At a glance
South Dakota is the outlier. By statute and Division of Insurance bulletin, a policy may not let either side demand appraisal, and an appraisal result may not bind either side. SDCL 21-25A-3 voids any insurance-policy provision "requiring arbitration", and Bulletin 98-5 (1998) applies that to appraisal: it must be optional, used only when both parties agree, and its outcome "can not be made binding upon the parties." The same statute and SDCL 53-9-6 void any policy clause shortening the time to sue. There is no demand date, umpire deadline or award to track, only optional appraisal by agreement.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No SD license found; Division says adjusters are not licensed
No state rule found
No South Dakota statute or rule requires a license or registration to serve as an appraiser or umpire. The producer license law covers only selling, soliciting or negotiating insurance. The Division of Insurance states on its licensing page that South Dakota does not license property and casualty adjusters; that is the agency's statement, not a statute.
South Dakota does not license property/casualty adjusters.
Contingency fees
No SD rule found on contingency-fee appraisers
No state rule found
We found no statute, rule, bulletin or South Dakota court decision on whether an appraiser paid a percentage of the award is disqualified. The Division-approved clause says only that each side pays its own appraiser. The farm mutual statute and the 1909 Mason case call for disinterested appraisers, but neither mentions fee arrangements.
Court decisions: Mason v. Fire Association of Philadelphia
Impartiality
1909 case and farm mutual law require it; approved clause does not
In a 1909 fire case the South Dakota Supreme Court held that appraisers and the umpire must act with judicial impartiality and hear both sides, and that an award made with a biased appraiser who refused to hear the insured was properly set aside. For farm mutual insurers, SDCL 58-35-49 requires each side to choose a disinterested party. The Division-approved clause for other policies asks only for a competent appraiser.
The appraisers and umpire are alike the agents of both parties, and not of one party alone, and are bound to exercise a high degree of judicial impartiality
Mason was decided under the old standard fire policy, which said competent and disinterested. SDCL 58-35-49 covers farm mutual insurers only. No later court has applied Mason to a nonbinding appraisal.
Mason v. Fire Ass'n of Philadelphia, 23 S.D. 431, 122 N.W. 423 (1909)
Court decisions: Mason v. Fire Association of Philadelphia
Umpire selection
Farm mutuals: the two pick a third by statute; others follow policy
For farm mutual insurers, SDCL 58-35-49 says each side chooses a disinterested party, and if those two cannot agree they choose a third person; it sets no deadline and no court appointment. For other insurers no statute applies. The Division-approved clause says the two appraisers select an umpire, with no deadline or court fallback. Policies may add terms: the policy in Batiz let either side ask a judge to pick an umpire after 15 days.
the claimant and the company shall each choose a disinterested party who shall constitute a board of arbitration to settle such loss, and in case the arbitrators cannot agree they shall choose a third person to act with them
The statute reaches only farm mutual hail, fire and casualty insurers under SDCL ch. 58-35. Other property policies follow their own wording.
SDCL 58-35-49; Division-approved appraisal clause; Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange, 2011 S.D. 35
Court decisions: Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange
Causation
No SD rule on whether an appraisal panel decides causation
No state rule found
We found no South Dakota decision on whether an appraisal panel may decide what caused the damage. For farm mutual insurers, SDCL 58-35-49 lets the board determine all matters in dispute, but no court has read that to include causation. For other policies, the Division treats appraisal as optional and nonbinding, and no case has raised the question.
Farm mutual insurers only (SDCL 58-35-49).
Court decisions: Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange
Coverage
No SD rule on whether the panel may decide coverage
No state rule found
No South Dakota statute or decision says whether a panel may decide coverage. In Batiz the Supreme Court said the appraisal clause does not change what the loss-settlement section requires the insurer to pay. For farm mutuals, SDCL 58-35-49 lets the board determine all matters in dispute, but no court has applied that to coverage.
The appraisal provision does not alter Exchange's obligation to pay under the policy or Batiz's rights to payment, which duties and rights are clearly controlled by the Loss Settlement provision.
Farm mutual insurers only (SDCL 58-35-49).
