioner appoints after 10 days
Massachusetts has no umpire clause. The insurer gives the insured three names within 10 days of a written demand, and the insured picks one within 10 days. The insured gives three names, and the insurer picks one within 10 days. If the two referees do not agree on a third within 10 days, any referee or party applies on oath to the Commissioner of Insurance, who appoints one. A vacancy is filled by the Commissioner on application, unless the parties agree.
then either of the said referees or parties may make written application on oath to the commissioner in such form as he may prescribe, for the appointment of the third referee
The clocks in § 100 start on the insured's written demand. The statute sets no comparable clock when the insurer demands a reference.
Causation
Referees may find what caused the damage, to fix covered loss
To fix the amount of loss under the policy, the referees decide how much of the damage came from covered causes. In Fox, referees properly counted lightning damage and left out wind damage the policy did not cover. Their views on what the policy means are only tentative, though. If the meaning of the policy is disputed, a court can reexamine it later.
it is the amount of the loss or damage under the policy which the referees must determine. It is not the amount of loss or damage whether covered by the policy or not.
Policies carrying the § 99 reference clause. Cause matters only to fixing covered loss. Whether a cause is covered or excluded is a policy-meaning question for the court.
Court decisions: Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.; Augenstein v. Insurance Co. of North America; Audubon Hill South Condominium Ass'n v. Community Ass'n Underwriters of America, Inc.
Coverage
Referees fix the amount only; the court decides coverage
The reference fixes only the amount of the loss. The insurer does not give up any defense by joining it. Referees may form tentative views about coverage in order to set the amount, but a court can reexamine coverage afterward. Where the insurer reserved coverage in writing, a court decided it after the award. Where it never argued the referees misread the policy, the award stood. The parties can instead agree in writing to proceed under the arbitration act, chapter 251.
such proceedings shall fix only the amount of the loss sustained by the insured or the sound value of the property, as the case may be
Policies with the § 99 reference clause. An insurer that raises no coverage point and lets the referees decide whether a loss happened can be held to their finding (Augenstein).
Court decisions: F. & M. Skirt Co. v. Rhode Island Insurance Co.; Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.; Augenstein v. Insurance Co. of North America; Audubon Hill South Condominium Ass'n v. Community Ass'n Underwriters of America, Inc.; Employers' Liability Assurance Corp. v. Traynor
The award
Majority's written award is final on amount; narrow grounds to attack
A written award signed by a majority of the three referees is conclusive and final on the amount of loss. The third referee publishes it by delivering a signed copy to each side. Courts will set one aside for fraud or bias shown by specific facts, or when it is so grossly low that it shows fraud or bias. Referees have discretion over what evidence to hear. The arbitration act's vacatur rules do not apply unless both sides agree in writing.
the award in writing by a majority of the referees shall be conclusive and final upon the parties as to the amount of loss or damage
Amount of loss only. The cause of action is on the policy, and the award is conclusive evidence of the amount.
Court decisions: Augenstein v. Insurance Co. of North America; Second Society of Universalists in Boston v. Royal Insurance Co.; Hanley v. Aetna Insurance Co.; Fox v. Employers' Fire Insurance Co.
Who pays
Third referee split; if insurer wins it pays, then deducts half
The statute covers only the third referee. If the award favors the insured, insurer and insured each pay half. If it favors the insurer, or there is no award, the insurer pays it all but may deduct half from any payment to the insured. Either side can ask the Commissioner to review the charges within 10 days. The statute does not set what each side pays its own referee.
The company and the insured shall, if an award is rendered by the referees in favor of the insured, each be liable to the third referee for one half of his charges for compensation and expenses.
Third referee's charges only. Each side's own referee and its other costs are not set by statute.
Demand and waiver
Reference is a condition to suit; insurer can waive it by conduct
If the sides disagree on the amount, a reference is a condition of any suit on the policy unless the parties waive it. The insured starts it by written demand. Waiver is a fact question, and the party claiming it must prove it. An insurer that only denies liability, without disputing the amount or mentioning reference, can be found to have waived it. A mere request for a reference does not stop the 2-year suit clock.
such reference, unless waived by the parties, shall be a condition precedent to any right of action in law or equity to recover for such loss
Policies with the § 99 reference clause. The burden of proving waiver is on the party claiming it.
