Skip to content
Claim King Core is free for 30 days. Start your trial
← All articles

How umpire work comes in

October 5, 2026 · 5 min read

By Nate King, appraiser and umpire

Appraisal work and umpire work arrive by completely different routes, and I think that surprises people more than it should. Appraisal work comes from a side: a policyholder, a public adjuster, a carrier, somebody who wants you representing their position. Umpire work cannot come from a side, because the moment it does it stops being umpire work.

So the question of where it actually comes from has a slightly awkward answer, which is that most of it comes from the two people who were arguing with each other, jointly, and usually because one of them has seen you work before.

The appointment is a negotiation you are not in

The mechanics are worth being precise about, because they explain nearly everything else.

When the two appraisers cannot agree on the amount of loss, they have to agree on an umpire, and they typically have a short window in which to do it. What happens in practice is that each of them puts forward a few names, and they look for one both sides can accept. If they cannot get there, the fallback in most policies is a judicial appointment.

What that means for you is that your name has to already be on somebody's short list before the conversation starts, and it has to be a name the other appraiser has no objection to. Those are two separate requirements, and the second one is the one people underestimate. What gets you appointed is being unobjectionable to the other side, more than being well regarded by your own.

Why your last file often brings the next one

Follow that through and the conclusion is a little uncomfortable, which is that a fair portion of umpire work seems to come from appraisers you were recently across the table from.

You served as an appraiser on a file, the appraiser on the other side watched how you handled it, and some months later a different file reaches an impasse and yours is one of the names they put forward. They do that because you were reasonable, you showed your reasoning, and you did not make the process harder than it had to be; agreeing with them has little to do with it, and agreeing too readily seems to work against you.

I find this is the part newer appraisers do not expect. What builds an umpire practice is different from what wins an argument on a single file. It is returning correspondence, putting your number on paper with the support behind it, being straight about what you are not sure of, and losing a point gracefully when the other side is right about it. Every one of those is visible from across the table, and all of them are being noticed whether or not anybody says so.

What a credential does for you

There are a good number of certification programs, directories and rosters in this line of work, and I would not tell anybody to ignore them. Which ones carry weight seems to vary quite a bit by state and by carrier, so that is worth asking about locally rather than taking anybody's word for it, including mine.

What a credential does is fairly narrow and still genuinely useful. It puts you in a list somebody can search when they need names and do not have any. It gives the appraiser proposing you something to point at when the other side asks who you are. And in the event the appointment ends up in front of a judge, it is part of what establishes that you are competent to serve, which is the other half of the standard most clauses set.

What it does not do is generate appointments on its own. A directory listing is a way of being findable, and being findable only matters once somebody has a reason to go looking for you specifically.

Appointment by a court

When the two appraisers genuinely cannot agree, one of them applies and the court appoints somebody, and how that list gets built varies enough by jurisdiction that it is worth finding out how it works in yours rather than assuming.

It is not a large share of the work for most people, as far as I can tell, and it is worth understanding anyway, because it is one of the few routes into umpire work that does not depend on already having done some.

The slow part, and what to do during it

The honest version of all this is that an umpire practice builds slowly, and the reason has to do with how appointments work and not with you. Every appointment requires two people to agree on you, one of whom has no particular reason to want you there, and that is simply a higher bar than getting hired by a side.

A few things seem to help while it is building.

Say yes to the small ones. A modest loss that nobody is fighting very hard over is still an appointment, and it still puts you in front of two appraisers who will remember how it went.

Keep the record of what you have done, because you will be asked. How many appointments, what kinds of losses, what jurisdictions, roughly what range of values — those questions come up when somebody is deciding whether to put your name forward, and reconstructing the answer from memory and old email is a miserable way to spend an afternoon that could have been avoided by writing it down as you went.

Decline cleanly when you have to. An appointment you turn down for a disclosable relationship, handled early and with a couple of other names offered, seems to do more for your reputation than the appointment itself would have.

And be findable. Somewhere that says plainly who you are, what you have done and how to reach you, so that when an appraiser is trying to remember the name of the person who handled that file reasonably last spring, they can actually get to you.

What I would want you to know starting out

The thing I would want somebody starting out to understand is that there is no marketing channel here in the ordinary sense. You cannot advertise your way into neutral appointments, and anything that looks like selling yourself to one side is actively working against the thing that makes you appointable at all.

What generates the work is your conduct on files you are already on, observed by people who are not on your side, over a period of years. That is a slow mechanism and not a comfortable one to rely on, and as far as I can tell it is the actual mechanism, so it is better to know that early than to spend a couple of years waiting for a faster one to show up.


We built The Claim King to keep the record of every appointment on one screen, with the role you served, the carrier, the dates and the disposition, so you can pull up what you have handled when somebody asks. You can see what it does without scheduling a sales demo.

More articles

Looking for a statute or a deadline? See the appraisal rules for each state.

Built by an appraiser and umpire.

The whole platform at one price, and everything it does is listed on the site.