At a glance
Arkansas law voids any insurance policy term that takes away the insured's right to a jury trial on a question of fact (Ark. Code § 23-79-203). The Insurance Department's Bulletin 19-89 says binding appraisal clauses are prohibited and policy language must make appraisal voluntary and non-binding, and a federal trial court applied that rule in 2015. No appraisal deadlines were found in Arkansas statute or Department rules. The day counts below are the Department's claim-handling standards in Rule 43, which are duties of the insurer and apply to appraisal only indirectly.
Fixed appraisal deadlines: no
By subject
Compare every state: License or registration, Contingency fees, Impartiality, Umpire selection, Causation, Coverage, The award, Who pays, Demand and waiver, After the award is paid, Deadlines
License or registration
No appraiser or umpire license found; adjuster law is insurer-side
No state rule found
We found no Arkansas license or registration for an appraiser or umpire. The adjuster license covers people who negotiate claims on behalf of the insurer. Arkansas does not license public adjusters, and the Insurance Department says that subject belongs to the state Supreme Court's unauthorized practice committee. A statute for insurance consultants, who advise anyone for a fee, was not tested against appraisal.
investigates and negotiates, on behalf of the insurer, settlement of claims arising under insurance contracts.
Property insurance. The adjuster definition is about work for the insurer; no text on neutral appraisers or umpires was found.
Contingency fees
No Arkansas rule on contingent-fee appraisers found
No state rule found
We found no Arkansas statute, rule, bulletin or court decision on whether an appraiser paid a share of the award is disqualified. Arkansas appraisal is voluntary, so the policy wording and the parties' agreement set who may serve.
Property insurance.
Impartiality
Appraiser must be disinterested under the policy; a jury decides
Arkansas decisions treat whether an appraiser is competent and disinterested as a question for the jury. In O'Bryan, an appraiser who had earlier been paid by the insured to estimate the loss was not disqualified by that fact alone. The cases applied policy wording. No statute sets the standard.
this preconceived opinion as an expert derived from personal inspection was not a disqualification as an appraiser.
Fire-policy appraisal clauses worded 'competent and disinterested', from the era when binding clauses were still used; the opinion applies the policy's own words.
Court decisions: National Fire Ins. Co. v. O'Bryan; Insurance Co. of North America v. Kempner
Umpire selection
Policy wording controls; no Arkansas statute on umpires
No state rule found
We found no Arkansas statute or rule on how an umpire is chosen, and Arkansas has no codified standard fire policy. Appraisal is voluntary, so the policy and the parties' agreement control. In a 1924 case the policy let either side ask a court of record to name the umpire when the appraisers could not agree, and the court's choice stood. One insurer's Arkansas endorsement, quoted by a federal court in 2015, has a judge pick the umpire if the appraisers cannot agree.
Policy wording only. The 1924 case applied its own policy's clause; the 2015 endorsement is one insurer's form.
Court decisions: Globe & Rutgers Fire Ins. Co. v. Hornor
Causation
No Arkansas ruling on whether an appraisal panel decides causation
No state rule found
We found no Arkansas statute or decision saying whether appraisers may decide what caused the damage. Because appraisal is voluntary and not binding, the parties define the panel's job in their agreement.
Property insurance.
Coverage
No Arkansas ruling on whether appraisers may decide coverage
No state rule found
We found no Arkansas statute, rule or appellate decision on whether appraisers may decide coverage. Arkansas appraisal must be voluntary and non-binding. One insurer's Arkansas endorsement, quoted by a federal trial court in 2015, says the insurer keeps its right to deny the claim after an appraisal. That court also remarked that an appraisal cannot settle a dispute over the scope of the loss.
Property insurance. The 2015 remarks are an unreported federal trial court's, one insurer's form and a side comment.
The award
Binding appraisal clauses are void; appraisal must be voluntary
Arkansas voids any policy term that takes away a jury on a question of fact. The Supreme Court held binding appraisal clauses void under that statute, and said an agreed appraisal can be revoked by either side before the award. The Insurance Department requires appraisal clauses to say they are voluntary and non-binding. Where an agreed appraisal was finished, the Supreme Court in 1924 let the award stand unless shown to come from fraud, mistake or misconduct, and an award must follow the terms of the agreement to submit. Arkansas's arbitration act does not apply to insureds.