Court decisions: Molea v. Aetna Insurance Co.; Moran v. Phoenix Insurance Co.; Lancaster v. General Accident Insurance Co. of America; Hawley v. Preferred Mutual Insurance Co.; Employers' Liability Assurance Corp. v. Traynor
After the award is paid
Paying award does not end c. 93A or 176D claims by itself
Unsettled
No statute says that paying a reference award ends statutory interest, unfair-claims or c. 93A claims. In a 2025 unpublished order, the Appeals Court let a c. 93A claim go to a jury after the insurer paid a referees' award; the insurer won at trial. A federal appeals court weighed an insurer's earlier estimates against a paid award and found no violation, saying a gap is not a violation by itself. No binding Massachusetts decision settles this. No interest runs during the 10-day review hold.
the company shall not be liable for interest on an award during said period of ten days or pending said decision
Homeowner and consumer claims under c. 93A § 9 based on c. 176D § 3(9) violations. Businesses sue under § 11, not covered here. Only non-binding decisions address a paid reference award.
Court decisions: Vento v. Vermont Mutual Insurance Co.; River Farm Realty Trust v. Farm Family Casualty Insurance Co.; Bobick v. United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co.
Deadlines
Fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No company may issue fire policies on property in the commonwealth "other than those of the standard forms herein set forth", with listed exceptions. On "a failure of the parties to agree as to the amount of loss … the amount of such loss shall be referred to three disinterested men, the company and the insured each choosing one out of three persons to be named by the other, and the third being selected by the two so chosen". "The award in writing by a majority of the referees shall be conclusive and final upon the parties as to the amount of loss or damage". The reference, "unless waived by the parties, shall be a condition precedent to any right of action".
In the standard form (clause Twelfth), no one may be chosen or act as referee, against the objection of either party, "who has acted in a like capacity within four months". Under clause Ninth, endorsements may not modify the provisions on "a reference of the amount of a loss to three referees".
Selection procedure and clocks are in § 100 (see Timelines). If the referees deadlock on the third, either referee or party "may make written application on oath to the commissioner", who appoints after any summary inquiry or hearing. If a referee dies, resigns, is incapacitated, leaves the commonwealth or refuses to serve before the award, the appropriate party or referees "shall forthwith make written application on oath to the commissioner" naming three persons (except when replacing a Commissioner-appointed third referee). The Commissioner must pick one of them, and the parties may also fill the vacancy by agreement.
The award is written and executed in duplicate, and the third referee "shall forthwith publish" it by delivering one duplicate to each side.
Third referee’s charges. If the award favours the insured, the charges are split equally. If it favours the insurer, or no award is made, the insurer pays all of them but may deduct half from any settlement payment. Either side may petition the Commissioner within 10 days, and the Commissioner’s findings are "final and conclusive".
Neither the referee’s charges nor an award to the insured may be paid until the 10-day review period under § 101B ends (or the Commissioner decides a petition), unless the insured waives review in writing, and no interest accrues on the award meanwhile. Paying a referee does not stop either side from contesting the award’s validity.
Scope. An insurer joining a reference does not waive "any legal defense", and the proceeding "shall fix only the amount of the loss sustained by the insured or the sound value of the property", unless both sides agree in writing to proceed under c. 251, the arbitration act.
Where a policy has a reduced-rate or coinsurance clause and the sound value of the property is disputed, the referees chosen to decide the loss set it, and a majority’s written award is "final and conclusive" on sound value. For actual cash value coverage, § 101H makes sound value synonymous with actual cash value.
Homeowner’s forms. The Commissioner approves homeowner’s multi-peril forms for owner-occupied condominium units and dwellings of four or fewer units, and their tenants, with alternative loss-settlement clauses. Except for loss settlement, they "shall otherwise conform to the substantive requirements" of § 99. Whether every homeowner’s or multi-peril form must carry the reference clause word for word was not confirmed, so the policy and its Massachusetts amendatory endorsement should be read.
The § 100 clocks start on a written demand from the insured. The statute sets no comparable clock when the insurer demands a reference.
The Superior Court applied the Supreme Judicial Court’s Augenstein decision as "controlling" in Dorfman: once the amount of loss was contested before the referees, the insurer could not relitigate at trial whether the loss was a sham. Policy-construction issues and fraud unrelated to the amount stay outside the reference. A footnote notes a contrary reading in Federal Ins. Co. v. Klinck (D. Mass. 1993). This is a trial court decision. No Massachusetts appellate holding was found on whether referees may decide causation.
