When to decline an appointment
October 19, 2026 · 5 min read
By Nate King, appraiser and umpire
In my experience, the appointments that cause trouble are rarely the ones that look like trouble; the ones that turn into a problem months later are the ordinary-looking ones, such as an appraiser you have worked across from a dozen times, a carrier you used to do staff work for, or a contractor on the scope who turns out to be somebody you know.
And because none of those feel like a conflict from the inside, the decision tends to get made quickly and without much thought, usually on the phone, while you are trying to be helpful.
What disinterested is actually asking
The word that shows up in most appraisal clauses is some version of competent and disinterested, and the second half of that is the one worth thinking about.
Disinterested does not mean you have no opinions about the loss, and it does not mean you have never met anybody involved. In a business this small, a standard that strict would leave nobody eligible to serve. What it seems to come down to, in every formulation of it I have read, is that you have no stake in which way the award goes, and no relationship with either side that would give a reasonable observer any doubt about that.
The hard part is that the test is about the parties more than it is about you: whether, once they know everything you know, they would still be comfortable with you deciding it. You almost certainly know you can be fair, and that does not answer it. Those two questions have different answers more often than people expect, and the second one is the one that governs.
The ones that are easy
Some of them are not close calls at all, and it is worth naming them so the harder ones stand out by contrast.
If you have any financial interest in the outcome, or a contingent fee of any kind, that is done before you start. If you have already worked the claim in another capacity — as a public adjuster, as either side's appraiser, as the engineer who wrote a report on it — you cannot then come back as the neutral. If you are related to somebody involved, or you have a lawsuit running with one of the parties, the same thing applies.
Those are the ones everybody already knows, and in my experience they cause almost no actual problems, because they are obvious enough that people decline them without being asked to.
The ones that are not
Then there are the ones that make up nearly all of the real difficulty.
A steady relationship with one appraiser is the most common of them. If one side's appraiser has put you forward on six files this year and the other side has never named you at all, there is nothing improper about a single one of those appointments, and the pattern still means something. It is worth disclosing, and it is worth being honest with yourself about whether the next appointment from that direction is one you should be taking.
Recent employment is another. Doing staff work for a carrier five years ago is not the same as having left them last spring, and there is no bright line anywhere that tells you where it stops mattering. When you cannot tell, that is usually the answer: disclose it and let the parties decide, because they are the ones entitled to make that call.
There is also the version where you already have an opinion. If you have publicly taken a strong position on the exact coverage question at the center of the file, or you have testified repeatedly on one side of it, that will follow you into the appointment whether or not it should.
And then there is capacity, which is not a conflict at all and gets ignored anyway. Taking an appointment you do not have the time to move is its own kind of harm to the parties, and I think it belongs on the same list.
Disclose early, and disclose in writing
The single practice that seems to prevent the most trouble is also the least dramatic one: whatever you find, put it in writing to both appraisers at the same time, before you accept.
Send the same message to both sides, and send it before you accept rather than after. Sending it to one and then the other invites a perfectly reasonable question about why the order went that way, and disclosing after the award has landed makes something ordinary look like something you were sitting on.
The thing worth understanding is that the disclosure is not really a confession. Most of what gets disclosed is fine, and the parties say so and the appointment goes ahead. What the disclosure does is move the decision to the people who are entitled to make it, and once they have made it with the facts in front of them, the point cannot be reopened later by somebody unhappy with the result.
How to actually say no
When the answer is no, say it early and say it plainly, and do not narrate the whole deliberation.
Something close to "I need to decline this one — I have a working relationship with one of the parties that I think is close enough to matter here" is sufficient. You are not obligated to make a case for it, and elaborating tends to read as either an apology or an argument.
Then, if you can, suggest two or three other names. That is a small thing and it is the part people remember, because the appraisers are now sitting on a file with a deadline running and no umpire on it, and you have just handed them most of the way to a solution. Declining well is, as far as I can tell, one of the more reliable ways to get called again.
The one worth being firm about
If the two appraisers cannot agree and one of them starts to lean, by sounding out how you might see a particular issue or mentioning what the other side is likely to accept, that is the moment to stop the conversation, and stop it clearly rather than politely.
Substantive communication with one side outside the presence of the other is the thing most likely to undo an award, and the awkwardness of saying so in the moment is very small next to the alternative. Most of the time nobody meant anything by it, and saying "let's put that to both of us together" costs nothing at all.
We built The Claim King so each file carries its own record of what was disclosed and when, alongside the appointment itself, because that record is the thing you will want years later and the thing that is easy to forget to keep at the time. You can see what it does without scheduling a sales demo.
More articles
Looking for a statute or a deadline? See the appraisal rules for each state.