All such provisions, conditions, or agreements shall be void.
Policies written in Arkansas. A 1954 federal court held the statute does not reach a policy written in another state. Hornor's award was relied on by the insured, not resisted.
Court decisions: Firemen's Ins. Co. v. Davis; Insurance Co. of North America v. Kempner; Niagara Fire Ins. Co. v. Boon; Globe & Rutgers Fire Ins. Co. v. Hornor
Who pays
Policy wording controls; no Arkansas statute on fees
No state rule found
We found no Arkansas statute or rule dividing the cost of appraisers or an umpire. Older fire-policy clauses quoted in cases had each side pay its own appraiser and split the umpire and expenses, but that was policy wording. The Arkansas endorsement quoted in Simmons says nothing on cost.
the parties thereto shall pay the appraisers respectively selected by them, and shall bear equally the expenses of the appraisal and umpire.
The quote is a 1905 policy clause as set out in the opinion, not a statute or holding.
Court decisions: National Fire Ins. Co. v. O'Bryan
Demand and waiver
No deadline; either side may refuse, or revoke before the award
We found no Arkansas statute setting a deadline to demand appraisal. A policy term forcing appraisal is void, so either side may decline. In 1918 the Supreme Court held that an agreed appraisal can be revoked by either side, for any reason, in writing, at any time before the award. A federal trial court in 2015 also held, in the alternative, that insurers waived appraisal by demanding it three months after suit was filed.
such an agreement is revocable, at any time before the award, at the will of either party.
Kempner applied the statute's predecessor to a fire policy. Simmons is an unreported federal order, persuasive only.
Court decisions: Insurance Co. of North America v. Kempner
After the award is paid
Late payment after suit still owes 12% and fees; no appraisal case
Arkansas adds 12% damages and attorney's fees when an insurer does not pay within the policy's time after demand. The Supreme Court says paying after the insured had to sue does not erase them. The fees and 12% also require the recovery to come within the statute's percentage of the amount demanded. We found no Arkansas case on an appraisal award paid on time.
attorney’s fees and penalty attach if the insured is required to file suit, even though judgment is confessed before trial.
General penalty rule from homeowners fire cases, not appraisal cases.
Court decisions: Silvey Companies v. Riley; National Standard Ins. Co. v. Westbrooks
Deadlines
No fixed appraisal deadlines
Where appraisal comes from
The statute says a policy may not contain a provision that "deprives the insured or beneficiary of the right to trial by jury on any question of fact arising under the policy or contract." It adds: "All such provisions, conditions, or agreements shall be void."
Insurance Department Bulletin 19-89 (July 21, 1989): "The provisions of Arkansas law prohibit binding arbitration or appraisal clauses in insurance policies or contracts." Policy language "must reference that arbitration/appraisal procedures are voluntary and non-binding." The bulletin itself cites Ark. Code Ann. §§ 23-79-208 and 16-108-201 (1987), not § 23-79-203.
In the policy described in Simmons, the general appraisal clause gave 20 days to name an appraiser after a written demand and 15 days to agree on an umpire, and made the award binding. Its Arkansas amendatory endorsement replaced that: an appraisal happens "only if both the Companies and the Insured agree, voluntarily," each side picks "a competent and impartial appraiser," and "An appraisal decision will not be binding on either party." The insurer keeps its right to deny the claim. Those day counts come from that policy, not from Arkansas law, and the endorsement as quoted adds none.
Policy and Arkansas amendatory endorsement, quoted in Simmons Foods (W.D. Ark. 2015)(PDF)
Ark. Code § 23-79-208 makes an insurer that fails to pay a loss "within the time specified in the policy after demand" liable for the loss plus 12% damages and reasonable attorney's fees. The damages and fees survive a recovery of less than the amount demanded if the recovery is within 20% of the amount demanded or sought in the suit; for a homeowner's policy the attorney's-fee threshold is 30%. The statute sets no number of days itself. The Arkansas Supreme Court has read the 20% rule strictly, because the statute is penal.