Appraisal timelines
Day counting is not settled in Massachusetts. G.L. c. 175 § 100 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days. The Claim King counts every deadline here in calendar days, weekends and holidays included, and never moves a date that falls on a weekend or holiday. Calendar days give the earlier date; if business days apply, the real deadline may be later than the date shown. Check the policy's appraisal clause and confirm with your own counsel before relying on a date.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurer submits three names and addresses to the insured | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the insured’s written demand for a reference | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 § 100 |
| Insured chooses one of the insurer’s three as a referee and notifies the insurer in writing | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the insurer’s names | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 100 |
| Insured submits three names to the insurer: no day count | Not applicable | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 100 | |
| Insurer chooses one of the insured’s three as a referee and notifies the insured in writing | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of the insured’s names | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 § 100 |
| The two referees agree on the third; after 10 days either referee or party may apply on oath to the Commissioner of Insurance | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Choice of the second referee | The two referees, then any referee or party | G.L. c. 175 § 100 |
| Apply to the Commissioner to fill a vacancy: "forthwith", no day count | A referee dies, resigns, becomes unable or refuses to serve | The party or referees named in § 100A | G.L. c. 175 § 100A | |
| Referees meet to hear the evidence | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Selection or appointment of the third referee | Referees | G.L. c. 175 § 101 |
| Gap between hearings: at most 1 week, unless all three referees agree | 7 days(calendar or business not stated) | Each adjournment | Referees | G.L. c. 175 § 101 |
| Award deadline: §§ 99 to 101H set none | Not applicable | Not applicable | G.L. c. 175 §§ 99-101H | |
| Deliver the award to both sides: "forthwith", no day count | Award executed | Third referee | G.L. c. 175 § 101A | |
| Petition the Commissioner to review the third referee’s charges | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Publication of the award (or the charges statement if no award) | Insurer or insured | G.L. c. 175 § 101B |
| Hold on paying the award and the referee, with no interest meanwhile, until the 10 days run out or the Commissioner decides, unless the insured waives review in writing | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | Publication of the award | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 § 101C |
| Pay (or replace the property); an amount not agreed "shall be ascertained by award of referees" | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Insured submits the sworn statement | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 § 99 (standard form) |
| Notice of intent to rebuild or repair | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Sworn statement submitted | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 § 99 |
| Interest at 1% over prime on the agreed figure, running while unpaid, starts 30 days after the insurer receives an executed proof of loss for it | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Insurer receives an executed proof of loss for the agreed figure | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 § 99 |
| Notice of loss and sworn proof of loss: "immediate" and "forthwith" | The loss | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 99 (standard form) | |
| A failure to file the sworn statement promptly does not bar recovery if the insured gave prompt written notice of the fire and files the statement right after the insurer asks for it in writing | The insurer’s written request for the sworn statement | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 102 | |
| Referee disqualification: a referee who served for either party within the prior 4 months may not act without the other side’s written consent (both sides, for the third referee) | Date of nomination; for the third, the second referee’s choice; for a Commissioner appointment, the application | Not applicable | G.L. c. 175 §§ 99, 100B | |
| Suit on the policy: 2 years | The loss | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 99 | |
| Suit after a reference: not less than 90 days after a valid award or an express waiver of the reference or award, where the loss was referred within the 2 years. A request for a reference alone does not stop the 2-year clock | 90 days(calendar or business not stated) | A valid award, or express waiver of the reference or award | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 99; Hawley v. Preferred Mut. Ins. Co., 88 Mass. App. Ct. 360 (2015) |
| New suit after an injunction or abatement: 1 year | Dissolution of the injunction or abatement of the suit | Insured | G.L. c. 175 § 99 |
Who can serve
Every referee nominated, specified or appointed under §§ 100 and 100A "shall be disinterested, a resident of the commonwealth and willing to act as referee". Service as referee for either party within the prior 4 months disqualifies, unless the other side consents in writing (both sides, for the third referee). No one previously nominated by either party in the same proceeding may be named in an application to the Commissioner.
Contracts for a public adjuster to represent an insured "in connection with the assessment of damages, negotiation, settlement, appraisal, or reference of a loss" must be on a Commissioner-approved form and can be cancelled within 3 calendar days. That treats the public adjuster as the insured’s representative in a reference, not as a referee.
