At a glance
No Indiana statute or regulation we found writes or requires an appraisal clause, and none sets a day count for naming an appraiser, choosing an umpire, issuing an award or paying after one. Any day counts come from the policy, not the law. What surrounds appraisal is case law: a party who submits to appraisal is bound by the award unless it is tainted with fraud, collusion or partiality. Two statutes matter in practice. A policy on a home of up to four units that the named insured lives in, or on household contents, may not limit the time to sue to less than two years from the date of loss, and a federal appeals court has held that an insured had no right to compel appraisal outside a policy’s two-year suit limitation, so the award was void. A public adjuster may not act as the appraiser on a claim they are advising on.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser license; a public adjuster can't appraise own claim
No state rule found
We found no Indiana license, registration or certificate for an appraiser or umpire in a property claim. A person who is paid to advise or assist an insured on a property claim is a public adjuster and needs a certificate of authority from the commissioner. A public adjuster may not act as the appraiser on a claim while advising the insured on that claim, and the adjuster's contract may not allow it. The statutes name appraisers, not umpires. We found no rule on an adjuster serving as umpire.
A contract term that would allow the public adjuster to perform the role of roofing contractor, appraiser, or any role other than that of rendering advice or assistance to the insured in the adjustment of a claim.
Public adjuster rules reach people paid to advise or assist an insured. They do not license appraisers or umpires as such. The appraiser bar came from P.L. 226-2023 (July 1, 2023).
Contingency fees
No statute; one federal court barred a percent-of-claim appraiser
Unsettled
No Indiana statute or rule says whether an appraiser may be paid on the outcome, and no Indiana state court has decided it. The only ruling is a federal trial court order applying Indiana law, which does not bind Indiana courts. It set aside an award because the insured's appraiser was paid hourly with his fee capped at 10% of the claim payment, which gave him a stake in the result. A later federal report in another case cited it. We found no decision going the other way.
Accordingly, because Mr. Hatfield was not an impartial appraiser, the Appraisal Award is set aside and is not admissible at trial because it was the product of an improper appraisal process.
Federal trial court orders applying a policy that required a "competent and impartial" appraiser. Not binding on Indiana state courts.
Court decisions: Shree Hari Hotels, LLC v. Society Insurance; Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point
Impartiality
Appraisers must act free of bias; biased award can be set aside
Indiana courts will set aside an award tainted by fraud, collusion or partiality, even though each side picks its own appraiser. Appraisers must act free from bias and prejudice in favor of either side. "Disinterested" means more than no money at stake. A biased or employee appraiser, or a biased umpire, is a ground to vacate. No statute defines the terms.
The Courts of Indiana will not hesitate to set aside an appraisal award if it is tainted with fraud, collusion or partiality for appraisers, though selected by the respective parties,
Fire-policy era cases reading "competent and disinterested" wording; later cases apply the same test to "competent and impartial" wording.
Court decisions: Insurance Co. of North America v. Hegewald; Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.; Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co.; Shree Hari Hotels, LLC v. Society Insurance; Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point
Umpire selection
Policy wording controls; court names umpire if appraisers deadlock
No state rule found
No Indiana statute or rule sets how an umpire is chosen or who may serve. The policy controls. Policies seen in Indiana cases have the two appraisers choose an umpire and, if they cannot agree, let either side ask a judge to name one. Courts have named umpires on that basis. Whether a person is truly an umpire or an extra appraiser depends on the powers the agreement gives them.
Applies to policies that use the usual appraisal clause. A policy with different wording controls.
Court decisions: Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.; Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co.; Herco, LLC v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co.
Causation
No Indiana court ruling; 7th Circuit says appraisers may decide cause
Unsettled
No Indiana state court has decided whether appraisers may decide what caused the damage. The authority is all federal and does not bind Indiana courts. A 2014 federal trial court let causation go to appraisal where the amount of loss could not be set without it. In 2025 the Seventh Circuit, predicting Indiana law, held an umpire acted within his authority when he found hail, not wear and tear, caused roof damage, and the award was binding. It called contrary language in a 2014 federal decision (Shifrin) dictum. Appraisers still may not decide liability.
decisions of causation are bound up with the appraisal process.
Federal courts predicting Indiana law; no Indiana state court has decided it. Policies with the usual amount-of-loss clause.
Court decisions: Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.; Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point; Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
Coverage
Panel sets amount of loss only; coverage and liability go to court
Appraisal in Indiana fixes the amount of loss, not whether the insurer owes it. Other policy terms decide the insurer's liability for that amount. An award that is conditioned on a court finding coverage is not binding on that item. The usual clause also lets the insurer deny the claim after appraisal. Federal courts add that a coverage dispute alongside an amount dispute does not undo an award.
it is only the amount of the loss which is fixed. Other possible issues such as liability are not determined.