The claim-handling clocks below are minimum standards. Rule 43 treats a violation as an unfair claims settlement practice only if it happens "with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice." The rule applies to all insurance policies except workers' compensation and employer's liability, and its time standards for acknowledgment, investigation and settlement (sections 7 to 9) do not apply to health carriers.
Appraisal timelines
No fixed appraisal deadlines in statute or regulation.
Who can serve
The appraisal clause in O'Bryan and the general clause in the Simmons policy both say "competent and disinterested"; the Arkansas endorsement in Simmons says "competent and impartial." Whether an appraiser is competent and disinterested is a question for the jury, and having earlier estimated the loss for the insured does not disqualify an appraiser by itself.
The Insurance Department's 2024 report to the Legislature lists the occupations it licenses or registers: claims adjusters, insurance consultants, surplus line brokers, producers, managing general agents and third-party administrators. It lists no appraiser or umpire license. It defines an adjuster as one who negotiates settlement of claims "on behalf of the insurer."
On public adjusters, the same report says the Department received one public adjusting complaint and referred it to the Arkansas Supreme Court Committee on the Unauthorized Practice of Law, "as that entity has jurisdiction over public adjusting." NAPIA lists Arkansas among the states that do not license public adjusters: "The only states that do not license public adjusters are: Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, and South Dakota." No Arkansas rule was found on public adjusters acting as appraisers, contingency-fee appraisers, or disclosure.
Arkansas Insurance Department report (2024); NAPIA (secondary source)
Claim-handling clocks that interact with appraisal
Day counting is not settled in Arkansas. Rule 43 § 7 does not say whether its deadlines are counted in calendar days or business days.
| Event | Time | Starts from | Who | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurer acknowledges the claim, unless payment is made in that time (working days; the rule does not define the term) | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Notification of claim | Insurer | Rule 43 § 7(a) |
| Insurer furnishes proof-of-loss forms, or waives the proof-of-loss requirement | 20 calendar days | The loss being reported | Insurer | Rule 43 § 7(a), citing Ark. Code Ann. § 23-79-126 |
| Insurer replies to another pertinent claimant communication that reasonably suggests a response is expected (working days; the rule does not define the term) | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | The communication | Insurer | Rule 43 § 7(c) |
| Insurer gives the Department a reasonably adequate response to its inquiry about a claim (working days; the rule does not define the term) | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | The Department inquiry | Insurer | Rule 43 § 7(b) |
| Insurer completes the investigation, or tells the claimant more time is needed and why | 45 calendar days | Notification of claim | Insurer | Rule 43 § 8 |
| Insurer tells the first-party claimant the claim is accepted or denied; a denial is in writing and cites the policy provision (working days; the rule does not define the term) | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of properly executed proofs of loss | Insurer | Rule 43 § 9(a)(1) |
| If the insurer needs more time on a first-party claim, it says so in writing within 15 working days, then, if the investigation is still incomplete, sends a letter within 45 calendar days of the initial notification and no less often than every 45 calendar days after that | 15 days(calendar or business not stated) | Receipt of proofs of loss; then the initial notification | Insurer | Rule 43 § 9(a)(2) |
| Insurer negotiating directly with a claimant who has no attorney gives written notice that a limitations period or policy time limit may be expiring (first-party claimant; working days, the rule does not define the term) | 30 days(calendar or business not stated) | Before the date the limit may expire (at least this many days ahead) | Insurer | Rule 43 § 9(d) |
| Same notice to a third-party claimant who has no attorney | 60 calendar days | Before the date the limit may expire (at least this many days ahead) | Insurer | Rule 43 § 9(d) |
| Insurer mails or delivers the claim check or draft (working days; the rule does not define the term) | 10 days(calendar or business not stated) | The claim is processed, investigations are complete, and the file is closed and ready for payment | Insurer | Rule 43 § 9(f) |
Court decisions
National Fire Ins. Co. v. O'Bryan, 75 Ark. 198
Arkansas Supreme Court, 1905
Whether an appraiser is "competent and disinterested" is a question for the jury. That the insured's appraiser had earlier been paid to estimate the loss for the insured is a fact for the jury on bias, and does not disqualify him by itself.
