The tax side of a solo practice
October 12, 2026 · 5 min read
By Nate King, appraiser and umpire
I should say at the top that I am not an accountant and nothing here is tax advice; get a CPA who has seen a one-person professional practice before, and if anything below contradicts what they tell you, listen to them and not to me.
What I can talk about is the problem itself, because the tax side of a solo appraisal practice goes wrong in a few specific and fairly predictable ways, and most of them are bookkeeping failures rather than tax failures. They are decided months before the return gets filed, by whether you were writing things down at the time.
You are being paid gross, and it does not feel like it
The first thing that catches people coming out of staff work is that every dollar arriving in the account is gross. Nothing has been withheld, nobody is paying half of anything for you, and the number in the bank is not the number you get to keep.
Between self-employment tax and income tax, the share of a given fee that is not actually yours is substantial, and the exact fraction depends on your bracket, your state, your deductions and your entity, which is precisely the sort of question a CPA exists to answer for your situation rather than in the abstract.
The mechanical fix is boring and it works: a second account, and a transfer into it every single time money lands, on the day it lands, and not monthly or at quarter end. The reason to do it on receipt is that a fee sitting in the operating account for six weeks stops feeling like somebody else's money, and by the time the estimate is due it has turned into a cash-flow problem you did not know you had.
Estimated taxes are four deadlines, and they do not move
Because nothing is withheld, the money goes in quarterly, and the quarters are uneven: the due dates are in April, June, September and January.
Underpaying carries a penalty, and while the penalty is not enormous, it is entirely avoidable.
The part that catches solo practices in particular is that appraisal income is lumpy. Three awards land in one month and then nothing closes for six weeks, and an estimate calculated off a good stretch will be wrong in one direction while an estimate calculated off a slow one will be wrong in the other. There are safe-harbor rules built exactly for this, based on what you paid the previous year, and they are worth asking your CPA about specifically, because they let you base the payment on last year's tax and not on a forecast.
Mileage is the deduction most often left on the table
A practice like this drives, and the driving is deductible, and an enormous amount of it goes unclaimed every year because nobody wrote it down.
The rule of thumb is that the deduction depends on the log more than on the driving. A mileage log needs the date, the destination, the business purpose and the miles, and it needs to be written at the time rather than reconstructed in March from a calendar and a fuel card.
The per-mile rate changes every year, so look up the current one rather than carrying last year's number forward. And it is worth knowing early that commuting does not count, that the first and last trips of the day are treated differently depending on whether you have a qualifying home office, and that this is exactly the kind of detail where an hour with a CPA pays for itself several times over.
The same principle runs through the rest of it. Certification fees, continuing education, the association dues, the software, the phone, the part of the house you actually work from; all of it is ordinary and deductible and all of it depends on a record existing.
The 1099s will not add up, and that is normal
Sometime in late January the forms start arriving, and the first year this happens it is genuinely alarming, because the total across all of them will not match what you know you were paid.
There are several reasons for that, and none of them mean anybody did anything wrong. Payers only issue a form above a threshold, and that threshold has moved recently, so check the figure for the year you are actually filing rather than the one you remember. Some payers issue forms they did not strictly need to. Some are late, some are wrong, and a payment made on December 29th may land on either year's form depending on how that payer's system handles it.
More to the point, on umpire work the split fee means two payers on one appointment, and the odds of both of them behaving the same way are not good.
The conclusion to draw from all of this is the one that matters: go by your books, and use the 1099s to check them. You report what you were paid, which you know because you were tracking invoices and payments as they happened. The forms are a cross-check, and when one of them disagrees with your books the first thing to do is find out which of the two is wrong, because it is not always the form.
Do it as you go, or you will not do it
None of the above is complicated, but all of it is easy to put off, and putting it off is where it goes wrong, because every one of these is a small task at the moment it happens and a miserable one in April.
Log the miles the day you drive them. Move the tax money the day the fee lands. Record the invoice when you send it and the payment when it clears. Keep the receipt at the point of purchase rather than hoping the card statement will be enough later, because a line item on a statement establishes that you spent money and not what you spent it on.
A practice that does those four things has a tax season that takes an afternoon. A practice that does none of them has one that takes a week and still leaves money uncollected, and in my experience what separates the two is usually whether things get written down at the moment they happen, or get left for later, when you will likely be busier than you are now.
We built The Claim King to track the invoice and the payment on each file, and to hold the date of an inspection alongside the job, so what happened is written down while it is happening. You can see what it does and what it costs without scheduling a sales demo.
More articles
Looking for a statute or a deadline? See the appraisal rules for each state.