Skip to content
Claim King Core is free for 30 days. Start your trial
← All articles

Setting your rate

September 28, 2026 · 5 min read

By Nate King, appraiser and umpire

I am not going to tell you what to charge. Rates vary by region, by the complexity of the loss, by whether you are serving as an appraiser or an umpire, and by how long you have been doing it, and any specific number I put in front of you would be wrong for most of the people reading this and stale within a year besides.

What I can be useful about is the structure, because the structure is the part that gets decided once, early, and then affects what kind of work you end up doing for years afterward. Most people I have talked to about this picked their structure by copying whoever they learned from, which is a perfectly reasonable way to start and a poor reason to still be doing it a decade later.

What each structure actually does to you

Hourly is the one most people start with, and its real virtue is that it does not punish you for a file going sideways. When a straightforward appointment turns into four inspections, a supplemental scope and three rounds of correspondence, hourly is the only structure that follows the work.

Its cost is that it puts you in the position of having to explain your time, and it makes the total unknowable at the point of engagement, which some parties genuinely dislike. It also means every hour you get faster at the job is an hour you no longer get paid for, which is a strange incentive to build a career on.

Flat solves the thing hourly is bad at. Everybody knows the number at the start, there is no timekeeping and nothing to justify, and you capture the whole benefit of getting good at this. Where it fails is the outlier, and outliers are not rare in this work. One badly behaved file can eat the margin from three clean ones, and if your flat fee was set by averaging the clean ones you will find that out the hard way.

Hybrid is where a lot of practices end up, and the common version is a flat fee that covers a defined scope with an hourly rate attached to anything outside it. Done well, that gives you a predictable number for the ordinary case and a way to handle the one that is not. Done poorly, it is a flat fee that ends in an argument, and the difference comes down to how precisely the scope was written down at the start.

If you take one thing from this, it is that the hybrid only works if what the flat fee includes is written in a sentence somebody else could read and agree with; "the usual" is not enough.

The parts that often go unbilled

Whatever structure you pick, there is a set of work that routinely goes unbilled, and it is not small.

Travel is the biggest of them. Windshield time on a rural loss is real time you cannot spend on anything else, and an awful lot of people absorb it because it does not feel like working. Decide deliberately whether you bill it, at what rate, and from where, and whether mileage is separate from time, because they are two different things and charging one does not cover the other.

The inspection itself is usually billed. The three hours afterward writing it up frequently are not, and that is the part that actually produces the document everybody is waiting on.

Then there is the correspondence, which on a file that runs long becomes a genuine share of the total. There is also the reading: a large loss can arrive with a few hundred pages of estimates, reports and photographs, and going through them properly is part of the work.

None of this means every one of those should be a separate line item. It means you should decide on each one deliberately.

Say it before you accept

Whatever you land on, it goes to everybody in writing before you take the appointment, and on umpire work that means both appraisers at the same time rather than one and then the other.

This is doubly true for an umpire, because raising the subject of money after the award has been signed can look like a fee that depended on the outcome, and the entire value of the appointment rests on the fact that it did not. Settle it before you have opened a single document and the question never arises.

What the written version needs to cover is short: the rate and the structure, what the fee includes, how travel and inspection time are handled, whether there is a retainer, and, for umpire work, plainly that the fee is split equally between the parties so nobody is surprised by an invoice for half.

Raising a rate you have had too long

Most of the people I have talked to were late to this, and the reason seems to be that nothing prompts it; the market moves slowly while your rate stays where you set it years ago.

A few things make it easier.

Raise it on new appointments rather than mid-file, so nobody experiences it as a change to something already agreed. Pick a date and apply it to everything accepted after that date, because a rate that starts on a set date is the same for everyone, and a rate quoted differently to different people on the same day invites negotiation. When you say it, say it once and without justification; explaining why it went up tends to invite a conversation about whether it should have.

Then let the market answer. If nothing changes, you were underpriced and now you are less so. If a portion of the work goes elsewhere, you have found the edge, which is genuinely useful information and considerably cheaper to learn this way than by never testing it at all.


We built The Claim King to hold the fee arrangement on the file alongside the appointment, and to invoice a split umpire fee as two halves from the start, because that is how it actually gets paid. Everything it does and what it costs is listed on the site, so there is no need to schedule a sales demo to find out.

More articles

Looking for a statute or a deadline? See the appraisal rules for each state.

Built by an appraiser and umpire.

The whole platform at one price, and everything it does is listed on the site.