Property policies with the usual amount-of-loss appraisal clause.
Court decisions: Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.; Weidman v. Erie Insurance Group; Westfield National Insurance Co. v. Nakoa; Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
The award
Binding on amount; set aside only for fraud, bias or injustice
An appraisal award is binding on the amount of loss for a party that submits to appraisal. A court will not replace the panel's judgment. It sets an award aside only for fraud, collusion, partiality, misfeasance or manifest injustice. Using a method the court would not have chosen is not enough. An award signed by the umpire and one appraiser is valid under the usual clause.
When, however, the award is uninfected with such unfairness or injustice, it is not to be set aside and replaced by the subjective judgment of a reviewing court.
Atlas was a fire policy. Later cases apply it to other property policies.
Court decisions: Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.; Insurance Co. of North America v. Hegewald; Carroll v. Statesman Insurance Co.; Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co.; Jupiter Aluminum Corp. v. Home Insurance Co.; Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.; Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point; Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
Who pays
Policy wording controls; usually each side pays its own appraiser
No state rule found
No Indiana statute or rule divides appraisal costs. The policy controls. The clauses in Indiana cases have each party pay its own appraiser and split the umpire and other expenses equally. A court enforced that split in an appraisal case.
Applies where the policy has the usual cost sentence.
Court decisions: Westfield National Insurance Co. v. Nakoa; Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co.
Demand and waiver
No deadline in law; demand within reasonable time, lost if prejudice
No Indiana statute sets a time to demand appraisal. If the policy sets none, the demand must come within a reasonable time. A party loses the right only if good-faith talks on the amount ended and the delay caused prejudice. An insurer can also waive policy defenses by standing by through an appraisal. A suit-limitation clause can end the right: a federal appeals court held that a motion to compel appraisal after the policy's two-year suit limit was not allowed and the award was void.
When the policy does not state a specified time within which demand for appraisal must be invoked, demand for appraisal must be made within a reasonable time under the circumstances of the case or the right to demand appraisal is waived.
Backstage was a commercial fire policy with no demand deadline. Legend's Creek is a federal ruling about that policy's suit-limit wording.
Court decisions: Monroe Guaranty Insurance Co. v. Backstage, Inc.; Westfield National Insurance Co. v. Nakoa; Legend's Creek Homeowners Association v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of America
After the award is paid
No Indiana ruling on a timely paid award; no statutory interest
Unsettled
No Indiana statute makes an insurer owe interest on an appraisal award, and the unfair claim practices act gives no private right to sue. Indiana appellate decisions let breach and bad-faith claims over a withheld or underpaid award go forward, and paying the award is not a condition of suing. A claim can be lost by waiting: a second suit for delay was barred while the first suit was open. No Indiana court has ruled on an award paid on time. A federal appeals court applying Indiana law found no bad faith where the insurer paid the binding award.
the cases do not establish that the agreement to pay or payment of an appraisal award is a prerequisite to suit.
Property policies. Policy payment-time terms (30 or 60 days) are contract terms. The only ruling on a paid award is federal.
Court decisions: Carroll v. Statesman Insurance Co.; Weidman v. Erie Insurance Group; Herco, LLC v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co.; Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
No Indiana statute prescribes an appraisal clause, and no standard fire policy statute was found. The old fire policy form rule, 760 IAC 1-2, is listed as repealed by a filing dated January 16, 1979 (2 IR 312). What it contained was not confirmed.
The unfair claim settlement practices statute lists 16 practices and none mentions appraisal. One of them touches arbitration: an insurer may not announce a policy of appealing arbitration awards in the insured’s favor as a way to push insureds into smaller settlements.
The appraisal clause itself is policy language. The clause quoted in the Pebble Point case read: "each party will select a competent and impartial appraiser," the two appraisers choose an umpire (a judge picks one if they cannot agree), and "A decision agreed to by any two will be binding." It also kept the insurer’s right to deny the claim after appraisal. The State Farm clause quoted in Villas at Winding Ridge (7th Cir. 2019) gave each side 20 days after a written demand to name its appraiser, and 15 days for the appraisers to agree on an umpire before either could ask a judge. Read your own policy; Indiana law does not set these terms or any day count for them.
A first-party policy on Indiana property covering a home of up to four units, one of them the named insured’s principal residence, or household personal property, may not limit the insured’s right to sue the insurer to less than two years from the date of loss. The Indiana Court of Appeals read this as voiding a shorter clause, not as itself setting a two-year limit; the ten-year default period in Ind. Code § 34-11-2-11 then applied.
The Department of Insurance consumer pages do not cover claim appraisal. Its page on property insurance mentions appraisals only for scheduling valuables.