Niagara Fire Ins. Co. v. Boon, 76 Ark. 153
Arkansas Supreme Court, 1905
On a standard fire-policy appraisal clause that made the award binding, every reasonable presumption favors the award, and the burden is on those attacking it. It is vacated only if made without authority or the result of fraud, mistake or misconduct of the appraisers, and not for an excessive valuation unless so grossly erroneous as to indicate bad faith or other grounds to set it aside.
MFA Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bradshaw, 245 Ark. 95, 431 S.W.2d 252
Arkansas Supreme Court, 1968
Not an appraisal case: it upheld an uninsured-motorist consent clause. In passing, the court noted that Ark. Stat. Ann. § 66-3233 (Repl. 1966) declares void a clause compelling an insured to submit any question of fact to arbitration. That is the statute before today's § 23-79-203.
U.S. District Court, W.D. Ark. (unreported trial-court order on a motion to exclude evidence, persuasive only), 2015
Under § 23-79-203, a non-voluntary, binding appraisal provision is unenforceable, so the insured did not have to comply with the insurers' demand for a binding appraisal; the insurers conceded this is Arkansas law. In the alternative, the court held the insurers waived appraisal by demanding it three months after suit was filed. The Eighth Circuit later decided other issues in the same case (863 F.3d 792 (8th Cir. 2017)) and did not address appraisal.
National Standard Ins. Co. v. Westbrooks, 331 Ark. 445, 962 S.W.2d 355
Arkansas Supreme Court, 1998
The 12% damages and attorney's fees of § 23-79-208 are available only if the insured recovers within 20% of the amount demanded or sought in the suit, read as the amount sued for (a house fire claim under a homeowners policy; the jury's verdict fell short of that). The statute is penal and strictly construed. The court reversed an award of fees and damages. This is not an appraisal case.
Recent and pending changes
The Insurance Department's June 12, 2025 summary of that session's insurance laws lists no act on appraisal, on who may adjust claims for insureds, or on property claim-handling time limits. This statement rests only on that list; the Department says it does not represent the list is complete, and no other source of 2025 or 2026 session acts was checked. Its property and casualty section lists Act 246 (SB 48), which requires owner-occupied residential property insurers to disclose all deductibles on the declarations page or renewal notice.
Arkansas Insurance Department Bulletin 9-2025 (June 12, 2025)(PDF)
HB 1811 (proof of payment of the deductible before recoverable depreciation) did not pass: its author withdrew it, and the House Insurance and Commerce Committee sent it to interim study on April 14, 2025.
Sources
- Ark. Code § 23-79-203, trial by jury, on FindLaw (current as of March 28, 2024)Secondary
- Ark. Code § 23-79-208, damages and attorney fees on loss claims, on FindLaw (current as of March 28, 2024)Secondary
- Arkansas Insurance Department Bulletin 19-89, policy provisions as to arbitration or appraisalOfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Code of Arkansas Rules, Title 23, Part 15: Unfair Claims Settlement Practices (Rule 43); the sections are 15-105 to 15-107Official
- Arkansas Insurance Department, report to the Arkansas Legislative Council Occupational Licensing Review Subcommittee, Aug. 22, 2024OfficialPDF · no web page version found
- Arkansas Insurance Department Bulletin 9-2025, 2025 Arkansas legislationOfficialPDF · no web page version found
- HB 1811, 2025 Regular Session, Arkansas State Legislature bill pageOfficial
- Simmons Foods v. Industrial Risk Insurers (W.D. Ark. 2015), order on a law firm's siteSecondaryPDF · no web page version found
- National Standard Ins. Co. v. Westbrooks (Ark. 1998), on JustiaSecondary
- National Fire Ins. Co. v. O'Bryan, 75 Ark. 198, Caselaw Access Project copySecondary
- Niagara Fire Ins. Co. v. Boon, 76 Ark. 153, Caselaw Access Project copySecondary
- MFA Mut. Ins. Co. v. Bradshaw, 245 Ark. 95, Caselaw Access Project copySecondary
- NAPIA, unauthorized practice of public adjusting (secondary source)Secondary
Appraisal rules in other states
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
Related reading: The clocks in an appraisal.