Court decisions: Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange
The award
Division says not binding; no court has ruled; farm mutuals differ
Unsettled
SDCL 21-25A-3 voids any policy term requiring arbitration, but it does not mention appraisal. The Division's Bulletin 98-5 reads it to cover appraisal, so appraisal may happen only by agreement and cannot bind, and the approved clause says so. No court has decided that appraisal is arbitration under the statute, and agency guidance is not binding. For farm mutuals, SDCL 58-35-49 makes the board's decision final unless a party appeals to court within 60 days. Older cases set aside binding awards for bias, no hearing, or a missing sound value finding.
Such arbitration or appraisal provisions must be optional and only permitted where it is agreed upon by both parties. Any arbitration or appraisal outcome can not be made binding upon the parties.
The Division reading applies to insurance policies generally. The 60-day appeal rule covers farm mutual insurers only. Mason and Lee dealt with binding awards under the former standard fire policy.
SDCL 21-25A-3; Division of Insurance Bulletin 98-5; Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange, 2011 S.D. 35
Court decisions: Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange; Mason v. Fire Association of Philadelphia; Lee v. Farmer's Insurance Co.
Who pays
Policy wording controls; approved clause: each pays own, split umpire
No state rule found
No statute sets who pays. The Division-approved clause says each side pays the appraiser it chose and the two share the appraisal and umpire expenses equally. Policies can word this differently.
Bear the expenses of the appraisal and umpire equally.
Searched: SDCL title 58 and ch. 21-25A; Division filing page; South Dakota decisions on appraisal
Demand and waiver
Division says appraisal can't be demanded; no court has ruled
Unsettled
SDCL 21-25A-3 voids policy terms requiring arbitration. The Division's Bulletin 98-5 reads that to bar any clause letting either side demand appraisal, so appraisal needs both sides to agree and there is no demand deadline; no court has ruled that appraisal counts as arbitration. In 1899 the Supreme Court held an insurer waived the appraisal condition by ignoring the insured's written requests to name an appraiser. For farm mutuals, SDCL 58-35-49 still sends disputed losses to a board.
This chapter does not apply to insurance policies and every provision in any such policy requiring arbitration or restricting a party thereto or beneficiary thereof from enforcing any right under it by usual legal proceedings in ordinary tribunals or limiting the time to do so is void and unenforceable.
Bulletin 98-5 is agency guidance. Schouweiler arose under an 1895 mutual insurer statute much like today's 58-35-49 for farm mutuals.
Court decisions: Schouweiler v. Merchants' Mutual Insurance Association; Batiz v. Fire Insurance Exchange
After the award is paid
No modern SD case; 1929 case denied penalty after timely payment
No state rule found
In 1929 the Supreme Court held an insured could not recover the statutory 10 percent penalty or interest after the insurer paid an agreed appraisal award within the time the policy allowed. That penalty statute is no longer in the code. Today SDCL 58-12-3 allows attorney fees when refusal to pay is vexatious or without reasonable cause, bars them when the insurer tendered before suit and the judgment is no more than the tender, and keeps other tort or contract remedies. We found no decision applying it after an appraisal payment.
Liability for penalty and for interest is not contemplated under the statute above quoted, where the loss is paid within the time the insurer is required to make payment by the terms of the contract.
Doherty was decided under a 1919 fire-insurance penalty statute that is no longer in force. No decision applies SDCL 58-12-3 after an appraisal payment.
Court decisions: Doherty v. Automobile Insurance Co. of Hartford
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
The arbitration chapter "does not apply to insurance policies", and any provision in such a policy "requiring arbitration" is "void and unenforceable". So is any provision restricting a party from enforcing a right "by usual legal proceedings in ordinary tribunals" or limiting the time to do so. Arbitration agreements between insurance companies are excepted.
Bulletin 98-5, "Arbitration Clauses" (May 27, 1998): policies with provisions "labeled as arbitration, appraisal or any other term whereby a claim dispute resolution process can be demanded or required by either party are likewise prohibited". Arbitration or appraisal provisions "must be optional and only permitted where it is agreed upon by both parties. Any arbitration or appraisal outcome can not be made binding upon the parties." Its example of a prohibited clause is wording saying either side "may demand an appraisal of the loss." It does not affect insurers’ underwriting appraisals or their own independent claim appraisals, and non-compliant forms must be re-filed.