Appraisal timelines
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name an appraiser, agree on an umpire, issue an award: no day count in any statute or regulation; the policy sets any | Set by the policy | Parties and the panel | No statute or regulation found; 760 IAC 1-2 (fire policy form) repealed | |
| Suit on a first-party policy on a home of up to four units the named insured lives in, or on household contents: the policy may not limit suit to less than two years from the date of loss | Date of loss | Insured | Ind. Code § 27-1-13-17(b) | |
| A court petition to compel appraisal had to come within the policy’s two-year suit limitation; an award made outside it was void (a federal appeals court applying Indiana law) | The policy’s suit-limitation period | Insured | Legend’s Creek HOA v. Travelers, 33 F.4th 932 (7th Cir. 2022) |
Who can serve
Wording comes from the policy. The clause in the Pebble Point case called for a "competent and impartial appraiser." No statute we found defines either term.
Case law says appraisers, though each side picks one, must act free from bias, partiality or prejudice in favor of either party. An award tainted with fraud, collusion or partiality can be set aside. Allegations that the umpire was biased were enough to defeat the insurer’s motion for summary judgment; no disclosure statute was found.
A public adjuster may not file a claim for the insured, commit the insured to a settlement, or act as a roofing contractor, an appraiser or in any other role on the subject of a claim while also advising or assisting the insured on it. Added by P.L. 226-2023 (HEA 1329), effective July 1, 2023. The ban names appraisers, not umpires, but it also covers "any other role" on a claim the adjuster is advising on. No rule was found on a public adjuster serving as umpire on a claim they are not advising on.
A separate section bars public adjuster contract terms that would let the adjuster act as roofing contractor, appraiser or in any role other than advising or assisting the insured. Where the fee is a percentage of the insurer’s payment, the contract may not let the adjuster collect before the insurer pays, or take the whole fee from the first of several payments. No statute or rule on contingency-fee appraisers or umpires was found.
No Indiana license for insurance appraisers or umpires was found. This is a negative search result, not a confirmed absence.
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge and act on claim communications: no fixed day count, only "reasonably promptly" | Communication about a claim | Insurer | Ind. Code § 27-4-1-4.5(2) | |
| Affirm or deny coverage: no fixed day count, only "within a reasonable time" | Proof of loss statements completed | Insurer | Ind. Code § 27-4-1-4.5(5) | |
| Explain the basis of a denial or compromise offer: no fixed day count, only "promptly" | Denial or offer | Insurer | Ind. Code § 27-4-1-4.5(14) | |
| Pay after an appraisal award: no statute or rule found | Award | Insurer | No statute or rule found | |
| Insurer’s written report to the Department of Insurance and the complainant on an unfair claim settlement practice complaint | 20 business days | The insurer’s receipt of the complaint | Insurer | Ind. Code § 27-4-1-5.6(d) |
Court decisions
Atlas Construction Co. v. Indiana Insurance Co., 309 N.E.2d 810
Indiana Court of Appeals, 1974
A party who voluntarily submits to appraisal is bound by it, but an appraisal tainted with fraud, collusion or partiality may be set aside, because appraisers, though each side picks one, "must act free from bias, partiality, or prejudice in favor of either of the parties." Read as quoted in Huber (Ind. Ct. App. 2006).
Weidman v. Erie Insurance Group, 745 N.E.2d 292
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2001
The appraisal agreement and award determined the amount of the insured’s loss, but not the extent of the insurer’s liability for it. Because the insured was doing his own repairs, the insurer could require proof of his expenditures before paying more, though it could not withhold overhead and profit on that ground. Bad faith and breach went back for trial.
Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co., 856 N.E.2d 713
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2006
Reversed summary judgment for the insurer, which the trial court had granted on res judicata. The insured alleged fraud by the insurer and a biased umpire: the umpire served as an expert witness for insurance companies, had known the insurer’s appraiser for over fifteen years, and said "I can ignore anything I want." Under Atlas that is an appropriate ground for setting the award aside, so the insurer was not entitled to judgment. Issued as a memorandum decision and later ordered published.
State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Riddell National Bank, No. 61A01-1204-PL-159
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2013
Ind. Code § 27-1-13-17 voids a policy suit limit shorter than two years but does not itself set a two-year limit; the policy’s one-year limit was void and, through the policy’s conform-to-state-law clause, the ten-year period in Ind. Code § 34-11-2-11 applied. An interlocutory appeal, affirming denial of the insurer’s motion to dismiss.