Because c. 251 applies only by written agreement (§ 101E), its vacatur grounds and deadlines do not automatically apply to a reference award.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Massachusetts. G.L. c. 175 §§ 99, 101C does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge and act on claim communications; affirm or deny coverage: no fixed day count, only "reasonably promptly" and "within a reasonable time after proof of loss statements have been completed" | Not applicable | Insurer | G.L. c. 176D § 3(9)(b), (e) | |
| Pay after a sworn statement or an award, with the 10-day hold after an award | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Sworn statement; see Timelines | Insurer | G.L. c. 175 §§ 99, 101C |
| Demand letter before a c. 93A suit: at least 30 days before filing | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Filing of the suit | Claimant | G.L. c. 93A § 9(3) |
| Written tender of settlement that can cap c. 93A recovery | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Mailing or delivery of the demand | Insurer (respondent) | G.L. c. 93A § 9(3) |
Court decisions
Hawley v. Preferred Mut. Ins. Co., 88 Mass. App. Ct. 360, 36 N.E.3d 1284, No. 14-P-917
Massachusetts Appeals Court (intermediate appellate court), 2015
Published, decided 9/16/2015. A request for a reference made five days before the two-year limit did not toll it, because § 99 does not toll before the reference begins. Even if it had, suit nearly two years after the insurer refused the reference was not prompt. The insureds could have sued in time and sought a stay under § 99’s enjoined-or-abated mechanism. Read on Cetient, a secondary host.
Dorfman v. Community Ass’n Underwriters of America, Inc., 15 Mass. L. Rptr. 566
Massachusetts Superior Court (trial court; reported in Mass. L. Rptr., not binding precedent), 2003
Trial court decision, decided 1/15/2003. Applying Augenstein as "controlling", the insurer could not relitigate at trial whether the loss was a sham once that was contested before the referees. Policy-construction issues and fraud unrelated to the amount stay outside the reference. A footnote notes the contrary reading in Federal Ins. Co. v. Klinck (D. Mass. 1993). From a secondary host.
55 New York Avenue LLC v. Seaco Ins. Co., 13 Mass. L. Rptr. 509
Massachusetts Superior Court (trial court; not binding precedent), 2001
Trial court decision, decided 6/7/2001. The parties agreed on the total losses and disputed only coverage. The court still ordered a reference under § 99, reading "the amount of such loss" as the amount of loss under the policy, and acknowledged this could mean a "repetitious or fragmented procedure". From a secondary host.
Recent and pending changes
No 2025 or 2026 enactment or pending bill changing the reference provisions of § 99 or §§ 100 to 101H was found. Two 194th-session bills would amend other clauses of § 99: H.1176 (complaint information on premium-increase notices, a new clause Seventeenth) and H.4081 (tenant relocation benefit, clause Fifteenth A). Neither touches the reference paragraph. Both went to study orders in April 2026 (H.1176 on April 21, H.4081 on April 2). § 101C still speaks of "the sixty day period prescribed in said standard form of policy", although the current § 99 payment period is thirty days.
Related 194th-session (2025-2026) bills that do not touch the reference: S.702 (temporary appraisers for auto damage; sent to Senate Ways and Means 1/8/2026), H.1231 (temporary emergency licensing of motor vehicle damage appraisers; placed in the Orders of the Day for a second reading 10/14/2025), H.1097 (homeowners’ insurance) and H.1225 (notice before a homeowner’s inspection); the last two went to a study order, H.5336, on 4/21/2026. Statuses as read on the legislature’s site 2026-11-08.
Sources
- G.L. c. 175 § 99, standard fire policy (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 99B, homeowner’s forms (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 100, selection of referees (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 100A, vacancies (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 100B, qualifications of referees (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 101, hearings (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 101A, the award (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 101B, third referee’s charges (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 101C, payment of charges and the award (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 101E, scope of the reference (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 101D, sound value (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 102, notice and proof of loss (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 175 § 172, public adjusters (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 176D § 3, unfair practices (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- G.L. c. 93A § 9, consumer suits (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
- Hawley v. Preferred Mutual (Mass. App. Ct. 2015), on CetientSecondary
- Dorfman v. Community Ass’n Underwriters (Mass. Super. Ct. 2003), on CetientSecondary
- 55 New York Avenue LLC v. Seaco Insurance (Mass. Super. Ct. 2001), on CetientSecondary
- G.L. c. 175 § 101H, sound value and actual cash value (Massachusetts Legislature)Official
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.