The Division’s current filing page says "Binding appraisal and arbitration provisions are prohibited in South Dakota insurance contracts pursuant to Bulletin 98-5 and SDCL 21-25A-3." Its approved wording: "an appraisal of the loss may be made if both parties agree to the appraisal." If so agreed, each party selects a competent appraiser and the two select an umpire. "A decision agreed to by any two will not be binding." Each party pays its own appraiser and shares the umpire and appraisal expenses equally, and the insurer waives no rights by agreeing. The page shows no last-updated date.
Division of Insurance, property and casualty filing requirements
The general contracts statute likewise voids any provision restricting enforcement "by usual legal proceedings" or limiting the time to do so, though agreements to arbitrate under the Uniform Arbitration Act are valid. SDCL 21-25A-3 says that arbitration chapter does not apply to insurance policies.
No statute sets appraisal steps or day counts. Any day counts in a South Dakota policy’s optional appraisal clause are policy terms, and the approved clause has none.
Appraisal timelines
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Demand appraisal: not permitted. Appraisal happens only by agreement of both parties | Not applicable | Not applicable | SDCL 21-25A-3; Bulletin 98-5(PDF) | |
| Name an appraiser, pick an umpire or issue an award: no day count is fixed; the approved clause has none | Mutual agreement to appraise | Parties and the appraisal panel | Division-approved clause | |
| Effect of the award: not binding on either party | Not applicable | Not applicable | Bulletin 98-5(PDF) | |
| Suit on the policy: no policy clause may shorten the time to sue | Not applicable | Insured | SDCL 53-9-6; SDCL 21-25A-3 |
Who can serve
No statute, regulation or bulletin sets qualifications for appraisers or umpires. The Division’s approved clause asks only for a "competent appraiser"; it does not say "disinterested" and sets no standard for the umpire.
The Division says "South Dakota does not license property/casualty adjusters."
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in South Dakota. SDCL 58-12-34(13) does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Provide forms needed to present a claim, with explanations | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Request | Insurer | SDCL 58-12-34(13) |
| Affirm or deny coverage, settle, and explain a denial: no fixed count, only "reasonable time" and "promptly" | Not applicable | Insurer | SDCL 58-12-34(4), (7), (12) | |
| Attorney’s fee when refusal to pay the full loss was vexatious or without reasonable cause: no day count; no costs if the recovery does not exceed a pre-suit tender | Judgment or award for the insured | Insurer | SDCL 58-12-3 |
Court decisions
Schouweiler v. Merchants’ Mut. Ins. Co., 11 S.D. 401, 78 N.W. 356
South Dakota Supreme Court, 1899
The insurer waived the policy’s appraisal condition: it did not appoint an appraiser when the insureds asked, and it then agreed to a separate common-law arbitration that was not under the policy’s terms. It predates SDCL 21-25A-3 by 72 years and is history only.
Recent and pending changes
No change found. The codified text of SDCL 21-25A-3 (last amended 1997), 53-9-6 (1988), 58-12-34 (2014) and 58-12-3 (2011) shows no later amendment, and no bill on appraisal or arbitration in insurance policies appears in the 2026 session list. The Division’s filing page still cites Bulletin 98-5.
SDCL source notes; 2026 session bill list; Division of Insurance filing page
Sources
- SDCL 21-25A-3, arbitration not applicable to insurance policiesOfficial
- Division of Insurance Bulletin 98-5, Arbitration Clauses (1998)OfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Division of Insurance, property and casualty filing requirementsOfficial
- Division of Insurance, licensing exemptionsOfficial
- SDCL 53-9-6, restraint of legal proceedingsOfficial
- SDCL 58-12-34, unfair practicesOfficial
- SDCL 58-12-3, attorney’s feesOfficial
- Schouweiler v. Merchants’ Mutual (S.D. 1899), on HallApprovedSecondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.