State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Smith, No. 45A04-1407-PL-336
Indiana Court of Appeals (memorandum decision, not precedent), 2015
An appraisal agreement signed by the insured’s appraiser and the umpire, with no input from the insurer’s appraiser, did not follow the policy’s process and was invalid. The court sent the case back for a new appraisal. A memorandum decision is not regarded as precedent.
Herco, LLC v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co., No. 20A-PL-1682(PDF)
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2021
The insured got a court-appointed umpire and an award in a first suit. While that suit was still open it filed a second suit for breach of contract and bad faith over the delay; the first suit then ended with a release and satisfaction after the award was paid. Res judicata barred the second suit: the claims could have been added to the first suit, and payment of an award is not a prerequisite to suing.
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. v. WE Pebble Point, 44 F. Supp. 3d 813
S.D. Ind., a federal trial court (order on motion to dismiss), 2014
Held the insured could invoke appraisal even though causation was disputed, noting the insurer keeps its right to deny the claim after appraisal under the policy.
S.D. Ind., a federal magistrate judge, 2016
Recommended setting the award aside as tainted by misfeasance, partiality or arbitrariness in the appraisal process. The district judge adopted the recommendation on November 18, 2016, and set the award aside.
Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., 942 F.3d 824
7th Circuit, a federal appeals court applying Indiana law, 2019
Held the State Farm policy, appraisal clause included, "unambiguous and enforceable," and rejected the argument that the umpire wrongly decided the scope of the loss rather than its amount: he resolved the dispute the parties put to him, and the signed award was binding. Affirmed summary judgment for the insurer on breach of contract and bad faith.
Legend’s Creek HOA v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of America, 33 F.4th 932
7th Circuit, a federal appeals court applying Indiana law, 2022
Affirmed summary judgment for the insurer: the insured had no right under the policy to petition the court to compel appraisal outside the two-year suit limitation, so the resulting award was void. A motion to compel appraisal counted as a "legal action" under the policy’s two-year limit.
Mesco Manufacturing, LLC v. Motorists Mutual Insurance Co., No. 1:19-cv-04875
S.D. Ind., a federal trial court, 2023
An order denying reconsideration of a summary-judgment ruling that the umpire’s finding that hail caused the damage, and the amount of loss, were binding, and that the "right to deny" clause reserves other reasons to deny but does not let the insurer disregard the award.
Recent and pending changes
P.L. 226-2023 (HEA 1329) added the public adjuster role bans, including the appraiser ban, in Ind. Code § 27-1-27-1.5. The Department of Insurance’s Bulletin 272 confirms P.L. 226-2023 and says its contract requirements took effect July 1, 2023.
Sources
- Ind. Code § 27-1-13-17, suit limitation in property policies, Indiana General AssemblyOfficial
- Ind. Code § 27-1-27-1.5, public adjuster limits, Indiana General AssemblyOfficial
- Ind. Code § 27-1-27-15, public adjuster contracts and fees, Indiana General AssemblyOfficial
- Ind. Code § 27-4-1-4.5, unfair claim settlement practices, Indiana General AssemblyOfficial
- 760 IAC Article 1 (1-2 repealed), Indiana Administrative CodeOfficial
- Indiana General Assembly, Indiana Code and bills (needs a browser to read)Official
- Indiana Department of Insurance, submit a complaint onlineOfficial
- Indiana Department of Insurance, Bulletin 272, public adjuster contracts (PDF)OfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Indiana Department of Insurance, Property InsuranceOfficial
- State Farm v. Riddell National Bank (Ind. Ct. App. 2013), Indiana courts Case Clips summaryOfficial
- Herco, LLC v. Auto-Owners Insurance Co. (Ind. Ct. App. 2021), Indiana courts opinionOfficialPDF · no web page version found
- State Farm v. Smith (Ind. Ct. App. 2015, memorandum), on HallApprovedSecondary
- Villas at Winding Ridge v. State Farm (7th Cir. 2019), on JustiaSecondary
- Legend’s Creek HOA v. Travelers (7th Cir. 2022), on JustiaSecondary
- Philadelphia Indemnity v. WE Pebble Point (S.D. Ind. 2014), order on motion to dismiss, on govinfoOfficial
- Weidman v. Erie Insurance Group, 745 N.E.2d 292 (Ind. Ct. App. 2001), on CourtListenerSecondary
- Huber v. United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co., 856 N.E.2d 713 (Ind. Ct. App. 2006), on CourtListenerSecondary
- Philadelphia Indemnity v. WE Pebble Point (S.D. Ind. 2016), report and recommendation, on govinfoOfficial
- Mesco Manufacturing v. Motorists Mutual (S.D. Ind. 2023), order denying reconsideration, on govinfoOfficial
- Ind. Code § 27-4-1-5.6, complaints to the commissioner, Indiana General AssemblyOfficial
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.